Sunday, July 01, 2007

Am I Coward? Yes, I Am!

happybus

Flipping through the June 28, 2007 issue of Rolling Stone, we stumbled upon "Rock's New Mission: Save the Planet" and it was like watching Laurie, Keith and the rest deboard the Partridge Family bus.

Brave Melissa Etheridge shares that she uses biodiesel when on tour. She's "walking that path" and even recycling! She says that "it's a real freedom. It feels great." Can she stay silent on Iraq? YES, SHE CAN! Brave Melissa. We bow before your easy and pathetic activism. Apparently, an open lesbian can only push the envelope so far -- even when her days of charting are long over. (And they are, hon, they really, really are.)

Alicia Keys want to share why she's taking part in a concert too, all are going to be on stages standing up for Al Gore, even if they won't stand up against the illegal war. The environment's topped her cause list because, "All of my favorite artists -- Nina Simone, Marvin Gaye, Curtis Mayefield -- have always been a voice for the people. Their music is real-life stories, war stories, painful stories, and, that's why it connects." We couldn't agree more, but Alicia, where's you war song?




Or is singing tired Pam Sawyer covers your way of 'stepping up'? Please tell us that you're not still trying to pass off "Wake Up" as 'maybe' about the Iraq war. "You used to be my closest ally/ In this cold, cold world of deception and lies/ We would defend and protect one another/ Now I can't tell if we're enemies or lovers/ So who's gonna rescue us from ourselves . . ." Love between a client state and a imperial power? Stop yourself before you decide to write an ode to Sally Hemings.



Dave Matthews wants you to know that the cause is all "about saving ourselves." Which apparently explains his silence on Iraq (or maybe he just can't work out a 'jam' on the topic of war?). Translation, Iraqis, save yourself because Dave Matthews has other things to do. Such as? He explains that he's all local these days, even riding a bike (doesn't appear to have reduced the belly). Local is one answer, Matthews explains by noting he "can walk to the store. I can walk to the doughnut shop" -- might want to lay off those crawlers -- "I can walk to get a cup of coffee." He explains that he has guilted over touring and the damage fuel does to the environment.




Strangely, for such a pro-environmenter, he mentions nothing about the band's bus dumping an alleged 800 pounds of human waste into the Chicago River. There were denials, of course, and there was a law suit and, finally, there was the bus driver pleading guilty.



Maybe Dave Matthews doesn't see that as "pollution"? Maybe he sees it as 'trinkets and souvenirs' left for the fans. 800 pounds of human waste dumped into the Chicago River? Again, lay off the crawlers.

After fretting over the damage using fuel to travel does to the environment and stressing how he walks and bike rides and doesn't even flush his toilet when it's just urine (oooh, the smell of it), Matthews forgets to mention that the Seattle based jammer will be performing July 7th in New York, New York . . . to help the environment. Peddle that bike quickly, Dave, peddle it quickly.

John Legend wants to inform that he reads The Atlantic -- it's the National Review with a bigger vocabulary -- and he wants to "save energy." Meanwhile the man whose ego broke up two super groups, Chris Cornell, wants to play all humble and talk about how "we" have to take the lead on this issue. Why? Well, he was in France and they care about this issue. So since they care and they lead, the natural thing for Cornell is to insist the US take control. Our imperialist proselytizer, Chris Cornell, who lost his looks in 1993 and they ain't never coming back. No. No, they're not.

Roger Waters, who has the good sense to at least allude to the illegal war, loses points for his tip: Drink warm beer. Mike D, the surfing Mike D, sees it "right in front of your eyes" but apparently, since 2004's download "World Gone Mad," he hasn't seen coverage of Iraq.

The Partridge Family tackled the environment as well (start with episodes 31 and 94). They never touched on the illegal war in Vietnam (not even when Danny was 'drafted').
So congratulations to our modern day Partridge Family. VH1 wasn't really able to bring them back, but they weren't striking that C'mon Get Happy mood enough apparently. The C'mon Get Happy vibe must be why the laughable and destructive Live 8 is presented so favorably throughout the Rolling Stone article. For reality, read Julie Hollar's "Bono, I Presume? Covering Africa through celebrities" in the new issue of Extra! (May/June 2007, pp. 21-25, Live 8 is addressed specifically on pages 22 and 23).

Now if you've been to a rally to end the illegal war (and no, Modern Day Partridges, 2004 Get Out The Vote For John Kerry concerts aren't rallies to end the illegal war), you are aware that multiple issues can and are addressed. The environment is not an off limits topic at a peace rally. But the Modern Day Partridges are quite happy to make sure that's not the case at an environmental rally. Might not get the fawning, easy press if you actually had something to say, right? Better to keep it safe and easy, that's what made Nina Simone a legend, right, Alicia?

Oh, it's not. No, bravery makes legends. All chicken sh*t results in is the Pathetic Plastiques. But stroke yourselves for doing nothing, year after year, as the illegal war drags on.

The Nation Stats

We have three issues of The Nation since we last checked in on this feature. That's, in part, due to the fact that last week's edition was our summer read/fiction edition. We're grabbing one and only one issue for this edition, the next one in line, June 25, 2007. That will become clear at a later (but not that far away) point. June 25, 2007 finishes out the month of June and since we began this feature with the first issue for January (issued in December, however), we think that's fitting. As always, we provide the photo of Katrina vanden Heuvel, editor and publisher of The Nation, attending a staff meeting where she's belle of the ball.

nationstats

This issue's cover story is "The New Atheists."



EDITORIALS & COMMENT



"The Great Pretender" -- unsigned, and no, it's not a confession from The Peace Resister.



Robert L. Borosage's "Jackal Time" -- it's been noted we have a book by Borosage and vanden Heuvel on our list of fave books in the profile. What can we say, but we've grown, to steal from Joni Mitchell, "Cart wheels turned to car wheels in the town" ("The Circle Game," off Ladies of the Canyon). But it should be noted, though it didn't result in as much e-mail as our current stance on the magazine does now (e-mails from the magazine's staff), we boosted The Nation here from day one, up until the disgusting summer of 2006 when their timid stance on the war (a fiery editorial followed by nothing) and refusal to cover war resisters became obvious.



