If you missed the news, Micah's called The Village Voice's time of death. What?? If you asked that question you obviously missed Democracy Now!'s "Village Voice Shakeup: Top Investigative Journalist Fired, Prize-Winning Writers Resign Following Merger with New Times Media." So now The Voice is part of a syndicate that brings about as many good things to life as G.E. What can you expect in the new and watered down Voice? A lot of the crap that the syndicate's other "alternative" weeklies offer. Here's our take on what we're sure we'll be the future of the weekly. Some of spoofs are based on the past publication history of New Times Media. One is based on a current story, one that required 'investigative' journalism and lots of leg work so you just know it has to be about an important topic, one affecting us all, right? Wrong. Add generic, grainy photo to the proposed cover items below.
New 'Tude Media presents . . .
NO VOICE FOR THE VILLAGE
NEWS!
HE SO COLORFUL!
Them Wacky Black Folks Always Got Their Hands Out!
An African-American claims a corporation owes him big bling-bling!
We side with the corporation and kick him to the
curb by recounting every messy episode
we can dig up from his dead mother's life!
Investigative journalism at its finest!
by Skip and Muffy Mayflower
BROKEBACK MY MOUNTAIN BE-OUCH!
Second period! Pavol Demitra scored on a breakaway!
Los Angeles grabs 2-1 victory! In your face, Calgary!
In your face!
by Chris Generic
WHEN WILL THEY LEARN
Topher was on the honor roll at his all White school,
Whites Only, in a quiet suburb. He had it all.
He had a girlfriend (with a wealthy family, like his own).
He drove a BMW. He was captain of his football team.
She was a cheerleader. Then he discovered
a deadly cocktail: 'roids and meth. As his
girlfriend vows to wait for him, Topher enters
an upscale rehab. We take a hard hitting look
at what this may mean for Whites Only's
varsity football team this fall. Warning: This heart
tearing story will have you quaking in
your Pradas.
by Tiffany Buckley
MUSIC!
BEHIND EVERY WOMAN, THERE'S A MAN
Pink's I'm Not Dead is a masterpiece! We give
all the credit to Billy Mann!
Chris Generic
Also: Chris tells you what's in Hip-Hop for
White people!
MOVIES!
ALL MONEY BUT NO BOOBIES!
The only thing missing from Friends With Money
is Meg Ryan to make this the total chick-flick disaster
of the year. Somebody tells the girls,
"Take it off or shut up!" That's what I'm
talking about.
CULTURE
WHEN PROMISES AREN'T MET
Consumer reporter Betsy Faulkner delves into
the issue of 2000 Flushes and you won't believe
what her probe of the toilet tank unearths!
1999 flushes, not the promised 2000!
Sunday, April 16, 2006
Quick Take: Scalia
Stephanie Reitz' "Scalia Stands by Decision in Cheney Case" (Associated Press):
Conservative U.S. Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia on Wednesday called his 2004 decision not to recuse himself from a case involving Vice President Dick Cheney the "proudest thing" he's done on the court.
In a long life, with little accomplishments, he had to point something.
Conservative U.S. Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia on Wednesday called his 2004 decision not to recuse himself from a case involving Vice President Dick Cheney the "proudest thing" he's done on the court.
In a long life, with little accomplishments, he had to point something.
Pacifica Radio Highlights
Pacifica Radio highlights for the week.
Via Ruth's most recent Public Radio Report:
KPFA's Sunday Salon will cover the following this Sunday (9:00 a.m. Pacific time, 11:00 a.m. Central, and noon Eastern time) :
First HourIn our first hour...
Imagine being one of several dozen women incarcerated with thousands of men. Harassment, humiliation, and in many cases, rape, are all a part of the daily routine. So is being called "sir." Outside of prison, transgender folks often face a hurtful lack of understanding; inside prison, that lackof understanding can be life-threatening...
Attorney Alex Lee of the Transgender, Gender Variant & Intersex Justice Project joins us, and others, to be confirmed.
Second HourIn our second hour...
Its been 100 years since the 1906 Earthquake. And 1989 -- when the last big one hit the Bay Area -- isn't recent history, either. Time to dust off your earthquake-preparedness savvy...
Our guests Ana-Marie Jones of Collaborating Agencies Responding to Disasters, Kiska Icard of the San Francisco SPCA, and others will remind you how to get yourself, your home, and your family -- including its non-human members -- ready for a rumbler.
Listen to past shows, get contact and reference info for guests, see announcements of upcoming programs, and more at: SundaySalon.org.
Sandra Lupien of KPFA's The Morning Show will fill in for Mr. Bensky as this Sunday's host.
KPFA is celebrating its 57th year and also on KPFA today (time given is Pacific):
6:30 pm
Radio Chronicles
See all Drama and Literature Programming
Radio Chronicles brings "Camp KPFA".
A look back at the KPFA-FM lock-out by Pacifica Radio, which took place July l5, 1999, inciting arrests, protests, and a nationwide campaign to save independent media and the country's most unique free speech radio station. First person accounts from the radio listener activists who barricaded themselves to KPFA's doors, and lived in the streets throughout those lock-out days.
On WBAI today (time given is Eastern):
6:30-7:00 pm: Equal Time for Freethought
Easter Day Special--Suffering, Salvation, Sexuality, & Spring: Or, are we the only ones who think the image of Jesus crucified, naked, tortured, and dripping with blood, is bursting with sadomasochistic overtures?
At this time of year it's common to see depictions of the brutal suffering of Jesus on the cross presented as a holy and glorious moment for humankind.
Yet the torment of Christ as an expression of God's love enabling humankind to be "cleansed of its sin" and "saved" is merely the official meaning of the brutal story that is primary to Western culture.
Passover which also takes place at this time of year also offers it's own share of blood and violence which is also presented as the expression of a loving God's plan.
To what extent might religious and spiritual traditions that glorify suffering and denial of our physical needs result in generalized violence and cruelty in our society?
Is there a relationship between the violence in faith based practices and people's unacknowledged psycho-sexual desires?
Might there be better ways to address such needs than to simply deny that they exist?
To help us examine this question we will have joining us Ms. Dorothy Hayden, a trained social worker, psychoanalyst and a practicing psychotherapist here in Manhattan, whose advice column "Black Leather Couch" appeared in the New York S&M scene's publication "Prometheus Magazine."
Also, back by popular demand, we will replay the classic showdown between the Easter Bunny and Jesus Christ himself!
So, tune in, pay it forward, and question everything with Equal Time for Freethought, Sunday at 6:00pm, on WBAI - 99.5 FM - streaming live at www.wbai.org.
Barry F. Seidman
Exec. Producer: Equal Time for Freethought
www.njhn.org/etff.html
Throughout this week (Monday through Friday), KPFT offers the following on Open Journal (airs at noon Central time):
April 17
Local Station Board Report
April 18
Hep C Show
April 19
Building Environmental Community
With Reginald Adams
April 20
Waking Up from the American Dream
Sustainability Issues with Flora Yeh
April 21
Religious Voices for Peace and Justice
With Herb Rothschild
Final Pacifica Radio note. Upcoming in June, Pacifica launches a daily news hour in Espanol. Support independent media.
Via Ruth's most recent Public Radio Report:
KPFA's Sunday Salon will cover the following this Sunday (9:00 a.m. Pacific time, 11:00 a.m. Central, and noon Eastern time) :
First HourIn our first hour...
Imagine being one of several dozen women incarcerated with thousands of men. Harassment, humiliation, and in many cases, rape, are all a part of the daily routine. So is being called "sir." Outside of prison, transgender folks often face a hurtful lack of understanding; inside prison, that lackof understanding can be life-threatening...
Attorney Alex Lee of the Transgender, Gender Variant & Intersex Justice Project joins us, and others, to be confirmed.
Second HourIn our second hour...
Its been 100 years since the 1906 Earthquake. And 1989 -- when the last big one hit the Bay Area -- isn't recent history, either. Time to dust off your earthquake-preparedness savvy...
Our guests Ana-Marie Jones of Collaborating Agencies Responding to Disasters, Kiska Icard of the San Francisco SPCA, and others will remind you how to get yourself, your home, and your family -- including its non-human members -- ready for a rumbler.
Listen to past shows, get contact and reference info for guests, see announcements of upcoming programs, and more at: SundaySalon.org.
Sandra Lupien of KPFA's The Morning Show will fill in for Mr. Bensky as this Sunday's host.
KPFA is celebrating its 57th year and also on KPFA today (time given is Pacific):
6:30 pm
Radio Chronicles
See all Drama and Literature Programming
Radio Chronicles brings "Camp KPFA".
A look back at the KPFA-FM lock-out by Pacifica Radio, which took place July l5, 1999, inciting arrests, protests, and a nationwide campaign to save independent media and the country's most unique free speech radio station. First person accounts from the radio listener activists who barricaded themselves to KPFA's doors, and lived in the streets throughout those lock-out days.
On WBAI today (time given is Eastern):
6:30-7:00 pm: Equal Time for Freethought
Easter Day Special--Suffering, Salvation, Sexuality, & Spring: Or, are we the only ones who think the image of Jesus crucified, naked, tortured, and dripping with blood, is bursting with sadomasochistic overtures?
At this time of year it's common to see depictions of the brutal suffering of Jesus on the cross presented as a holy and glorious moment for humankind.
Yet the torment of Christ as an expression of God's love enabling humankind to be "cleansed of its sin" and "saved" is merely the official meaning of the brutal story that is primary to Western culture.
Passover which also takes place at this time of year also offers it's own share of blood and violence which is also presented as the expression of a loving God's plan.
To what extent might religious and spiritual traditions that glorify suffering and denial of our physical needs result in generalized violence and cruelty in our society?
Is there a relationship between the violence in faith based practices and people's unacknowledged psycho-sexual desires?
Might there be better ways to address such needs than to simply deny that they exist?
To help us examine this question we will have joining us Ms. Dorothy Hayden, a trained social worker, psychoanalyst and a practicing psychotherapist here in Manhattan, whose advice column "Black Leather Couch" appeared in the New York S&M scene's publication "Prometheus Magazine."
Also, back by popular demand, we will replay the classic showdown between the Easter Bunny and Jesus Christ himself!
So, tune in, pay it forward, and question everything with Equal Time for Freethought, Sunday at 6:00pm, on WBAI - 99.5 FM - streaming live at www.wbai.org.
Barry F. Seidman
Exec. Producer: Equal Time for Freethought
www.njhn.org/etff.html
Throughout this week (Monday through Friday), KPFT offers the following on Open Journal (airs at noon Central time):
April 17
Local Station Board Report
April 18
Hep C Show
April 19
Building Environmental Community
With Reginald Adams
April 20
Waking Up from the American Dream
Sustainability Issues with Flora Yeh
April 21
Religious Voices for Peace and Justice
With Herb Rothschild
Final Pacifica Radio note. Upcoming in June, Pacifica launches a daily news hour in Espanol. Support independent media.
Musings and thoughts on why you should be watching/listening/reading Democracy Now!
AMY GOODMAN: It's very good to have you with us. Well, let's talk about your vantage point, from having served on the Church Committee. And for young people who are watching or listening right now, they may have never have heard of this committee.
GARY HART: Basically, what the country is going through now is a rerun of what happened during periods of the Vietnam War, in which largely the Nixon administration undertook illegal activities to place American citizens under surveillance and accuse them of unpatriotic conduct, and justifying support for the war -- using support for the war as a justification for violation of constitutional rights and liberties. So, what's happening now is a rerun of history, in effect.
AMY GOODMAN: And at that time, can you talk about some of the things that you uncovered? You've been writing about it, talking about deja vu all over again.
GARY HART: Well, I think the most startling discovery of our committee -- and let me just put that committee in context. There had never been genuine congressional oversight of the intelligence community in the United States since the C.I.A. was formed in 1947. By and large, members of Congress did not want to know what was going on. When press leaks of unconstitutional behavior on the part of the administration occurred, there was public demand for some kind of investigation. That's what led to our committee.
We had eleven members -- six Democrats, five Republicans -- including the late Barry Goldwater and others, and we began a unique undertaking which was to try to find out what the C.I.A. and the F.B.I. and N.S.A. and others were up to. And it was during that that the most startling revelations had to do with our efforts to assassinate foreign leaders, particularly Fidel Castro, over two or three administrations, and this massive scheme to surveil American citizens. AMY GOODMAN: Can you elaborate on that, the attempts to assassinate Fidel Castro?
GARY HART: Well, it's a long, long story, obviously. With almost demented insistence, we tried to kill him. What we spent our time doing, once we discovered these plots, was to find out who ordered it. And to this day, I don't think anyone ever found out where the instructions came from or whether the officials in the C.I.A. and other agencies just simply decided on their own. There clearly was indication that President Kennedy and his brother wanted --
AMY GOODMAN: Robert Kennedy.
GARY HART: -- Castro gone. Robert Kennedy. But they never, to our knowledge, they never said, 'Kill him.' It's one thing to say we want somebody out of office, another thing to say assassination. And we found no record that an assassination order was ever given by the president.
AMY GOODMAN: And the killing of Kennedy?
GARY HART: Well, it was outside our mandate to go back and reopen the Warren Commission. We had no authority to do that, but former senator Schweiker and myself undertook a kind of subcommittee effort to see if there was any connection between the efforts to kill Castro and President Kennedy's subsequent death, and we found some evidence that was new, but nothing that was determinative. I think the real question that we were trying to get at was why would the C.I.A. employ senior Mafia figures in this effort? And that was rather startling discovery on our part.
