The Third Estate Sunday Review focuses on politics and culture. We're an online magazine. We don't play nice and we don't kiss butt. In the words of Tuesday Weld: "I do not ever want to be a huge star. Do you think I want a success? I refused "Bonnie and Clyde" because I was nursing at the time but also because deep down I knew that it was going to be a huge success. The same was true of "Bob and Carol and Fred and Sue" or whatever it was called. It reeked of success."
Kat:
Summer 2024 -- June, July and August -- has been about a lot of
garbage and a lot of crap. Trash like, for instance, FOREVER.
Jon
Bon Jovi is not a major talent and never was. But with Richie Sambora
co-writing songs, the group Bon Jovi seemed to have an anthem or two to
shout. And with Sambora on lead guitar, there was a reason to listen.
Ahead of the forgettable FOREVER being released this summer, the usual
false rumors circulated that Richie might be back with the band -- or
with whatever passes for a band. Instead, there was no Richie Sambora
and twelve tracks that stood as twelve arguments for Jon Bon Jovi to
retire.
Speaking of musty, Moby showed up with one of the
worst albums of all time. The music itself was quickly forgotten as we
marveled instead over the fact that ALWAYS CENTERED AT NIGHT didn't
make it onto BILLBOARD's TOP 200 selling albums -- not even for one week
-- his eleventh album since 2013 that's failed to chart in the US.
Eminem called it a little too soon (2002's "Without Me"), but, yes, when
it comes to Moby, "It's over." The same news should be broken to Neil
Young. He's released over 20 albums since 2018. Albums of new stuff?
No, this is Neil desperate for money and raiding the archives. Someone
break it down to him, he was never Stevie Wonder and he's certainly not
Prince. Meaning? It all sounds like the same f**king song and no one
needs his archival releases -- although, in fairness, EARLY DAZE did
manage to chart this summer and even make it into the top 100 on
BILLBOARD's album chart -- something only one of the previous 20
managed. And, speaking of bad, don't forget Ice Spice's Y2K! -- an album
so simplistic that it made her Dunkin Donuts commercial seem layered
and meaningful by contrast.
This summer brought the news that we're still done with Ani DiFranco. Her embarrassing and racist plantation retreat did get purged from her WIKIPEDIA page but not from our memories. The 'lesbian' sunk a little lower on the honesty scale as she began performing old songs with newly censored lyrics that the twice-married-to-a-man wrote back when she pretended she was into women.
Even so, UNPRECEDENTED SH*T brought no one to the yard and that awful
title track sounds like a wounded cat needing to be put down. "I've got
a lot of heart," Ani insisted over some 'musical' notes far creakier
than the ones coming out of her throat before telling us she had "a lot
of balls." If you hadn't bailed on her by then, you did when the second
verse featured a 'whistle' that was about as musical as a car alarm.
The album failed to chart and the official video of the title track
couldn't even crack 3,000 views in three months of release. Like
OneRepublic's ARTIFICIAL PARADISE, UNPRECEDENTED SH*T begged the
question who wanted to toss money into the sinkhole? In Ani's case,
it's Ani. She's the head of her own label which makes you wonder will
she keep releasing crap albums until all her money is gone or will she
be her own best A&R, take herself to a bar and explain, "The
career's over. You're dropping yourself from your own label"?
July
brought one album that did actually sell: Eminem's THE DEATH OF SLIM
SHADY (COUP DE GRACE) which didn't have the strong humor of his first
two albums but was his best release since 2002's THE EMINEM SHOW and was
also one of the few bright spots of the summer. And while it didn't
sell, July also brought Jack White's NO NAME. It was solid if a little
light weight. But it wasn't enough to resurrect the career. I think by
now, we've all gotten over Jack's lie that his former White Stripes
partner was his sister. No, she was his wife. And although we've
gotten over the long ago lie, I think we're all still grossed out that
for years a then-married couple pretended they were brother-and-sister.
The bad taste still lingers.
August brought about
Khalid's SINCERE which was frothy enough to make you hope for more but
there was no more there. (Khalid is one to watch, however. He needs
stronger material than this, but he's got real talent.) Any positive
vibes Khalid managed to send out quickly went scurrying with the release
of AGHORI MHORI MEI. The what? The latest garbage from Billy Corgan.
Whenever he needs money, it's back to what he tries to pass off as the
Smashing Pumpkins. The Pumpkins, a grunge era band, has two classics:
SIAMESE DREAM and MELLON COLLIE AND THE INFINITE SADNESS. The first
remains a sonic landscape, the second finds Billy at his most heavily
Anne Sexton-influenced. Nothing since has ever mattered in the
slightest. Maybe that's because even Billy's huge ego hasn't been
enough to fill the holes left by the departure of original bassist Darcy
or the death of Jonathan Melvoin.
At any rate, I was
willing to toss in the towel and be done with the dreadful summer of
2024 when I learned Vanessa Williams' SURVIVOR was out.
The
title track crackles with life and makes you want to swing your hips on
the dance floor. "I really love that and am looking forward to the new
album" -- I wrote that sentence August 24th.
Didn't realize that the album had been released the day before until
e-mails started coming in. There's been a lot of interest in this album
because SURVIVOR has already produced two dance classics.
"The Legs (Keep Dancing)."
Vanessa Williams, Trixie Mattel and LION BABE doing "BOP!"
She
does a great job covering Natalie Cole and Linda Williams "La Costa"
from Natalie's 1977 release THANKFUL. Even more on the money is her
cover of 1934's "Junk Man."
The
life she breathes into that Frank Loesser and Joseph Meyer classic is
amazing. As is what she does with Cab Calloway's "Zaz Zuh Zaz." Those
songs and their dynamic vocals are probably supposed to remind you that
Vanessa's triumphed on Broadway with the musicals KISS OF THE SPIDER
WOMAN, INTO THE WOODS, SONDHEIM ON SONDHEIM, AFTER MIDNIGHT and next
month starts wowing British audiences in THE DEVIL WEARS PRADA --
London's first ten shows are already sold out.