John Nichols' "Neoconned Again"



Herman Schwartz' "Summer Lunch Crunch"



Max Fraser's "Farewell, Tony and Carm"



6 pieces



Score: 6 men, 0 women



COLUMNS



Calvin Trillin's "Alberto Gonazles Is Still at His Post"



Alexander Cockburn's "Dissidents Against Dogma"



Katha Pollitt's "Tough Luck, Ladies"



Patricia J. Williams' "Divining Demeanor" -- wherein Professor Patti makes like most law professors and gets her 'hard science' from People magazine. This allows her to utilize "Dog Discrimination" as her jumping off point on how black dogs are like African-Americans. And people question the magazine's commitment to exploring race!



4 pieces



Score: 2 women, 2 men



ARTICLES



Ronald Aronson's "The New Atheists" -- what is that, "new" atheists? Is there a ceremony for that? Is it like born-again Christians?



Felicia Mello's "Coming To America"



2 pieces



Score: 1 man, 1 woman



CRITICS



Rick Perlstein's "Chinese Mirrors"



Susan Stewart's "There Is No Natural Death (poem)"



Stuart Klawans' "12:08 East of Bucharest"



3 pieces



Score: 2 men, 1 woman



Issue score: 10 men, 4 women



Year to date score: 255 men, 74 women



Which brings the score for the last six months to 3.447 men receiving bylines for every single woman. In her column in the issue, Katha Pollitt noted, "For those who believe the feminist movement marginalized itself by taking its eye off the dollar" -- no, we don't know what she's talking about either unless she's talking about the raunch 'feminists' she's played den mother too -- "this is the perfect opportunity to get back to economic issues that have cross-class appeal."

Having all read Virginity or Death, including Sista' Katha's decree that that NAACP shouldn't 'waste' time worrying about TV portrayals, we can't predict that she'll be the least bit concerned with representation of women. But before she again trots out the column on The New York Times' sorry number of women showing up on the op-ed pages, she might need to weigh in on the magazine she works for.



The lack of women being featured in the magazine was brought to C.I.'s attention by a group of women late in 2006. For a column at Polly's Brew, C.I. went back and compiled the stats for that year. What we had discussed was following 2007's issues each time they arrived in the mailbox. Ava and C.I. were in charge of the December 24, 2006 edition and that was the first week that a 2007 issue had arrived (January 1, 2007 issue). They immediately started up "The Nation Stats." "The Nation Stats" ran again in our December 31st edition (covering the magazine's January 8, 2007 issue -- a "double issue"). January 21st, we covered the January 22nd issue in "The Nation Stats." January 28th, "The Nation Stats" covered two issues since two arrived the same day for three of us participating in this feature. February 4th, we covered the Feb 12th issue in "The Nation Stats." February 11th we covered the February 19th issue in "The Nation Stats." February 25th, we coved the February 26th issue in "The Nation Stats." March 4th we covered the March 5th and March 12th issues of the magazine in "The Nation Stats." March 11th, we covered the March 19th issue in "The Nation Stats." April 1st, we covered the March 26th and April 2nd issues in "The Nation Stats." April 8th, we covered the April 9th and April 6th issues in "The Nation Stats." April 22nd, we covered the April 32rd and April 30 issues in"The Nation Stats." April 29th, "The Nation Stats" addressed the May 7th issue. May 20th, "The Nation Stats" covered four issues -- May 14th, May 21st, May 28th and June 4th. June 10th, "The Nation Stats" covered the June 11th and June 18th issue.

Mailbag

mailcall

Dipping into the e-mail bag and replying to questions are: The Third Estate Sunday Review's Dona, Jess, Ty, Ava and Jim, Rebecca of Sex and Politics and Screeds and Attitude, Betty of Thomas Friedman Is a Great Man, C.I. of The Common Ills and The Third Estate Sunday Review, Kat of Kat's Korner (of The Common Ills), Cedric of Cedric's Big Mix, Mike of Mikey Likes It!, Elaine of Like Maria Said Paz, and Wally of The Daily Jot



First, to the economist who wrote us: Are you trying to be funny?



While we appreciate the contact information you provided (including cell phone number), we're really busy. We'll assume you are as well. But if we had a question about something you wrote, or your general theories, we'd ask you about it specifically. We certainly wouldn't send you a generic question about your writing if, like us, you had published multiple features each week since January 2005.



Second, to the NYU professor who wrote, we enjoyed your e-mail (very thoughtful and we applaud the work you are doing) but we're not sure we were you intended recipient. If we were, we think you may be on a fishing expedition as to Ava and C.I.'s identities. If we're wrong, our apologies. Ava, wisely, didn't use her real name her. (Dona points out that "Dona" is hardly a common name, so she's the most screwed over if she attempts to get a job in journalism. Jess has given up on journalism as has Ty so that comment is obviously aimed at Jim.) There was already a community member with Ava's first name, so she used "Ava."



How e-mails to us work are, Ty reads the bulk of them. Dona reads about a third. Jim is supposed to help out and when he's reminded repeatedly or when Dona gives him a dirty look, he will dip into the mail bag. Unless Ty has the week off, Ava and Jess do not go to our inbox. Ava and Jess are helping out at The Common Ills. (And Ava adds, "Ripping into professional journalists who whine like 4-year-olds is far too much fun for me to give up helping out with the public account at The Common Ills. I especially enjoy the e-mails from big babies.") Each week, week after week, we've put out an edition. Some have been hit or miss, some have been worse than that, some have been ones we're proud of.



Jim long ago noted that e-mails come second. The focus is on what goes up here. Did the site take Christmas off? No, it did not. We've posted features every week. (Dona notes, "Thank you to Ava and C.I. for steering the Christmas edition in 2006 while the rest of the core six took the week off.") Right now, Ava and C.I. are in a panic about the TV commentary that they haven't started, haven't even thought of and it's four in the morning as this feature is being completed. Last Sunday's edition went up with the understanding that Ava, C.I. and Wally would correct typos in three features and Jim and Dona would grab the rest. Ava, C.I. and Wally did their corrections. That's all that got corrected.



You've got Jess focused on his LSATs. You've got all of us focused on something. Robyn e-mailed to ask if we'd even do an edition the week Ava, Jim, Jess, Ty and Dona graduated from college? We have not missed a week and do not plan to. (And Robyn, to answer your question more fully, Jim will be replying on Monday. For now, we'll just note that you are correct.)



The core six is Jim, Dona, Ty, Jess, Ava and C.I. Betty, Rebecca, Cedric, Elaine, Wally, Mike and Dallas help out as well. They can all take time off anytime they want but if an edition doesn't go up, it reflects on the core six. (The same if a lame edition goes up and, yes, we've had those as well.)



Longterm readers get replies from Ty, Dona and Jim. We do not, however, have time to reply to every e-mail and we certainly do not have time, in the case of the economist, to spare calling him and asking, "What are you writing in regards to?" We would assume a professional economist and writer would be wise enough to note that on his own without a reminder from us. Maybe he feels he's a name? If so, he's not even in the top 100 most famous names of people who have e-mailed this site. And not all of them got personal replies. (If it's a friend of Ava and/or C.I.'s and that's known, Ty does attempt to reply.)



When Ty saw the economist's name in the inbox, he clicked on the e-mail wondering, "What is he writing about?" After reading the e-mail, he was still wondering. He shared it with the rest of us and we can't figure it out either. It could be a question about our mission statement, a specific feature, Ava and C.I.'s TV commentaries (as most e-mails are), or who knows what. But we don't have the time to track down you or your question. Were we to write you, we would note specifically what our question -- even the exact same question you asked -- applied to.



Since we're starting with these basics, let's note again, Ava and C.I. are not interested in doing interviews. They are not interested in being quoted in your magazine or newspaper. That has been stated over and over and yet the requests continue to come in. They don't even get a reply anymore because this has been REPEATEDLY noted here. They have a weekly forum here and anything they wish to say, they can do so here. They are not interested in publicizing themselves or their writing. (And Ava adds, "The last thing I'd ever want to be known publicly as is a TV critic. Please, I'm an adult woman.")



Having taken care of general business, let's get to readers' e-mails.



Bren wants to know if there's any "undue influence going on"? She notes that C.I. pays for Mike's college and that Jess, Ava, Ty, Dona and Jim all live with C.I. She feels that situation is "ripe for disaster."



Mike: C.I. doesn't try to control what I write. I'm often surprised C.I. even reads it, especially when on the road speaking out. I have, in the past, tempered my remarks about Katrina vanden Heuvel for C.I. But I think that's pretty much over. That had nothing to do with my tuition but because I know how it bothered C.I. I would have done the same on anybody else if any one else participating had a problem. In terms of the funds themselves, C.I. had a health scare in 2005 so when my tuition came up, C.I. brought it up, it was set up. It's not done piecemeal. If C.I. and I had a huge argument tomorrow, the money would still be there. It would be rude, and my parents raised me to be well mannered, to spit on that but I really don't think C.I. cares what I write. In instances where I've been concerned, I've called and C.I.'s listened and always said, "Write about it." I've called out two close friends of C.I.'s at my site. It's not been a problem.



Cedric: Can I jump in? I don't get tuition from C.I., just to state that upfront, and I don't live out in California so that doesn't apply to me either. But Mike talked about censoring himself with regards to wanting to avoid hurting C.I.'s feelings. I believe I was the first to call out Katrina vanden Heuvel for the shameful line drawing between herself and the truly great Harry Belafonte. I did call C.I. before that. C.I. listened and said I should write about it. Not only did I do that, but C.I. linked to my piece when it went up and has noted it several times since. Another example, this is a while back, was when a man was on with Jay Leno. He was making racist remarks. The man is White. It really pissed me off. I chose not to write about it and the main reason was because the man is involved with a good friend of C.I.'s. A couple of days afterwards, I mentioned that to C.I. on the phone and was told I should have written about it. I said no because it wasn't meant to be racist. The man thought he was being funny. I also knew it would -- and it did -- pass without anyone commenting on it. So I didn't want to be the one to draw attention to it and the reason for that was because of C.I.'s friend. An hour after we got off the phone, my phone rings and it's the man explaining C.I. called and explained there was a problem with the remarks. We discussed it and I explained my view, as an African-American male, and how those remarks were offensive. That moment really got the point across to me that if I'm bothered by anything, I should write about it. Otherwise, I may get a call from the person.



Ty: I'll grab the living aspect and the reason is, we all live here and I've got something additional. Along with Dona, Jim, Ava, Jess and I living with C.I., I also have an incredible job with a friend of C.I.'s. I was the first to move out, and I'll get back to that in a second, and that was in June of 2006. C.I. sat up an internship for me with a friend because I was soured on journalism. I've talked about the whys of that here before. But that internship turned into much more and it's really now a career stepping stone, if not a career. I don't think we've ever disagreed, C.I. and me, on anything except when C.I. says, "You need to go visit your family." I do but I do that when C.I.'s speaking in that area. Trust me, my family would be happy to see me at other times but also demanding, "How could you waste money on this?" So that's really the only disagreements we ever have, when C.I.'s trying to get me a plane ticket or to use frequent flier miles. Now Jim argues with everyone, ask Dona, and that includes C.I. It's never been a problem. But I'll let Jim speak on that. In terms of Ava, it needs to be noted, she has family in the area. She could stay with them. She also has more than enough money to have her own place -- or places -- and chooses to live here. Jim?




Jim: Actually, Kat wants to speak.



Kat: Yeah. First, a joke I forgot to do at my site last week. I've been teasing C.I., "I'm in your bedroom more than you are!" Because C.I.'s on the road so much and when I blog most nights, I'm at C.I.'s and I'll head straight to the bedroom and that computer when it's time to blog. But, I do CD reviews at The Common Ills and I used to worry about giving someone C.I. knew a critical review. It's not a problem. I also used to avoid C.I.'s offer of a CD when I was planning to review something. I'd go buy it myself at Tower because if I'm offering my opinion, it should be as someone who paid for it. It's easy to go, "Well it's okay," when you didn't spend your own money. But to clarify, the last CD I reviewed and the next three that I'll be reviewing were all passed on by C.I. With Tower now dead, it's much easier to go through C.I.'s CDs. So if Bren's looking for conflicts of interest, she can see if she notices any changes at the end of the year in my reviews.



Jim: I'll pick up in terms of music. When we first moved out here, I would call the house any time I was thinking of getting a CD. I'd say, "Jess" or "Ty, check to see if C.I.'s already got that." And I am the worst about opening packages that come here. C.I. doesn't mind and has told us all to feel free and if there's something in it we want, help ourselves. But I've noticed I'm really the one who keeps doing it. I'll also take this opportunity to say thank you to C.I., publicly, from all of us.



Dona: The only thing I really have to add, other than thank you, is an experience. My younger brother had a rough patch and dropped out of college his first semester. He came out here. C.I. was fine with it and swore to me that was the case. But C.I. did point out it needed to be addressed with my parents in some way. C.I. was speaking near my home town in two weeks so we took my brother back then and explained what had been going on. But the issue there was that if my parents didn't find out soon what was going on they might not be thrilled about me living with C.I. And that's really the only worry or concern regarding the living situation that has come up. C.I. does have staff in the house so it's not like we can say thank you by cleaning it top to bottom, we do clean up our own messes. And the staff is off at five and we follow the rule, the only one I can think of in fact, that if we want something prepared, we request it by three so no one's put out or has their evening ruined. Ava, who Ty pointed out has money, did say thank you by getting the outside of the house repainted. But, yeah, we've got room and board and entertainment. But, to be honest with you, when we're working here we're not giving any deference. We probably should but I can tell you that Jim will be all over Ava and C.I. shortly about their TV commentary and what's needed and blah blah blah and I'll have to say, as I've done every week since February 2005, "Jim, back off. You're putting too much pressure on them."



Ava: I wasn't planning on speaking but I know this whole conversation makes C.I. uncomfortable, I don't even need to look over to know that. Sunny, Elaine's assistant, she runs the office, filled in for Elaine when Elaine was on vacation last year and noted that she'd stayed at C.I.'s. Sunny was trying, if I remember right, one summer to get out here and her reservations got screwed over and the trip was going to be called off. C.I. told her, "I'm going to be out of town. My house will be empty." Sunny wasn't sure but C.I. said, "You'll be doing me a favor." So, I mean, and not to minimize what moochers we -- Jim, Dona, Ty, Jess and myself can be -- that is one aspect. Jess, Wally and I were on the road last week with C.I. speaking about the illegal war and you had Dona, Ty and Jim here. There was no need to ask someone to house sit in the evenings. And this is really the important thing, if it was just sitting here empty, as it would be most weeks, C.I. would probably sell it and get something much smaller. I was sick of New York the whole time we were there. I have family there and have family out here. I grew up out here and I was planning on coming back. I'd griped about this to C.I. over and over. About the cold, about everyone assuming I was "Mexican," etc. And for anyone who is just reading for the first time. There is nothing wrong with being a Mexican-American or Mexican but every Latino or Latina is not "Mexican." Out here that assumption isn't made the way it was in New York and that was probably my biggest shock because I really did assume New York was a lot more street smart than it turned out to be. I'll never forget a professor, my first year, stopping the class and asking me to explain to the class about Cinco de Mayo. A professor, sorry to get off track. But I had already been complaining. C.I. had listened, over and over, and said I should just move back out here. Jess and I were already a couple at this point and that raised other issues. Then, when Ty told us all about his internship, I called C.I. and asked, "Can I move in too?" I could live with family or, as Ty pointed out, on my own. I love my family but moving back in didn't seem the thing that a college woman does. I'm also not into decorating so the idea of a place of my own wasn't high on my list. But anyway, C.I. said sure and said if Jess wanted to come that was fine to. We -- Jess, Ty and myself -- honestly didn't expect that Jim and Dona would move out as well. When they reached their decision, about mid-way through last summer, only C.I. may have been more pleased than I was. So the point being, it's a big place and I really believe C.I., for concerns of being wasteful, would have considered selling it were it not for the fact that house guests moved in.



Jim: In terms of Bren's question about disagreeing?



Ava: Elaine?



Elaine: Ava and C.I. are so close that I hated Ava before I met her. Rebecca, C.I. and I went to college together. We're all friends. But Rebecca would always complain over the years how C.I. and I were always on the same page. That's been true forever. And I never got, or pretended not to, how that could cause a problem for Rebecca. Then along comes Ava. Ava this, Ava that. I had a Rebecca moment or two. Then I met Ava over the phone and understood why. The two of them, Ava and C.I., are so much alike it's scary. They have similar backgrounds, similar interests, they can finish each other sentences.



Rebecca: I fear they are melding into one person.



Elaine: (Laughing) Exactly. But, from the outside, to wrap up this point, I think Ava's correct. I know C.I.'s brought up the issue of so much space going to waste. I also know C.I. loves that home. So, yes, it buys time on making any decision. I should also add, because I know the issue of staff will have made C.I. uncomfortable, I have someone who comes in and cleans my home three times a week. C.I. has some live in staff and if they do anything after 5:00 pm, that's their choice and they are paid for it. If there's a formal dinner, for instance, it's noted ahead of time and if they want to work it, that's fine and it's extra money, if they don't, that's fine and C.I. brings in other people to work it.



Ava: And, not working, they are more than welcome to take part as a guest in any of the non-stop parties that seem to take place each evening.



Elaine: Correct. It's like the party in Shampoo at C.I.'s place nightly. The good party, not the Republican dinner that preceeds it in the film.



Monica e-mailed to note that a debate took place Thursday and she hopes we will address it.



Betty: We can address it in the mailbag. I wasn't thrilled with. I wasn't thrilled with it before hand or after. Before it started, I asked C.I. if it was going to be noted at The Common Ills and shared my opinion that I'd prefer it not be.



Cedric: And I get C.I. on the phone a day later about the same topic and am told, "Betty just said the same thing."



Ty: At which point, Keesha's e-mailing me, Keesha a longterm community member, asking me to talk to C.I. about not noting it. This was all before last week. The feeling among African-American members such as myself was it doesn't need to be noted. And last week only confirmed that.



Betty: Thank you to Amy Goodman for inviting African-Americans on Democracy Now! I mean that. But if I had any doubts about being less than enthused about it before, Cornell West and Tavis Smiley confirmed my worst fears.



Cedric: Betty and I are the most up front about our religion of people who do sites in the community. We'll mention being at church or something. Trina's Catholic and she'll mention church as well from time to time. But Betty calls me that night and asks if I caught Goodman's interviews? We were laughing on the phone about that, not at Goodman, but at West and Smiley. Cornell West, you're a distinguished college professor, do you think you can lay off the "my brother" talk? Seriously. And if we were laughing at it, and we're in church every Sunday morning and every Wednesday night, you better believe others were laughing at it as well.



Ty: And that pass he gave Obama was offensive. I'm going to quote it as I remember it and Dallas can fix the quote, thank you Dallas, for when this goes up.



CORNEL WEST: When you look at what, in fact, Obama, Edwards, Clinton -- let's say the top three, as it were -- there's no doubt that Edwards has an impressive concern about poverty and so forth. And Brother Obama -- and you know I am a critical supporter of my dear Brother Obama -- I think that his campaign is kicking in, but it’s still got to be more intensified when it comes to focusing on issues that concern progressives.

[. . .]

AMY GOODMAN: When you say, Professor West, a critical supporter of Obama, what do you mean? Where do you think he hasn't come out strong enough?
CORNEL WEST: Well, I’m in his camp, but I'm just -- I put pressure -- I think that he's got to be more bold. I think that he's got to be more courageous, in terms of highlighting issues of the poor, issues of working people, the legacies of white supremacy that are still very, very real. And I know he’s got to be a politician about this, on the one hand, because he's got a larger constituency, but you know and I know we're looking for statesmen. And I think my dear Brother Obama has a potential to be a great statesman, but he's in process. And we're putting -- we're pushing and hoping that he enacts this kind of statesmanship, which has to do so much with bold unflinching honesty and candor regarding the levels of injustice in our society.




Ty (Con't): He's got to be more progressive, more courageous, address issues of poverty, etc. He's not doing any of that. Exactly why are you a supporter of Obama? That's insane. I'm African-American and I will not be voting for the neoliberal Obama, or as I like to think of him "OBomb Iran," in the primary. I'm hoping that in the general election, he won't be it and I won't have to deliberate on Mr. Phoney anymore.



Cedric: Well, we should note, none of us who are African-American, Betty prefers Black, should have any more stake in Obama than a White person since Obama is not African-American, he's bi-racial. And he dances very well for the White folk. He just doesn't do a damn thing for African-Americans. Cornel West plummeted in my opinion when he made a fool out of himself with those remarks. Poverty is at least one big issue for West and Obama's not done a thing there, except issue a conservative screed against African-American fathers, and West admits that John Edwards is the most impressive on that topic. So this nonsense about being a "critical supporter" of Obama . . . I'm not a "critical supporter" of Cornel West. In fact, I'm not interested in another word from the mouth of my non-brother Cornel because he's made himself sound like an idiot. When you're one of the leading African-American intellectuals, you have an obligation to sound informed, my non-brother.



Betty: And Cedric and I were just laughing on the phone about West and Tavis. I like Tavis Smiley. He's a good looking man, he's often informed. But that day it was like a really bad version of The Gospel Hour. And Tavis Smiley came off foolish as well. "We're not to dwell" on Iraq, but he's sure someone will ask a question about it. Maybe he's been hob knobbing with Wal-Mart too much, but talk to Black people, the illegal war has never gone "off the table." That's why less Black people are enlisting currently. We were opposed to this war, as a people, from the beginning. For him to say that it's not going to be "dwelled" on is just sporting ignorance. I know no one wants to go into the whole Media Matters issues, because they are multi-part, but if we can insert the question by Amy Goodman and some of Tavis' response:



AMY GOODMAN: Tavis, I was wondering your response to this letter from David Brock of Media Matters to PBS for after your discussion, the forum that you’re having with the presidential candidates, having Frank Luntz. The headline of the Media Matters objection is “PBS Using Discredited GOP Pollster to Provide Analysis of Democratic Forum? Selection of Frank Luntz Raises Serious Questions Heading into [the] Presidential Forum.”
TAVIS SMILEY: I thank you for the question, because it allows me to set the record straight. First of all, with all due respect to Mr. Brock, I think one has to consider the source. It always amazes me that people, through their own choices, lose their own integrity, lose their own credibility, and for some reason find a way to then, from time to time, start attacking others who protect and regard their integrity and their credibility, like I do, about things that they’re quite frankly wrong about. Mr. Brock first reported that Frank Luntz was going to be on and participating in the debate. He’s not. You will not see or hear from -- his name will not be raised Thursday night, tonight, in the debate, Frank Luntz.
What Mr. Luntz has been asked to do, what he quite frankly offered to do, was to set up a people-metering room where some thirty African Americans -- they’re all black, they’re all Democrats, they’re all voters -- are going to be asked what they think of the debate, the forum, as it unfolds. So, you know, Amy, how this people metering works, so we’ll be able to read the data as to what they thought about every person on the stage answering these questions, as they were answering the questions. [. . .]
And the role he’s playing is helping us to understand what the top line is for what these African American Democrats had to say.



Betty (Con't): Consider the source? He means David Brock. How right-on Godly you sounded then Tavis. I was being sarcastic, if anyone's confused. But, Tavis, let's consider the source. Frank Luntz is a White man. In this supposed forum for Black America are you trying to tell me that there's not one African-American pollster who could have used a job? Get real. Who's holding Black people back? In this instance Tavis Smiley who thinks a White man can better poll Black people. Get real. That is disgusting. And if you really want to know what Black people think, don't put an aged White male in charge of the questions.



Ty: Hear 'ya and support 'ya 100%. I'll also add that Bore-Ass Obama seemed lost, no surprise, on the topic of race. Who energized the crowd? Hillary Clinton and I do not like Hillary Clinton but, watching, even I was nodding along with her. It reminded me of the point C.I. made here last year about how she could take over the discussion, just energize the crowd.



C.I.: Right, and I'm not endorsing her or anyone, but Hillary is grossly understimated as a public speaker. She doesn't have to learn her way. I was blown away by a 1992 speech she gave to the ABA. I wasn't for Bill Clinton in the primary, I don't think I knew much about Hillary, if anything, at that point. But that speech was incredible and she can move a room. Some critics have been going on about how she's flat or she's this or that. They're missing the point. Before a crowd, Hillary can cut to heart of the matter and win them over. I've always felt she was a better public speaker than her husband. And her height may work in her factor there. I'm serious about that. When she comes to life on stage, especially standing with others who are taller, and she just grabs your attention, I think she comes off more as "one of us." Her size makes her "the little guy" in a way that her famous name never could. Again, that's not an endorsement of her, I'm not endorsing anyone. That is noting that she is a highly gifted speaker who can move a crowd of people. And that's what Ty's referring to. She needs to address Iraq seriously and do so quickly but the point I made before, I believe, was about while each of the candidates tried to out macho each other and tough it up, all Hillary has to do is seize on a topic like education and she'll blow everyone off the stage. She has that power and anyone paying attention in the nineties should be aware of it.



Ceasar2003 wishes we would do more on music and books. He wonders if anything's planned?



Dona: We have things planned each week, we rarely get to them. When C.I.'s not on the road, we're more focused. That's because we're all here and will discuss things throughout the week. So when the weekend rolls around we have a strong idea of what we'll be writing about. In terms of books, I think everyone's really busy. C.I. and I make the time but that's because we're addicted readers. Elaine's doing heavy reading right now in her field so a book discussion would leave her out and Mike's taking summer courses which are intensified due to the shorter schedule. He'd be left out as well. Jim will tell you he's in lazy mode. Jess, who I do not believe has spoken during this feature, nor has Wally and Rebecca's been very brief, has a full plate currently. A book on Iraq that interested us all would certainly be the focus for a book discussion. Other than that, I wouldn't expect anything anytime soon. In terms of music, we could do a playlist this edition but we're already so far behind that I would kill any other proposal because we love music and end up talking amongst ourselves. That's a real time eater and we don't have enough features completed yet. In fact, I'm about to start screaming my mantra of "Short pieces! Short pieces!" any second.



Clara wanted to know if anything had stood out so far this summer and we'll limit this to Jess, Rebecca and Wally since they haven't spoken much, or at all in two cases.



Jess: I'm thinking of something from last week but thinking it could work as a "Short Piece" so I'm going to just say that it's been a fun and exciting summer personally. Rebecca?



Rebecca: Well, on the personal, I've wanted a child forever and I have one finally. That's a really big deal with me and the biggest difference this summer from any other. On another personal level, the Iraq war continues and supposedly Harry Reid's going to address it after the July 4th break. I won't hold my breath. I didn't expect miracles from this Congress but, at this point, I'm really not expecting anything. Bully Boy should be impeached and the war should be ended. I'm glad my child's too young for me to have explain what's going on.



Wally: Well said. Well I got to spend time with my buddy Mike earlier this summer and that's always fun. And last week, I got to go to a few states and speak with people my age and younger about the war which is always exciting and encouraging. I know the incident Jess is talking about and agree it's a short piece. I'm wondering how we do it though. But it was a lot of fun being out on the road. I was really pissed that C.I. had to do an entry Wednesday night. I don't even remember why that was, why the entry needed to be done. But that was the only downside. Ava, Jess and I would get to cut loose and we'd hope C.I. would be coming along but last week was crazy. I do know that C.I. and Mike did some strong work covering the deaths of the 3 British soldiers and considering how little noted those were deaths were and how much community members in the UK appreciated them, I took part in the roundtable for Polly's Brew, I think that's worth noting.



Mike: Right and Polly e-mailed me when C.I.'s entry Saturday morning had gone up saying, "You're right. Your media isn't even interested in the death of American soldiers. It's no surprise they don't care about our soldiers."

They Were Turned Into Shoplifters!

This is a true story.



On the road last week, Ava, Jess, Wally and C.I. stopped a small store, part of a corporate chain. Jess, who is a huge fan of the Cowboy Junkies (we all are), found a five track disc entitled 'neath your covers part 1. There was no price on it. He took the disc to the counter to inquire about the price. The clerk noted there was no bar code on it.



"We can't sell it to you."



Jess offered twenty bucks, pointing out it was a 5 track disc.



"We can't sell it to you."



Not only did they refuse to sell it, they didn't hand it back. Jess goes over to Wally, Ava and C.I. to tell them about it.



"What a ___. Did you go over his head and ask for the manager?"



He was the manager.



C.I. explained that it was a bonus disc released with the Cowboy Junkies' One Soul CD. We should note here that Jess is a huge Neil Young fan and one of the tracks on the EP was a cover of Neil Young's "Helpless." Also covered was Bruce Springsteen's "Thunder Road," The Cure's "Seventeen Seconds," the Youngbloods' "Darkness, Darkness" and Towne Van Zandt's "Lungs."



There was no One Soul in the racks. There were three other copies of 'neath your covers part 1. None had a bar code on it. That was because none were supposed to be sold. It was a bonus when you bought One Soul. (For anyone wondering, they also didn't have the Cowboy Junkies' latest CD, at the end of paths taken. They only had one of those best of, millennium collections and the three copies of the EP, all unmarked.)



One said, they shouldn't stock merchandise if they're not going to sell it. One said, I'm tempted to put it under my shirt. C.I. said, it would be better to get the clerk & manager to ring us up and sack the EPs.



Ava agreed and noted, "If they're not selling it, they shouldn't stock it."



ROCK SOUND "MUSIC WITH ATTITUDE." That's a magazine. It's offering a bonus disc (and posters! Most of all, it's offering a CD in a paper case on the front. Taking off that CD and putting the Cowboy Junkies CD on the cover, they were good to go.

rocksoundscowboy

At which point, Wally says, "Man, I wanted a copy of that!" C.I.'s reply was a hissed, "Do you know how hard it was to get this one to stick on the magazine?"



But there they were, casually pulling off the CD freebie to substitute . . . a CD freebie. It was planned as a bonus and the store had obviously not sold it with One Soul (as it was supposed to). The store had four in stock (one held by the manager, three on the racks). One Soul came out in 2004. They've had three years to figure this out. Jess offered them 20 bucks for one copy. The store wasn't interested.



So they headed to the counter with twelve magazines, two of which were ROCK SOUND, as well as a CD they'd found for Jim (which they were paying for). The clerk (also manager) who'd been rude and surly to Jess was suddenly all smiles as the plastic came out. He couldn't stop chatting with them about the weather as he rang up and sacked the purchases.



When they got back home Friday, they played the CD and we've listened nonstop. It wasn't until we were working on another feature that they shared this story.



The late and great Clamor once did a feature article where people shared their experience stealing something. We're a rather boring crowd in that regard. Dona once stole a pack of gum in first grade and showed it to her mother after (not in a I-was-bad way) and they had to march right back into the store, return the gum, apologize privately to the manager and, at the insistence of her mother, go up to the checkout lanes and confess publicly what she had done. "Humiliating, yes," she says, "but I never swiped anything again."



As we learned about the Cowboy Junkies EP story, Dona shared that and we thought that was it. Until Rebecca said, "I had a huge crush/heavy lust on Kurt Cobain in 1991. Ask C.I. what happened?" Rebecca wanted a display that was going to be tossed in the trash. She asked about it and was told, "We're not allowed to sell them. Next."



"For whatever reason, I wanted that and was furious." She was with C.I. and the display left with them. On another story Rebecca steered us to from decades ago, Elaine and C.I. clam up except to note that it was information that needed liberating, not merchandise, and this wasn't a store. So they helped liberate it.



Cedric insists we put in this "Kids don't try this at home" note. What would have happened if, after paying and beginning to leave the store, they'd have been stopped? C.I.: "I would have been on the phone to one of the corporations' vice-presidents, someone I've known for 15 years, explaining they had four copies of it on the racks, no price on it, and that they refused to sell it, a freebie, even when they had been offered twenty bucks. That explanation wouldn't have been to avoid the trouble, the call alone would have taken care of that, but it would put the store manager in trouble for not ensuring that the store did inventory regularly and for refusing to sell stocked merchandise."



So, while we applaud this act of liberation, we also caution that unless you've got someone in corporate you can call, follow that example at your own risk.

Don't Nobody Bring Me No Blonde News

coulterpark


"Are you going to write about Ann Coulter this week?" a few e-mails this week wondered. No. No. And no. We think there's been more than enough Blonde News in the month of June to tide everyone over until 2008. Above is a picture. Let it paint a thousand words. If you need more, please refer to Cedric's "More Blonde Woman "News" to Distract the US" and Wally's "THIS JUST IN! JUNK NEWS DOMINATES!"

Highlights

This feature is written by Elaine, Rebecca, Betty, Cedric, Wally and Mike. Unless otherwise noted, we selected the highlights.



"Page Six Calls" -- okay, we begged Betty to tell us what comes next for Betinna. She gave us two upcoming developments. You need to read this one closely for what's coming up next.



"Cucumber and Madarin Orange Salad in the Kitchen" -- Mike, and only Mike, will be commenting on this one. Mike: "I didn't think Ma would write it. In that one paragraph, she went into more detail about the damage than I did. The house was trashed. Ma's still not sure she should have written about it but Dad's glad she did. I am too."



Mike's "3 British soldiers dead in Iraq" and C.I.'s "Iraq snapshot," "Other Items," "25 Iraqis killed in Baghdad car bombing, 3 British soldiers dead in Basra" and "And the war drags on . . ." -- we all live in the US and it's easy to turn the deaths of British soldiers into a sentence and move on -- as many in the media did last week. Mike and C.I. hit hard on it and Polly asked us to highlight each of the above. Be sure to check Polly's Brew today for Mike's column on this and more including Polly's roundtable on Moonbat (which Wally participated in).



"Spying, Marjorie Cohn" -- Rebecca's full of praises for everyone's posts but her own today. She notes that Elaine had a really strong week and we all agree. This is Elaine addressing the CIA revelations and more.



"Law and Disorder: Laura Flanders, Stanley Aronowitz" and "Laura Flanders & Stanley Aronowitz (Law and Disorder)" -- Kat and Mike offer their takes on the debate/discussion between Stanley Aronowitz and Laura Flanders at the Left Forum earlier this month -- approximately 28 minutes were broadcast on Monday's Law and Disorder.



"More Blonde Woman "News" to Distract the US" & "THIS JUST IN! JUNK NEWS DOMINATES!" -- Cedric and Wally's commentary that didn't go for funny, just got straight to the point.



"Ruth's Report" -- we almost forgot this. It went up after we started working on this week's edition. More hard hitting commentary from Ruth.



Isaiah's The World Today Just Nuts "Pace and Gates frolic in Operation Happy Talk" -- Isaiah's comic capturing the care-free nature of Peter Pace and Bill Gates, two men, alone together in the surf. Very From Here To Eternity.



"snakes slither out of the alberto gonzales cesspool," "the mishandling party plaanner alberto gonzales," "gonzales: the booing never stops!," "gonzales & other scandals" and "gonzales & cheney - hey now, young lovers" -- Rebecca continues covering the Alberto Gonzales Scandals.



"Adam Kokesh (and my rambles)" -- Kat notes Kokesh and the way things have changed in the country.



"Iraq snapshot" -- Thursday's snapshot by C.I. which Kayla requested we highlight because "I didn't see anyone else calling out the AP story." Neither did we, Kayla.





"THIS JUST IN! DON'T CALL HER A "POOR"!" & "Whining Whitman" -- Jonah picked this a as "something you have to highlight." We agree. Wally and Cedric take on Christy Todd Whitman.



"Tony Peyser, Corporate Crime Reporter" & "Tony Peyser, Ron Jacobs" -- all sites posting Tuesday evening linked to the Peyser article (including C.I. who did an evening post for that reason among others). Hilda asked that we link to Elaine and Mike's post which also provided commentary. She notes she will be addressing this topic Tuesday in Hilda's Mix.

Sunday, June 24, 2007

Truest statement of the week

AMY GOODMAN: Jimmy, how often do you get to talk about war at school?
JIMMY PRESSON: We very rarely to never talk about the war through the curriculum. In classes in which we discuss current events, we are required to not bring in current events that relate to the war.
AMY GOODMAN: Wait, what do you mean? What about social studies or history?
JIMMY PRESSON: In history classes, the current events that we bring in are -- we've been instructed to have the articles be unrelated to the war.
AMY GOODMAN: You're not allowed to talk about war in your history class?
JIMMY PRESSON: We're not allowed to talk about the war.
AMY GOODMAN: Why?
JIMMY PRESSON: Because it's too controversial, I guess. Because they don't want kids arguing in class.
AMY GOODMAN: Is there any class that you can talk about it?
JIMMY PRESSON: We can talk about it a little bit in Middle Eastern studies, a little bit, but it's not even that much in that class.
BONNIE DICKINSON: That class is not offered.
JIMMY PRESSON: Every year. It's only offered every other year.
AMY GOODMAN: So this past year, it wasn't offered?
JIMMY PRESSON: It was not offered this past year.
AMY GOODMAN: So the only class to discuss this was in drama?
JIMMY PRESSON: Yeah.


-- Democracy Now!, June 20, 2007, "War and Censorship at Wilton High: Connecticut High School Students Perform Play on NY Stage After Ban by Principal." See also Amy Goodman's "War and Censorship at Wilton High" (Truthdig).

A Note to Our Readers

Hey --
Sunday and we're making fairly good time for us. (Dona swears when she's done with her diet soda and two more cigarettes, the edition is done, whether or not the note is.)

First let's note this week's credits:


The Third Estate Sunday Review's Dona, Jess, Ty, Ava and Jim,
Rebecca of Sex and Politics and Screeds and Attitude,
Betty of Thomas Friedman Is a Great Man,
C.I. of The Common Ills and The Third Estate Sunday Review,
Kat of Kat's Korner (of The Common Ills),
Cedric of Cedric's Big Mix,
Mike of Mikey Likes It!,
Elaine of Like Maria Said Paz,
and Wally of The Daily Jot

All of the above worked on this edition as did Dallas and we also thank Isaiah for the use of one of his comics.

What have you got?

books

It's our third annual summer read edition. Yes, there have been two others. The archives are a joke but you can refer to "The summer reads" from last April for links to the summer 2006 edition and the summer 2005 edition. If you check the dates (Jess just did, Dona was curious), we are about the same time period this year as in 2005 but we are several weeks behind 2006.
That may have been why we felt like we were running late on this all month.


Truest statement of the week -- an interview by Amy Goodman that everyone should know about.

Editorial: Iraq silences -- our editorial for this week on the silences surrounding Iraq and wondering why Congress is the only thing disgusting many people currently.

TV: Hidden Yawns -- Ava and C.I. go creative for this review to fit the summer read edition. They'd planned to do something with this show last week, when it was planned that we'd be doing the summer edition before events changed that. In this commentary, Ava and C.I. visit Hidden Yawns, er Palms, and find out what's what.

Base Is Hell -- We had twenty ideas coming into this session but an ex-Marine saw our list Friday and suggested we do something on the "cushy commanders." We're always open to suggestions from people we know. C.I. adds, "Don't say 'ex,' he's in IRR and, as we've seen with
Liam Madden, Cloy Richards and Adam Kokesh, the brass doesn't consider a discharge a discharge anymore." (That also cleverly allows the third set of links for Madden, Richards and Kokesh this edition.) We read the first draft over the phone to our friend right before midnight. He said good but punch it up. We did. This is also the closest we have to a sci-fi piece.

The Tired Tryst -- This was the hardest one to get a handle on. There were probably ten drafts of this until Elaine asked, "What was that thing on Bruce Springsteen back in the 80s?" C.I. immediately said, "Tama Janowitz' 'You and the Boss'?" Yes, said Elaine. Did anyone have a copy of that? C.I. found one. (It ran in Spin's November 1985 issue.) The piece, about a groupie who waylays Bruce Springsteen's first wife to take her place, was written in second person ("you") and with that and Janowitz's own tale, we found our way into this on the eleventh try. In this short story, YOU get to sleep with Bono.

The Asbury Park Murder -- Susan and Dale both e-mailed back in May asking if we could offer some sort of mystery. Susan wanted it so badly, she said "even a really bad attempt would do." Susan, we may have pleased you. (Though not exceeded your expectation!)

Creation Theory -- Barack Ba-Boring gets born.

Samantha Power Between Her Knees -- We were listening to the Tori Amos collection (Tales of a Librarian) a lot recently and it includes "Sweet Dreams" (about Poppy Bush) and the line, "You've even got their zipper between your teeth" which led us to ponder other things. Ty's saying right now, this actually is a sci-fi piece. In this tale, a woman encounters Samantha Powers and is invaded.

Cut The Fat! Newt Takes It Off! -- C.I. had nixed another advice column from Cokie ("too simple unless someone's got something extra to add") which left us wondering what else we could do and "a diet book" was proposed. Who better to write one than Newt! We wrote 12 pieces and whittled them down to what we felt were the best six (after Ty and C.I. pulled a prose poem that they'd worked on).

So that's what you've got and, on this end, we think it's better than 2006 which none of us have still yet to read over since it published. How does it fare compared to 2005? We don't want to make that judgement. We're just glad we're able to post with minimal embarrassment.

Hopefully, you'll enjoy the summer read, fiction edition. If not, take comfort in the fact that you don't have to see it again for twelve more months.

Highlight -- No one caught that it was "Highlight" and not "Highlights" until it posted. We thank Mike, Betty, Wally, Rebecca, Cedric and Elaine for doing this feature.

Ava and C.I. bonus -- If you missed it, doubtful judging by the e-mails that came in, Ava and C.I. did a joint-entry at The Common Ills Tuesday. We repost it here this week.

And that's it. We'll see you next weekend.

-- Jim, Dona, Ty, Jess, Ava and C.I.
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported License.
 
Poll1 { display:none; }