The above is from Amy Goodman's interview with former US Senator Gary Hart which aired on Democracy Now! March 28, 2006 ("Fmr. Democratic Senator and Presidential Candidate Gary Hart: 'Both Houses of Congress Belong to the President's Party'"). Did you see it on the Evening News? On Nightly News? On World News Tonight? No. Which is why we agree with Ava and C.I.'s point in another feature in this edition that we wouldn't curse Amy Goodman by wishing she anchored on a corporate news network.
Let's back up for anyone new to Amy Goodman (or her co-host Juan Gonzalez). Democracy Now! is an hourly broadcast that airs Monday through Friday. Where can you watch it? At the site online. On public access television around the country. On some PBS stations. On Direct TV and Free Speech TV. Maybe you prefer listening? You can listen online at the website. You can listen on Pacifica Radio stations (over the airwaves and online). You can listen on community radio stations and on some NPR stations. Not able to do that? Your computer doesn't handle streaming? Well, online at the Democracy Now! website, you can read transcripts.
So what's your excuse for not checking it out? (We hope you have none because you already are checking it out.)
If you're not checking it out, what did you miss last week? How much time do you have? Wait, how much time do we have?
For one thing you missed an interview with Seymour Hersh of The New Yorker on Bully Boy's planning for bombing Iran. "Oh," you say, "I saw him on 360 with Anderson Cooper this week."
Ah yes, the soundbyte as dialogue. Trust us, you missed out. How about Gustavo Jiminez?
Please don't tell us you asked who? He is one of the student leaders in the walkouts that have taken place across the nation.
And speaking of activism, how about the people of St. Augustine Parish? They got the Church reopened. They had to fight for days and days . . . What? You don't know about the flihgt against the Church's flight from New Orleans?
Huh. Well that net neutrality issue, that's pretty big, right? Without it the "information highway" will be come a toll road, know what we're saying? You missed that too?
We'll we're sure you got valuable information from your news source. You must have heard about the trouble going down at The Village Voice, though, right? Nothing on that?
Exactly what did your news programming provide you with this week? Oh, you got a clip of Diane Sawyer's then upcoming interview with Tom Cruise? Sweet! We bet that help put food on your table and keep you informed.
What's that you say? That's the least of your problems? Well unload, we've got a few minutes.
Spill.
"There I was," you say, "with the nation on the eve of the war, trying to get the facts about what was going on and what the issues were. I was watching the evening news, I was watching the cable news, I even watched the NewsHour and their bump-bump-bah-bump bumper music gives me a headache. So I put in all that time and now it turns out, it was all a waste. Everything they said -- repeated, whatever! Lies. I was lied into war! I spent all that time watching these programs that were supposed to inform me and all I got was like way uninformed!"
Interesting. And yet you still watch those programs.
Here's the thing, viewers (and listeners and readers) of Democracy Now! knew there was administration spin and then there were actual realities. We didn't get blindsided because there was discussion, there was debate, there was much more than "Today our fearless leader stated . . ."
So let us repeat: And yet you still watch those programs?
Amy Goodman doesn't need a corporate network behind her. What she and Juan Gonzalez and the staff of Democracy Now! do could never fly on corporate news where the only voices that matter are those in office or those who've just left offices (appointed or elected). Now there's a time to utilize those voices. But they shouldn't become the only voices out there. Or, as Amy Goodman has repeatedly noted, ex-generals shouldn't be regular guests (on the payroll of the broadcasters, no less) when peace activists are left uninvited.
Everyone makes a mistake. That's not the issue here. A mistake can be corrected. You say, "We reported wrongly . . ." and can move on. But what was practiced by corporate news wasn't a "mistake" in reporting -- implying they got a detail wrong as they attempted to convey a total picture. To convey a total picture, they would have had to have listened and given space to dissenting voices (as prominent as the space they gave to those supporting the war). They didn't do that. The mistake wasn't in one report. The mistake was their concept of reporting itself which is acting as a newsletter for those in office.
World News Tonight For and By the Government would be a better title. Nightly News For The Beltway is another example. The Evening News If You Matter to Us.
So having been misled, why are you still relying on the same news sources. As the Bully Boy infamously said (or maybe we misunderstood him), "Fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, I'm a corporate news whore." Something like that anyway.
Laura Flanders is on vacation so we thought we'd use this week to note Amy Goodman and the decision was based in part upon this by Elaine:
I'll note a moment of panic today during Democracy Now! that Sunny and I both had. Amy Goodman was coughing and had to take a break. Before she came back, Sunny and I were both pointing out that the show broadcasts not far from ground zero in NYC and remembering this item from Thursday:
"Report: 15,000 Suffer From Medical Problems in NYC Post 9/11" (Democracy Now!):
In other news, the BBC is reporting the number of victims suffering medical problems in connection to the 9/11 attacks on the World Trade Center has risen to at least 15,000 people. The US government has been hit with a class-action lawsuit that alleges it offered false assurances to Manhattan residents and workers that the air was safe in the aftermath of the attacks. In a landmark ruling, a New Jersey coroner said this week that a police officer's death was "directly linked" to his work at Ground Zero after 9/11. The officer, James Zadroga, died in January.
When she came back, she explained that she had a spring cold. (I think that probably comes from the fact that she's all over the country, getting the word out, covering news and doing outreach work for community media.) We both sighed in relief when she said that. Amy Goodman, who celebrated a birthday Thursday, does so much for indymedia and, if you found yourself worried in that moment, do your part to get the word out or do your part to get the word out because she had a birthday. But get the word out. Twenty years from now, due to further media consolidation (I think it will happen short of a major citizen revolution), the media landscape will have changed. I also think it's true that, twenty years from now, we'll see hundreds of Amy Goodmans because she's made a difference and she's demonstrated the role that journalists can and should play. She's altered the landscape and become a role model.
That cough was a scary moment. But on the week of Amy Goodman's birthday, a number of us were noting the realities of what DN! provides and the realities of the attention it gets (or, more often, doesn't get). As C.I. noted:
The left can be critiqued (in any manner, in any tone) by the left -- that's not a problem. What's a problem is repeating easy slams from the right, distortions made by the right, to prove how "reasonable" you are. (Also not helpful is taking a story Democracy Now! covers -- and covers well -- and instead noting the mainstream as though they just broke news or discovered a topic. A point Cedric wants noted but one that I'm sure the community will agree with. This week alone, Amy Goodman's interviewed Seymour Hersh, Greg Palast -- and shown some of his BBC report -- and others while she and Juan Gonzalez have addressed the issue of the Village Voice. The attention level Democracy Now! receives could be upped by about a thousand and still not note the degree to which this program breaks ground daily. Irritating to members is reading statements such as "NPR just did a really wonderful report that was groundbreaking and blah blah blah" when in fact the topic was covered by DN! and other Pacifica Radio programs days, weeks, months ago. There's a lot of stroking NPR from our left print set. Not a great deal of support for Pacifica Radio.)
So are you complaining about how the corporate media failed you but still using it as your primary source for news? How much sense does that make?
GARY HART: Basically, what the country is going through now is a rerun of what happened during periods of the Vietnam War, in which largely the Nixon administration undertook illegal activities to place American citizens under surveillance and accuse them of unpatriotic conduct, and justifying support for the war -- using support for the war as a justification for violation of constitutional rights and liberties. So, what's happening now is a rerun of history, in effect.
AMY GOODMAN: And at that time, can you talk about some of the things that you uncovered? You've been writing about it, talking about deja vu all over again.
GARY HART: Well, I think the most startling discovery of our committee -- and let me just put that committee in context. There had never been genuine congressional oversight of the intelligence community in the United States since the C.I.A. was formed in 1947. By and large, members of Congress did not want to know what was going on. When press leaks of unconstitutional behavior on the part of the administration occurred, there was public demand for some kind of investigation. That's what led to our committee.
We had eleven members -- six Democrats, five Republicans -- including the late Barry Goldwater and others, and we began a unique undertaking which was to try to find out what the C.I.A. and the F.B.I. and N.S.A. and others were up to. And it was during that that the most startling revelations had to do with our efforts to assassinate foreign leaders, particularly Fidel Castro, over two or three administrations, and this massive scheme to surveil American citizens. AMY GOODMAN: Can you elaborate on that, the attempts to assassinate Fidel Castro?
GARY HART: Well, it's a long, long story, obviously. With almost demented insistence, we tried to kill him. What we spent our time doing, once we discovered these plots, was to find out who ordered it. And to this day, I don't think anyone ever found out where the instructions came from or whether the officials in the C.I.A. and other agencies just simply decided on their own. There clearly was indication that President Kennedy and his brother wanted --
AMY GOODMAN: Robert Kennedy.
GARY HART: -- Castro gone. Robert Kennedy. But they never, to our knowledge, they never said, 'Kill him.' It's one thing to say we want somebody out of office, another thing to say assassination. And we found no record that an assassination order was ever given by the president.
AMY GOODMAN: And the killing of Kennedy?
GARY HART: Well, it was outside our mandate to go back and reopen the Warren Commission. We had no authority to do that, but former senator Schweiker and myself undertook a kind of subcommittee effort to see if there was any connection between the efforts to kill Castro and President Kennedy's subsequent death, and we found some evidence that was new, but nothing that was determinative. I think the real question that we were trying to get at was why would the C.I.A. employ senior Mafia figures in this effort? And that was rather startling discovery on our part.
The above is from Amy Goodman's interview with former US Senator Gary Hart which aired on Democracy Now! March 28, 2006 ("Fmr. Democratic Senator and Presidential Candidate Gary Hart: 'Both Houses of Congress Belong to the President's Party'"). Did you see it on the Evening News? On Nightly News? On World News Tonight? No. Which is why we agree with Ava and C.I.'s point in another feature in this edition that we wouldn't curse Amy Goodman by wishing she anchored on a corporate news network.
Let's back up for anyone new to Amy Goodman (or her co-host Juan Gonzalez). Democracy Now! is an hourly broadcast that airs Monday through Friday. Where can you watch it? At the site online. On public access television around the country. On some PBS stations. On Direct TV and Free Speech TV. Maybe you prefer listening? You can listen online at the website. You can listen on Pacifica Radio stations (over the airwaves and online). You can listen on community radio stations and on some NPR stations. Not able to do that? Your computer doesn't handle streaming? Well, online at the Democracy Now! website, you can read transcripts.
So what's your excuse for not checking it out? (We hope you have none because you already are checking it out.)
If you're not checking it out, what did you miss last week? How much time do you have? Wait, how much time do we have?
For one thing you missed an interview with Seymour Hersh of The New Yorker on Bully Boy's planning for bombing Iran. "Oh," you say, "I saw him on 360 with Anderson Cooper this week."
Ah yes, the soundbyte as dialogue. Trust us, you missed out. How about Gustavo Jiminez?
Please don't tell us you asked who? He is one of the student leaders in the walkouts that have taken place across the nation.
And speaking of activism, how about the people of St. Augustine Parish? They got the Church reopened. They had to fight for days and days . . . What? You don't know about the flihgt against the Church's flight from New Orleans?
Huh. Well that net neutrality issue, that's pretty big, right? Without it the "information highway" will be come a toll road, know what we're saying? You missed that too?
We'll we're sure you got valuable information from your news source. You must have heard about the trouble going down at The Village Voice, though, right? Nothing on that?
Exactly what did your news programming provide you with this week? Oh, you got a clip of Diane Sawyer's then upcoming interview with Tom Cruise? Sweet! We bet that help put food on your table and keep you informed.
What's that you say? That's the least of your problems? Well unload, we've got a few minutes.
Spill.
"There I was," you say, "with the nation on the eve of the war, trying to get the facts about what was going on and what the issues were. I was watching the evening news, I was watching the cable news, I even watched the NewsHour and their bump-bump-bah-bump bumper music gives me a headache. So I put in all that time and now it turns out, it was all a waste. Everything they said -- repeated, whatever! Lies. I was lied into war! I spent all that time watching these programs that were supposed to inform me and all I got was like way uninformed!"
Interesting. And yet you still watch those programs.
Here's the thing, viewers (and listeners and readers) of Democracy Now! knew there was administration spin and then there were actual realities. We didn't get blindsided because there was discussion, there was debate, there was much more than "Today our fearless leader stated . . ."
So let us repeat: And yet you still watch those programs?
Amy Goodman doesn't need a corporate network behind her. What she and Juan Gonzalez and the staff of Democracy Now! do could never fly on corporate news where the only voices that matter are those in office or those who've just left offices (appointed or elected). Now there's a time to utilize those voices. But they shouldn't become the only voices out there. Or, as Amy Goodman has repeatedly noted, ex-generals shouldn't be regular guests (on the payroll of the broadcasters, no less) when peace activists are left uninvited.
Everyone makes a mistake. That's not the issue here. A mistake can be corrected. You say, "We reported wrongly . . ." and can move on. But what was practiced by corporate news wasn't a "mistake" in reporting -- implying they got a detail wrong as they attempted to convey a total picture. To convey a total picture, they would have had to have listened and given space to dissenting voices (as prominent as the space they gave to those supporting the war). They didn't do that. The mistake wasn't in one report. The mistake was their concept of reporting itself which is acting as a newsletter for those in office.
World News Tonight For and By the Government would be a better title. Nightly News For The Beltway is another example. The Evening News If You Matter to Us.
So having been misled, why are you still relying on the same news sources. As the Bully Boy infamously said (or maybe we misunderstood him), "Fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, I'm a corporate news whore." Something like that anyway.
Laura Flanders is on vacation so we thought we'd use this week to note Amy Goodman and the decision was based in part upon this by Elaine:
I'll note a moment of panic today during Democracy Now! that Sunny and I both had. Amy Goodman was coughing and had to take a break. Before she came back, Sunny and I were both pointing out that the show broadcasts not far from ground zero in NYC and remembering this item from Thursday:
"Report: 15,000 Suffer From Medical Problems in NYC Post 9/11" (Democracy Now!):
In other news, the BBC is reporting the number of victims suffering medical problems in connection to the 9/11 attacks on the World Trade Center has risen to at least 15,000 people. The US government has been hit with a class-action lawsuit that alleges it offered false assurances to Manhattan residents and workers that the air was safe in the aftermath of the attacks. In a landmark ruling, a New Jersey coroner said this week that a police officer's death was "directly linked" to his work at Ground Zero after 9/11. The officer, James Zadroga, died in January.
When she came back, she explained that she had a spring cold. (I think that probably comes from the fact that she's all over the country, getting the word out, covering news and doing outreach work for community media.) We both sighed in relief when she said that. Amy Goodman, who celebrated a birthday Thursday, does so much for indymedia and, if you found yourself worried in that moment, do your part to get the word out or do your part to get the word out because she had a birthday. But get the word out. Twenty years from now, due to further media consolidation (I think it will happen short of a major citizen revolution), the media landscape will have changed. I also think it's true that, twenty years from now, we'll see hundreds of Amy Goodmans because she's made a difference and she's demonstrated the role that journalists can and should play. She's altered the landscape and become a role model.
That cough was a scary moment. But on the week of Amy Goodman's birthday, a number of us were noting the realities of what DN! provides and the realities of the attention it gets (or, more often, doesn't get). As C.I. noted:
The left can be critiqued (in any manner, in any tone) by the left -- that's not a problem. What's a problem is repeating easy slams from the right, distortions made by the right, to prove how "reasonable" you are. (Also not helpful is taking a story Democracy Now! covers -- and covers well -- and instead noting the mainstream as though they just broke news or discovered a topic. A point Cedric wants noted but one that I'm sure the community will agree with. This week alone, Amy Goodman's interviewed Seymour Hersh, Greg Palast -- and shown some of his BBC report -- and others while she and Juan Gonzalez have addressed the issue of the Village Voice. The attention level Democracy Now! receives could be upped by about a thousand and still not note the degree to which this program breaks ground daily. Irritating to members is reading statements such as "NPR just did a really wonderful report that was groundbreaking and blah blah blah" when in fact the topic was covered by DN! and other Pacifica Radio programs days, weeks, months ago. There's a lot of stroking NPR from our left print set. Not a great deal of support for Pacifica Radio.)
So are you complaining about how the corporate media failed you but still using it as your primary source for news? How much sense does that make?
Quick Media Take
We need thoughtful criticism, not knee-jerk media bashing
Dallas Morning News
"Whether you are on the right or the left, take off the media conspiracy goggles," writes Steve Blow. "They distort everything. The same reporters and editors are on the job today as when [President] Bush had some of the highest approval ratings in history. There wasn't a conspiracy to pump him up then. There's no conspiracy to bring him down now."
Posted at 9:36:00 AM
E-mail this item QuickLink this item: A99878
[Item from Romeneskso media column at PoynterOnline.]
Yes, the same ones are "on the job." Including Blow, who in 2003, compared protestors against the war to traitors. Two readers wonder if, as long as he's weighing in on the past, Blow can explain how people identified as being pro-peace or anti-Bush (or both) ended up being trashed, we're sure it was an accident, in local columns? The Dixie Chicks? Michael Moore? Moore's Oscar acceptance speech took place in Dallas? We're confused. But so was the columnist who said she'd rather watch sports than the Oscars when she attempted to navigate the topic for readers.
Hey, so eager was the Dallas Morning News to trash Sheryl Crow (for the peace guitar strap?) that they invented a claim of how Christina A should have had Crow's Grammy nomination that year -- even though the big A wasn't eligible due to release date rules!
Best of all may have been an insulting column that (mis)informed readers that women in India wear the "dot" on the forehead to signify their marital status.
Those freaky columnists -- proving yet again that those with brain wave patterns need not to apply to many of our daily papers.
Blow, who's dubbed "Hippie With A Hard On For War" by readers Casey and Heather who e-mailed the item, was a war cheerleader from the start. A recent column on Falluja also caused eye rolls. Where there's blood and destruction, Casey and Heather write, "There's Blow, toking up on the buzz of a good bloodletting."
Blow has wondered, publicly, "how we ended up so polarized"? Maybe because of his and his cohorts "accidental" but consistent attacks on any who questioned the war?
Dallas Morning News
"Whether you are on the right or the left, take off the media conspiracy goggles," writes Steve Blow. "They distort everything. The same reporters and editors are on the job today as when [President] Bush had some of the highest approval ratings in history. There wasn't a conspiracy to pump him up then. There's no conspiracy to bring him down now."
Posted at 9:36:00 AM
E-mail this item QuickLink this item: A99878
[Item from Romeneskso media column at PoynterOnline.]
Yes, the same ones are "on the job." Including Blow, who in 2003, compared protestors against the war to traitors. Two readers wonder if, as long as he's weighing in on the past, Blow can explain how people identified as being pro-peace or anti-Bush (or both) ended up being trashed, we're sure it was an accident, in local columns? The Dixie Chicks? Michael Moore? Moore's Oscar acceptance speech took place in Dallas? We're confused. But so was the columnist who said she'd rather watch sports than the Oscars when she attempted to navigate the topic for readers.
Hey, so eager was the Dallas Morning News to trash Sheryl Crow (for the peace guitar strap?) that they invented a claim of how Christina A should have had Crow's Grammy nomination that year -- even though the big A wasn't eligible due to release date rules!
Best of all may have been an insulting column that (mis)informed readers that women in India wear the "dot" on the forehead to signify their marital status.
Those freaky columnists -- proving yet again that those with brain wave patterns need not to apply to many of our daily papers.
Blow, who's dubbed "Hippie With A Hard On For War" by readers Casey and Heather who e-mailed the item, was a war cheerleader from the start. A recent column on Falluja also caused eye rolls. Where there's blood and destruction, Casey and Heather write, "There's Blow, toking up on the buzz of a good bloodletting."
Blow has wondered, publicly, "how we ended up so polarized"? Maybe because of his and his cohorts "accidental" but consistent attacks on any who questioned the war?
When Poodles Snarl
FOR SALE:
Two high strung poodles. Cannot, REPEAT CANNOT, be sold as a set. Both are neutered and prone to barking at non-existant threats. Be advised: The yapping cannot be curtailed. Must be kept well groomed -- high maintenance. Known to attack one another and their own reflections.
"Liberals hate America!" whined Not Quite Anonymous.
"Oh that is just like NQA to conflate liberals in the Democratic Party with America haters!" sniffed What Lisping Media.
"I said 'left-wing'!" screamded NQA.
"The Nation is not a part of the left-wing of the Democratic Party! They supported Ralph Nader! They do not hate America, except for Alexander Cockburn!" responded WLM laughing at his own joke (since no one else will).
Two poodles squaring off. And America's supposed to give a damn?
One came to uber-fame on the back of a book he lied about writing (in the old days, that lie would get you drummed out of the press -- in World 'o Luce, it makes you a columnist). The other never made an argument without attempting to figure out how it polled first.
Two fey pets of the chattering class, hiking up their legs to 'baptize' one another and be sure that they get a little attention. (Pets need attention. If you're not able to devote time to one, you shouldn't take it home.)
One churns out useless thoughts for a useless magazine. The other still can't get away from the hoots and hollers over his lament that some in the press "malign West Side elitist liberals like me."
One barks, the other lisps.
Running on Empty from NYC vs. Full of Beans from Queens!
The chattering class. Can't be informed by them, can't inform them.
Two high strung poodles. Cannot, REPEAT CANNOT, be sold as a set. Both are neutered and prone to barking at non-existant threats. Be advised: The yapping cannot be curtailed. Must be kept well groomed -- high maintenance. Known to attack one another and their own reflections.
"Liberals hate America!" whined Not Quite Anonymous.
"Oh that is just like NQA to conflate liberals in the Democratic Party with America haters!" sniffed What Lisping Media.
"I said 'left-wing'!" screamded NQA.
"The Nation is not a part of the left-wing of the Democratic Party! They supported Ralph Nader! They do not hate America, except for Alexander Cockburn!" responded WLM laughing at his own joke (since no one else will).
Two poodles squaring off. And America's supposed to give a damn?
One came to uber-fame on the back of a book he lied about writing (in the old days, that lie would get you drummed out of the press -- in World 'o Luce, it makes you a columnist). The other never made an argument without attempting to figure out how it polled first.
Two fey pets of the chattering class, hiking up their legs to 'baptize' one another and be sure that they get a little attention. (Pets need attention. If you're not able to devote time to one, you shouldn't take it home.)
One churns out useless thoughts for a useless magazine. The other still can't get away from the hoots and hollers over his lament that some in the press "malign West Side elitist liberals like me."
One barks, the other lisps.
Running on Empty from NYC vs. Full of Beans from Queens!
The chattering class. Can't be informed by them, can't inform them.
Sexto ex comandante militar pide reununcia de Rumsfeld
Sexto ex comandante militar pide renuncia de Rumsfeld
Maria: Buenos dias. De parte de "Democracy Now!" diaz cosas que vale hacer notar este fin de semana. Paz.
Sexto ex comandante militar pide renuncia de Rumsfeld
En Estados Unidos, otro militar retirado de alto rango pidió públicamente la renuncia del Secretario de Defensa Donald Rumsfeld. En una entrevista con el New York Times, el general Charles Swannack Jr. dijo: "No creo que el Secretario Rumsfeld sea la persona indicada para pelear esa guerra, teniendo en cuenta sus completos fracasos en lo que refiere al manejo de la guerra contra Saddam en Irak". Hasta el 2004, Swannack era comandante de la 82º División Aerotransportadora del Ejército. Swannack es ahora el sexto general retirado que ha pedido la renuncia de Rumsfeld durante las últimas semanas. El jueves, el portavoz de la Casa Blanca, Scott McClellan, defendió a Rumsfeld alegando que está haciendo un "muy buen trabajo".
En Estados Unidos, otro militar retirado de alto rango pidió públicamente la renuncia del Secretario de Defensa Donald Rumsfeld. En una entrevista con el New York Times, el general Charles Swannack Jr. dijo: "No creo que el Secretario Rumsfeld sea la persona indicada para pelear esa guerra, teniendo en cuenta sus completos fracasos en lo que refiere al manejo de la guerra contra Saddam en Irak". Hasta el 2004, Swannack era comandante de la 82º División Aerotransportadora del Ejército. Swannack es ahora el sexto general retirado que ha pedido la renuncia de Rumsfeld durante las últimas semanas. El jueves, el portavoz de la Casa Blanca, Scott McClellan, defendió a Rumsfeld alegando que está haciendo un "muy buen trabajo".
La Casa Blanca no habla sobre afirmación de la existencia de laboratorios de armas en Irak
El jueves, por segundo día consecutivo, el portavoz de la Casa Blanca Scott McClellan no pudo decirle a los periodistas cuándo se informó al Presidente Bush -- o a otros funcionarios del gobierno -- que una misión de investigación del Pentágono no había encontrado laboratorios móviles de armas biológicas en Irak. La fecha en que se presentó el informe sobre la misión está bajo intenso escrutinio. Sólo dos días después de que el informe fuera presentado, el Presidente Bush dijo que los laboratorios demostraban que Estados Unidos había descubierto armas de destrucción masiva en Irak. El Presidente y otros funcionarios del gobierno continuaron con su afirmación errónea durante más de un año, y nunca dijeron que ésta había sido cuestionada.
El jueves, por segundo día consecutivo, el portavoz de la Casa Blanca Scott McClellan no pudo decirle a los periodistas cuándo se informó al Presidente Bush -- o a otros funcionarios del gobierno -- que una misión de investigación del Pentágono no había encontrado laboratorios móviles de armas biológicas en Irak. La fecha en que se presentó el informe sobre la misión está bajo intenso escrutinio. Sólo dos días después de que el informe fuera presentado, el Presidente Bush dijo que los laboratorios demostraban que Estados Unidos había descubierto armas de destrucción masiva en Irak. El Presidente y otros funcionarios del gobierno continuaron con su afirmación errónea durante más de un año, y nunca dijeron que ésta había sido cuestionada.
2 millones de personas marchan en Día Nacional de Acción por la Justicia para los Inmigrantes
El lunes, dos millones de personas salieron a las calles en más de 100 ciudades y localidades de todo el país, para marchar por los derechos de los inmigrantes. Trabajadores indocumentados, inmigrantes legales, sindicatos de trabajo, defensores de los derechos de los inmigrantes y quienes los apoyan, llevaron a cabo manifestaciones en lo que fue llamado el Día Nacional de Acción por la Justicia para los Inmigrantes. En Nueva York, más de mil manifestantes cruzaron el Puente de Brooklyn y colmaron las calles del Bajo Manhattan, para llevar a cabo una protesta cerca del edificio de la Alcaldía. En Atlanta, 80.000 personas inundaron las calles. En Phoenix, se calcula que 100.000 personas se congregaron en el Capitolio de Arizona; otras 25.000 personas marcharon en Madison, Wisconsin; 10.000 en Boston y 8.000 en Omaha, Nebraska. Las protestas del lunes se produjeron luego de un día de manifestaciones en San Diego, Miami, Birmingham, Alabama, Utah, Idaho y Iowa. Medio millón de personas participaron en una protesta en Dallas, lo que la convirtió en la mayor manifestación en la historia de la ciudad. En Washington DC, cientos de miles de personas pasaron frente a la Casa Blanca, para dirigirse a una protesta en el centro comercial National Mall. La manifestación tuvo lugar a pocos metros del Capitolio, donde la semana pasada los senadores no lograron un acuerdo con respecto a la amplia reforma de inmigración, que le daría a los más de 11 millones de inmigrantes indocumentados que viven en Estados Unidos la oportunidad de trabajar legalmente en este país, y convertirse finalmente en ciudadanos estadounidenses.
El lunes, dos millones de personas salieron a las calles en más de 100 ciudades y localidades de todo el país, para marchar por los derechos de los inmigrantes. Trabajadores indocumentados, inmigrantes legales, sindicatos de trabajo, defensores de los derechos de los inmigrantes y quienes los apoyan, llevaron a cabo manifestaciones en lo que fue llamado el Día Nacional de Acción por la Justicia para los Inmigrantes. En Nueva York, más de mil manifestantes cruzaron el Puente de Brooklyn y colmaron las calles del Bajo Manhattan, para llevar a cabo una protesta cerca del edificio de la Alcaldía. En Atlanta, 80.000 personas inundaron las calles. En Phoenix, se calcula que 100.000 personas se congregaron en el Capitolio de Arizona; otras 25.000 personas marcharon en Madison, Wisconsin; 10.000 en Boston y 8.000 en Omaha, Nebraska. Las protestas del lunes se produjeron luego de un día de manifestaciones en San Diego, Miami, Birmingham, Alabama, Utah, Idaho y Iowa. Medio millón de personas participaron en una protesta en Dallas, lo que la convirtió en la mayor manifestación en la historia de la ciudad. En Washington DC, cientos de miles de personas pasaron frente a la Casa Blanca, para dirigirse a una protesta en el centro comercial National Mall. La manifestación tuvo lugar a pocos metros del Capitolio, donde la semana pasada los senadores no lograron un acuerdo con respecto a la amplia reforma de inmigración, que le daría a los más de 11 millones de inmigrantes indocumentados que viven en Estados Unidos la oportunidad de trabajar legalmente en este país, y convertirse finalmente en ciudadanos estadounidenses.
Coalición por los derechos de los inmigrantes exhorta a boicot y protestas durante un día
Una coalición de grupos que defienden los derechos de los inmigrantes está exhortando a un boicot laboral y económico masivo durante un día, que se llevaría a cabo el 1 de mayo. Algunos llaman a este evento "Un día sin inmigrantes". Los organizadores están instando a los inmigrantes a que se nieguen a trabajar o a gastar dinero durante este día, para protestar contra las acciones del Congreso que buscan criminalizar a los trabajadores indocumentados. Durante las últimas semanas, millones de inmigrantes y quienes los apoyan han salido a las calles, en una ola de protestas sin precedentes.
Una coalición de grupos que defienden los derechos de los inmigrantes está exhortando a un boicot laboral y económico masivo durante un día, que se llevaría a cabo el 1 de mayo. Algunos llaman a este evento "Un día sin inmigrantes". Los organizadores están instando a los inmigrantes a que se nieguen a trabajar o a gastar dinero durante este día, para protestar contra las acciones del Congreso que buscan criminalizar a los trabajadores indocumentados. Durante las últimas semanas, millones de inmigrantes y quienes los apoyan han salido a las calles, en una ola de protestas sin precedentes.
Médico de la Real Fuerza Aérea encarcelado por negarse a servir en Irak
En Gran Bretaña, un médico de la Real Fuerza Aérea fue condenado a ocho meses de prisión por negarse a ir a Irak. El teniente de aviación Malcolm Kendall-Smith, sostuvo que se niega a cumplir con la misión que se le asignó porque no quiere formar parte de una guerra ilícita.
En Gran Bretaña, un médico de la Real Fuerza Aérea fue condenado a ocho meses de prisión por negarse a ir a Irak. El teniente de aviación Malcolm Kendall-Smith, sostuvo que se niega a cumplir con la misión que se le asignó porque no quiere formar parte de una guerra ilícita.
Informe: el gobierno de Bush planea ataque nuclear contra Irán
En medio de informes de que el gobierno de Bush planea atacar las instalaciones nucleares de Irán, aumentan las especulaciones sobre un posible ataque militar. En un importante artículo publicado en la revista "New Yorker", el periodista investigador Seymour Hersh dice que hay una creciente convicción en la comunidad diplomática y de defensa de que el cambio de régimen es el principal objetivo del gobierno de Bush en el estancamiento de las negociaciones nucleares con Irán. Un ex funcionario de defensa de alto rango, dijo que los planes militares del gobierno de Bush se basan en la esperanza de que "una campaña de bombardeos constantes a Irán humillará a los líderes religiosos y provocará que la población se subleve y derroque al gobierno". Y agregó: "Me impactó oír esto, y me pregunté ¿Qué están fumando?".
En medio de informes de que el gobierno de Bush planea atacar las instalaciones nucleares de Irán, aumentan las especulaciones sobre un posible ataque militar. En un importante artículo publicado en la revista "New Yorker", el periodista investigador Seymour Hersh dice que hay una creciente convicción en la comunidad diplomática y de defensa de que el cambio de régimen es el principal objetivo del gobierno de Bush en el estancamiento de las negociaciones nucleares con Irán. Un ex funcionario de defensa de alto rango, dijo que los planes militares del gobierno de Bush se basan en la esperanza de que "una campaña de bombardeos constantes a Irán humillará a los líderes religiosos y provocará que la población se subleve y derroque al gobierno". Y agregó: "Me impactó oír esto, y me pregunté ¿Qué están fumando?".
Bush no niega planes de atacar Irán
En sus primeros comentarios públicos sobre Irán -desde que surgieron informes de que su gobierno estaba planeando un ataque- el Presidente Bush descartó estas afirmaciones, pero no las negó explícitamente: La doctrina de prevención es trabajar juntos para impedir que los iraníes tengan armas nucleares. Yo sé, sé que estamos en Washington, y ya saben, [aquí] prevención significa fuerza. Pero no necesariamente significa fuerza. En este caso, significa diplomacia. Y por cierto, leí los artículos publicados en los periódicos este fin de semana. Sólo había especulaciones absurdas, por cierto. Lo que están leyendo son especulaciones absurdas, que como ya saben, pasa muy a menudo aquí en la capital del país. Este asunto atrajo atención nuevamente tras la publicación en la revista "New Yorker" de un nuevo artículo escrito por el periodista investigador Seymour Hersh. El artículo cita a funcionarios de defensa diciendo que el gobierno de Bush trazó planes minuciosos para utilizar armas tácticas contra las instalaciones nucleares iraníes. Seymour Hersh también estuvo el lunes en Washington, donde habló sobre la posibilidad de un ataque estadounidense. Hersh dijo: Están llevando a cabo lo que ellos llaman planeamiento operativo, en el cual hay campañas de bombardeo serias, consecuentes y cuidadosamente planeadas, y lo que se les ocurra. Quiero decir, no se han tomado decisiones con respecto a qué hacer, pero no son solo vanas esperanzas, son cosas serias.
En sus primeros comentarios públicos sobre Irán -desde que surgieron informes de que su gobierno estaba planeando un ataque- el Presidente Bush descartó estas afirmaciones, pero no las negó explícitamente: La doctrina de prevención es trabajar juntos para impedir que los iraníes tengan armas nucleares. Yo sé, sé que estamos en Washington, y ya saben, [aquí] prevención significa fuerza. Pero no necesariamente significa fuerza. En este caso, significa diplomacia. Y por cierto, leí los artículos publicados en los periódicos este fin de semana. Sólo había especulaciones absurdas, por cierto. Lo que están leyendo son especulaciones absurdas, que como ya saben, pasa muy a menudo aquí en la capital del país. Este asunto atrajo atención nuevamente tras la publicación en la revista "New Yorker" de un nuevo artículo escrito por el periodista investigador Seymour Hersh. El artículo cita a funcionarios de defensa diciendo que el gobierno de Bush trazó planes minuciosos para utilizar armas tácticas contra las instalaciones nucleares iraníes. Seymour Hersh también estuvo el lunes en Washington, donde habló sobre la posibilidad de un ataque estadounidense. Hersh dijo: Están llevando a cabo lo que ellos llaman planeamiento operativo, en el cual hay campañas de bombardeo serias, consecuentes y cuidadosamente planeadas, y lo que se les ocurra. Quiero decir, no se han tomado decisiones con respecto a qué hacer, pero no son solo vanas esperanzas, son cosas serias.
Bush criticado por afirmar erróneamente que Estados Unidos encontró laboratorios de armas móviles en Irak
La Casa Blanca está bajo una intensa inspección, luego que el "Washington Post" reveló que el gobierno continuó afirmando que había descubierto laboratorios biológicos móviles en Irak, incluso después de que un equipo de investigadores del Pentágono había concluido que no se habían encontrado dichos laboratorios. El 27 de mayo de 2003, el Pentágono informó sobre sus hallazgos. Dos días después, Bush dijo: Encontramos las armas de destrucción masiva. Encontramos laboratorios biológicos. Días después, el Secretario de Estado Colin Powell, afirmó: Ya descubrimos fábricas biológicas móviles... No tenemos ninguna duda que ese era su propósito. A nadie se le ocurrió otro propósito que tenga sentido. El gobierno de Bush continuó con su afirmación errónea durante más de un año.
La Casa Blanca está bajo una intensa inspección, luego que el "Washington Post" reveló que el gobierno continuó afirmando que había descubierto laboratorios biológicos móviles en Irak, incluso después de que un equipo de investigadores del Pentágono había concluido que no se habían encontrado dichos laboratorios. El 27 de mayo de 2003, el Pentágono informó sobre sus hallazgos. Dos días después, Bush dijo: Encontramos las armas de destrucción masiva. Encontramos laboratorios biológicos. Días después, el Secretario de Estado Colin Powell, afirmó: Ya descubrimos fábricas biológicas móviles... No tenemos ninguna duda que ese era su propósito. A nadie se le ocurrió otro propósito que tenga sentido. El gobierno de Bush continuó con su afirmación errónea durante más de un año.
En Washington, el Secretario de Prensa Scott McClellan intentó voltear la controversia de los laboratorios móviles criticando a la prensa por cubrir una noticia basada en lo que fue descrito como una repetición, información vieja. McClellan calificó a la noticia como una vergüenza para la prensa y como una muestra de irresponsabilidad, porque el gobierno de Bush ya había admitido que la información sobre Irak en el período previo a la guerra era errónea. Pero McClellan no pudo contestar si el Presidente tenía conocimiento de las conclusiones del Pentágono, antes de afirmar públicamente que los tráileres demostraban que Irak tenía armas de destrucción masiva.
Powell admite que nunca creyó que Irak representaba una amenaza nuclear inminente
Mientras tanto, el ex Secretario de Estado, Colin Powell, ahora admite que ni él ni sus asesores creían que Irak representaba una amenaza nuclear inminente antes de la invasión estadounidense. En una entrevista con el periodista Robert Scheer, Powell dijo que las afirmaciones sobre el riesgo nuclear efectuadas por el Vicepresidente Dick Cheney y por la CIA convencieron al Presidente. Powell dijo: La CIA ejercía mucha presión con el argumento de los tubos de aluminio, y Cheney apoyó esta postura en lugar de apoyar lo que escribió nuestra gente. Cuando le preguntaron acerca de la afirmación errónea del Presidente Bush de que Saddam Hussein intentó comprarle material nuclear a Níger en su discurso del Estado de la Unión, Powell supuestamente respondió: Nunca se debió mencionar eso en el discurso... Yo nunca lo creí.
Mientras tanto, el ex Secretario de Estado, Colin Powell, ahora admite que ni él ni sus asesores creían que Irak representaba una amenaza nuclear inminente antes de la invasión estadounidense. En una entrevista con el periodista Robert Scheer, Powell dijo que las afirmaciones sobre el riesgo nuclear efectuadas por el Vicepresidente Dick Cheney y por la CIA convencieron al Presidente. Powell dijo: La CIA ejercía mucha presión con el argumento de los tubos de aluminio, y Cheney apoyó esta postura en lugar de apoyar lo que escribió nuestra gente. Cuando le preguntaron acerca de la afirmación errónea del Presidente Bush de que Saddam Hussein intentó comprarle material nuclear a Níger en su discurso del Estado de la Unión, Powell supuestamente respondió: Nunca se debió mencionar eso en el discurso... Yo nunca lo creí.
Reverendo William Sloane Coffin Jr. muere a los 81 años
El reverendo William Sloane Coffin Jr. murió a los 81 años de edad. Durante los últimos 50 años, fue un destacado activista en contra de la guerra, y fue defensor de los derechos civiles. Como capellán de la Universidad de Yale durante la década del 60, criticó la Guerra de Vietnam y defendió fuertemente el uso de la desobediencia civil como forma de protesta contra la misma. En uno de los juicios célebres de la década del 60, Coffin fue acusado -junto con el Dr. Benjamín Spock y otras personas- de conspirar para fomentar la evasión del alistamiento obligatorio. También fue un seguidor del Reverendo Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., y participó en algunas de las primeras Freedom Rides (viajes en autobús efectuados por grupos multirraciales de jóvenes, que buscaban poner a prueba la segregación racial). El valor, predicó por años, era la principal virtud, porque hace posible todas las otras virtudes. En la década del 70, se convirtió en el principal pastor de la iglesia de Riverside en Nueva York, y en la década del 80 jugó un papel clave en el movimiento antinuclear.
El reverendo William Sloane Coffin Jr. murió a los 81 años de edad. Durante los últimos 50 años, fue un destacado activista en contra de la guerra, y fue defensor de los derechos civiles. Como capellán de la Universidad de Yale durante la década del 60, criticó la Guerra de Vietnam y defendió fuertemente el uso de la desobediencia civil como forma de protesta contra la misma. En uno de los juicios célebres de la década del 60, Coffin fue acusado -junto con el Dr. Benjamín Spock y otras personas- de conspirar para fomentar la evasión del alistamiento obligatorio. También fue un seguidor del Reverendo Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., y participó en algunas de las primeras Freedom Rides (viajes en autobús efectuados por grupos multirraciales de jóvenes, que buscaban poner a prueba la segregación racial). El valor, predicó por años, era la principal virtud, porque hace posible todas las otras virtudes. En la década del 70, se convirtió en el principal pastor de la iglesia de Riverside en Nueva York, y en la década del 80 jugó un papel clave en el movimiento antinuclear.
Maria: Good morning. Now in English, here are ten stories from Democracy Now! Peace.
6th Ex-Military Commander Calls For Rumsfeld's Resignation
Here in the United States, another high-ranking retired military commander has publicly called for the ouster of Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld. In an interview with the New York Times, Major General Charles Swannack Jr. said: "I do not believe Secretary Rumsfeld is the right person to fight that war based on his absolute failures in managing the war against Saddam in Iraq." Up until 2004, Swannack was the commander of the Army's 82nd Airborne Division. He is now the sixth retired general to call for Rumsfeld's resignation in recent weeks. On Thursday White House spokesperson Scott McClellan defended Rumsfeld, saying he is doing a "very fine job."
Here in the United States, another high-ranking retired military commander has publicly called for the ouster of Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld. In an interview with the New York Times, Major General Charles Swannack Jr. said: "I do not believe Secretary Rumsfeld is the right person to fight that war based on his absolute failures in managing the war against Saddam in Iraq." Up until 2004, Swannack was the commander of the Army's 82nd Airborne Division. He is now the sixth retired general to call for Rumsfeld's resignation in recent weeks. On Thursday White House spokesperson Scott McClellan defended Rumsfeld, saying he is doing a "very fine job."
White House Maintains Silence on Iraq Weapons Lab Claim
Meanwhile, for the second straight day Thursday, White House spokesperson Scott McLellan could not tell reporters when President Bush or other administration officials were informed a Pentagon fact-finding mission had found no mobile biological weapons labs in Iraq. The timing of the fact-finding mission's report has come under intense scrutiny. Just two days after it was submitted, President Bush cited the trailers as proof the US had discovered weapons of mass destruction in Iraq. The President and other administration officials continued to make the faulty claim for more than a year - and never once said their claim had been disputed.
Meanwhile, for the second straight day Thursday, White House spokesperson Scott McLellan could not tell reporters when President Bush or other administration officials were informed a Pentagon fact-finding mission had found no mobile biological weapons labs in Iraq. The timing of the fact-finding mission's report has come under intense scrutiny. Just two days after it was submitted, President Bush cited the trailers as proof the US had discovered weapons of mass destruction in Iraq. The President and other administration officials continued to make the faulty claim for more than a year - and never once said their claim had been disputed.
Up to 2 Million March in National Day of Action for Immigrant Justice
As many as two million people took to the streets in more than 100 cities and towns across the country on Monday to march for immigrants' rights. Undocumented workers, legal immigrants, labor unions, immigrant rights advocates and their supporters demonstrated in what was billed as the National Day of Action for Immigrant Justice. In New York, more than one thousand demonstrators crossed the Brooklyn Bridge and packed the streets in lower Manhattan for a rally near City Hall. In Atlanta, as many as 80,000 people flooded the streets. In Phoenix, an estimated 100,000 rallied at the Arizona Capitol. 25,000 marched in Madison, Wisconsin. 10,000 in Boston. 8,000 in Omaha, Nebraska. The rallies Monday followed a day of demonstrations in San Diego, Miami, Birmingham, Alabama, Utah, Idaho and Iowa. A rally in Dallas drew half a million people, the largest protest in the city's history. In Washington DC, hundreds of thousands streamed past the White House to a rally on the National Mall. The demonstration took place just yards from the Capitol, where Senators last week failed to reach agreement on wide-ranging immigration reform that would allow the more than 11 million undocumented immigrants living in this country a chance to work here legally and eventually become U.S. citizens. We'll spend the hour looking at the growing immigrant rights movement after headlines.
As many as two million people took to the streets in more than 100 cities and towns across the country on Monday to march for immigrants' rights. Undocumented workers, legal immigrants, labor unions, immigrant rights advocates and their supporters demonstrated in what was billed as the National Day of Action for Immigrant Justice. In New York, more than one thousand demonstrators crossed the Brooklyn Bridge and packed the streets in lower Manhattan for a rally near City Hall. In Atlanta, as many as 80,000 people flooded the streets. In Phoenix, an estimated 100,000 rallied at the Arizona Capitol. 25,000 marched in Madison, Wisconsin. 10,000 in Boston. 8,000 in Omaha, Nebraska. The rallies Monday followed a day of demonstrations in San Diego, Miami, Birmingham, Alabama, Utah, Idaho and Iowa. A rally in Dallas drew half a million people, the largest protest in the city's history. In Washington DC, hundreds of thousands streamed past the White House to a rally on the National Mall. The demonstration took place just yards from the Capitol, where Senators last week failed to reach agreement on wide-ranging immigration reform that would allow the more than 11 million undocumented immigrants living in this country a chance to work here legally and eventually become U.S. citizens. We'll spend the hour looking at the growing immigrant rights movement after headlines.
Immigrant Rights Coalition Calls for One Day Boycott, Walk-Out
A coalition of groups advocating for immigrant rights are calling for a massive one-day job and economic boycott to take place May 1st. Some are calling the event "A Day Without Immigrants." Organizers are calling on immigrants to refuse to work or spend any money on May Day to protest moves in Congress to criminalize undocumented workers. In recent weeks millions of immigrants and their supporters have taken to the streets in an unprecedented wave of protests.
A coalition of groups advocating for immigrant rights are calling for a massive one-day job and economic boycott to take place May 1st. Some are calling the event "A Day Without Immigrants." Organizers are calling on immigrants to refuse to work or spend any money on May Day to protest moves in Congress to criminalize undocumented workers. In recent weeks millions of immigrants and their supporters have taken to the streets in an unprecedented wave of protests.
RAF Doctor Jailed For Refusing Iraq Service
In Britain, a doctor in the Royal Air Force has been sentenced to eight months in jail for refusing to go to Iraq. Flight Lieutenant Malcolm Kendall-Smith maintained he is refusing his assignment in order to not take part in an illegal war. "Now more so than ever he feels that his actions were totally justified and he would not if placed in the same circumstances seek to do anything differently," Justin Hugheston-Roberts, the lawyer representing Kendall-Smith, said after the sentencing.
In Britain, a doctor in the Royal Air Force has been sentenced to eight months in jail for refusing to go to Iraq. Flight Lieutenant Malcolm Kendall-Smith maintained he is refusing his assignment in order to not take part in an illegal war. "Now more so than ever he feels that his actions were totally justified and he would not if placed in the same circumstances seek to do anything differently," Justin Hugheston-Roberts, the lawyer representing Kendall-Smith, said after the sentencing.
Report: Bush Administration Has Plans For Iran Nuke Strike
Speculation over the possibility of a US military attack on Iran is increasing amid reports the Bush administration has drawn up plans to strike Iran's nuclear facilities. In a major piece in the New Yorker, investigative journalist Seymour Hersh says there is a growing conviction in the defense and diplomatic community that the Bush administration's ultimate goal in the nuclear standoff with Iran is regime change. A high-ranking former defense official said the Bush administration's military plans are premised on the hope "a sustained bombing campaign in Iran will humiliate the religious leadership and lead the public to rise up and overthrow the government." The official went on to say: "I was shocked when I heard it, and asked myself, 'What are they smoking?' "
Speculation over the possibility of a US military attack on Iran is increasing amid reports the Bush administration has drawn up plans to strike Iran's nuclear facilities. In a major piece in the New Yorker, investigative journalist Seymour Hersh says there is a growing conviction in the defense and diplomatic community that the Bush administration's ultimate goal in the nuclear standoff with Iran is regime change. A high-ranking former defense official said the Bush administration's military plans are premised on the hope "a sustained bombing campaign in Iran will humiliate the religious leadership and lead the public to rise up and overthrow the government." The official went on to say: "I was shocked when I heard it, and asked myself, 'What are they smoking?' "
No Denial From Bush on Iran Attack Plans
In his first public comments on Iran since reports emerged that his administration has drawn up plans for an attack, President Bush was dismissive -- but did not issue an explicit denial: "The doctrine of prevention is to work together to prevent the Iranians from having a nuclear weapon. I know -- I know we're here in Washington; you know, prevention means force. It doesn't mean force, necessarily. In this case, it means diplomacy. And by the way, I read the articles in the newspapers this weekend. There was just wild speculation, by the way. What you're reading is wild speculation, which is kind of a, you know - happens quite frequently here in the nation's capital."
In his first public comments on Iran since reports emerged that his administration has drawn up plans for an attack, President Bush was dismissive -- but did not issue an explicit denial: "The doctrine of prevention is to work together to prevent the Iranians from having a nuclear weapon. I know -- I know we're here in Washington; you know, prevention means force. It doesn't mean force, necessarily. In this case, it means diplomacy. And by the way, I read the articles in the newspapers this weekend. There was just wild speculation, by the way. What you're reading is wild speculation, which is kind of a, you know - happens quite frequently here in the nation's capital."
The issue has received renewed attention following a recent piece by investigative journalist Seymour Hersh in the New Yorker. The article cites defense officials saying the Bush administration has drawn up elaborate plans to use tactical weapons against Iranian nuclear sites. Seymour Hersh was also in Washington Monday, where he discussed the possibility of a US attack. Hersh said: "It's going into what they call operational planning, in which there's serious, consistent very carefully drawn up bombing campaigns and what you will. I mean, there's no decision made about what to do but it's not just pie in the sky, this is serious stuff."
Bush Criticized For Falsely Claiming U.S. Found Mobile Weapon Labs in Iraq
The White House is coming under intense scrutiny after the Washington Post revealed that the administration kept asserting it had uncovered mobile biological labs in Iraq even after a team of Pentagon investigators had concluded no such labs had been found. On May 27, 2003 the Pentagon made its findings available. Two days later President Bush said We found the weapons of mass destruction. We found biological laboratories. Days later Secretary of State Colin Powell said We have already discovered mobile biological factories There is no question in our mind that thats what their purpose was. Nobody has come up with an alternate purpose that makes sense. The Bush administration continued with its faulty claim for more than a year.
The White House is coming under intense scrutiny after the Washington Post revealed that the administration kept asserting it had uncovered mobile biological labs in Iraq even after a team of Pentagon investigators had concluded no such labs had been found. On May 27, 2003 the Pentagon made its findings available. Two days later President Bush said We found the weapons of mass destruction. We found biological laboratories. Days later Secretary of State Colin Powell said We have already discovered mobile biological factories There is no question in our mind that thats what their purpose was. Nobody has come up with an alternate purpose that makes sense. The Bush administration continued with its faulty claim for more than a year.
In Washington, Press Secretary Scott McClellan attempted to spin the controversy of mobile labs by criticizing the press for covering a story based on what he described as rehashed, old information. He called the story an embarrassment for the media and irresponsible because the Bush administration has already admitted its pre-war intelligence on Iraq was mistaken. But McClellan could not answer whether the President knew of the Pentagons conclusions before he publicly said the trailers were proof Iraq had weapons of mass destruction.
Powell Admits He Did Not Believe Iraq Posed Imminent Nuclear Threat
Former Secretary of State Colin Powell is now saying neither he nor his aides believed Iraq posed an imminent nuclear threat before the US-led invasion. In an interview with journalist Robert Scheer, Powell said the President was convinced by nuclear claims given to him by Vice President Dick Cheney and the CIA. Powell said: The CIA was pushing the aluminum tube argument heavily and Cheney went with that instead of what our guys wrote. Asked about President Bushs faulty claim that Saddam Hussein attempted to buy nuclear material from Niger in his State of the Union speech, Powell reportedly answered: It should never have been in the speech... I never believed it.
Former Secretary of State Colin Powell is now saying neither he nor his aides believed Iraq posed an imminent nuclear threat before the US-led invasion. In an interview with journalist Robert Scheer, Powell said the President was convinced by nuclear claims given to him by Vice President Dick Cheney and the CIA. Powell said: The CIA was pushing the aluminum tube argument heavily and Cheney went with that instead of what our guys wrote. Asked about President Bushs faulty claim that Saddam Hussein attempted to buy nuclear material from Niger in his State of the Union speech, Powell reportedly answered: It should never have been in the speech... I never believed it.
Rev. William Sloane Coffin, 81, Dies
And the Rev. William Sloane Coffin Jr. has died at the age of 81. For the past half century he has been a leading anti-war and civil rights advocated. During the 1960s as chaplain of Yale University he was a leading critic of the Vietnam War and strongly advocated the use of civil disobedience to protest the war. In one of the most celebrated trials of the 1960s he faced charges along with Dr. Benjamin Spock and others of conspiracy to encourage draft evasion. He was also an early supporter of the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. and took part in some of the first Freedom Rides. Courage, he preached over the years, was the first virtue, because ''it makes all other virtues possible.'' In the 1970s he went on to become a senior minister at the Riverside Church in New York. And in the 1980s he played an instrumental role in the anti-nuclear movement.
And the Rev. William Sloane Coffin Jr. has died at the age of 81. For the past half century he has been a leading anti-war and civil rights advocated. During the 1960s as chaplain of Yale University he was a leading critic of the Vietnam War and strongly advocated the use of civil disobedience to protest the war. In one of the most celebrated trials of the 1960s he faced charges along with Dr. Benjamin Spock and others of conspiracy to encourage draft evasion. He was also an early supporter of the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. and took part in some of the first Freedom Rides. Courage, he preached over the years, was the first virtue, because ''it makes all other virtues possible.'' In the 1970s he went on to become a senior minister at the Riverside Church in New York. And in the 1980s he played an instrumental role in the anti-nuclear movement.
Yahoo! Messenger with Voice. PC-to-Phone calls for ridiculously low rates.
C.I. on the Kerry "plan" and Dexy Filkins
C.I. said "One, only one." Fine. Here's our background on this post. It's dictated. It's dictated in parts as we moved from location to location. Why does C.I. never dictate to us? Feel for the poor soul taking dictation because the speech comes out rapid speed as C.I. attempts to make a point of several paragraphs in about three minutes. (Often causing C.I. to ask, seriously, "Okay, well what part didn't you get?") Some entries, as we heard them dictated, would cause us to laugh (we love C.I.'s sense of humor). That was early in the week. We learned quickly that there was no stopping for laugh lines. We'll reveal (with permission) that the person asking for something to be linked to (a friend, not a community member) at the end is actually, in that instance, the person taking dictation.
Democracy Now: Seymour Hersh, Greg Palast; Danny Schechter, Tom Hayden, Dexy
Report: Bush Admin. Suppressed Evidence Refuting Iraq WMD Claim
The Washington Post is reporting the Bush administration claimed to have found mobile weapons labs in Iraq after the invasion despite the explicit conclusions of a Pentagon-sponsored mission the claim was untrue. On May 29, 2003, President Bush cited the discovery of the trailers in an attempt to justify his decision to go war two months earlier. Bush said: "We have found the weapons of mass destruction." But just two days before, a Pentagon team sent to Iraq had concluded that the trailers were in fact "the biggest sand toilets in the world." One team member said: "Within the first four hours, it was clear to everyone that these were not biological labs." The Bush administration failed to make the findings public and continued with its faulty claim for more than one year.
Looming Health Care Measure Requires Proof of Citizenship
In other news, the Boston Globe is reporting thousands of low-income Americans are at risk with the pending activation of a federal law that would require them to show proof US of citizenship in order to receive health care. The requirement was attached to the Deficit Reduction Act, which President Bush signed into law this year. Healthcare advocates said the requirements could adversely affect undocumented immigrants and Medicaid recipients who will be unable to provide the necessary documentation. Bill Walczak, chief executive officer of the Codman Square Health Center in Massachusetts, said: '"We didn't create the healthcare centers to become citizenship enforcement centers."
Government Agency Colluded with CIA in Re-Classification Scheme
The National Security Archive has revealed that the government agency responsible for state archives colluded with the CIA and other intelligence agencies to remove thousands of previously declassified historical documents that were previously available to the public. In a secret agreement, the National Archives and Records Administration agreed to remove the archival records and re-classify them in order to avoid scrutiny from researchers. The re-classification scheme was disclosed earlier this year but details of how it came about were largely unknown.
Cheney Booed At Washington Baseball Game
And in Washington, Vice President Dick Cheney was greeted with loud boos Tuesday when he threw out the ceremonial pitch at the opener for Major League Baseball's Washington Nationals. This wasn't the first time Cheney has gotten a hostile reception at a baseball game -- in June 2004, Cheney was booed at a Yankees game here in New York.
The above four items are from today's Democracy Now! Headlines and were selected by Markus, Brenda, Susan and ??? Democracy Now! ("always informing you," as Marcia says):
Headlines for April 12, 2006
- Iran Says It Has Enriched Small-Scale Uranium
- Report: Bush Admin. Suppressed Evidence Refuting Iraq WMD Claim
- Suicide Attack Kills 57 in Pakistan
- Berlusconi Refuses to Concede Italian Elections
- 29 Indicted Over Madrid Train Bombings
- Thousands Mark Death of Palestinian Girl in Gaza
- Three Killed, Hundreds Arrested in Nepal Unrest
- Cheney Booed At Washington Baseball Game
Seymour Hersh: Bush Administration Planning Possible Major Air Attack on Iran
We speak with Pulitzer Prize winning journalist Seymour Hersh about his latest article in the New Yorker that the Bush administration has increased clandestine activities inside Iran and intensified planning for a possible major air attack.
French Student Leaders Hail 'Historic Victory' After Mass Protests Force Government to Abandon Controversial Youth Job Law
In France, mass student protests and labor strikes have forced the French government to abandon a controversial new law that would have made it easier for companies to fire young workers. We speak with University of Paris professor, Gilbert Achcar.
Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi Refuses to Concede Defeat Despite Official Election Results
In Italy, opposition leader Romano Prodi has been declared the official winner in the country's elections, defeating Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi in one of Italy's closest races ever. Berlusconi is now refusing to admit he lost the race and is calling for a recount of thousands of disputed ballots.
Investigative Reporter Greg Palast: U.S. Energy Dept. Concludes Venezuela Could Have Biggest Oil Reserves in OPEC
In an interview with BBC investigative reporter Greg Palast, Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez said he would ask the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries to set the long-term price of oil at $50 a barrel. Palast reports that analysis by the US Department of Energy shows that Venezuela -- not Saudi Arabia -- could have the biggest oil reserves in the OPEC.
In England, Malcolm Kendall-Smith's court martial continues and today he stated that, "As early as 2004 I regarded the United States to be on par with Nazi Germany as regards its activities in the Gulf." The Associated Press seems to be fudging that quote and stating Kendall-Smith said "I have evidence" and not "I regarded" as Reuters and other news outlets have reported.
Gareth recommends Kim Sengupta's "RAF doctor refused to fight 'illegal' Iraq war" (London's Independent) and, from that, we'll note Kendall-Smith's statements:
As a commissioned officer I am required to consider... every order that is given to me and I am required to consider the legality of each order... Since my initial operational deployments, I have studied... the commentaries and... notes, including one prepared by the Attorney General and in particular the note to the Prime Minister dated 7 March 2003.
I believe the occupation of Iraq is illegal... and for me to comply... would put me in conflict with both domestic and international law. The illegality of the use of force against Iraq was the only reason I could not follow this order... [and] was the only reason for my resignation.
I would, in fact, refuse the orders as a duty under international law, the Nuremburg principles and the law of armed conflict...
To take the decision I have taken saddens me but I feel I have no choice.
I was subjected, as was the entire population, to propaganda depicting force against Iraq to be lawful but it was not until the middle of 2004 that I researched and found that not to be the case.
Iraq? The Associated Press reports that bombs have killed 13 in Iraq -- "including three U.S. soldiers" -- and that gun fire claimed an addition six civilians.The BBC reports that Jeffery Chessani, Lucas McConnel and James Kimber, US marines, have been "stripped of their commands" as a result of an investigation into the murder of fifteen Iraqis. AFP reports car bombs claimed at least two people in Tal Afar (wounding at least seven), and two in Kirkuk (with four wounded). In Tuz Khurmatu, Reuters reports, a roadside bomb has killed at least two and wounded at least four while in Khalis, a car bomb has wounded at least twenty and killed two. In Baghdad last week, a bombing outside a Shi'ite mosque killed ninety people, today a bombing outside a Shi'ite mosque has killed at least twenty.
Lynda notes that Danny Schechter's back (from Switzerland, I believe) and steers us towards "Your Letters, A Passover Greeting" (News Dissector):
Years ago, I directed a film (now on DVD) called BEYOND JFK featuring the story behind the story told in Oliver Stones controversial film JFK. One of Stones heroes was the widely discredited New Orleans DA Jim Garrison who put on the only trial of men accused of being part of the assassination. He lost the case and lost his reputation under heavy FBI and media assault until Stone came along to dramatize his story. Our film featured Garrison's last interview on his death bed when he insisted that the full story must be told.
All these years later, I ran into Temple University English Professor Joan Mellen who has exhaustively and painstakingly told that story in a thoroughly documented and detailed book called "A Farewell to Justice." (Potomac Books) It's a great read filled with newly unearthed facts that link Oswald and Ruby to a plot hatched in New Orleans. Don't scoff. She has done in-depth reporting the press missed and knows how to tell a story. (She teaches writing!) You can read about it on her website: JoanMellen.net.
In a dinner with Joan I asked her about her obsession with the case. Like many of the today's 911 researchers, she can't let it go. Her site carries a speech that explains why and it touches on the press:
A few comments on the above. If you'd like to see Danny's documentary, it's available on the director's cut of JFK. It features interviews with Robert MacNeil, Walter Cronkite and others. (And is more than worth watching.) (Need another reason? Tom Wicker comes off more ridiculous on film than in print so New York Times readers of old can enjoy that.) Second, please read Joan Mellen's A Farewell To Justice. Members who have read it can't stop singing the book's praises. (I read it as well and also recommend it strongly.)
Remember Lewis Lapham's "The Case for Impeachment" (Harper's Magazine)? Remember that they also hosted a debate on the topic? Brandon notes that text excerpts and an MP3 are available online. Participants included Michael Ratner, Elisabeth Holtzman, John Conyers Jr., John Dean and Lapham.
Visitor Debbie notes Tom Hayden's "Kerry Steps Up...Who Will Respond?" (Huffington Post):
Will Kerry, a much more formidable candidate, take the same course? No one can be certain, but the primary winds are blowing in the direction of peace and progressive politics. Sen. Hillary Clinton, the seemingly invincible front-runner, is not likely to emerge from Iowa and New Hampshire unscathed. Her hardline support of the Iraq War is not only out of touch with Democratic voters, but appears to many as chronic opportunism. Unless the war suddenly ends, her credibility will suffer severely in the primaries.
This is why the "Kerry factor" becomes important. As the former nominee, Kerry commands media and public attention. As an anti-war voice, he is in sharp contrast with the silence of the lambs. As a potential presidential contender, he is a credible foil to the centrist hawks and challenges the party leadership to make up its mind.
On the other hand, many anti-war Democrats still blame Kerry for vascillating on Iraq in 2004 in the same ways the party leadership does today. Some in the anti-war movement will continue demanding withdrawal "now" instead of by year's end. Others will insist, rightly on real reconstruction and sovereignty for post-war Iraq, not its transfer to control by the WTO. Still others will watch how Kerry connects the war with domestic issues of jobs, poverty, immigration and racism. The potential of a progressive majority, or center-left politics is there. Not since Watergate has there been the opportunity. In both crises, the unpopularity of an imperial war led the White House to illegally discredit and spy on its critics, lose credibility with a majority of Americans, and prompt Congress to cut off funding for war.
Visitor Debbie feels that I have "raked Kerry over the coals" for the past few days. She notes she was a John Kerry supporter in 2004 and hopes he runs in 2008.
My comments on John Kerry's "plan" appeared on Sunday and only on Sunday. Since then, members have highlighted two commentaries on Kerry's "plan." I didn't write those critiques. I noted that I was "blah" to it. I don't think it's impressive. I do think it's past time to stop looking at 'solutions' from the eyes of the United States:
The occupation needs to cease, the troops need to return home. If Kerry's plan does that, fine. But it's a great deal like the IMF in that there are "deadlines." And you'll note the deadlines are for the Iraqis. There's no deadline in there for the occupying power. There's no deadline that states the United States will, for instance, have 35% of the hospitals in Iraq back up to pre-war levels within six months or the United States will leave Iraq. It's a "jump through our hoops, Iraqis" plan to me.
They're occupied and each week brings a new administration-outsourced reconstruction scandal. But the expectations are placed upon Iraqis, not upon the occupying power. Iraqi's didn't bomb their own infrastructure. But there are no expectations for the administration (other than to tell the truth -- which, sadly, does need to be put into Kerry's plan).
If it ends the occupation, great. Anything that ends the illegal occupation is appreciated. But the operating principles continue to be "Iraqis must do" while they've had no real power under the illegal occupation. Expectations for the occupying power are aims/goals/deadlines that are never thought of.
I stand by those remarks; however, until now, Sunday is the only time I've written about Kerry's plan. The other times have been highlights.
Hayden is correct that Kerry making some sort of a call has an impact. I remain blah on Kerry's call. If his call/plan helps, great. But I'm not going to stroke his ego online to get him to take another step. "Come on, Baby Kerry, you can do it, one more step, one more! Come on!"
I'm not invested in Kerry or his plan. Congress has had three years to do something. I'm not seeing anything to clap over. Nor am I pinning hopes on the elections with regards to Iraq.
The only thing that will end the war is the people. And not by responding to a phone survey that's then run by the New York Times or whomever.
The country turned against the war long ago. This hasn't been followed by courage in Congress. (Quite the contrary.)
I understand what Hayden's getting at and how this can be another milestone. That's not to be underestimated. But the plan itself? Blah.
Iraqis aren't idiot-savants (or idiots). They're an educated people (and the brain drain hasn't changed that). It's past time that elected leaders grasped that. I see nothing in Kerry's plan that indicates he grasps that. I see, "Iraqis will do this and then they will do . . ." I see no obligations for the United States.
Did Iraq invade itself?
Kerry's speaking out against the war in some form. Good for him. He's where the American public was almost a year ago. If I'm supposed to get excited about leadership, I'll need to see some. The politicians are starting to follow the public. And maybe some would have high-fived and head butted over Kerry's plan a year ago?
I'd like to hear his old voice -- the one he hid (was forced to hide) at the convention. That might excite me. This plan where he plays "Mean Daddy" with the Iraqis? I think he needs to be sent to his room.
Where is the morality? In his plan, where is it? I thought that was on the BIG DEM BLACKBOARD these days: no to abortion, talk a lot of God, push morals . . .
Where's the morality of writing a plan for an (illegal) occupation that seems unaware of the occupation? As long as our "leaders" act like we're just over there visiting, as opposed to occupying, we'll continue to be underwhelmed by our elected leaders. (And to follow the Carter Doctrine?)
I do understand what Hayden's sees as noteworthy and possible. The 'plan' continues to leave me with a case of the blahs. I do understand why Debbie feels Kerry's being attacked. Except to note the xenophobic assumptions of the plan (a key point, true), I've had little to say until now because in terms of 'action,' Americans were ready for that a year ago. Members have highlighted criticisms of the 'plan' and may continue to do so. That's how it works and the site title remains "The Common Ills" as opposed to "The John Kerry Fan Club." As for another fear Debbie had -- that I'm "tearing him down to build up Hillary" -- Debbie, have you seen Isaiah's "Got War?"
Walk on, walkon.org.
But not too far. Another visitor sputters how dare I say the Times took part in a propaganda scheme.
US Exaggerating Zarqawi Role in PR Effort
The Washington Post is reporting the Pentagon is conducting a propaganda campaign to magnify the role of al-Qaeda figure Abu Musab al-Zarqawi in Iraq. Some military intelligence officials believe the campaign may have exaggerated Zarqawi's importance and helped the Bush administration link the Iraq war with the September 11 attacks. The propaganda effort has also been reportedly used to build sentiment against non-US foreigners in Iraq. One military briefing was entitled: "Villainize Zarqawi/leverage xenophobia response." Another document lists "U.S. Home Audience" as a target audience for the campaign.
That's from Monday's Democracy Now! (and we skipped it because it had been noted in "Other Items" that day). Propaganda? Iraq?
Let's ease on down the road to the one and only Dexy Filkins. But let's not fall back into something prior to the mea culpa/non mea culpa of the Times. Let's drop back to March 25th of this year for "NYT: SITE gives Dexy translations, he gives them play -- None dare call it reporting."
Dexter Filkins files "Iraq Qaeda Chief Seems To Pursue A Lower Profile" in this morning's New York Times. Files from where? Readers may wonder since it's a front page article without a dateline. So let's give it the byline and dateline it's earned: "By DEXTER FILKINS and RITA KATZ, SITE Institute, March 24."
Without a dateline, but never without experts, wherever he goes, Dexter always packs his cliches and his experts. This time he tells us that "experts believe" and "American and Iraqi officals . . . are divided." An unnamed "American intelligence official" gives him an actual quote.
In paragraphs sixteen and seventeen of the twenty-five paragraph article (check my math), Filkins finally has names. Rita Katz comes stumbling in in paragraph sixteen. Ms. Katz is identified by Filkins as "the director of SITE Institute, which tracks violent Islamist groups" and someone who wrote "an opinion article in The Boston Globe."
Katz, though Filkins doesn't tell you this, has also written at least three times for The National Review. Katz has been sued by several groups who accuse her of falsely labeling them terrorist groups, another fact that Filkins doesn't provide to readers. She is also an Iraqi exile which Filkins forgets to tell readers. He also can't state she is a supporter of the Patriot Act. She has stated that the US had "success" in Afghanistan. (That laughable comment alone should prevent the Times from quoting her.) Despite Bully Boy's famous/infamous statement on his so-called war on terror ("I don't think you can win it."), Katz firmly believes that you can.
Dexy loves Rita. But when he noted her on December 2, 2005, he was able to note that she and her organization were "now working under a United States government contract to investigate militant groups." Today she's just an independent "expert" -- not affiliated with anything but the 'truth.' It's a loose affiliation, not unlike Dexy's affiliation with reporting.
Well Dexy's had go-go boy gone wild times in the Green Zone and apparently never learned the language so he has to depend on Katz and her organization "which provided the translations of his statements . . ." Him being Zarqawi, whose alleged statements are the focus of Dexy's article. She gives him translations (which he can't evaluate) and he gives her quote play. Rita Katz used to be "anonymous" but when she went on 60 Minutes in 2003, she was "Sarah." Anonymous is one thing, false alias, however, should give the press pause. Not Dexy. Dexy runs with the administration doggies.
It's called propaganda and Dexy's quite familiar with it. Again, Judith Miller was not the paper's problem. The paper has many problems. One of which is Dexy and he's in a completely different league. (Miller didn't witness a massacre that she then turned into feel-good-propaganda.) Dexy Filkins's work should be examined everytime he files. It rarely holds up to even a basic once over. So this week, we learned that the Pentagon implemented a propaganda campaign and somehow, Dexy just happens to swallow it. It's almost as though he's riding around in a jeep with his mouth open, isn't it? And isn't Rita Katz's involvement interesting?
Especially since this was a US propaganda campaign and she just happened to have documents that would let Dexy pad out his article. How strange? And what is she on the government payroll for? And why didn't Dexy note that in his article?
Dexy benefits from the fact that people look the other way. Judith Miller became infamous in a period of time that he won an award, an actual award, for his propaganda. It's past time people paid attention to what he writes. And I think that requires more than what Greg Mitchell notes with regard to a February 9, 2004 article. Thomas E. Ricks wrote "is conducting." And we saw Filkins' with a new "scoop" less than two weeks ago on the same topic.
It's past time that people played connect the dots. Falluja, propaganda (which didn't end in 2004), there's a lot to examine. It's a body of work (including the "award winning" piece) that goes far beyond one story and, when you consider its scope and how it was used to sell the war after it began, as damaging as anything Judith Miller could have done. We're seen as Dexy "haters" by some. I'll take that as a compliment. Filkins may have gotten a pass in many places, but he never got one here.
And we should pay attention to the fact that the operation was illegal. The government intended this propaganda to reach Iraqis and to reach Americans. The later of which is illegal. It must be nice to have a New York Times reporter that you can rush to when you're trying to lie to the American people. It must be nice to know he'll type up the lies and they'll end up on the front page.
Are people going to start noticing Dexter Filkins? Probably not. Since the invasion he (and his mentor John F. Burns) have largely gotten a pass. But let's all play bash-the-bitch one more time and go after Miller, right?
Miller (and others) helped get us over there with bad reporting. Filkins has helped keep us there with lies and distortions.
Lastly Danny Schechter (again) has a take on Katie Couric that I was dared to note (by a friend, not a community member). I'll note it. I know both the writer and the topic. So I will just wonder whether the same sort of critique greeted Brian Williams move to anchoring the evening news? Or if "gravitas" just 'hang naturally' on men? I think we're seeing a lot of criticism come into play that doesn't when the topic is a male. Having noted the prior link, we'll also note Feminist Wire Daily's "Katie Couric Makes History."
However, I actually may say more later because, going beyond Danny's piece, there's an attitude that's really beginning to grate on my nerves popping up throughout. In fact Ava thinks we may take it on together in a joint entry here or at The Third Estate Sunday Review.
The e-mail address for this site is common_ills@yahoo.com. And members should use the designated backup site or the public site because there have been problems with the site designated for members since this morning.
democracy now
seymour hersh
greg palast
danny schechter
joan mellen
harpers magazine
michael ratner
center for constitutional rights
articles of impeachment against george w. bush
lewis lapham
elizabeth holtzman
tom hayden
the new york times
dexter filkins
feminist wire
the third estate sunday review
The Washington Post is reporting the Bush administration claimed to have found mobile weapons labs in Iraq after the invasion despite the explicit conclusions of a Pentagon-sponsored mission the claim was untrue. On May 29, 2003, President Bush cited the discovery of the trailers in an attempt to justify his decision to go war two months earlier. Bush said: "We have found the weapons of mass destruction." But just two days before, a Pentagon team sent to Iraq had concluded that the trailers were in fact "the biggest sand toilets in the world." One team member said: "Within the first four hours, it was clear to everyone that these were not biological labs." The Bush administration failed to make the findings public and continued with its faulty claim for more than one year.
Looming Health Care Measure Requires Proof of Citizenship
In other news, the Boston Globe is reporting thousands of low-income Americans are at risk with the pending activation of a federal law that would require them to show proof US of citizenship in order to receive health care. The requirement was attached to the Deficit Reduction Act, which President Bush signed into law this year. Healthcare advocates said the requirements could adversely affect undocumented immigrants and Medicaid recipients who will be unable to provide the necessary documentation. Bill Walczak, chief executive officer of the Codman Square Health Center in Massachusetts, said: '"We didn't create the healthcare centers to become citizenship enforcement centers."
Government Agency Colluded with CIA in Re-Classification Scheme
The National Security Archive has revealed that the government agency responsible for state archives colluded with the CIA and other intelligence agencies to remove thousands of previously declassified historical documents that were previously available to the public. In a secret agreement, the National Archives and Records Administration agreed to remove the archival records and re-classify them in order to avoid scrutiny from researchers. The re-classification scheme was disclosed earlier this year but details of how it came about were largely unknown.
Cheney Booed At Washington Baseball Game
And in Washington, Vice President Dick Cheney was greeted with loud boos Tuesday when he threw out the ceremonial pitch at the opener for Major League Baseball's Washington Nationals. This wasn't the first time Cheney has gotten a hostile reception at a baseball game -- in June 2004, Cheney was booed at a Yankees game here in New York.
The above four items are from today's Democracy Now! Headlines and were selected by Markus, Brenda, Susan and ??? Democracy Now! ("always informing you," as Marcia says):
Headlines for April 12, 2006
- Iran Says It Has Enriched Small-Scale Uranium
- Report: Bush Admin. Suppressed Evidence Refuting Iraq WMD Claim
- Suicide Attack Kills 57 in Pakistan
- Berlusconi Refuses to Concede Italian Elections
- 29 Indicted Over Madrid Train Bombings
- Thousands Mark Death of Palestinian Girl in Gaza
- Three Killed, Hundreds Arrested in Nepal Unrest
- Cheney Booed At Washington Baseball Game
Seymour Hersh: Bush Administration Planning Possible Major Air Attack on Iran
We speak with Pulitzer Prize winning journalist Seymour Hersh about his latest article in the New Yorker that the Bush administration has increased clandestine activities inside Iran and intensified planning for a possible major air attack.
French Student Leaders Hail 'Historic Victory' After Mass Protests Force Government to Abandon Controversial Youth Job Law
In France, mass student protests and labor strikes have forced the French government to abandon a controversial new law that would have made it easier for companies to fire young workers. We speak with University of Paris professor, Gilbert Achcar.
Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi Refuses to Concede Defeat Despite Official Election Results
In Italy, opposition leader Romano Prodi has been declared the official winner in the country's elections, defeating Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi in one of Italy's closest races ever. Berlusconi is now refusing to admit he lost the race and is calling for a recount of thousands of disputed ballots.
Investigative Reporter Greg Palast: U.S. Energy Dept. Concludes Venezuela Could Have Biggest Oil Reserves in OPEC
In an interview with BBC investigative reporter Greg Palast, Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez said he would ask the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries to set the long-term price of oil at $50 a barrel. Palast reports that analysis by the US Department of Energy shows that Venezuela -- not Saudi Arabia -- could have the biggest oil reserves in the OPEC.
In England, Malcolm Kendall-Smith's court martial continues and today he stated that, "As early as 2004 I regarded the United States to be on par with Nazi Germany as regards its activities in the Gulf." The Associated Press seems to be fudging that quote and stating Kendall-Smith said "I have evidence" and not "I regarded" as Reuters and other news outlets have reported.
Gareth recommends Kim Sengupta's "RAF doctor refused to fight 'illegal' Iraq war" (London's Independent) and, from that, we'll note Kendall-Smith's statements:
As a commissioned officer I am required to consider... every order that is given to me and I am required to consider the legality of each order... Since my initial operational deployments, I have studied... the commentaries and... notes, including one prepared by the Attorney General and in particular the note to the Prime Minister dated 7 March 2003.
I believe the occupation of Iraq is illegal... and for me to comply... would put me in conflict with both domestic and international law. The illegality of the use of force against Iraq was the only reason I could not follow this order... [and] was the only reason for my resignation.
I would, in fact, refuse the orders as a duty under international law, the Nuremburg principles and the law of armed conflict...
To take the decision I have taken saddens me but I feel I have no choice.
I was subjected, as was the entire population, to propaganda depicting force against Iraq to be lawful but it was not until the middle of 2004 that I researched and found that not to be the case.
Iraq? The Associated Press reports that bombs have killed 13 in Iraq -- "including three U.S. soldiers" -- and that gun fire claimed an addition six civilians.The BBC reports that Jeffery Chessani, Lucas McConnel and James Kimber, US marines, have been "stripped of their commands" as a result of an investigation into the murder of fifteen Iraqis. AFP reports car bombs claimed at least two people in Tal Afar (wounding at least seven), and two in Kirkuk (with four wounded). In Tuz Khurmatu, Reuters reports, a roadside bomb has killed at least two and wounded at least four while in Khalis, a car bomb has wounded at least twenty and killed two. In Baghdad last week, a bombing outside a Shi'ite mosque killed ninety people, today a bombing outside a Shi'ite mosque has killed at least twenty.
Lynda notes that Danny Schechter's back (from Switzerland, I believe) and steers us towards "Your Letters, A Passover Greeting" (News Dissector):
Years ago, I directed a film (now on DVD) called BEYOND JFK featuring the story behind the story told in Oliver Stones controversial film JFK. One of Stones heroes was the widely discredited New Orleans DA Jim Garrison who put on the only trial of men accused of being part of the assassination. He lost the case and lost his reputation under heavy FBI and media assault until Stone came along to dramatize his story. Our film featured Garrison's last interview on his death bed when he insisted that the full story must be told.
All these years later, I ran into Temple University English Professor Joan Mellen who has exhaustively and painstakingly told that story in a thoroughly documented and detailed book called "A Farewell to Justice." (Potomac Books) It's a great read filled with newly unearthed facts that link Oswald and Ruby to a plot hatched in New Orleans. Don't scoff. She has done in-depth reporting the press missed and knows how to tell a story. (She teaches writing!) You can read about it on her website: JoanMellen.net.
In a dinner with Joan I asked her about her obsession with the case. Like many of the today's 911 researchers, she can't let it go. Her site carries a speech that explains why and it touches on the press:
"I would like to suggest that the truth about the Kennedy assassination, far from being a matter of interest only to historians, and not even to most of them, will help us understand how we have arrived at a point where people as respectable as New York attorney Martin Garbus are comparing the current U.S. government with the rise of fascism in the mid-twentieth century. It's my belief that the present state of our political culture is a direct result of the fact that those responsible for the murder of President Kennedy have never been brought to justice.
"To sum up: "A Farewell To Justice" suggests that the clandestine service of the CIA not only covered up the truth about the Kennedy assassination -- that's easy to demonstrate from the four million documents now residing at the National Archives -- but organized the event itself. That the CIA escaped without penalty, this extraordinary fact, has been integrated over these forty-two years into the body politic. It has produced a political culture where the unthinkable has become accepted practice. Meaningful freedom of the press has fallen into serious jeopardy."
A few comments on the above. If you'd like to see Danny's documentary, it's available on the director's cut of JFK. It features interviews with Robert MacNeil, Walter Cronkite and others. (And is more than worth watching.) (Need another reason? Tom Wicker comes off more ridiculous on film than in print so New York Times readers of old can enjoy that.) Second, please read Joan Mellen's A Farewell To Justice. Members who have read it can't stop singing the book's praises. (I read it as well and also recommend it strongly.)
Remember Lewis Lapham's "The Case for Impeachment" (Harper's Magazine)? Remember that they also hosted a debate on the topic? Brandon notes that text excerpts and an MP3 are available online. Participants included Michael Ratner, Elisabeth Holtzman, John Conyers Jr., John Dean and Lapham.
Visitor Debbie notes Tom Hayden's "Kerry Steps Up...Who Will Respond?" (Huffington Post):
Will Kerry, a much more formidable candidate, take the same course? No one can be certain, but the primary winds are blowing in the direction of peace and progressive politics. Sen. Hillary Clinton, the seemingly invincible front-runner, is not likely to emerge from Iowa and New Hampshire unscathed. Her hardline support of the Iraq War is not only out of touch with Democratic voters, but appears to many as chronic opportunism. Unless the war suddenly ends, her credibility will suffer severely in the primaries.
This is why the "Kerry factor" becomes important. As the former nominee, Kerry commands media and public attention. As an anti-war voice, he is in sharp contrast with the silence of the lambs. As a potential presidential contender, he is a credible foil to the centrist hawks and challenges the party leadership to make up its mind.
On the other hand, many anti-war Democrats still blame Kerry for vascillating on Iraq in 2004 in the same ways the party leadership does today. Some in the anti-war movement will continue demanding withdrawal "now" instead of by year's end. Others will insist, rightly on real reconstruction and sovereignty for post-war Iraq, not its transfer to control by the WTO. Still others will watch how Kerry connects the war with domestic issues of jobs, poverty, immigration and racism. The potential of a progressive majority, or center-left politics is there. Not since Watergate has there been the opportunity. In both crises, the unpopularity of an imperial war led the White House to illegally discredit and spy on its critics, lose credibility with a majority of Americans, and prompt Congress to cut off funding for war.
Visitor Debbie feels that I have "raked Kerry over the coals" for the past few days. She notes she was a John Kerry supporter in 2004 and hopes he runs in 2008.
My comments on John Kerry's "plan" appeared on Sunday and only on Sunday. Since then, members have highlighted two commentaries on Kerry's "plan." I didn't write those critiques. I noted that I was "blah" to it. I don't think it's impressive. I do think it's past time to stop looking at 'solutions' from the eyes of the United States:
The occupation needs to cease, the troops need to return home. If Kerry's plan does that, fine. But it's a great deal like the IMF in that there are "deadlines." And you'll note the deadlines are for the Iraqis. There's no deadline in there for the occupying power. There's no deadline that states the United States will, for instance, have 35% of the hospitals in Iraq back up to pre-war levels within six months or the United States will leave Iraq. It's a "jump through our hoops, Iraqis" plan to me.
They're occupied and each week brings a new administration-outsourced reconstruction scandal. But the expectations are placed upon Iraqis, not upon the occupying power. Iraqi's didn't bomb their own infrastructure. But there are no expectations for the administration (other than to tell the truth -- which, sadly, does need to be put into Kerry's plan).
If it ends the occupation, great. Anything that ends the illegal occupation is appreciated. But the operating principles continue to be "Iraqis must do" while they've had no real power under the illegal occupation. Expectations for the occupying power are aims/goals/deadlines that are never thought of.
I stand by those remarks; however, until now, Sunday is the only time I've written about Kerry's plan. The other times have been highlights.
Hayden is correct that Kerry making some sort of a call has an impact. I remain blah on Kerry's call. If his call/plan helps, great. But I'm not going to stroke his ego online to get him to take another step. "Come on, Baby Kerry, you can do it, one more step, one more! Come on!"
I'm not invested in Kerry or his plan. Congress has had three years to do something. I'm not seeing anything to clap over. Nor am I pinning hopes on the elections with regards to Iraq.
The only thing that will end the war is the people. And not by responding to a phone survey that's then run by the New York Times or whomever.
The country turned against the war long ago. This hasn't been followed by courage in Congress. (Quite the contrary.)
I understand what Hayden's getting at and how this can be another milestone. That's not to be underestimated. But the plan itself? Blah.
Iraqis aren't idiot-savants (or idiots). They're an educated people (and the brain drain hasn't changed that). It's past time that elected leaders grasped that. I see nothing in Kerry's plan that indicates he grasps that. I see, "Iraqis will do this and then they will do . . ." I see no obligations for the United States.
Did Iraq invade itself?
Kerry's speaking out against the war in some form. Good for him. He's where the American public was almost a year ago. If I'm supposed to get excited about leadership, I'll need to see some. The politicians are starting to follow the public. And maybe some would have high-fived and head butted over Kerry's plan a year ago?
I'd like to hear his old voice -- the one he hid (was forced to hide) at the convention. That might excite me. This plan where he plays "Mean Daddy" with the Iraqis? I think he needs to be sent to his room.
Where is the morality? In his plan, where is it? I thought that was on the BIG DEM BLACKBOARD these days: no to abortion, talk a lot of God, push morals . . .
Where's the morality of writing a plan for an (illegal) occupation that seems unaware of the occupation? As long as our "leaders" act like we're just over there visiting, as opposed to occupying, we'll continue to be underwhelmed by our elected leaders. (And to follow the Carter Doctrine?)
I do understand what Hayden's sees as noteworthy and possible. The 'plan' continues to leave me with a case of the blahs. I do understand why Debbie feels Kerry's being attacked. Except to note the xenophobic assumptions of the plan (a key point, true), I've had little to say until now because in terms of 'action,' Americans were ready for that a year ago. Members have highlighted criticisms of the 'plan' and may continue to do so. That's how it works and the site title remains "The Common Ills" as opposed to "The John Kerry Fan Club." As for another fear Debbie had -- that I'm "tearing him down to build up Hillary" -- Debbie, have you seen Isaiah's "Got War?"
Walk on, walkon.org.
But not too far. Another visitor sputters how dare I say the Times took part in a propaganda scheme.
US Exaggerating Zarqawi Role in PR Effort
The Washington Post is reporting the Pentagon is conducting a propaganda campaign to magnify the role of al-Qaeda figure Abu Musab al-Zarqawi in Iraq. Some military intelligence officials believe the campaign may have exaggerated Zarqawi's importance and helped the Bush administration link the Iraq war with the September 11 attacks. The propaganda effort has also been reportedly used to build sentiment against non-US foreigners in Iraq. One military briefing was entitled: "Villainize Zarqawi/leverage xenophobia response." Another document lists "U.S. Home Audience" as a target audience for the campaign.
That's from Monday's Democracy Now! (and we skipped it because it had been noted in "Other Items" that day). Propaganda? Iraq?
Let's ease on down the road to the one and only Dexy Filkins. But let's not fall back into something prior to the mea culpa/non mea culpa of the Times. Let's drop back to March 25th of this year for "NYT: SITE gives Dexy translations, he gives them play -- None dare call it reporting."
Dexter Filkins files "Iraq Qaeda Chief Seems To Pursue A Lower Profile" in this morning's New York Times. Files from where? Readers may wonder since it's a front page article without a dateline. So let's give it the byline and dateline it's earned: "By DEXTER FILKINS and RITA KATZ, SITE Institute, March 24."
Without a dateline, but never without experts, wherever he goes, Dexter always packs his cliches and his experts. This time he tells us that "experts believe" and "American and Iraqi officals . . . are divided." An unnamed "American intelligence official" gives him an actual quote.
In paragraphs sixteen and seventeen of the twenty-five paragraph article (check my math), Filkins finally has names. Rita Katz comes stumbling in in paragraph sixteen. Ms. Katz is identified by Filkins as "the director of SITE Institute, which tracks violent Islamist groups" and someone who wrote "an opinion article in The Boston Globe."
Katz, though Filkins doesn't tell you this, has also written at least three times for The National Review. Katz has been sued by several groups who accuse her of falsely labeling them terrorist groups, another fact that Filkins doesn't provide to readers. She is also an Iraqi exile which Filkins forgets to tell readers. He also can't state she is a supporter of the Patriot Act. She has stated that the US had "success" in Afghanistan. (That laughable comment alone should prevent the Times from quoting her.) Despite Bully Boy's famous/infamous statement on his so-called war on terror ("I don't think you can win it."), Katz firmly believes that you can.
Dexy loves Rita. But when he noted her on December 2, 2005, he was able to note that she and her organization were "now working under a United States government contract to investigate militant groups." Today she's just an independent "expert" -- not affiliated with anything but the 'truth.' It's a loose affiliation, not unlike Dexy's affiliation with reporting.
Well Dexy's had go-go boy gone wild times in the Green Zone and apparently never learned the language so he has to depend on Katz and her organization "which provided the translations of his statements . . ." Him being Zarqawi, whose alleged statements are the focus of Dexy's article. She gives him translations (which he can't evaluate) and he gives her quote play. Rita Katz used to be "anonymous" but when she went on 60 Minutes in 2003, she was "Sarah." Anonymous is one thing, false alias, however, should give the press pause. Not Dexy. Dexy runs with the administration doggies.
It's called propaganda and Dexy's quite familiar with it. Again, Judith Miller was not the paper's problem. The paper has many problems. One of which is Dexy and he's in a completely different league. (Miller didn't witness a massacre that she then turned into feel-good-propaganda.) Dexy Filkins's work should be examined everytime he files. It rarely holds up to even a basic once over. So this week, we learned that the Pentagon implemented a propaganda campaign and somehow, Dexy just happens to swallow it. It's almost as though he's riding around in a jeep with his mouth open, isn't it? And isn't Rita Katz's involvement interesting?
Especially since this was a US propaganda campaign and she just happened to have documents that would let Dexy pad out his article. How strange? And what is she on the government payroll for? And why didn't Dexy note that in his article?
Dexy benefits from the fact that people look the other way. Judith Miller became infamous in a period of time that he won an award, an actual award, for his propaganda. It's past time people paid attention to what he writes. And I think that requires more than what Greg Mitchell notes with regard to a February 9, 2004 article. Thomas E. Ricks wrote "is conducting." And we saw Filkins' with a new "scoop" less than two weeks ago on the same topic.
It's past time that people played connect the dots. Falluja, propaganda (which didn't end in 2004), there's a lot to examine. It's a body of work (including the "award winning" piece) that goes far beyond one story and, when you consider its scope and how it was used to sell the war after it began, as damaging as anything Judith Miller could have done. We're seen as Dexy "haters" by some. I'll take that as a compliment. