Sunday, July 08, 2007

Roundtable

Jim: This will be a brief roundtable. Participating are The Third Estate Sunday Review's Dona, Jess, Ty, Ava and me(Jim), Rebecca of Sex and Politics and Screeds and Attitude, Betty of Thomas Friedman Is a Great Man, C.I. of The Common Ills and The Third Estate Sunday Review, Kat of Kat's Korner (of The Common Ills), Cedric of Cedric's Big Mix, Mike of Mikey Likes It!, Elaine of Like Maria Said Paz, and Wally of The Daily Jot. After we'd finished last time, we ended up doing the usual of putting in a DVD and all watching as we fell out. While we were falling out, C.I. made a comment and Dona said, "If I'd known you were going to make that point, I would've demanded that we do a roundtable."



Jess: To clear something up, "we" was Kat, Dona, Jim, Ava, C.I., Ty and myself. In the feature that posted at all sites on Thursday ["Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you must have a penis," "Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis,"
"Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis," "Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis," "Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis," "Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis," "Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis," "Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis," "Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis," "Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis"], we -- Jim, Dona, Ty and myself -- wrote a lengthy bit about this site's beginning. We had input from all except Ava and C.I. who walked off during that portion because they were mentioned it. No one thought to note "and Rebecca, Mike, Wally, Cedric, Betty, Kat and Elaine regularly help out while Ruth's always been there to help out when we were short handed -- like Christmas 2006 when the only ones in charge of this site doing any work were Ava and C.I. -- or that Trina has also helped out here." That should have been noted. The fact that it wasn't goes to Dona, Jim, Ty and myself. When Ava finally read that part, I don't believe C.I. still has, her first comments was, "Why didn't you credit everyone?" We were rushing and not thinking. So our apologies to Rebecca, Kat, Betty, Cedric, Elaine, Wally and Mike.



Jim: Good point, but Dona's told me "Be brutal." So unless there's anything else like that, we're diving in. No? Okay. Ty, briefly, explain this edition.



Ty: We're calling this our "Sense of Purpose" edition. After Pretenders' song "Sense of Purpose" on the CD Packed! Why that? C.I. was e-mailed last Monday by The Nation. It's . . . You know what, I'm tossing to Ava or Jess.



Ava: I'll grab. Jess was typing away on the laptop without stopping and it had been a good thirty minutes. I stopped him and said, "What are you doing?" I knew he was in the e-mails and 30 minutes for a reply is excessive. Jess.



Jess: The e-mails for The Common Ills. Ava, Martha, Shirley, Eli and myself all help C.I. out with those. I explained The Nation had written C.I. about us and I was replying. Ava asked me to save to draft and let her read the e-mail.



Ava: So he slid the laptop over to me and I said, "Forget it." I actually worded it more strongly. But my point is, no one deserves an e-mail that takes more than 30 minutes unless they are a community member and there's not even time to give them that. We're certainly not wasting time on someone who e-mails to insult us. Ty?



Ty: The e-mail was meant to be 'passed on' and it was. The Nation thinks they know all about us and that we're in need of their keen sense of direction. Cedric just burst out laughing. So for anyone who's confused, this is the "Sense of Purpose" edition. I'll toss to Mike who's eager to go. I should note that we're all together for a change and no one's by phone except for Dallas.



Mike: Yeah. We're all out here hoping to have some fun after The Nation ruined 4th of July for all of us. So what's going on is that sections of the e-mail are being quoted with a response. That's the theme for everything.



Elaine: Except Ava and C.I.'s TV commentary.



Mike: Right. So you've got whatever The Nation says and our response. There's a point to it and we hope it reads it well but, like Jim said when he read over Ava and C.I.'s piece, "With this TV commentary, nothing else we do this week is even going to be noted."



Jim: So that's the set up for this edition and it works well with the comment C.I. made last week. We've touched on it here before and that's usually been Elaine or C.I. talking about it. But it just really became clear last Sunday. I can go to Kat here or go to Wally.



Kat: Go to Wally.



Wally: Okay. The plan has been that come the 2008 election, all sites would go dark and I'm the wrong one to go to because I wasn't doing a site when that decision was made.



Betty: I'll grab. We were doing an edition, summer of 2005, our sixties edition, in fact. I loved our editorial on Iraq then and still do, about the tripping point or the tipping point? During that, in a fiction piece, we were working on some things and responding to them humorously and C.I. said, "The thing that happens is it goes up here and I'm the one who has to hear about it."



Rebecca: Truer words were never spoken. True to this day.



Betty: Exactly. C.I. was exhausted, more so than usual. It was after the health scare and the response had been to hit the road even harder than before. C.I. was worn out and really had no protective layering.



Jim: I'll jump in here. Betty can get back to that point but just to note, I do use that in editorials and always have. When C.I.'s exhausted, we have always gotten some of our most powerful passages for editorials. Dona's said at times it was flat out cruel. Mike's described it as I'm the pitcher and C.I.'s the catcher but I think it's more like a home run than tossing back. But what Betty's talking about is just what my father's called "naked soul." And --



C.I.: I hope we're going to talk about something other than me.



Jim: We are. But whatever the topic is, I'll be on C.I. about "put yourself there" and we'll get this amazing passage out of it. Because there are no defenses up. Dad said it was painful to watch and like listening to Joni Mitchell's Blue. So that's the end of any edition. Betty's talking about how it was that way throughout.



Betty: Right. And we reached the breaking point. I don't remember exactly how. I just know C.I. was frustrated, not angry, not mad. Just wiped out. And that's when we were all shocked to find out that The Common Ills would be going dark in November 2008 and that, here was the real shocker, C.I. thought the illegal war would still be going on. There was a lot of denial about that on our parts initially, that the war would could still be continuing. How wrong we were.



Rebecca: C.I.'s about to get up and walk out so let me finish quickly. It's a lot of work to do a site. Just to do a site. C.I.'s on the road speaking out against Iraq, working friends in the press to get serious about Iraq and doing a lot at The Common Ills on top of that, including e-mails. C.I. needed an end date. And the fact that we were about to post something that was going to lead, as it always do, to people complaining to C.I. and being angry with C.I. was just too much. Kat, and we're off you, so sit back down. That was to C.I. for those reading.



Kat: So from that moment, we've all worked with the idea that we would shut down in November of 2008. That's those of us who were part of that edition and those who joined up after. What that really did was free us up. There's a song by David Rovics entitled "Crashing Down." And that just clicked last Sunday, this section of the song: "It can happen in a moment, And sometimes it does, When what could be is, And what shouldn’t be was, There are times, When you gotta stand steady, There are other times, When you gotta be ready." I mean, we all knew that was target date, November 2008. And we knew we had to do our bit and all. But we've talked about how silences on the part of the left allow the right to grab the conversation before. We'd addressed that. But only C.I. and Elaine had addressed, here and at their own sites, this whole notion of a moment. I think the fact that approximately 70% of the American people are now against the illegal war drove the point home last weekend.



Elaine: If it wasn't clear before, blame me. And C.I.'s waving a hand so blame us both. But --



Rebecca: " There are moments you remember all your life, There are moments you wait for ans1 dream, Of all your life. This is one of those moments." Barbra Streisand from the Yentl soundtrack.



Elaine: Rebecca loves her Streisand, always has. But that's right. There are moments. And these moments matter. They don't come around all the time. But when they are arriving, they define many years to come.



Wally: C.I. was using FDR and other examples.



Elaine: Right. That was a moment, the lead up there. All the things Americans got as a result of FDR administration's came about not from appeasers and realists on the left and left of center saying, "We'll just go along." It came about from intensive pressure in the lead up to FDR.



C.I.: And that's just one example. You could use the '60s' as well. What happens is in defining moments, and the right has them as well, but we're focused on the left, is that the lead up sets up what can be achieved. What follows is the implementation of some of that. Then comes the mini-backlash which leads the reformers, supposedly of the left, to make 'alterations.' Such as, using the choice issue, deciding government funds won't go for abortion. Now, the reformers say, we're not taking away abortion. We're just saying government funds won't pay for them. The reformers overreact to a mini-backlash. These 'friends' are the first to chip away at what we have. This is followed by a very real backlash and reformers have already set up the stage for bigger caves. It's actually followed by a back and forth and then comes the big backlash but I'm simplifying for time.



Mike: And Wally was telling me about the conversation when he called the next day and I was all, "Man, I wish I'd been there." To me, it backs up about a dozen points that Stanely Aronowitz makes in his books. And I was talking to Elaine about it and she pointed out Howard Zinn's points as well. Like his point about we are not Congress and we do not go along and just settle when we're not even given anything. It's not like they say, "Okay, we can't give you that, but we can give you this much." That didn't happen with the Pelosi-Reid measure, forget the eventual sell out on the supplemental, it wasn't even there in the Pelosi-Reid measure that many pushed.



Cedric: Including The Nation in their timid editorial endorsing the measure and the benchmarks,which, for the record, blame a puppet government for not having more control over events.



Jess: So the point is we're getting up to a moment and we can make something out of it or we can't and I think I leapt ahead. Dona?



Dona: No, that's fine. But there's a mood in the country that creates one of those moments, calls for a response. And we can either be demanding responses or we can play Party Hack and cheer the Democratic Party for the legislative equivalent of remembering to flush the toilet.



Cedric: It has to do with where the bar's at. Like right now, Bill Clinton's a supposed hero and why is that? I'm not saying he's evil.



Rebecca: This isn't a thread, you don't have to explain. That's a joke and Cedric's laughing, just FYI. Clinton gave us a good economy is the big talking point there. Well it wasn't that good, first of all. Second of all, this is an accomplishment? I thought that was a duty, if you're going to credit a president -- any president -- with an economy. I mean that is a basic. That's like expecting someone to show up to work on time. You expect it. If you're voting someone into office, you aren't saying, "I'm voting for her or him because I hope they'll tank the economy."



Elaine: Just noting, Betty's uncomfortable. I'll try to temper my remarks. Betty really loves Bill Clinton.



Betty: I do.



Elaine: And she should share why, we all know why participating, and no one devalues her reasons or says, "You're wrong." But Clinton was, at best, a reformer. The safety net got attacked repeatedly. He is the backlash responding president. Not the Bully Boy who has not responded but has pushed the country to the right. This was one of those moments for the right but we're coming out of that. Clinton backed NAFTA and a whole host of other things that we all know so I'm stopping to let Betty make her point.



Betty: I've said this before so I won't go in to much detail. But I remember life under Poppy Bush and I remember there was a change, a move towards inclusion, signaled by Bill Clinton coming into office. He has his faults like any of us do. He has some policies that I would've smacked him on the back of his head if I'd known him and he'd asked my opinion. But when he's called the first Black president, a lot of that is coming from the fact that he set a tone which rejected Bush's previous tone and said, "We are all Americans." I think that's true of Hillary as well and if she could address Iraq honestly, I'd be supporting her but I'm behind Dennis Kucinich because he is addressing Iraq.



Kat: I don't like Bill Clinton or Hillary. But, just to follow up on what Betty's talking about, Bill did make steps towards inclusion. That was African-Americans, that was gays and lesbians, that was a whole host of people. And I think it is worth noting that what Rush Limbaugh does, that hateful 'humor,' wasn't relegated to AM radio under the previous Bush. Or under Ronald Reagan. I don't care for Bill Clinton but, if you were old enough, you saw a big shift. It was other things as well but gone were the days of someone thinking, a public figure, that they could, for example, say "AIDS is God's curse on homosexuals" and have most people either look the other way or fail to object. With other administrations, it seemed like you defended your own subgroup whatever it was. Under Bill Clinton, it seemed like the country, with regards to differences, got smarter. That's not a minor thing. Think of Matthew Sheppard and the reaction to his murder. If that had been under the first Bush or Ronald Reagan, even in the nineties, but under them, I don't think there would have been the awareness and outrage there was. I'll blame him for many things, but I will credit Bill Clinton with fostering a tone of inclusion when he went into office.



Rebecca: I'll just add that we're not just talking about 'symbolic.' We're talking about a change of tone and it was real. And if you're underestimating that, chances are you're a White male or someone who identifies with them, a straight White male, and never grasped how limiting and limited the view being put down was.



Cedric: And I credit him for that but he was a reformer and, either the way he was set up or the way the system was, the reforms all ran to the right.



Jess: Well he and Al Gore both favored that nonsense of Reinventing Government which I finally read, pulled it off C.I.'s book shelves, and that really explains the attacks on government, on the safety net and everything else. Under Clinton and today. They came in wanting to reform and their reform was privatization and the belief that business could do better than government.



Cedric: Right. We need to be really clear that the Clinton administration, along with NAFTA and other things, allowed privatization. Made it 'bi-partisan.' Gave it a Democratic cloak. FDR must have rolled over in his grave.



Dona: I am loving this discussion and hate to be the bad guy --



Elaine: The grown up.



Dona: Thank you. But I'm aware that when we finish this, we'll still need two hours before everything can be posted due to the technical problems Dallas is having with links currently and the problems we already knew about with regards to titles.



Jim: Blogger/Blogspot won't let us do titles. Our way around that is going to be e-mailing titles to the site, putting titles in posts we e-mail, then clearing out the post and pasting everything in. That's going to take a long time. Dona, who's not speaking?



Dona: I think everyone's doing a good job. I was worried about Cedric getting enough time and then he jumped in. Right now, I think everyone's making strong points but Ava and C.I. are taking notes and they'd know better.



Ava: Cedric made some strong points strongly but that just gave the appearance that he's contributed a lot, the force with which he spoke. Wally and Cedric both should be encouraged to speak more. C.I.'s taking notes and that makes it hard to speak but C.I. needs to grab more as well. Mike, I'm saying, step it up.



Jim: Okay, that was the heads up, we're all grown ups, we're informed, it'll either happen or not. We need to get back to moments. Tossing out to Wally, Cedric or Mike and then it's open to anyone.



Cedric: I'm being motioned to by Wally and Mike. Moments. The Democrats have no ideas. That's been said for over a decade and a half. They're running on fumes from the New Deal or the Great Society. Some would say the Great Society was just an update to the New Deal, those people would probably not be African-Americans. But either of those didn't just happen in DC or in the DNC leadership. With the Great Society, it was a reaction to the Civil Rights movements and other things. With the New Deal a reaction to what was learned from the Depression. What's followed, Republican or Democrat, has been back off and chip away.



Mike: I'll go concrete. Call me Laura Flanders! That's not an insult. But take health care. People are ticked off by the costs, outraged by the system, you name it. People favor universal health care. They favored it before Hillary Clinton presented her plan, which wasn't universal health care, it was managed care. The press, as my mother or Elaine can tell you, did a real good job clamping down by refusing to address what the people overwhelmingly favored. When a moment comes, the people can be so powerful that the press is overridden. So, one instance, we can push there or we can accept whatever comes. We can blow the moment or we can fight.



Wally: And that's not coming about, fighting, with sloppy, open kisses to the Democratic Party. That's not coming about by enlisting into the Party Hack division. We need an independent press. We don't need all these "Ooooh, Obama." We need reality and, regarding The Nation, it's in short supply. We were going through the issues, from the last six months of The Nation, and, yeah, they hit hard on Hillary. Obama? Four or five open mouthed kisses, which was it? Point is, your press or your a fan club. If you're press, start acting like it.



Kat: Dona will kill me for this after, but Wally and Cedric got slammed for an Obama post last week and I want them to put their response on record. I thought they should have posted it.



Cedric: Wally's motioning to me. We got multiple e-mails asking basically, "Who do you think you are to criticize Obama?" Wally and I do joint-posts. Our response, short version, was we are the best qualified to criticize Obama. Wally's White, I'm African American. Together, we are Obama.



Betty: (Laughing) I'm glad Kat got that put in there.



Dona: Me too but everyone's laughing so I'm signaling out C.I. for a comment to get us back on track.



C.I.: Okay. The point is, Howard Zinn, Stanley Aronowitz, Laura Flanders, all in their own way, and more, make the point that people have the power. There are times when people power is up against a wall of indifference. The corporate press doesn't, now or ever, exist to serve the people. Those classified ads don't provide as much money as corporate ads do. They exist to maintain the status quo and, occassionaly, modify it. Howard Zinn . . . I'm not going to say. I wasn't going to say anything unfavorable but Elaine's always loved Zinn so I'll let her pick that up. Stanley says we need theories and we need to get them out. He says the people want them. He's right. Call it theories or proposals, we want them. Laura's actually backing that up. Her travels through the country, her connections with callers from around the country, have shown her what's happening on the ground. She can back up that point in a hundred ways. Tossing to Elaine and I'll grab back if she wants.



Elaine: I will want. So Laura's got the factual proof, Stanley's got the idea that if we put it out there, people will respond and Howard Zinn's point is that the people have more power than they ever know. Or, more Zinn-like, more power than they are ever told. Only The Nation magazine would set out to put Laura Flanders and Stanley Aronowitz in a debate -- and a debate over the Democratic Party no less. That was a waste of both their talents. A real conversation would have teamed them with Zinn and they could have ended with a strategy. None of the three are at odds. They all compliment one another. Call it theory, call it framework, call it dreams, we need it. The moments coming and we're either ready or we're not. Carly Simon, "Let the River Run," "Let all the dreamers wake the nation." That's what we're talking about. Not stop-gap measures. Not reform. This isn't where we take an existing program and dispute what to do -- usually how much to cut from it. This is where what used to be called "people's programs" get established.



Mike: Because, when Dems are slammed for having no ideas, what that's really about is that there's nothing. There's "We'll do this and we'll do that" and it's nothing. It's a tiny raise in the minimum wage. It's not universal health care. Bully Boy grabbed his moment to slam through an attack on education -- with the help of one of my senators, Ted Kennedy -- and to slam through his attack on just about everything. Democrats saying, "We'll roll it back to the way it was" isn't good enough. Things weren't perfect the way they were. Everything had been chipped away and chipped away.



C.I.: So the point, Dona's pointed to me, so the point is this won't come from Democratic leadership. It has to, Howard Zinn's points, come from the people. Laura Flanders notes people in the grass roots are already trying to make changes and doing so on the municipal and state levels. Stanley's saying changes, to be successful, need to be popular and, for that to happen, people need to know about them and know what's at stake. You don't get that in article after article chasing after Obama or anyone. You don't get that by responding. Independent media needs to lay off the counter-narratives and start leading. This is a moment. We can imagine it. When we do, we can make it happen.



Ava: Can I jump in? C.I.'s nodding. That's really all I cared about because if I'm not taking notes and C.I.'s not, no one is. This really goes to our TV commentary. About how awful that Live Earth was. That was reform. "Everybody shop better! We'll stop global warming!" Last time I checked my shopping list, plant stacks pouring pollution wasn't on them. That's all Live Earth could repeatedly offer. "Okay, you're going to use less napkins, you're going to take your own bag to the store, and you're going to use better light bulbs." By all means, inform people of what they can do in their own lives, but don't act like that's the real issue. The real issue is Jose Valdez and Joan Smith and whomever aren't polluting the rivers. We're not seeing the Mississippi resemble the Dead Sea in parts because of that. It's industrial, commercial pollution. Let's all stop being so stupid and stop playing like Al Gore's Give a Hoot, Don't Pollute campaign is about anything other than placing government responsibilities off on the people. He's yet again privatizing. This time he's taking global warming and privatizing it off on citizens.



Jess: That's said wonderfully. And, as a non-Democratic Party person, I'm a Green, that sums it up on every issue. We need to stop this nonsense of, "You are the problem."



Betty: Jess, I know you've got more to say but I'm getting your point ahead of you and want to grab it.



Jess: Go for it.



Betty: The big move in Black politics, usually from outside but Bill Cosby and Obama love to bring it inside, is that our problems are us. We just aren't responsible. Thomas Friedman plays that card with all races in his column. No surprise. So we get, from Cosby and Obama, blame Black fathers. As if Black men are so naturally cold or cowardly that they set out to have children and walk away. Some end up doing that because they are creeps -- I know from personal experience. But that's true of every race. Do not look at what's happening to Black America and try to pin it off as a personal, individual problem. It is a problem that goes to employment and lack of opportunites. And we sure can't count on the Supreme Court under Roberts. But we certainly don't need 'leaders' who can't face reality. Obama's Chicken Sop for the Soul goes down well for some White people. But it's got a bitter after taste for Black people as we hear him repeatedly tell the mainstream, read White, that our problems are because of our personal behaviors. That's not reality. Our personal behaviors, one example, did not create the drug laws. They did not create a judicial system that looks one way towards White people and another towards Black people. They did not create a public that hears Al Gore the third was stoned and traveling with drugs that he didn't have a prescription for but Al Gore says it's a private matter that his adult son was busted so everyone backs off. Don't refuse to note the problems, the systemic problems, and turn around and tell me, "The problem is Black fathers walking out." Some do, believe me, I know. I've got three kids I'm raising myself and their father doesn't see them, doesn't contribute towards them. I know what reality is. I also know, and I hate saying this, that he originally left because, their father, because he couldn't get a job. And I live in one of the more Black friendly areas of the country. A system has been set up where Black men are either thrown in prison or denied opportunites in large numbers. Don't come tell me that it's a personal choice. Once upon a time, we had jobs in this country where we made things. It's a service economy and just when my generation should be benifitting, of all races, because the Baby Boom's stepping down, we find that the government's shipping everything overseas. So quit telling me that the crisis is a sudden refusal of Black men to take their responsibilities seriously when the crisis is caused by the decay of the manufacturing segment in this country, the attacks on unions and a whole lot more.



Elaine: I agree with what Betty said. I'm glad she said it. And I want to note just one example that drives home how much the jobs have left. It's a simple example for anyone who was an adult in the 90s. People of Betty's generation were told it was going to be an employees market. And employers were going to offer this and that. All that really happened was casual Friday and, Rebecca's pointed this out, has anyone noticed the attacks on that from big media?



Rebecca: Oh my God. The ones whining about Darfur coverage, have they noticed how many ads and how many articles have appeared about men not tucking in their shirts? Suddenly that's a serious problem? No. What is it? A sign that the announced employee market has already shifted away. I read fashion all the time but rarely talk about it because people think "It's fashion." It's a shift and a signal. And it's gone beyond the fashion press. And we're dealing with what was supposed to be "Oh, kids can go to work in blue jeans blah blah blah" to this huge shift to uniforms. I'm not talking about business dress. I'm talking about moving to uniforms. Those ugly things that I see someone behind the counter at a fast food place wearing. To give one example, I've got a friend who's still in p.r. and is having to sell this to municipalities, those type of uniforms coming into government jobs. Jobs where you used to be expected to dress nice and 'professional.' And now these city workers are going to have wear uniforms like they're asking, "You want fries with that?" I mean, they're ugly. I've seen photos and seen them up close when she came by to show me and ask, "Should I walk?" I said walk. Don't help sell that crap. But the fashion, pay attention, isn't about professionalism. It's about taking what were respected jobs and changing the clothes so that they're no longer the jobs they were. Sending the message, with other ways to come, that you're nothing but an assembly line worker. I'm talking about people working in offices where, let's say it's a guy, they would probably be expected to wear a dress shirt and a tie with slacks. And they're about to get these really ugly, forest-green is the ugliest color I've seen, uniforms. This will effect the way you see the job and the way you see yourself and that's what the point of it is. So we've already left the employees market. And I'm sitting here thinking, "Oh, we are off topic!" Don't hate me, Dona.



Dona: I won't. But I will toss to C.I. and note this needs to wrap up quick.



C.I.: Just to follow up, Rebecca told me about that. The selling point in the uniforms, how they're being marketed to cities, is that it will make the worker more dispensible. It's prettied up but we don't have time for the long version. And the attack bought their way into a TV show, by the way, just FYI. It didn't just start this year. And money was exchanged for that buy in. But the point is, there's a lot everyone's up against. That's always true. What happens in moments is that people get disgusted and something changes when enough are outraged. The illegal war has already led to many rethinking the issue of the occupied territories. At some point, the people will end the war, they will force Congress to address it. When that moment comes, the immediate reaction isn't, "Oh, let's all go away." The reaction is, as in Nine to Five, "We've done this, but we could do a lot more." That's how moments are created. The people are disgusted. They push to change one thing and others are carried along. I am really short handing this and my apologies but I know Dona wants this wrapped up so it's simplified to the max. We're approaching a moment. The population is not tipping against the war, America is against the war. An independent press would use that as a calling card. They would work that repeatedly and use the attention from that as a spotlight for other areas. An independent press would stop responding and start leading.



Jim: C.I.'s looking over at Dona so I'll wrap up. Don't e-mail to say, "Please don't shut down in November of 2008." We may not. If C.I. does, we probably will but maybe C.I. won't. Regardless, that's not the issue. The issue is we need to use our time wisely. All of us, each of us. In terms of those of us working on sites, we're going to be strong voices. If you're the press and you don't like it, too bad. And, let me do an aside that will have Dona rolling her eyes, if I hear one more idiot complain about Rebecca, some drive by always does, you don't know what she's doing. Rebecca worked in p.r. for years. She knows the hard sell, she knows the soft sell. If you're wondering, "Why did she write about that?" focus on yourself. She knows what she's doing and she regularly gets points across to her audience, largely high school and middle school, that have me shaking my head in amazement. A lot of times, I see her posts as fables.



Kat: Agreed and I'm jumping in here. If one more man e-mails about Rebecca I'm going to let it rip at my site. Like Jim's saying, Rebecca's geared to the youngest audience of any of us. She knows what she's doing. She also is a new mother. If you're obsessing over what she writes and find it lacking (a) you don't know what you're talking about and (b) go away. She doesn't do one post. Rebecca's laying groundwork all the time. Two weeks later, you're reading something and, if you really pay attention, you grasp she set that up long ago. She's either the most brilliant person I know or the most devious.



Rebecca: Thank you both.



Dona: I'm not going to complain about that. Other things but not that. Rebecca tosses out what seems the most random line. She returns to it. It seems like trivia or gossip. Then she zooms in on a subject, apparently unrelated, weeks later and you realize she guided your reaction to it from long ago. But I am going to wrap up. Our time is likely limited. We will likekly go dark. We are not going to waste our time being cheerleaders for Democratic leadership. That's not our role and it shouldn't be. Our job is to press for change. Our job is to push and push and if you don't like our tone, I believe we inform you to go elsewhere at the top of our site. Our job is to expand not to shrink. We either take on what needs to be addressed or we write dopey things like cat blogging. Hide behind us if you like. Say "Oh I'm reasoned, look at those lefties over at The Third Estate Sunday Review!" But we are here to push the conversation to the left. A lot of cowards have allowed the conversation to move center-right so it's important that we push hard. Do your job and you won't get called out. Don't do your job and you will. And we don't need to hear your whines. We believe a moment's approaching and we're not going to waste time with "Oh the up side of this is blah blah" or "Well, Dems have a really hard time in Congress . . ." You have accepted limitations on who you are and what you can ask for. We're not accepting those. We are fighting for better.

Got a feeling that you're playing some game with me, babe

The coverage there of the Nation is warranted and has its place, but its also riddled with errors and inaccuracies; the "count" makes a very valid point, but its also compounded by mistakes that detract from its impact; it would be a step to at least have a channel to challenge glaring errors when they appear.



So wrote The Nation, to C.I., about us, last week.



If you're starting with this feature, you may wonder about "it would be a step to at least have a channel to challenge . . ." What's that about?



The Nation magazine wants to write about us errors while complaining that we don't allow comments or post an e-mail address.



"You do post your e-mail address!"



Yes, we know. That would be an error on the part of The Nation . . . in an e-mail where they complain about our alleged "glaring errors."



To steal from Phoebe (Friends), we respond, "Hello Monica, this is kettle. You're black."



And pot, er, The Nation has many other errors as well, don't they. We're not going to list all but, let's see, which one stands out the most of all we've noted in the last almost a year?



Gee, how about Christopher Hayes' claim that John Kerry made a statement at the DNC convention in 2004 that he didn't make. John Kerry, readers, made that statement where? In an advertisement that ran in Iowa.



Did he say that at the convention?



No.



Is The Nation aware of that?



Yes.



Have they ever corrected it?



No.


Got a feeling that you're playing some game with me, babe
Got a feeling that you just can't see
If you're entertaining any thought that you're gaining
By causing me all of this pain
And making me blue
The joke's on you.
-- "Got A Feeling," written by John Phillips and Denny Doherty, appears on the Mamas and the Papas' If You Can Believe Your Eyes and Ears.

And how do we know The Nation knows about that error?



Well, we knew they knew in December. And, of course, we got the admission in January.



But, shh, on the down low.



The Nation thinks they know everything. They don't even know how to find an e-mail address.

So let's leave comments and participants in the round-robin out of it. Yes, The Nation magazine, one of you has participated in a roundtable for the gina & krista round-robin. (C.I. did check with ___ to make sure that could be noted. On speaker phone, we were given permission to note it here.)



They want to lecture us about errors? They don't know the first thing about us, do they?



As we stated in:

"Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you must have a penis"
"Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis"
"
Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis"
"
Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis"
"Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis"
"
Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis"
"
Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis"
"Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis"
"Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis"
"Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis"



We're sure we have errors. We're human. We make mistakes. Point it out and it will be corrected. (We've got a link that doesn't work that we're correcting from the feature above -- correcting only at this site -- and also a date issue on one "Nation Stats" -- the date's correct at the link, it's not correct in the summary of the previous links.)



But here's the thing, "What errors?"



The Nation says we are "riddled with errors and inaccuracies" and that we have "glaring errors". Okay.



Well where are they?



The Nation never says.



But we're told they're pissed off about a parody feature. Hint, something set years in the future is parody. Take the stick out of your ass -- unless it's there because you enjoy it -- and get a sense of humor. Isn't it funny, C.I. says keep this part brief, that someone with The Nation attacked C.I. publicly well over a year ago and C.I.'s never commented on it. C.I.'s never said a bad word against the person -- not even to any of us. But do a Gilligan's Island parody and suddenly check out who's all thin skinned.



Golly gee, if you've finally managed to reach us, through C.I., and want to tell us we have tons of errors, you might think that in your long e-mail (67K), you could take a moment to note even one error. 67K. And not one error noted.



We have typos. Tons of them. We're sure there are errors. But if you're going to accuse someone of repeated and glaring errors, it's probably a smart idea to note at least one.



Like we have with Christopher Hayes. We could note more from him (and have before) but we've really tried to avoid the issue of Christopher Hayes in the last few months. (And he's not the only in the magazine with errors.)



But, a question. Christopher Hayes writes a feature and what happens then?



Does Christopher Hayes rush it into print?



No.



See the magazine has a staff. A paid staff. And guess what, it's someone's responsibility to check for errors.



How hard is it to find out what John Kerry said in his acceptance speech at the 2004 DNC convention?



It's not very hard. We managed to do it and we're known (at The Nation) for "glaring" errors, for "repeated' ones.



Strange, isn't it?

A bit of free advice (vice, vice) We'll tell it to you now (tell it to you now)

Its odd, and it turns the "third estate" from something that is really leading the way on discussing something important (representation of women in print in the Nation) to something that feels oddly ... personal, or like a grudge more than an intelligent discussion.


So writes The Nation to us (via C.I.). First off, you've got a lot of nerve pretending to want an intelligent discussion when you feature the scribbles of AlterPunk.



But let's get serious.



We've been accused of a "war with The Nation" for some time.



Ironically, no one ever notes when they were briefly not linkable.



Let's start with that story. When The Nation was trying to beef up their online presence, they utilized Technorati. Tags. If a website mentioned The Nation, tagged the article and was read by Technorati (most aren't read by it), if you clicked on an article at The Nation and it had been commented on somewhere online (that met the qualifications we just noted), you'd be listed on their web page (most recent were listed, you could click for additional posts).



In this community, Rebecca discovered Technorati. She says we're making her sound like an explorer. We're not trying to. It already existed but she's the one who found out about us among our group. She insisted we all use it. Including C.I. It would help the community. C.I. doesn't want drive-by readers and already had more than enough attention for The Common Ills but, Rebecca argued, "If you tag, it could draw attention to any of the community sites." C.I. tagged. We all did. Even this site. Rebecca, Elaine and this site were never read by Techonrati and we dropped the tags. Kat, Betty and Cedric were read. Briefly. Technorati would read their tags and include them. Then they weren't. Cedric stopped tagging (before he and Wally started doing joint- posts). Wally was never read and stopped tagging early on. Mike and C.I.'s tags were and are still read. It is a pain in the butt to do tags. C.I. points out, "I didn't want to and now I'm stuck with it." (And if someone's quoted in an entry at The Common Ills and doesn't also get a tag, believe it or not, some will e-mail to complain. Professional journalists will e-mail that they were quoted, named and linked but they, heavens no!, didn't get a tag. It really is a pain in the ass and Ava usually replies to those e-mailing C.I. about this with two words: "Poor baby.")



Because C.I. tagged, when there was a problem, we all got e-mails. The problem? The Nation wasn't reading their tags. Bloggers, small ones, were noting their articles and tagging and not getting the links via The Nation's articles. They were furious. They staged a three week no-link to The Nation (and some never linked again). Ty estimates this was over thirty but less than fifty e-mails in all. But we honored the strike. (We always honor strikes.)



When it was over, we went back to linking. It's strange that so many want to note an undeclared war (on our part) and never notice that first incident.



Do we have a grudge against The Nation? (Mike asks, "Do they ask Stanley Aronowitz that, or just us?") Here's reality for The Nation. This site linked to it more in 2005 or 2006 than most sites ever did. Even if you don't count the multiple links to Elizabeth Holtzman's original article on impeachment by C.I., The Common Ills probably linked to The Nation more than any site online. That was partly due to the fact that friends with the magazine asked for things to be linked to (but it's also true, C.I. only linked to things worth linking to).



Now The Nation, in the same time period, linked to us how many times? If you guessed zero, you are correct. So, to pull from Sharon Stone, "Don't ask me what my problem with Ahnuld is, ask him what his problem with me is!"



As did C.I., we noted here that the impeachment talk in print in 2006 was started by Elizabeth Holtzman. For those who don't remember, she led the way. Several men followed with print articles. Several men were being credited for starting for the impeachment talk with their print articles. The only reason the record is semi-correct is because some of us repeatedly noted that Holtzman started it.



We noted The Nation repeatedly in our first edition. We noted it repeatedly throughout 2005 and 2006 until that summer when Iraq fell off the radar and the issue of the low amount of women being published was raised.



So it's a bit strange that all this time later, they want to show up and claim we have some personal grudge with The Nation.



We actually (and actively) sat on criticism about The Nation prior to that out of respect for C.I.'s fondness for Katrina vanden Heuvel. When that became an issue, we all decided we weren't going to be gatekeepers.



We've called out Amy Goodman (we've also praised her) and she's never e-mailed to whine about what we wrote. (She's never e-mailed period.) We now have a very small list of people we won't call out. There are no bigger whiners than thoses at The Nation.



The e-mail we quoted from above is from a whiner. How do we know that?



He (it's a man) wants to set the guidelines for what we can or cannot do.



Guess we missed those paychecks signed by KvH, huh?

A bit of free advice (vice)
We'll tell it to you now (nice, twice).
If you've got some habits
Some people won't allow (won't allow, allow)
Be cool; be clean
If you know what I mean.
-- "Free Advice," written by John and Michelle Phillips, recorded by the Mamas and the Papas for The Papas & The Mamas [and no, The Nation won't "know what I mean"]


If someone thinks they can dictate how we'll write, they must be paying us to write, right?



One of our few off limits groups is Media Matters. We've avoided calling them out even when we disagree. Why? Because the left (and MM is more Democratic than left) has been cowardly for too long. If MM ever goes overboard on a topic (if), we say it's long overdue and applaud their energy. The Insanity Crowd (Spinsanity) for too long represented the left with their faux b.s. It was weak and it was geared to MSM coverage and attention.



Media Matters is needed. We applaud their spirit. We applaud their passion.



The Nation apparently thinks that conversations can only take place in one manner and that they get to decide on the rules.



Doesn't work that way.



We don't work for The Nation.



And we have always argued that the answer in democracy is more voices not less and more voices speaking their truths in their voices.



But The Nation wants to tell us that we need to speak their way.



No, we don't and no, we won't.



Who's really out of bounds here?



The Nation is.



They want to show up over two years after we started, after we've built up a sizeable audience and tell us what to do.



Who the hell is The Nation to tell us anything?



Do they not get how offensive what we've quoted above is?



Now they can ask one of their writers that Ava tore into when he whined too often (yes, it was a man) to The Common Ills and he can repeat what Ava said which was, "We're focused on ending the illegal war."



We don't have time for the glad handing. We don't pretend to float on clouds and be above it all.



When we've gone to campuses with C.I., we hear the same gripes about The Nation that we've offered here and the only thing is, we heard the gripes before we wrote them. This site is run by Jim, Dona, Ty, Jess, Ava and C.I. All but C.I. were college students when it started. In addition, Mike and Wally are college students. We see the same things that other students committed to ending the illegal war see. We feel the same way.



If the writer of the e-mail wants to apologize for assuming that we needed his direction or his orders, we'll be happy to forgive and move on. But as it stands now, he's insulted us. He can have all the other nice words in the e-mail and just include that portion and he's insulted us.



Unlike AlterPunk, we haven't called for a Ps & Qs online. We say, let it rip. If that's what you want to do, do it. If it's not, don't. But write in your own voice. Speak your own truths.



That's why the comments above are so damn offensive to us. We'd expect it from The New Repbulic(an) a few years back. We would have never, even at this late date, assumed The Nation would ever think they could get away with telling other people how to write.



Rebecca, who is not a college student, says, "It's as though they arrived without an invitation at my front door, stepped inside and began insulting my decor. It's flat out rude. No one asked their opinion of what we wrote and no one asked for instructions."



Elaine (using her field, we're sure ) points out an obvious: The Third Estate Sunday Review is not only reduced to Third Estate, it's in parenthesis and lower case. The Nation, on the other hand isn't in parenthesis or in lower case. What's really being said with that?



If we hear from The Nation again, we hope they will address that because we're reading it as an insult.



Betty notes that in the last mailbag, Rebecca talked about the summer thus far, for her, personally. She noted her newborn child and she noted the illegal war.



The war is personal.



We're sorry that it's not to The Nation, but we take it personally. As citizens of the US, we are responsible for an ongoing illegal war and it is our obligation to try and end it. It is our duty. We take it very personally.



To the issue of a "grudge," we didn't even see that movie. We joke, we kid. But a grudge? Our main goal is to end the illegal war. If you're in our way, you're in our way. A writer for The New Republic(an) (who, ironically, first wrote us in July 2006 telling us that we always praised The Nation and, quote, "they're not that perfect") writes this site every three to four weeks. Sometimes he includes links to the magazine. Always, he asks why doesn't he get links, what does he have to do to get links? Get serious about the illegal war.



We wish he would. We stand opposed to this day to the attacks on Arundhati Roy. But the rag could change into a mag. If it did, we'd link. C.I. has always said no to links to Newsweek (for their attack on Jean Seberg among many other things) but C.I. linked to it repeatedly last month (all one column). We'd written off In These Times but recent developments (and advocacy by one person with the magazine) are making us think we will be linking to it in the future.



We may hold a personal grudge against a person forever if it's warranted. We may not. But an outlet? You're the one, the man e-mailing from The Nation, that's personalizing.



Even with the fallout The Nation's seen recently (before we ever started calling out), if the magazine got serious, we'd link to it. We avoided linking to the editorials on the illegal war because we saw where that led. The magazine got their praise and proceeded to ignore the war. No site but C.I.'s will note any fund raising appeals from The Nation but The Nation could be linked to again if it got serious about the war and stopped this centrist crap.



This site was started by Jim, Dona, Ty, Jess, Ava and C.I. (C.I. didn't come on board for full credit as a core sixer until last year.) Let's talk about The Nation for a minute because it may be past time. We're focusing on Jim, Dona, Ty, Jess and Ava here.



The magazine that thinks we have a grudge? One of the five of us has had a letter printed in your magazine praising a story. Did you know that?



No, because you don't know what you're talking about you're just assuming.



Before this site started, what were Jim and Dona doing? Regularly calling out CJR's then Campaign Desk for refusing to cover The Nation. Calling them out in all kinds of ways. One way you could check that is to go to CJR Daily and, if they still have their old discussion pages, you could look for Jim and Dona who regularly posted comments noting the fact that The Nation was ignored in "Blog reports" and "Magazine reports" and in every other way.



When this site started, that was carried over and you could check our parodies of CJR (here and here) for that as well.



So you really don't know what the hell you are talking about.



The five of the core six were like every other college student in 2004, reading The Nation, being thankful for hard hitting coverage of Iraq, praising Naomi Klein through the roof, praising many.

That's reality. Once this site started, we continued to praise The Nation.



The Nation doesn't deserve praise now. That's our opinion and you can disagree but before you toss around words like "grudge," you need to know what the hell you're talking about and, frankly, you don't.



Want to return to those days of yore? Get serious about the damn war.



C.I. pointed it out weeks ago. This silence from so many on the left (or, worse, thinking dropping back to what Judith Miller did in 2002 and 2003 counts for 'coverage') is allowing a lot of space for the center and the right. Both are interested in selling the war as 'won' and the occupation as 'lost.' That's why we use the term "war" here. If they can sell one phase as won, that means they have a chance of convincing Americans that we can win illegal wars and should win them, we just need to fine tune our occupation skills!



The left can't afford to be silent.



When the left makes like a travel study and covers every other topic in the world but Iraq, you better believe it creates huge spaces for the illegal war to be rewritten and to continue.



The current makeup of The Nation is embarrassing. But, historically, the magazine's bounced back from shoddy phases. It may happen again and, sorry, but you're honestly not important enough for a grudge.



If any of this is confusing to you, maybe next time you'll do a little research before you write an insulting e-mail that questions our character, questions our writing, questions our commitment to feminism and oh so much more. Your e-mail was insulting.



But the biggest insult was your mistake that we wanted to be on your 'level' that you (wrongly) assume we value. It's a funny sort of 'level'. It was nowhere to be seen when your magazine ripped apart Janeane Garofalo over a joke. It was nowhere to be seen when you ripped apart Sarah Chayes and Ann Jones. It was nowhere to be seen when you published that screed against Joan Mellen and others. So if you think you have a 'level,' how about you start rising to it and stay there consistently instead of lecturing us?



We know we're not supposed to talk about that, especially not about Garofalo. We know the fallout that came from that and let's go on the record and say that The Nation earned that fallout and more. That wasn't just not rising to the level you seem to think the magazine addresses from, it was a brutal stab in the back to one of the magazine's strongest supporters. If you've forgotten, until that stab in the back, Katrina vanden Heuvel was a regular guest each week and Garofalo went out of her way to be supportive no matter what was said. And her thanks for that is to be ridiculed as a second rate hack?



We honestly believe she should have cancelled the next day interview with Katrina vanden Heuvel's husband. Instead, Janeane Garofalo rose to a higher level than the magazine and did the interview.



But let's be real clear, your suggestion that there's a level is not only insulting to everyone, the laughable claim that the magazine's ever maintained a level of discourse is a flat out lie and we're too wise to buy into that myth.

You're so vain
I bet you think this song is about you
You're so vain
You probably think this song is about you
Don't you, don't you, don't you
-- Carly Simon, "You're So Vain," appears first on her album No Secrets



You're not preaching to the converted, you're preaching to the observant and we know the acutalities.



As for our risk in leading . . . We already lead. We don't need the permission of The Nation to lead or the suggestions of how to lead. We lead by default in many cases because the so-called left drops Iraq all the time. We don't.

Get on your pony and ride, Get on your pony and ride

Frankly the most irritating thing about that site is the lack of an email or even comments. I think there is some cowardice in failing to have ANY mode for response or feedback, so I appreciate that you have an email address you provide.



The Nation wrote that last Monday (to C.I.) about us. Well, get on your pony and ride. Get on your pony and ri-i-i-ide. ("Too Late," written by John Phillips, recorded by the Mamas and the Papas on The Papas & The Mamas.)



First of all, we do have an e-mail address posted on our profile.



C.I. got an "Oops!" e-mail after the original from The Nation noting that we did have one.



After we were said to be cowards. The Nation called us cowards? Fine by us. They did the same with Ehren Watada. We'll happily stand with Ehren Watada any day, any hour.



Here's the deal on the e-mail address. It was up when this site started. Awhile back, Blogger/Blogspot made everyone using them switch to Beta. All community sites switched to Beta. When we did, it disappeared the e-mail address from our profiles (all profiles). We never go to them, we had no idea it had happened.



An organization wrote C.I. (in May) about something at another site and noted that there was no e-mail address posted for the site. Jess read the e-mail (Jess and Ava are among those helping C.I. with e-mails), called C.I. who had a few minutes before speaking with some college students about the illegal war. C.I. gave a bit of reply. Ava helped Jess round out some points because she knew what C.I. was talking about. But on that day, all sites (except Kat's) were informed that there was no e-mail address.



As Mike noted that same day, all anyone had to do to contact Rebecca (that's what the e-mail was about) was search her site's name and e-mail address ("Sex and Politics and Screeds and Attitude" "e-mail") on Google and the address was right there. You didn't even have to click on a result for the search page. When Jess read the e-mail from The Nation, the first thing he did was search "The Third Estate Sunday Review" "e-mail" on Google and there our address was. The second thing listed. And, no, you didn't have to leave the search page to find it.



The Nation wrote last Monday which was July. Our e-mail address has been back up since May. Others at The Nation have written to us in the last six months, readers have written us and all have apparently been able to do a search to find an address.



For whatever reason, The Nation couldn't even click on our profile to get our address which was up last Monday, was up all last month and was up for some of May.



We could call names here right back at The Nation, but let's move on.



We're cowardly for not having an e-mail address (we do have one) and for not allowing comments?



We don't allow comments. We've been over this before.



You'd think the e-mailer would have paid attention to what hurt Cindy Sheehan online, The Nation did write about it after all, but apparently, paying attention isn't a strong suit.



The Common Ills was the first community site. It is not a blog. When it went up, C.I. thought it would be. Comments were allowed. (Sorry to our older and recent readers, we've been over this ground before, but some, like The Nation, are really slow.) Why did comments get pulled from The Common Ills?



Because readers (they were readers then) complained. Specifically African-American readers complained. Keesha led the charge but she was not alone. She'd seen how life is online. She knew how this ended. C.I. e-mailed back that comments would be pulled, that there was no reason for anyone ever to be hurt but, "give me some time to figure out how to do that because I don't know how right now." Two days later, two Blue Dogs who haunted the comment threads let rip at Keesha with racist remarks, including the n-word. C.I. learned in thirty minutes how to close comments. They closed and they've been closed ever since.



Stan Goff has written of how women can end up feeling that they're not welcomed in the commenting. We're glad he has. But what we've heard repeatedly is that African-Americans really aren't welcomed.



Betty can tell you that. She's talked about this, she's blogged about this. She did so last in May at Rebecca's site. (Betty blogs there from time to time. She's also Rebecca's official guest blogger.) She went to many 'left' sites (really Democratic ones) and was welcomed. As long as she never wrote about an issue to African-Americans. If she did and pointed out that the Dems weren't especially strong on it, it was time to heap on the scorn and the ridicule. We didn't know Betty when we started this site. We knew why the comments were closed at The Common Ills from reading the site. We also pumped C.I. that first weekend but really didn't have to. Once C.I. started explaining it, Ty jumped in with his own experiences.



So there were never going to be comments here.



Only one community site allows comments. That's Cedric's site. Every now and then Keesha will post a comment. Most members don't post comments. (Cedric got seveal comments in May.) Cedric's been through the same crap Ty and Betty (and Keesha and Carl and Demetrika and others) have. He checked, when he started his Blogspot/Blogger site. He was already doing his site at Blogdrive. He was already getting the racist e-mails. He announced he'd be switching in the gina & krista round-robin and revealed he was thinking about allowing comments because he thought/hoped it would cut down on the racist e-mails. He shared three of the e-mails so everyone would know what was coming in. His thinking was that if comments were there, some of those types might leave a comment and might curb their racism for public consumption. Gina and Krista polled and not one member objected to Cedric having comments.



No other site does.



Oh, you're thinking, those are old stories. How old are they? Cindy Sheehan, in her announcement that she was regrouping, noted that Democratic Underground had vicious comments about her. DU staff (we're not sure if they're paid or not) responded to note their support for Cindy Sheehan. Those were people leaving comments, that didn't reflect DU.



But here's the thing. A few weeks later, when a woman (presumably African-American) shared her thoughts on Hillary Clinton (mild compared to anything we've ever posted here), she began to get attacked in the thread. F-you was repeated over and over.



We were able to see what Betty has so often described. As long as you don't note the obvious, you're welcome. Raise one issue and you're not slammed, you're attacked.



That woman was attacked. And, just like Betty, she was a Democrat. She was being attacked by other Democrats with the sort of venom you'd expect to be tossed at Jonah Goldberg. Instead it was heaped on her repeatedly.



That's when Democratic Underground got delinked from The Common Ills. Originally, it was offered along with The Green Party. Now it's just The Green Party.



That's no reflection on DU staff. They weren't doing it. But that was the mob mentality that rips apart African-Americans online. The rest of us never doubted Betty, Cedric or Ty's stories. We believed them. But seeing it play out was so different than just hearing about it.

Community members began e-mailing C.I. repeatedly about it when it started. C.I. even commented in a snapshot to the effect of "I've heard about the e-mails, when I'm at a computer, it will be delinked." And it was.



This is a really ugly side of online life. The woman at DU noted she was going to vote for whomever won the Democratic Party (vote in the general election) but shared she didn't trust Hillary Clinton. That led to not a response or two, which would be one thing, but a mob typing away "F-you" and worse.



This is a very real issue. We've heard about from African-American community members. We've heard about it from Betty, Cedric, Ty and other friends. And we saw it at DU.



Cedric thinks it was "about a year ago" that he noted here how one of his relatives wouldn't even go anywhere online now that wasn't "an African-American site." He got tired of it and washed his hands of the other sites. He's a political person. But he can't take the dog pile. In his case, he 'dared' to note that Jesse Jackson had done many good things. But this was when Jesse Jackson was speaking out on Terry Shiavo (and had the non-Democratic side) so he (and Jackson) got ripped apart in a thread. It was vicious and it was ugly. He didn't cry. He just grasped that African-Americans weren't really welcome. A White person could, and often did, sing Wesley Clark's praises (despite the 90s) and nothing ever came of that. But posting, "I don't think it's fair to call Jesse a sell out" resulted in a dog pile.



Why is that? And why are African-Americans more likely to experience that? Gina and Krista did a round-table on that last September. The general consensus was that most going to a thread hopes that others will agree or at least consider a point. They think they're among friends. That's everyone, regardless of race. But, this was the consensus of the roundtable, what happens is some people are suspect. So when an African-American makes a comment, even though they seemed friendly, suddenly they become the 'other' and the dog pile takes place out of shock that they don't agree on every issue 100%.



What's happening, regardless of why, is that some (we'd argue, a lot) of African-Americans are getting the message that you're welcome as long as you bite your tongue. Biting your tongue means every presumed White person can say who they are for and why (even cutting down another candidate) but if you are for, for instance, John Edwards and are asked about, for instance, Hillary and share you don't like her, you've 'opened' yourself up to the attacks.



The so-called free exchange isn't taking place and a lot of sites (Gina and Krista compiled a list) are seen as unwelcoming for African-Americans. That includes a huge chunk of the 'big sites.'



DU may or may not have cleaned up that thread. But it did exist (and may still) and we all saw it. The staff does some strong writing, some amazing writing. They also follow the news closely.

But it wasn't about the staff, it was about "Are we a welcoming site to people on the left or not?" (C.I.) There was no way to continue linking without ignoring the very strong feelings of TCI community members (of all races). The staff wasn't the issue but that didn't change what happened in the threads.



So the next time before The Nation calls someone a coward for not having comments, they might try learning why. We don't have comments (except Cedric) and the reason is not 'cowardice'. The reason is to be welcoming to all members. Keesha's gone through this and we're so late (in writing) that we could call her for a comment without worrying about waking her.



"When I saw that," at DU, "it didn't just make me angry for the woman. I was angry for her. But it also brought back all the times it had happened to me. I don't know how to explain it other than to say it's like you walk into a room and everyone smiles. Then a minute later, when you've got your guard down and think you can just talk, all the sudden you're being attacked and realize, 'No, I can't really be honest. Not unless I want to be attacked.' If you've been through it, any time you see it happen to someone else, you probably relive it."



Note that Keesha was fighting the Blue Dogs when they were commenting at The Common Ills with their crap about how there's nothing more beautiful than a Blue Dog Democrat and blah, blah, blah. They were doing what they always do ('Try to take control of a cool site and destroy it," says Keesha). We're glad she was fighting for the space that was her's. (C.I. will tell you, members deserve all the credit for The Common Ills and that Keesha, more than anyone, determined what it is now. She fought hard and continues to.) We're sad that she had to.



We're sad every time we write about this topic because it means someone will e-mail about how it happened to them. Then we'll realize it's even bigger than we thought. The thing is, all of us, even Betty, Cedric and Ty, think we get it. And then we find out it's even worse.



So, to The Nation, we'll say you didn't know what you were talking about when you wrote in July and stated we didn't have an e-mail address up (we did, it had been back up for over a month by that time and it was always searchable). We'll say you not only didn't know anything about us when you slammed us for not having comments, you also didn't now about a very real problem online. But, hey, pretend it doesn't exist and maybe it will go away. That seems to be the magazine's approach to the illegal war as well.

Get on your pony and ride
Get on your pony and ri-i-i-ide.

Boys & Girls . . . have a good time together

[The title is from "Boys & Girls Together," recorded by the Mamas and the Papas for Deliver and written by John Phillips. All features this edition were supposed to have Mamas and Papas references in their titles except "Highlights" and the TV commentary. We're all tired which is how Jim screwed it up. We can't get into the title box so we can't fix it. Jess is trying to be forgiving.]


So, in a six month period, The Nation ran 181 more men than they did women. Did you know that was our fault? Apparently it is.



The Nation notified us (via an e-mail to C.I. last week): "The imbalance of men to women appearing in print is disturbing and should be corrected; but the extent to which 'third estate' absolutely excoriates the women who DO write is also problematic. There is a cry and a call for more women to write, and then a disproportionate level of criticism of women who write in the magazine than men."



This was the thing that upset C.I. Not get upset and tell them they are full of sh*t. If a complaint comes in, C.I. considers it. If the complaint seems sincere, C.I. takes it so seriously that it's sick to the stomach time. Now the rest of us called it what it was ("sh*t") immediately. C.I., between trips to the bathroom to throw up, kept ticking off the writers and trying to see if that could be true?


It wasn't.



Unless they're saying AlterPunk's a girl? AlterPunk, we didn't say that. In fact, we've acknowledged your wee wenus before. (Remember the parody "The Elector"?)



Were we really unfair to women? Were we focused on them to the extent of ignoring the men?


We've reviewed the topic at length. (After being sick repeatedly and reviewing, C.I. knew it wasn't true Tuesday night.)


Let's talk reality. In "The Nation Stats" figures, any one was up for grabs. That's the last feature we would do (yes, even after the editorials), we were all tired. But read over them. Very few women writers get more than their name and the title of their piece.


The magazine has three columnists who are women: Katha Pollitt, Patricia J. Williams and Naomi Klein.

Katha Pollitt. Pollitt was first critiqued here negatively when we included Virginity or Death! in a book discussion. We immediately included another collection by her in the next book discussion (and critiqued it favorably). That was back when we were Nation cheerleaders. Those days are gone. Page 45 of her book she mocks Kweisi Mfume (then president of the NAACP) for being bothered by the representation of African-Americans on TV. (Pollitt calls it the "absence of black faces.") To back up her point (or hide behind Black face), she mentions the centrist African-American who butters her bread with attacks on Cynthia McKinney among others.

As Betty can tell you, that centrist columnist cannot move freely around Atlanta. "Black people have her number and have had it for years," says Betty.

But let's get to the issue Katha Pollitt says is a non-issue. Katha's White daughter certainly got to see herself growing up on screen. So maybe Katha doesn't grasp the importance. Cedric, Betty and Ty did but, then, they aren't White. Now Katha can talk all her love of The Ego of Us All (didn't write about Coretta though) but is Katha available when Betty's daughter next asks where the people like her are on TV?

Betty's oldest son finally wised up to the score. She now lets both of her sons watch Everybody Hates Chris and the youngest "really is too young for that show but he kept asking and finally said 'It's got people like me on it'." Her daughter, the youngest of the three, has been lulled (briefly) into believing Betty that some of PBS' various animated animals are actually African-American.

So since Katha doesn't think it's a pressing issue, could she please give Betty her phone number because her daughter's about to get to the age her sons were when they finally started asking the very serious question as they saw one program after another without a person of color in the lead and sometimes without even a person of color in the cast.



"She can dismiss it all she wants, but if it was the other way around and it was her child or children, she'd realize how serious this is. It's true of the cartoons, it's true of PBS, it's true of all TV. This isn't a minor issue and I find it insulting that she treated it as something to laugh about. I think White people should think twice before they attempt to tell people of color that representation doesn't matter and that includes David Corn," says Betty.



So that's a very serious issue. It's a serious one to Betty, it's serious to Ty and Cedric and it's serious to all of us. That stood out more than anything else in her book to Ty, Cedric and Betty.



Then there's the issue of what Pollitt has elected to write about. Iraq? "BE HONEST." That's what she said when she finally included the topic in one paragraph of a column. The woman who hadn't written about Iraq in 2006 (slamming CODEPINK isn't writing about Iraq especially when Pollitt ignored Abeer at the same time). In 2007, she finally wrote a column about Iraq. But Abeer Qassim al-Janabi got her first mention in the magazine not by Pollitt but by Alexander Cockburn ("Here Comes Another 'Crime Wave'," April 2nd). Cockburn contribute two paragraphs on Abeer and one of her gang-rapists (Paul Cortez). Pollitt finaly got around to writing about Abeer for the May 28, 2007 issue. Here is her commentary on Abeer in full:



Think of Abeer Qassim al-Janabi, the 14-year-old girl raped and then murdered with her family by US soldiers in Mahmoudiya in March of last year.


Abeer was gang-raped. And an article about violence against women in Iraq might need to mention that both her mother and her five-year-old sister were killed. Seven sentences are spent on the "Romeo & Juliet" love affair of a 17-year-old woman and how she was stoned to death. An Iraqi killed by other Iraqis, Pollitt can call out. (Even though, outside of the footage of the stonings, some say the facts on that remain murky.) But US soldiers that are supposed to be guarding an area instead leering at and touching (Steven D. Green ran his fingers on her) a 14-year-old Iraqi girl, unnerving her so that she tells her parents who make plans for her to leave the area but, before she can, the US soldiers put together the plan to gang-rape her and kill her as well as her family? That's reduced to a single sentence and goes into print a year after Ellen Knickmeyer and others have already told Abeer's story. Pollitt was too busy bird-dogging CODEPINK for bird-dogging Hillary Clinton to write about Abeer last year.



Recently, Katha Pollitt wanted to get down to brass tacks and decry the lack of focus on economics. What is that? In bar tabs? What we mean by that is she also offers her endoresement of the Mud Flap Gals and, yes, we will call that out. The raunch culture passing itself off as feminist is something we'll call out.



But outside of noting how sad it is that a grown woman 'learns' something constantly from a site that's 2006 sole contribution on Iraq appears to be noting only that a book entitled C*nt was brought into an Abu Ghraib hearing (by a woman), we've only said "Sista Katha" and that's in regards to her dismissive treatment of the issue of representation.



Patricia J. Williams. Before Patti went goo-goo for Obama, she never had a harsh word or even a joke from this site. Apparently passion dulls her senses because she's gone all mushy since going public with her crush on Obama. The turning point for Patti came with that embarrassing interview on KPFA (and, no, it wasn't Andrea Lewis' fault). Now we aren't insisting that Patti put down People and pick up Essence, but we do think she needs to be aware of African-American writers. When she stated that only the likes of Fox 'News' was questioning Obama's commitment to race, she revealed she doesn't read Glen Ford, Bruce Dixon and Margaret Kimberely. Her loss. They have more passion and fire than she ever will. In the same interview, a woman from a Middle Eastern country phoned in to talk about how she saw Obama's stance on the illegal war. Patti made like the Cookies ("Don't Say Nothing Bad About My Baby"), cutting off the woman and insisting Obama was against the war while offering as proof that he didn't vote for the authorization in 2002. Now, not having gone slack jawed over the sight of Obama, we're aware he didn't vote for it, he wasn't in the Senate then. How Patti thought offering that up as proof of Obama's strong anti-war credentials would sway an audience, we don't know. Patti came off foolish, light headed and elists when she offered the Harvard Law Review as proof of why Obama was fit to be president. After the anger subsided, we all burned that on disc and we listen to it the way we would a Nichols & May CD. It's hilarious. Cedric is still furious that Patti thought African-Americans and dogs could be compared. Cedric says, "I don't know if she thought it was a step up from gorilla but this African-American never sees 'progress' when someone compares my race to animals. It's sad that a law professor can't see the historic problems with that sort of comparison in this country."



Naomi Klein? Never wrote a word against her. C.I. did note at The Common Ills (we believe it's in April) that a college crowd brought up the fact that Klein's not written about Iraq since returning to the magazine and that the crowd isn't planning on Klein's forthcoming book as a result. Klein left to write that book with a reputation for being one of the strongest writers on the topic of Iraq. That was years ago now.



Who does that leave? Katrina vanden Heuvel is editor and she is publisher. She's responsible for not publishing an equal number of women in the end. She's been ridiculed for that. She's been ridiculed for being "The Peace Resister." We stand behind both and would do the same if she were male. We would further add that writing about topics like American Idol when Congress is voting on the supplemental leave her open to ridicule. Ava and C.I. nicely addressed an embarrassing, on air moment by Katrina vanden Heuvel in 2005. She's prone to those moments and, were one to happen today and we couldn't avoid witnessing it, we'd write about it. (C.I. avoided the Democracy Now! episode last week because KvH was on and C.I. didn't want to address it. For those not in the know, KvH's 2005 meltdown left Krista so humiliated by comments she'd shared at The Common Ills, she vowed never to share again. It was only because of Gina and C.I. that Krista agreed to start a private forum to share in, the gina & krista round-robin.)

We've written mockingly/humorously whatever about Matthew Rothschild. And at much greater length. But, thing is, Rothschild's never written a post about American Idol. Let alone written it while Congress was voting on the war supplemental. Nor has Rothschild made a post disappear as KvH did. Days after KvH's gushing over American Idol, Cindy Sheehan issued her goodbye noting that some adults care more about American Idol than they do about the Iraq war. At which point, KvH's post vanished. (Preserved online by this community thanks to a tip off to C.I. from The Nation.) If you don't want to be mocked or treated humorously, don't waste everyone's time, as you close in on fifty, writing about something as dumb and unimportant as American Idol. When KvH was devoted to The Apprentice, C.I. notes, she at least had the good sense not to blog about it.



Who does that leave us with? Lakshme? Exactly what magazine does she write for? C.I. and Ava cover TV for this site. That means when Lazy joined another magazine's staff and decided she would cover TV from time to time, they'd get e-mailed about Lazy's latest blunder, usually being asked, "Is this true?" No, it wasn't. They noted that repeatedly and never named Lakshme. They wrote one piece when Lakshme played dumb (it was playing, right?), went gunning for Nora Eprhon and took Susan J. Douglas' theme over to The Nation. For those not paying attention, the area Lakshme has tried to carve out for herself is already covered, and covered very well, by Susan Douglas. If Lakshme wants to play Eve, better believe we'll defend Margot. (And we're not even going into the whole Mike issue. Mike will be writing an F-you to Lakshme in his final post and there's not any reader of this site, or member of the community, that doesn't know what Mike's going to be writing about.) Lakshme's problems are her own.



Who is the most mocked person at The Nation? The Cindy Brady of the Faux Left, AlterPunk. The Nation can research it. From one liners to whole pieces devoted to him, it's AlterPunk.



Who else at The Nation has gotten a single piece devoted to them? (Lakshme doesn't work at The Nation -- and Ava and C.I. were no harder on her than was CJR. A point The Nation seems to miss.) Well, Dumb Ass got a feature when he wrote the response to Elizabeth Holtzman's call for impeachment. Who else? Christopher Hayes has at least two features, here and here. Who else? Christopher Phelps.



C.I. was informed The Nation Isle has especially pissed off The Nation. (Informed over the phone.) It's a parody and it's funny. People are cast in roles for Gilligan Island. This is one of our allegedly 'error filled pieces'. We love that. We love that The Nation thinks there are errors in a piece set many years in the future, based on Gilligan's Island, obviously played for laughs. (You'd think they'd at least enjoy the illustration!)

Are women treated worse in that? The worst would probably be being turned into Gilligan. No woman's turned into Gilligan. Patti gets made fun of. KvH gets made fun of. In the original draft Liza Featherstone was a joke and a joke for being stupid. Ava and C.I. rewrote all of Liza's lines but two and they did so to make her a strong character. They take serious offense to any suggestion that Featherstone comes off badly in that feature. Prior to the overhaul Ava and C.I. did, Featherstone was a carbon copy Mrs. Howell. (Which is why she's called "Lovey" early on.) They added fire and strength to the character.



Two women are jokes in the feature, Katrina vanden Heuvel and Patricia Williams. Two men are as well, ____ and Richard Dreyfuss. Doug Henwood lost out (we think he's now neutral) because Ava and C.I. were adamant that Featherstone was not going to be a doormat. We think Liza Featherstone, in that feature, is the most likeable character and the response to it, from outside The Nation, demonstrates that most people do as well.



Again, AlterPunk's had multiple features. Christopher Hayes has been loudly called out. Christopher Phelps was rightly called out and mocked. So was a Texas professor who went out East and got discovered by The Nation. The only woman who has gotten the treatment in an article just for her is Lakshme. And technically, she's not really part of The Nation, now is she? We've called out Stab for her dumb ass repeating on NYT lies. She has posts online at The Nation. She writes for another magazine (in print) but we guess The Nation can call us out for that if they like. Strange though, she spits out NYT lies to slam Gloria Steinem and Jane Fonda. And does so to get a cheap laugh at a highly public event. She's lucky we've held back. We find her tired, boring and a bad writer. Slam Gloria Steinem and Jane Fonda, you get what you deserve. [And to one e-mailer last week, we're not linking. The Gloria Steinem factor. Your writing attacks her. We stand with her. Sorry, no link from us as a result.]



The Nation needs to work on their math skills.



They also need to work on the issue of whom they feature. Amy Goodman has pointed out that when she asks network and cable news why Noam Chomsky can't be a guest, she's told they don't know him personally. The Nation's being run the same way. That's one of the reasons the Slow Creep of the Centrists has taken place. (And people at the magazine know it too.)



Women are not treated more harshly here. If you're a War Hawk, you'll be called out. Regardless of gender. But there's not a word that ever makes it up here about a woman that isn't vetted and re-vetted. Ava and C.I. will ask that a joke be explained. Not for why is it funny but what's underneath it. They will pull jokes that are actually funny because they are uncomfortable with them. (A Madonna joke, that was funny, to a friend who was once involved with her, took three hours of persuasion before they'd agree to it. The friend had told them to put it in. We were telling them to. Jim's father was telling them to. It took three hours to get that joke in.)



Questioning their feminist credentials may make The Nation feel better about their sorry record of publishing women. Pushing the blame for that record off on us may make them feel better. But the reality is that The Nation, led by Katrina vanden Heuvel, is solely responsible for how many women they print or do not print.



Prior to the summer of 2006, we never said a word against the magazine here and noted it repeatedly. Only three people with the magazine wrote about that. (We did hear from friends of C.I.'s but we're not counting them in this tally.) Lately, it's non-stop crying and whining from the magazine. We'll listen to most of it and consider it but when the magazine wants to blame us for their sorry record of publishing women or wants to call into question Ava and C.I.'s commitment to feminism, we won't stand for it.

That's leadership on Iraq?

So The Nation magazine wanted us to know that Iraq has been taken seriously by the magazine in 2007. Of course, the examples offered by the magazine reached back to 2005. But were they addressing the illegal war seriously in the first six month of issues for 2007?


These are eye-balled figures. We may be missing something. It's done quickly and the numbers are impressions, not precision. (We've done more research with just that than The Nation did when they dumped their crap in our lap last week.) There were over 250 features, not counting the critics section, so, to be a leader on Iraq, how many features would they have to run? A third, a small number, would mean at least 80. Pay attention as we walk through.

The January 1st issue contained two articles on Hurricane Katrina. Iraq? That was left to Alexander Cockburn who penned the only feature on Iraq. (We're leaving out the critics section -- they don't review Iraq movies, they rarely tackle Iraq books. The e-mail from The Nation pointed to no review, but noted features and and an editorial -- from 2005.)



January 8th? A poem by Calvin Trillin. There's also the Pooper's cover story about a petition signed by active duty military. That's the article that contains the magazine's first ever mention of Ehren Watada and calls him a coward. The sidebar with this article doesn't make up for the lack of (print) coverage nor for printing that nonsense to begin with. But we'll be kind and count the article and the poem. That's three articles.



The January 22st issue (the 8th was an alleged 'double issue')? Calvin does another brief poem and Bruce Shapiro writes about Saddam Hussein. That's five.



January 29th? "No to Escalation" an unsigned editorial. AlterPunk looks into Iraq. That's seven.



February 5th? Empire is more than just Iraq and so is the scope of the article. Zero. We're still at seven pieces (including Calvin's brief poems).



February 12th? The lengthy editorial "Showing Bush the Way" mentions Iraq in only one sentence (and a parenthetical at that). That's not writing about Iraq. John Nichols writes a column about the "Iraq Debate." That's one piece. The total score is now eight pieces.



February 19th? "Which Side Are You On?" ponders the editorial and it's back to lapping up the pits of Jim Webb (former or recovering Republican, now conservative Democrat) and, no, it's not about Iraq. Having pissed on the peace movement online in 2006, Liza Featherbrain now writes an essay, kind of, sort of 'the peace movement' and it's failures. Go Liza! Can someone inform Featherbrain that WalkOn.org is not a part of the peace movement? Most peace movements aren't created to stop the impeachment of Bill Clinton and that's your first clue. We'll count it since it's supposed to be about Iraq (and we're sure light readers think it is). It's once again left to Alexander Cockburn to write about Iraq and, it should be noted, his column (a lengthier version) also publishes at his own CounterPunch. We've got more Obama madness. (He may end up the most covered candidate by the magazine.) Being generous, that's two pieces bring the score to ten. In seven issues (one of which was a 'double issue' -- should we count it as two?).



February 26th? Not a single piece. Eight issues (we're counting double issues as one issue) and our score is ten articles ("articles" for this piece refers to features, columns or editorials).



March 5th they come to life! Two articles, in the front of the magazine!, one an editorial, about war! Of course it's Iran, so it doesn't count. Calvin does another poem that touches on Iraq (Douglas Feith) and Alexander Cockburn remains the most consistent means by which Iraq gets covered (here he's addressing Michael Gordon). But then, Cockburn knows their life beyond The Nation. Patti Williams writes at least the third piece on Obama this year (and a cover story! who knew drool could be printed!). We're not at nine issues and twelve pieces.



March 12th? By going historical (Lincoln) Eric Foner writes about Iraq. 13 pieces, ten issues.



March 19th? One article (by Christian Parenti). 14 pieces, 11 issues.



March 26th? One article (C.I.: "Stephen F. Cohen had little competition but even if there had been some, it was the best article the magazine's printed on Iraq. I'm not counting columns.")
15 pieces, 12 issues.





April 2nd? Jeremy Scahill writes as if he's at another magazine (that's a compliment), Calvin offers another poem on Iraq, and by running two unsigned editorials, the second one manages to cover Iraq. 18 pieces, 13 issues. Oh and a coffee fetcher (now with the Chris Dodd campaign, and one prone to attacking Alexander Cockburn's writing) writes about the war and students. 19 pieces, 13 issues.



April 9th? With Anne Hull and Dana Priest's incredible work on the veterans issue in The Washington Post, The Nation decides they better touch on the issue and do so with two pieces. Some might argue why they didn't cover it before? Some might even note that Mother JonesThe Washington Post to cover it first didn't need . 21 pieces, 14 issues.



April 16th? We're going to be real generous and call the crap on the Pelosi-Reid measure a short story, piece of fiction on Iraq. Alexander Cockburn keeps it real about the measure (and gets Abeer's name finally into the magazine), Calvin does a poem. 24 pieces, 15 issues. Chrissy rewrites history about the SDS and wants to pass off his rant as about students today. Not enough Iraq to qualify. But good news, more Obama features. What is that, the fourth article on Obama?





April 23rd? Another Iran war article. Juan Cole writes about Iraq and he blew any trust factor when, as Steve Rendell rightly noted, he came out in favor of continuing the illegal war and occupation (a fact Cole wants to pretend didn't happen but Rendell is correct, it did). 25 pieces, 16 issues.



April 30th? Calvin writes another brief poem on Iraq (this time on Senator Crazy's visit to Baghdad). 26 pieces, 17 issues.



May 7th? Zero. Still 26 pieces. Now 18 issues.



May 14th? Thanks to Calvin's poem, Iraq is not forgotten. 27 pieces, 19 issues.



May 21st? Editorial on Iraq. (Well, on Congress.) David Corn actually covers Iraq (unlike the editorial -- by the same staff, remember, who applauded the 'benchmarks' for Iraqis in the Pelosi-Reid measure). 29 pieces, 20 issues.



May 28th? Katha Pollitt finally weighs in on Iraq for 2007. (No, the insulting "BE HONEST" paragraph doesn't count and didn't for that craptacualr column.) She manages to mention Abeer finally as well. Strange isn't it, that Cockburn wrote about her before Pollitt could. 30 pieces, 21 issues.



June 4th? Spencer Ackerman writes about Iraq. It's about Iraq. A bit pedestrian. A bit centrist actually. What does the mag tell us? Slug line page 20 that he's "a senior correspondent for The American Prospect and a national security correspondent for The Washington Monthly." Oh, those Democratic Bibles. The ones that couldn't call out the illegal war for the longest, but could argue for a 'smarter' illegal war. Hmmm. But there's something that C.I. and Ava just really feel is being left out. What could it be? Oh, that's right! He was an associate editor for The New Republic(an). Well why not. It's not like the magazines really had any different outlooks to begin with, right? (Slow Creep of the Centrists.) Moving to cowardly, ____ (couldn't mention Darrell Anderson was a war resister when quoting him in the Guardian of London, so he will not be named here) writes about Tony Blair and mentions Iraq every now and then. (Very little, strange since he thinks Iraq is the biggest issue, or that's what he writes in this column.) 32 pieces, 22 issues.



June 11th? By running three unsigned editorials, they manage to write on about Iraq and, yes, it's the last editorial printed. Nick Turse's online piece is pruned (severely, online originally and fully at TomDispatch) and run. They also offer Iraqi refugees. 35 pieces, 23 issues.



June 18th? John Nichols writes about Cindy Sheehan's announcement. The party organ for the Democratic Party announces, in an unsigned editorial, "The Honeymoon Is Over." We say, "Yes, we see the bruises on your face." But it's not about Iraq. Iraq's mentioned in three sentences. Not even three sentences about Iraq, mind you, Iraq is a subclause in all. The third time probably sums up the magazine's attitude best: "Beyond ending the war . . ." They're always moving "beyond" Iraq at the magazine. This doesn't count for crap. It's about progressives and health care and the 100 days, and corporations and, probably, daisies growing out of someone's ass. 36 pieces, 24 issues. Naomi Klein includes "Baghdad" in her title but she's writing about Canada's natural resources and it doesn't count either.



June 25th? Nothing on Iraq. Apparently the issue of People magazine Patti Williams was using as a social science resource didn't cover Iraq. 37 pieces, 25 issues.





Now, if we take out Calvin's seven brief poems (no offense to him or poetry), we're left with 30 pieces. If we take out Alexander Cockburn the figure drops even lower. Maybe we should take him out after that shameful note the magazine recently wrote about him. As we remember it, when they ran that anti-Palestinian ad, activists had to organize writes in, start a petition and protest to get that weak-ass "We take money, we do not necessarily agree with ad content" nonsense. But Cockburn rates something akin to The New York Times non-mea-culpa.



So leaving out Calvin's poetry (and we didn't count poetry in the critical section that they run reviews in), we're left with 30 articles. Some of which, like ___'s article on Gordon Brown replacing Tony Blair, only touched on Iraq, didn't focus on it. So while the US was engaged in a declared war -- an illegal one -- 30 articles could touch on Iraq? How proud they must be.



Not one article on war resisters ran. (A sidebar is not an article.) Liza Featherstone's laughable 'peace movement' article is included. This is the magazine stepping up?



During the six month period, there was a special issue on the environment (May 7th) and a special issue on Cuba (May 14th). We've already had the special issue on food in 2006. July's already offered the special issue on health care. We're told a special issue on Iraq is on the way. It's nice that 4 years and 4 months after the start of the illegal war, they finally think it warrants a special issue. Over 250 articles and 30 can be ranked as having to do with Iraq. That includes Calvin's poems. That includes Cockburn's columns. That includes editorials. 30? A bit like Charlie Gibson reducing Iraq to two minutes in a broadcasting week if you ask us. Even more so when you grasp that 70% of Americans turned against the war, that the war decided the 2006 elections and that The Nation is seen as the strongest magazine speaking out against the illegal war. (It's based on what they used to do. Not what they do today.)

Meanwhile, the cover we never saw on Iraq in 2006? We noted it in 2006. We still haven't seen. Not of any individual war resister. In fact, there's not been one article in print that covered a war resister (a sidebar is not an article).

Those wonderful Republicans

Have you noticed what's been going on with your boy Jim Rutenberg in The New York Times for the last two weeks? ("Your boy?" He's not ours.)

Richard Luger speaks out against the war. Did you catch that fawning press? Pete Domenici joins him last week and BOOM! Ruten-tootin-Rutenberg's got an article in the paper.

Those Republicans, they care.

Right?

You might think that. We warned you about it, actually.

Remember?

The country's turned against the war. The Republicans know they need more than their base to win. You'd see defections. By the time the general election rolled around, conventional wisdom would be on the side on the Repubes. They'd be the party that woke up. Remember all of that?

If not, your homework is to read "Editorial: The Party of Stella Toddler" which ran the last Sunday of May.

You'll grasp what's going on.

You may grasp why we, unlike Lotta Links and other alleged left sites, haven't run fawning coverage. We ignored the idiot who backed down when Bully Boy called him French in 2002. But we're not fawning over Dick and Pete. Others are.

Amazing considering they haven't done anything. They've talked, but it's not like they crossed party lines for a vote yet. It'll happen.

But are you noticing the narrative already emerging in the press. Just focus on Rutenberg's stories from last week and the week before. Isn't it strange that Republicans get named. Dems? They're "Democrats." It's almost as though no Democratic running for president or in Congress has spoken out.

This is how the GOP attempts their 2008 wins. They have to dump the war. (All but Senator Crazy know that.) They've got to step away from it. It's not a campaign winner. So they move away and the same press that, for example, ignored Ted Kennedy's call for a withdrawal years ago, now rushes in pieces about these 'maverick' Republicans. Look at 'em go, bucking the system.

While Dems stood still, Republicans were ahead of the game. All all you Dem sites posing as left, grab some common sense and quit propping up the narrative with your nonsense headlines about Dick and Pete and "Oh look!" b.s.

This was their plan, the Republicans, all along if the country turned against the war in this large of numbers. It's the roll out and if you're a Dem site, quit playing GOP advance team.

Pete and Dick have talked. They haven't done anything.

But they talked! Contrast the press treatment they're getting with what Kennedy or Dennis Kuckinich or any other Democrat, making the same or stronger statements, got.

That wasn't news, argues the press. This is 'bucking' a system! Ted Kennedy's lone voice in the Senate wasn't bucking the system?

Of course it was. But the war's gone, beyond lost, and the press needs a hero and an excuse. So it's build up the Republicans. And, back them up, because if they only wised up, it's cover for the press as well. It's a mutually self-serving relationship which is why the narrative may work. Dems don't need to be assisting.

Highlights

Here's how it's going to work. Titles will be e-mailed to this site because Blogger/Blogspot still won't let us put in titles. (This problem started on Friday night. Have they fixed it? No.)

When titles go up, we will then go in and copy and paste the features already written. There will be very few links because we can copy and paste without them much more quickly. (It has to do with using the "Edit Html" option in the "Create" box instead of "Compose." "Edit" allows us to have the spacing right. But copy and pasting in "Edit" does not carry over links. If you're lost, sorry.)

If they counted right, they told us there are 9 features more to go up after this one. However, make it ten. There was a promised feature last week that we all forgot about. Dona says it will be a short feature and (2 paragraphs is her desire). So it will go up slowly but it will go up.

The core six and Kat are doing final edits on the other pieces. C.I.'s about to fall over and probably will only do an entry this morning. Due to the issue with titles, we doubt C.I. will even post Isaiah this morning. Kat's review? Unless she has a burst of speed when she wakes up, postponed again. (Blame The Nation.)

So this is Elaine, Rebecca, Betty, Wally, Cedric and Mike selecting the week's highlights and writing this feature.

"Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you must have a penis"
"Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis"
"Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis"
"Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis"
"Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis"
"Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis"
"Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis"
"Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis"
"Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis"
"Are You A Writer For The Nation? If so, chances are you have a penis"
-- the July 4th feature posted at all sites. We're all still pretty proud of it. Be sure to check it out.

"The Side Saddle Friedman" -- Betty's latest. She says it's nothing. Whatever, get your laughing pants on. :D

"Pizza in the kitchen. Pizza in the kitchen. This ..." -- Friday posts have titles like this because they couldn't be written -- Blogger/Blogspot. This is Jess filling in for Trina.

"About the 60s . . . It's Friday. Were I back on t..." -- amazing post by Elaine. Betty says it's "perfect." It's addressing the realities of the '60s.' Something many males seem unable to do today.

"iraq, draft, sexism, more" -- Rebecca breaking down some realities as well. About the '60s.'


"And the war drags on . . ." & "Iraq snapshot" -- C.I.'s two pieces explaining the realities of the draft regarding college campus actions in the '60s.'

"Marjorie Cohn, Laura Flanders & more I'm adding t..." -- Mike explains that we all love the feature that ran on the Fourth and screw those who didn't. (Among other things.)


"THE WOULD BE BULLY BOY" & "Boreass Obama Bullies Up" -- Wally and Cedric give the 411 on Obama's latest campaign 'move.'


"Talking Post" -- Mike explains (some of) how The Nation ruined our 4th of July.

Isaiah's The World Today Just Nuts" The Quotable Bully Mama" -- Big Babs breaks it down in Isaiah's comic.

"NYT, guess who they don't name (again) today" -- who is the unnameable? For The New York Times, it's Abeer. Always.


"THIS JUST IN! SCOOTER WALKS!" & "Scooter Scoots" -- Wally and Mike on the walk Bully Boy took, hand-in-hand, with Scooter.
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported License.
 
Poll1 { display:none; }