SURVIVOR
celebrates Vanessa's voice by providing her with dance numbers, jazz
and Broadway staples and ballads. This is the artist whose chart hits
include "Save The Best For Last," "The Right Stuff," "Dreamin'," "(He's
Got) The Look," "Work To Do," "Running Back To You" and "Colors Of The
Wind." That's a wide range and SURVIVOR honors it. Make a point to
check it out.
Did you know: Sarah Huckabee Sanders, who legalized child labor in Arkansas, based her entire personality on this Nellie Oleson doll, which remains her only friend: pic.twitter.com/NSKvMRflom
Over and over, last week, we had to keep telling ourselves that. And then we'd hum along to Mary J. Blige's "No More Drama."
But drama was all last week offered. Some of the low lights?
Well there was Friday afternoon when we watched on TV as Robert Kennedy Jr. spoke and our jaws dropped. Not over his endorsement of Donald Trump in the presidential race. We knew that was coming. What we couldn't believe was the face.
Did no one ever explain to Junior that blush is an accent, not a foundation?
Yeah, it's just for the cheeks. And it should look like it was put on with a brush, not with a brick.
There are circus clowns that wear less make up.
A mutual friend of Junior's had told us earlier in the week about the call that was put in. Was he making a mistake if he endorsed Donald Trump? Yes, the friend told him.
"It was so different from the call a decade ago," he explained. "That time it was him asking if he should marry Cheryl [Hines] and my yes answer got a lot more push back."
Indeed.
Junior raised the issue of Cheryl's name value (not as high as he wanted) and her "horse face" and the dangling boob that was smaller than the other and -- Well, let's leave it there. We don't want to be unnecessarily cruel. Besides we had to jog his memory on the fourth complaint Junior had about Cheryl, he'd forgotten.
We hadn't because Junior made four calls that time, to four trusted friends, who'd repeated the story over the years. Three of them didn't think the marriage would last five years and that Junior would leave her. Fortunately for Cheryl, with her, he just cheats and "she gives him time, [he] makes it back home." That was from another man he called about whether or not he should marry Cheryl. When we found out he'd called at least one about both (whether to marry Cheryl, whether to endorse Donald), we decided to check and see if he'd called all four.
Three. He called three of the four. One didn't return the call ('when someone's dead to you, that's it."), another explained that Junior no longer has his phone number ("I ended it when he announced he was running as an 'independent'") but on the fourth, we struck gold.
He explained that Junior "seemed more worried about endorsing Trump -- kind of strange you know, since he was marrying Cheryl three months after wife number two killed herself."
Yes, that is strange until you grasp that the American people, unlike Cheryl, are not a doormat.
They'll rebuke him. They'll call him out. They'll refuse to support him.
Cheryl?
Oh, honey, you made a mistake again! I forgive you! Don't leave me! Don't leave me!
Desperate.
Desperate like JD Vance.
Last week, he went into a donut shop. It did not go well.
No one wanted to talk to him. He came off as even a bigger weirdo than he normally does. And what was up with that hair?
It’s
almost definitely not intentional. But the unstyled shelf of hair atop
his dome, with no gradation to the rest of his hair, is not a great look
for anyone and most certainly not a Vice Presidential nominee. So what
exactly is happening to Vance’s coiff? We called up a few hairstylists
to find out.
“It
looks like someone just plopped a toupee on top of his head,” said
Kevin Baker, a hairstylist at Material Salon in Tampa, FL, who went on
to note that it seems like Vance went to an unskilled barber. Taking
that idea further, another barber we spoke to (who wanted to remain
anonymous) said it looked like either a DIY cut or a rush job—or both.
“That’s someone who thought ‘something is better than nothing,’ which is
obviously incorrect,” they said.
Vance is probably the type of guy who would look down his nose at paying
for an expensive haircut, but you don’t have to pay a lot to get a good
haircut provided you go to a good barber. Either Vance actually did try
to DIY his hair (or maybe asked an aid to trim him up on the campaign
bus—while it was moving) or he didn’t vet his barber properly to make
sure they give a good cut regardless of how much he’s paying for it. A
good rule of thumb is to always check out a barber’s work before going
to a new one, either on their own social media (or the shop they work
at) or with real life referrals so you know the quality of their work
before sitting down in their chair. And if you’re going the DIY route,
make sure you or whoever is cutting actually knows what they’re doing.
Goodness, Munce, haven't you ever hear of Occam's razor?
The most obvious explanation is that he paid someone to cut his hair and that someone -- like the bulk of the country -- can't stand him. It was an accidentally bad haircut, it was one more member of the working class making it clear that they didn't support JD Vance.
And why should they? His best known moments? JD Vance repeatedly insulting single women as "childless cat ladies" over the years -- not one, not twice, not three times -- No, at least a dozen times he stated that these women were hurting the country.
But there he was this morning on NBC's MEET THE PRESS refusing to apologize for it. Refusing to take it back. Refusing to call it a mistake.
KRISTEN WELKER:
All right. Let's talk about
women voters more broadly. The Census Bureau estimates there are 22
million women between the ages of 20 and 40 who, for whatever reason, do
not have children. What do you say to those women who hear some of your
comments, including "childless cat lady" comments, which you've been
asked about, but who feel as though you won't represent them?
SEN. JD VANCE:
Well,
I'd say, first of all, I will represent you. I want to be the vice
president for the whole country, and I want to represent everybody. And
yes, I made a sarcastic comment years ago that I think that a lot of
Democrats have willfully misinterpreted. But what I’ve simply said is
that I think that it's really a profound change that's happened in our
country, where we've become anti-family. And I would like to change
that. And I think if you talk to young women, whether they have children
or don't want to have children, what you consistently hear is that a
lot of young women feel like they don't have options. I saw this with my
own wife, who's a working mother, who's a very, very accomplished
litigator. She has three beautiful kids and always felt like she was
having to balance being a good mom with being the kind of litigator that
she wanted to be. I just want women to have more choices. I've seen
that very personally in my own family, and I think it's something that
is broken about our country.
KRISTEN WELKER:
Let
me zoom out a little bit then. You're calling it a sarcastic comment,
and yet some women – and you got the feedback in real time – felt like
it was a gut punch to them personally. Do you regret making that
comment?
SEN. JD VANCE:
Look, I regret
certainly that a lot of people took it the wrong way, and I certainly
regret the DNC and Kamala Harris lied about it.
KRISTEN WELKER:
But do you regret what you said, Senator?
SEN. JD VANCE:
Look,
Kristen, I'm going to say things from time to time that people disagree
with. I'm a real person. I'm going to make jokes, I'm going to say
things sarcastically. And I think that what's important is that we focus
on the policy. There are certainly going to be things that I say if I'm
elected vice president that people are going to say, "Well, I wish he
had said that differently." I think it's most important to actually be
the person I actually am, and to say those sarcastic comments were made
in the service of a real substantive point. This country has become too
anti-family. It's too expensive to afford a house. It's too expensive to
afford groceries. Donald Trump and I want to change that. And unless we
get better leadership, we're not going to.
KRISTEN WELKER:
But
again, just very quickly, given that people have told you directly,
have spoken out, have said that they were offended, they were hurt by
those comments, do you wish you never made those "childless cat lady"
comments?
SEN. JD VANCE:
I think that it's much more important for me to just be a normal human being who sometimes says things --
KRISTEN WELKER:
So no regrets?
SEN. JD VANCE:
– people disagree with. I have a lot of regrets, Kristen, but making a joke three years ago is not at the top ten of the list.
He lied and tried to pretend it was a one-time remark.
He lied and tried to blame Kamala Harris for his own words.
He lied and could only offer others -- Kamala, the people who took it the 'wrong' way and were offended.
The remarks came from his mouth and he won't own it or take accountability.
President Harry Truman didn't just say, "The buck stops here." He had it made it into a sign that sat on his desk in the Oval Office. Contrast that with JD who instead says, "The buck stops with everyone else."
About the only thing the clown improved on was his makeup. Here he is a month ago on MEET THE PRESS.
And here he is from today.
As you can see, for the facial skin, he's now just sticking with foundation and applying it evenly proving that even Miss Sassy College Draq Queen can still learn a thing or two about makeup.
Maybe he and his buddy Donald can learn about music rights? Beyonce's forced Donald to stop using her song "Freedom" at the rallies by having her attorneys send a cease-and-desist order. Last week also saw a lawsuit against the Donald-JD campaign over music usage. Mitchell Peters (BILLBOARD) notes, "On Friday (Aug. 23), the late soul singer's son Isaac Hayes III
announced on social media that a federal judge had granted his father's
estate an emergency hearing in their lawsuit against the former
president, who has been using 'Hold On, I'm Coming' without
authorization during multiple campaign rallies." Ourselves, we keep wondering when Donna Mills is going to sue JD Vance? Or did making 1984's THE EYES HAVE IT makeup video relinquish all of her rights to her patent eye makeup.
Last week also saw the DNC in Chicago. The national convention brought out a lot of crazies.
For example?
We highlight
Roland S. Martin from time to time. Ja'Mal Green is having a
big problem with Roland and is all over Twitter (and amplified by a
grifter named Sabby Sabs). We have no idea what the problem is because
Ja'Mal Green is too stupid to Tweet properly. If you are calling
attention to some falling out you have with someone, it's incumbent upon
you to explain what it is. Reading his Tweets, you never know what
Ja'Mal's griping about or whining about. But, for the record, we don't
say, "How dare you say that about someone that age!" By the same token,
Ja'Mal shouldn't hide behind his alleged youth to try to churn up
sympathy.
Ja'Mal has many problems. Including Tweets like this:
BREAKING:
Since yesterday morning, over 25 people have been shot in Chicago.
While those at the DNC are downtown being protected in their cozy rooms,
we’re still living real life problems in our neighborhoods. No one has
been arrested for these shootings but over 100 protesters downtown have.
Really?
That's your Tweet? Chicago's main news is -- and for decades has been
-- its murders. That's one of the reasons we don't live there. We fail to see
what your point is other than whining.
Are you going to do the same in 2028 when the Olympics come to LA?
Maybe so, maybe you're just that damn worthless.
A
political convention is an opportunity for a city to rake in some money
and for it to try to spin itself as good for tourism. That's all it
is. Same with hosting the Olympics.
As with your gripes about Roland, your other Tweets really have no point either.
Rightly challenged by MDJ,
"What do you do to help your community? It didn’t start just
yesterday," all Ja'Mal can do is whine, "Do your research?" Why,
Ja'Mal, because you don't think African-American men do research?
It's
not incumbent upon MDJ to research you -- you're a failed political
candidate who appears to grift under any situation -- where others see a
pandemic, you saw a nail salon opportunity! -- and no research is
necessary to note the stupidity of your Tweet.
X number of people killed in Miami on Monday while those at the DNC are being protected in their cozy rooms!
That
makes about as much sense as the garbage you Tweeted. And then Joel C
@ RunNuri Tweeted a racist attack on MDJ and, Ja'Mal, you didn't call
that out. (The n-word, the c-word - though he spells it with a "k" --
and we're noting that because the comment does violate the rules so it may
be gone if anyone goes to look for it. But it was there and it was
racist. And included some form of a gif of a Stepin Fetchit dancing.)
If you're not getting how disgusting Ja'Mal and his audience are,
there's a man insisting that African-Americans have to vote for Donald
to stop Communism. Really, Ja'Mal, that's how you want to live online?
They're the ones propping you up with comments and hugs, Ja'Mal, like
@brianlevine33 who is one of your biggest supporters and he -- White MAGA --
is calling for the shooters in Chicago to start shooting the
protesters.
We have no idea
what your problem with Roland Martin is; however, it's very clear that
whatever it is, you've got a larger problem with whom you're attacking
(Roland and MDJ) while MAGA racists are embracing you. Maybe take a
look at that. And maybe notice how you allowed that thread to further
devolve into an attack -- from your right wing supporters -- on
immigrants. Or maybe notice how your audience includes a lot of
foreigners like the guy from London who, at his own account, is MAGA
24x7. And at your account, he decries abortion and Democrats in the
same thread we're talking about.
You
do get, don't you, that the people who are supporting you are MAGA
supporters? You do get, don't you, that you've become a tool for MAGA?
So maybe lay off the attacks on Roland and address the problems in your
own household.
A little advice that could have applied to a lot of people last week.
CODESTINK was present. The elderly figureheads -- Jodi and Susan (aka Medea). Doing the same thing that they've been doing for over 20 years. When your efforts have achieved nothing for two decades, maybe it's time to either step down and let younger people take over or at the very least rethink how doing the same thing over and over is ever supposed to produce different results.
"Saying Their Names At The DNC."
That was one of the more ignorant YOUTUBE video whines last week.
Their names? The dead in Gaza.
Say their names why? This wasn't an episode of NIGHTLINE, it was a political convention.
And that might have been the biggest problem for some on the left last week: Knowing what a political convention was.
DEMOCRACY NOW! expanded to two hours a day last week to cover the convention; however, they never managed to get the basics right. There hasn't been a real convention since 1968. 1972? McGovern's team ensured abortion and women were rendered invisible. Nora Ephron covered it all in "Miami" decades ago. Apparently, however, ignorance of history found a lot of the left playing Gloria Steinem screaming in tears at Gary Hart in 1972, "You promised us you would not take the low road, you bastards!" She had made deals and promises and been played like the fool she is.
See Veronica Geng's "Requiem for the women's movement," the November 1976 cover story of Harper's.
And for a take on 1972 that paints Gloria as a sell-out to women, see
Germaine Greer's "McGovern, the big tease" from the October 1972 issue
of Harper's.
We've noted that repeatedly over the years. These conventions are spectacle, planned spectacle, ever moment orchestrated ahead of time except the audience's response.
But last week, no one wanted to tell all the slow kids what was happening and what was going to happen.
When we note the conventions, we also like to note 1984 when ABC broke into the Democratic Party's convention for a late-breaking rerun of HART TO HART.
That statement -- not claim, it happened -- has resulted in more e-mails than anything else per Ty who reads the bulk of the e-mails that come in. And thousands and thousands of people have e-mailed to insist that we think we're clever with that joke but it never happened.
Two nights earlier, one major participant in the
convention-as-electronic-event had turned off the television, perhaps
forever transforming the manner in which future conventions would be
covered by television: ABC, impatient with a scheduling lag on Jesse
Jackson's speech - which that network considered the only newsworthy
part of the evening - cut away from the event and put on a rerun of
''Hart to Hart,'' a segment of one of its canceled detective series. It
was the plug-pull heard 'round the broadcast world. The moment ABC
viewers across the country saw Robert Wagner and Stephanie Powers in a
screeching car chase car instead of the presentation of the Democratic
platform, an era of pro-forma public-affairs responsibility in television
had effectively been challenged.
You'd do well to read the entire article. It addresses the reality of the political conventions.
Again, reality was ignored last week.
We wanted one speaker!
Well you were never going to get them. Certainly not some minor state official. But you deluded and tricked yourself into believing otherwise and people who live for drama encouraged you to indulge in the psychotic break with reality.
It reminded us, honestly, of 2008. The DNC was in Colorado where Barack Obama tricked and manipulated IAVW -- punked them like an episode of Ashton's now forgotten TV show. All these years later, there were whiners yet again.
As we noted in 2008, they're infomercials, that's all the conventions are. They're selling a product.
And it's a pre-packaged product, no substitutions. It's not Burger King, you can't go up to the counter and pick from an assortment of products and then order one with "hold the lettuce and extra pickles please."
So maybe try dealing with reality. There aren't multiple contestants. The winner in November will either be Kamala Harris or Donald Trump. You don't need a dozen roses, it's not an episode of THE BACHELOR.
The 2024 Democratic National Convention was
an exhausting rollercoaster ride for Arab Americans and supporters of
Palestinian rights. It was a messy affair, with highs and lows, some
small victories and some setbacks. But on balance, the naysayers are
wrong, because Palestine and supporters of Palestinian rights were big
winners during the four days in Chicago.
We didn’t get language on the Palestine-Israel conflict changed in the party platform, nor did we get a Palestinian-American speaker
in prime time from the convention’s main stage. But the issue of
Palestine was front and centre from Monday to Thursday, and in the days
that followed. They were small wins, to be sure, but they were
victories, nonetheless.
To know what goals we should make and pursue, we need to know the basics.
"Saying Their Names At The DNC." That's beyond stupid,
it's actually insulting. The ignorance is not an excuse. Let's
spoon-feed the uninformed masses. Over one million Iraqis died in
something known as the Iraq War. Their names weren't listed at the
2004, 2008, 2012 or ever. Not at any convention -- not the DNC, not the
RNC, not the Greens. Equally true, not even the US troops who died in
Iraq after being sent there by the US government got their names read.
For a number of you, the expectations were ahistorical and unrealistic and, therefore, setting yourselves up for failure. There is no revolution without education.
The 2024 presidential election plays out like a wheel series. Give it a week and each campaign will come even more into focus. Take the Trump campaign where the news emerged last week that former US House Rep Tulsi Gabbard -- or, as Trina calls her, Trashy Garbage -- was advising Donald Trump. Make sense, in 2017, she advised Bashar al-Assad so she has a history of playing footsie with brutal dictators.
The week's most political embarrassing moment, however, took place on Saturday as the US Green Party held both a coronation and a viewing of the corpse. The coronation was for political failure Jill Stein and the viewing of the corpse was for whatever remains of the Green Party.
The Green Party of the United States? It arrives on the national political map in 1996 as the Association of State Green Parties and has its greatest success in 2000 when Ralph Nader is their presidential candidate and Nader wins 2.8 million votes. It was the high moment of the party which morphs into The Green Party of the United States and never, ever again has the same impact.
Every four years, they serve up the lie that they're trying to build a national party. And then they disappear for three years. No one epitomizes this "catch you later" platform than the hideous Jill Stein.
The party's 2012 presidential nominee and 2016 presidential nominee more than Jill Stein who is now the party's 2024 nominee because nothing screams "NOTHING LEFT!" louder than a political party willing to run the same nominee three times. The Grand Old Party also suffers from this fate and it speaks just as poorly for them.
The choice of a nominee sends a message to voters.
Selecting 74-year-old Jill Stein sends the message that: We're not building a future, we're stuck in a geriatric past. Long before the noted deaths of Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Dianne Feinstein -- deaths that took place while one elderly woman sat on the Supreme Court and the other elderly woman served in the US Senate -- Americans were already feeling unrepresented by a government made up of the extreme elderly. In a country where the minimum age to run for president is 35 and not 70, Jill's coronation isn't reassuring anyone.
Nor are her press stumbles. For example, she's been citing a 900+ pages Senate Intelligence Committee report, insisting it praises her, and it doesn't. But she knows the lazy media's not going to go through the text and footnotes to a 900+ page report. She and her campaign also lie that she has 45% of Arab American voters who will be voting for her. She doesn't. She's basing that claim on one poll, taken in July, before Kamala Harris was the DNC official nominee. More to the point, the organization in question, The American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee, is an organization that represents some Arab Americans, not all. Its membership isn't that large and its rules do not require that you be Arab American to become a member. But if Jill didn't have lies, she wouldn't be able to speak.
In her acceptance speech on Saturday, she insisted, "We are rising up and we are unstoppable."
She wishes. What is she? An eternal failure whose own campaign website doesn't provide a text for yesterday's acceptance speech probably because she served up more lies than even Donald Trump. For example, "In the last election in 2020, one out of every three eligible voters chose not to vote for the two candidates that were rammed down their throats. This is a revolution in the making."
One-third of eligible voters (not registered voters) did not vote in 2020. It wasn't due to "the two candidates that were rammed down their throats." Howie Hawkins, for example, was the Green Party's presidential nominee and he got 400,000 votes. The Libertarian Party's presidential nominee was Jo Jorgensen and she got 1.8 million votes. They weren't the only candidates in the presidential election but, along with Joe Biden and Donald Trump, they made up the top four vote getters. If people in 2020 wanted to vote for someone other than "the two candidates that were rammed down their throats," they had the opportunity to do so despite the lies of Jill Stein.
A month after the 2020 election, Domenico Montanaro (NPR) reported on the 80 million eligible voters (again, not registered voters) who elected not to vote in 2020
To better understand what motivates these nonvoters, NPR and the Medill School of Journalism commissioned Ipsos to conduct a survey
of U.S. adults who didn't vote this year. The Medill school's graduate
students did deep dives into various aspects of the survey here.
Nonvoters' reasons for not voting include:
not being registered to vote (29%)
not being interested in politics (23%)
not liking the candidates (20%)
a feeling their vote wouldn't have made a difference (16%)
being undecided on whom to vote for (10%)
Yeah, Jill's lie isn't backed up by actual facts or data.
She's a grifter and a fake ass. She fails at everything.
Including picking a vice presidential running mate. She offered the slot to Abdullah Hammoud who had to remind her that, per the Constitution, he was too young to qualify as a running mate. After that fiasco, Jill and her campaign let the press know that her pick would be a Palestinian American -- see NBC NEWS, THE GUARDIAN, ALJAZEERA and THE NEW REPUBLIC.
And then she picked . . . Rudolph T. Ware III.
Who?
That's the question you have to ask about a minor character who's WIKIPEDIA page is a violation of the very openness and transparency WIKIPEDIA says it promotes. How else to describe a webpage with multiple revisions including 16 -- that in violation of transparency -- can't even be pulled up any longer?
Who's Rudolph? Someone who goes by "Butch" now. Why? Who knows? When was he born? Who knows? Is he married? Who knows?
Jill announced Butch was her running mate on Friday. And they still can provide you the basics.
In fairness, Jill refuses to provide her own basics -- like explaining her marriage or that she has two kids.
And not only is the text of the speech not posted, it's also not wanted. On YOUTUBE, currently, the video of her speech that she has posted has only 916 views. No one's interested in her failed campaign.
If they were, they'd be calling out the shell game she's trying to pull off. She said she'd name a Palestinian American as her running mate. Apparently, all approached rejected the idea of being the prop intended to give depth to the ultimate Karen and that's how she ended up with 'Butch' who, for the record, isn't Palestinian and also isn't Arab. He's African-American and he converted to Muslim. Only in the world of political theater -- and bad political theater at that -- does Butch qualify as Palestinian American.
Jill spends a lot of time whining about how mean Democrats are and how they try to keep other people off the ballot. We're just supposed to
listen to her whines and pretend she's rightfully aggrieved. One of
today's whines? She can't get on the ballot in New York state. Why?
Because of a rule from when Andrew Cuomo was governor. Here's the Green Party on that,
"A source tells us Andrew Cuomo has SUCCEEDED in inserting the same
language into the 2020 New York State Budget to kill the Green Party
that was struck down by a judge in March." And that reveals the
fraudulent nature of the national Green Party. That's from their March
20, 2020 press release. Over four years ago. They had four years to
address this through the courts, via ballot action, what have you. Lazy
Jill shows up every four years to do nothing but whine. Nationally,
the Green Party is inactive unless it's a presidential election year.
And last week saw a New York judge rule that Robert Kennedy Jr could not be on the ballot in New York. Why? He lied on his paperwork. He doesn't live in New York. He tried to put a lie over and that's why candidates face lawsuits.
Or take independent presidential candidate Cornel West's removal from the Arizona ballot. AP reported last week:
When Denisha Mitchell was asked why she filled out paperwork to serve as an Arizona elector for the independent presidential candidate Cornel West, her first response was “What?!” Her second: What’s an elector?
“I
was shocked and surprised by it all. I didn’t even know what an elector
was,” Mitchell told The Associated Press on Friday. “The crazy thing is
it was all forged. None of it was my handwriting. It was definitely not
my signature. My email was wrong, my address was wrong.”
Mitchell’s
case is the latest example of dubious tactics used in an effort to
qualify West, a left-wing academic, for the ballot in states across the
U.S. It’s also among the more egregious. It’s an effort that West
himself apparently knows nothing about. His campaign did not immediately
respond for comment Friday evening.
You won't hear Jill Stein condemn Junior for lying about his residency or condemn whatever group collected signatures for Cornel's campaign. Doing so would be admitting that there is a reason, a justified reason, for the legal challenges that come about every four years. It would also be admitting to how they do nothing for three years and then spend a presidential election year pretending otherwise.
Starting with Iraq and specifically women and girls in Iraq. So we're all on the same page, let's drop back to July 29th:
Baghdad's Tahrir Square was the scene of a protest today. SHAFAQ NEWS reports:
Hundreds of Iraqi women took to the streets of Baghdad on Sunday to
protest against proposed amendments to the country’s personal status
law, expressing particular outrage over provisions that would legalize
child marriage.
Demonstrators, including members of women’s rights
organizations, gathered in Tahrir Square, carrying signs that read "No
to child marriage" and "The era of child brides is over." The protesters
denounced the proposed amendments to Law 88 of 1959, arguing that they
would roll back women’s rights.
Iraq’s
1959 Personal Status law prohibits marriage for individuals under the
age of 18. Exceptions can be made for women as young as 15 if they have
permission from both a judge and the parents, according to Marsin
Alshamary, a scholar of Middle Eastern politics and an assistant
professor at Boston College.
Iraq’s
1959 law was heavily influenced by the Iraqi Women’s League and is one
of the most progressive laws in the region, according to Nadje Al-Ali, a
professor of anthropology and Middle East studies at Brown
University.
“The
reason it is perceived to be one of the most progressive laws of the
time and even later on, is because it made it much more difficult for a
man to marry a second, third, or fourth wife. He actually had to have
the permission of the first wife,” Al-Ali tells TIME. “It also made
divorce possible for women, it pushed the marriage age to 18, and very
crucially, it was a unified set of laws that applied to both Shia and
Sunni Muslims.”
That
law and other customs which protected the rights of women went out the
window after the US-led invasion and occupation of Iraq. US 'help' --
real or pretend -- rarely helps those in need. It didn't help Iraqi
women when the US government put cowardly fundamentalists in charge of
Iraq (cowardly because they'd all fled Iraq and only returned after the
US invaded). Instead of backing freedom and rights, the US focused on
advancing crooks and cretins who they hoped would sign away Iraq's
rights to oil. THE WEEK notes, "After youth protests erupted across Iraq in 2019, politicians 'saw that
the role of women had begun to strengthen in society', Nadia Mahmood,
co-founder of the Aman Women's Alliance, told The Guardian. 'They felt that feminist, gender and women’s organisations, plus civil
society and activist movements, posed a threat to their power and
status'." Cathrin Schaer (FRANCE 24) adds, "The other big problem is how the choice could divide Iraqi society.
While the current law applies to all Iraqis equally, separate legal
systems could inflame societal and sectarian tensions and degrade the
status of Iraq's judiciary." ANHA notes a statement from Iraqi women opposed to proposal who are calling "on all institutions and organizations
advocating for women's and children's rights in Iraq to raise their
voices against these legal amendments. It stressed that 'a 9-year-old
girl’s place is not in marriage and childbirth, but in playing in parks
and attending school.' The women urged for the cancellation of this
decision before it is approved and called on Iraqi society to oppose
these amendments that threaten women's rights and dignity." At Brookings, Marsin Alshamary observes, "Iraqi women have more rights than many of their regional counterparts,
but they must constantly battle to preserve them. In response to the
proposed bill, activists, politicians, and lawyers formed Coalition 188 (named after the original PSL) and demonstrated throughout Iraq. Female legislators and policymakers including Nour Nafea, who emerged from the 2019 protest movement -- and veteran politician Ala Talabani -- have worked tirelessly to protest the law." And Christina Lamb (SUNDAY TIMES OF LONDON) provides this context, "It’s not the first time Iraqi lawmakers
have tried this -- previous attempts were blocked. But the country's
political system is dominated by conservative Shia Muslim parties who
form the largest coalition in parliament and have been pushing to erode
women's and LGBT rights. In April they made same-sex relationships
punishable with up to 15 years' imprisonment. Initially they were trying
to impose the death penalty. The law also criminalised transgender
people and what it called 'intentional practice of effeminacy'."
The proposed legal change is clearly in violation of international law standards and Iraq’s international law obligations.
Iraq is a party to the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW).
However, at the time of accession, Iraq made several reservations that
ultimately undermined the treaty and its effectiveness. As its
reservation, Iraq indicated that “approval of and accession to this
Convention shall not mean that the Republic of Iraq is bound by the
provisions of article 2, paragraphs (f) and (g), nor of article 16 of
the Convention. The reservation to this last-mentioned article shall be
without prejudice to the provisions of the Islamic Shariah according
women’s rights equivalent to the rights of their spouses so as to ensure
a just balance between them.” Article 2 of CEDAW states that “States
Parties condemn discrimination against women in all its forms, agree to
pursue by all appropriate means and without delay a policy of
eliminating discrimination against women and, to this end, undertake:
(...) (f) To take all appropriate measures, including legislation, to
modify or abolish existing laws, regulations, customs and practices
which constitute discrimination against women (g) To repeal all national
penal provisions which constitute discrimination against women.”
Article 16 of CEDAW states that “1. States Parties shall take all
appropriate measures to eliminate discrimination against women in all
matters relating to marriage and family relations and in particular
shall ensure, on a basis of equality of men and women (...) 2. The
betrothal and the marriage of a child shall have no legal effect, and
all necessary action, including legislation, shall be taken to specify a
minimum age for marriage and to make the registration of marriages in
an official registry compulsory.”
Iraq’s parliament is moving forward an amendment
to the country’s Personal Status Law that would allow Iraqi religious
authorities, rather than state law, to govern marriage and inheritance
matters at the expense of fundamental rights, Human Rights Watch said
today. The Iraqi parliament, which completed its first reading of the
bill on August 4, 2023, will have two more readings of the bill and a
debate before deciding whether to vote it into law.
If passed, the
amendment would have disastrous effects on women’s and girls’ rights
guaranteed under international law by allowing marriage for girls as
young as 9, undermining the principle of equality under Iraqi law, and
removing protections for women regarding divorce and inheritance. Child
marriage puts girls at increased risk of sexual and physical violence,
adverse physical and mental health consequences, and being denied access
to education and employment.
“The Iraqi parliament’s passage of
this bill would be a devastating step backward for Iraqi women and girls
and the rights they have fought hard to enshrine in law,” said Sarah Sanbar,
Iraq researcher at Human Rights Watch. “Formally legalizing child
marriage would rob countless girls of their futures and well-being.
Girls belong in school and on the playground, not in a wedding dress.”
The
draft amendment would legalize, rather than try to reverse, Iraq’s
significant and growing child marriage problem, Human Rights Watch
said.
Under
the draft amendment, couples concluding a marriage contract could
choose whether the provisions of the Personal Status Law or the
provisions of specific Islamic schools of jurisprudence would apply. If
couples are from different sects, the school followed by the husband’s
sect would apply.
This arrangement would effectively establish
separate legal regimes with different rights accorded to different
sects. It would further enshrine sectarianism in Iraq, undermining the
right to legal equality for all Iraqis found in article 14 of the constitution and international human rights law.
For instance, the Jaafari school of law, which many Shia Muslims in Iraq follow, allows
for girls as young as 9 and boys as young as 15 to be married. The
Personal Status Law sets the legal age for marriage at 18, or 15 with a
judge’s permission and depending on the child’s “maturity and physical
capacity,” which already contravenes international legal standards and
best practices.
The draft amendment would also authenticate
unregistered marriages, which are conducted by religious leaders but not
registered with personal status courts and are illegal
under the current Personal Status Law. The amendment would also remove
criminal punishments for men entering into these marriages and allow
religious leaders, rather than the courts, to finalize marriages.
Unregistered
marriages are already a loophole enabling child marriage in Iraq, where
child marriage rates have been rising over the last 20 years, a March
2024 report by Human Rights Watch found. The United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) reported that 28 percent of girls in Iraq are married before age 18. According to the UN Assistance Mission in Iraq, 22 percent of unregistered marriages involved girls under age 14.
Unregistered
marriages also have extremely harmful effects on women and girls’
ability to obtain government services, register their children’s birth,
and claim their rights, Human Rights Watch said.
Without a civil marriage certificate, women and girls are unable to
give birth in hospitals, itself an unjust obstruction to health care,
and are forced to give birth at home with limited access to emergency
obstetric services. This increases the risk of medical complications
that threaten the life of both the mother and her baby. Children and
young women are especially vulnerable to some pregnancy complications.
The
amendment would also remove and undermine protections for divorced
women. Under the existing Personal Status Law, if a husband requests a
divorce, the wife has the right to remain in their marital home for
three years at the husband’s expense and to receive two years of spousal
maintenance and the current value of her dowry. If a wife requests a
divorce, a judge can award her some of these benefits depending on the
circumstances.
If religious law were applied, women would lose
many of these protections. For example, under the Jaafari school of law,
a woman who gets divorced
has no right to the marital home, maintenance, or her dowry, and
children would continue living with her for only two years, regardless
of their age, contingent on her not remarrying.
Women would also
lose some inheritance rights. Even under existing law, daughters inherit
a lower proportion of a parent’s wealth than sons. But under some religious laws, daughters would inherit even less, and if a family has no son to inherit the agricultural land, it would revert to the state.
Finally,
the amendment stipulates that the Scholar Council of the Shia Endowment
Office and the Fatwa Council of the Sunni Endowment Office will develop
a “code of Sharia [Islamic law] rulings on personal status matters” and
submit it to the house of representatives within six months from the
date of entry into force of the law.
This would mean lawmakers
and the general public would not have a chance to review or vote on the
code before it becomes law, removing democratic oversight and granting
disproportionate power to religious authorities in setting the law,
Human Rights Watch said.
The proposed amendment was introduced by
Raad al-Maliki, an independent member of parliament who also introduced
the amendment to Iraq’s Law on Combatting Prostitution that criminalized same-sex relations,
gender-affirming medical interventions, and “promoting homosexuality,”
which passed in April 2024.The law violates fundamental human rights,
including the rights to freedom of expression, association, privacy,
equality, and nondiscrimination of lesbian, gay, bisexual, and
transgender (LGBT) people in Iraq.
The proposed amendment would violate the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW),
which Iraq ratified in 1986, by depriving women and girls of their
rights on the basis of their gender. The amendment also violates the Convention on Rights of the Child,
which Iraq ratified in 1994, by legalizing child marriage, putting
girls at risk of forced and early marriage, leaving them susceptible to
sexual abuse, and not requiring decisions about children in divorce
cases to be made in the best interests of the child.
The draft
amendment appears to violate the International Covenant on Civil and
Political Rights and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and
Cultural Rights by depriving certain people of their rights on the basis
of their religion.
“Iraqi parliamentarians should reject efforts
to strip women and girls of their legal protections and refuse to undo
decades of hard-won rights,” Sanbar said. “Failure to do so means
current and future generations of Iraqi women will remain strangled by
an oppressive patriarchal legal system.”
Ty: Darwin Porter and Danforth Prince wrote the book and it's about Debbie Reynolds was Carrie Fisher's mother and the two were actresses. Debbie was nominated for an Academy Award, a Tony, an Emmy (in fact prime time and daytime nominations), Golden Globes, etc. Carrie lucked into STAR WARS -- a franchise that made her famous and provided her with three big hits. Otherwise her acting career really isn't anything except SHAMPOO, WHEN HARRY MET SALLY . . ., HANNAH AND HER SISTERS and THE BLUES BROTHERS. She really didn't do much on screen as an actress. She did have more of an impact as a writer -- of screenplays, novels, monologues and memoirs. But in terms of acting? She was better than her father Eddie Fisher but not as prolific or as talented as her mother.
Now your husband has been really interested in Debbie Reynolds this year.
Ty: Yes. Before 2024, I was much more familiar with Carrie Fisher than Debbie Reynolds and I had no idea that Debbie had such a strong career. I knew SINGING IN THE RAIN and IN AND OUT, for example, but she had a lot more than that. She had HOW THE WEST WAS WON, for example, a huge hit, and I didn't even note that in my review of the book. So this year, we read two of Debbie's memoirs and we read that awful book on Carrie Fisher, see Marcia's "Sheila Weller's Carrie Fisher: A Life On The Edge" and we read this book and I'd argue this is the best one. It covers the battle that it was for Debbie to have a career. It covers so much and you really respect her and start to feel sympathetic to her -- it's one thing to write POSTCARDS FROM THE EDGE -- a solid novel by Carrie -- but to turn into that piece of garbage film? It is a piece of garbage and Carrie really did whore there because the movie star mother is really not in the novel but she becomes the co-lead character in the film. And I would be insulted if I was Debbie Reynolds because, yes, that was her that Carrie was writing about. And, again, the film's story is not the book's story.
So the book made you really admire Debbie Reynolds?
Ty: It really did. Carrie was a taker -- this is me, not the book. She took so much from her mother and it's amazing that Debbie was able to, for example, do the Liberace movie with Michael Douglas and to be so good in it. She did that while dealing with all of Carrie's never-ending crazy. At some point, you need to grow the hell up but Carrie never did. And that shock therapy that she did and claimed cured her didn't help a damn bit. Just another lie -- another lie that harmed others -- in a long list of lies.
Darwin Porter and Danforth Prince wrote this 2018 book about mother and daughter Debbie Reynolds and Carrie Fisher who both passed away in December of 2016. I read the book because my husband did. We generally try to read books together and talk about them. This year, we read Debbie Reynolds' UNSINKABLE: A MEMOIR and MAKE 'EM LAUGH: SHORT-TERM MEMORIES OF LONGTIME FRIENDS and Sheila Weller's CARRIE FISHER: A LIFE ON THE EDGE.
And? Debbie (and co-writer Dorian Hannaway on both books) wrote in an entertaining manner but the books were sleight. Sheila Weller's fan girl book was an embarrassment.
Debbie Reynolds was an Academy Award nominated actress, a Tony nominated one and an Emmy nominated one. Her classic films include SINGING IN THE RAIN, MOTHER, IN AND OUT, TAMMY AND THE BACHELOR (the film's theme "Tammy" also provided Debbie with a number one hit on BILLBOARD's pop chart), THE CATERED AFFAIR with Bette Davis, GOODBYE CHARLIE, THE UNSINKABLE MOLLY BROWN, THE GAZEBO, THE SINGING NUN, ONE FOR THE MONEY and the TV movie THESE OLD BROADS. Her daughter Carrie Fisher is known for the STAR WARS films, the comedy classic WHEN HARRY MET SALLY . . . , SHAMPOO and HANNAH & HER SISTERS. She was also a writer with a string of strong books including POSTCARDS FROM THE EDGE and THE BEST AWFUL and she wrote the screenplays for the film of POSTCARDS FROM THE EDGE and THESE OLD BROADS as well as being a script doctor on many other films. She was also the voice of Peter's boss Angela on 25 episodes of FAMILY GUY.
Porter and Prince's book is a strong one and it restores some order in that you get Debbie Reynolds was a film star and not just a celebrity who was famous because her then-husband Eddie Fisher left her (and daughter Carrie and son Todd) for Elizabeth Taylor.
She made a lot of films -- many of which were hits. Not all were good as she herself noted. MGM, for example, didn't really care for her. When Dore Schary took over after ousting Louis B. Mayer, she was contracted to a studio whose boss made no effort to hide that he hated her. The only reason she was kept on at that point was because she was so popular with film audiences and MGM could make a small fortune by loaning her out to other studios.
And it was a small fortune. She was a big star but when she married Eddie Fisher, MGM was only paying her a little less than $500 a week -- that was three years after SINGING IN THE RAIN. But she was under contract and they could pay her peanuts and turn around and loan her out to RKO and pocket about $40,000 dollars since they would demand that other studios pay her actual value to have her on loan. (MGM would continue paying the less than $500 a week and pocket the thousands extra.)
She didn't like Dore Shary and you can't blame her. (He wasn't very likable for many.) She also didn't care for Richard Brooks who didn't want her in THE CATERED AFFAIR and who, she shared, slapped her across the fact after one take during THE CATERED AFFAIR when he realized Debbie still had on her actual wedding ring. She had to be strong to survive that and so much more.
She fought for roles. She had a very productive 60s film career post-MGM. Then she had THE DEBBIE REYNOLDS SHOW on NBC -- a success that got cancelled because she refused to go along with cigarette advertising during her show. That left her pretty much banned from TV. But she goes on to Broadway. And she has her own cabaret and club act.
No roadblock ever stopped Debbie Reynolds, she just turned a corner and took off on another road.
I really appreciated her and her accomplishments after reading this book.
And it will make you wonder about parents and children. Debbie was a survivor. Carrie was a basket case.
Who didn't want to her mother. Ever.
Her most convincing performance on screen is in SHAMPOO -- espcially when she's arguing with Warren Beatty and insisting, "I'm nothing like my mother!"
I don't really see the heroic on Carrie. THE BEST AWFUL is a great book. But when you think about the story it tells and when you grasp that it was always autobiographical when it came to Carrie's novels, that's not a hero. That's a mother whose addictions, disease and other things aren't really heroic.
Carrie was also a bit of a star f**ker. She was a little too devoted, for example, to Elizabeth Taylor.
While Debbie appeared to have forgiven her and moved along with life, there's really no reason for Carrie to want so badly to be close to the woman her father left the family for.
Or Michael Jackson. That's just creepy. She came off like a real star f**king bitch in SHOCKAHOLIC -- a transcript pretending to be some form of a book. Yes, Carrie, the boys are the liars. Yes, Carrie, the dentist was the big problem. She was just a star f**ker and you can understand why Penny Marshall had stepped away from her.
As Princess Lea, her big claim to fame, she delivered a so-so performance that wasn't all that. Her friendship with Meryl Streep was largely two mean women bonding over the women they hated.
Debbie had an amazing live and CARRIE FISHER & DEBBIE REYNOLDS: PRINCESS LEIA & UNSINKABLE TAMMY IN HELL makes that clear while noting that drug odyssey Carrie got herself lost on and that's apparently supposed to excuse her acting career.
Jim, Dona, Jess, Ty, "Ava" started out this site as five students enrolled in journalism in NY. Now? We're still students. We're in CA. Journalism? The majority scoffs at the notion.
From the start, at the very start, C.I. of The Common Ills has helped with the writing here. C.I.'s part of our core six/gang. (C.I. and Ava write the TV commentaries by themselves.) So that's the six of us. We also credit Dallas as our link locator, soundboard and much more. We try to remember to thank him each week (don't always remember to note it here) but we'll note him in this. So this is a site by the gang/core six: Jim, Dona, Ty, Jess, Ava and C.I. (of The Common Ills).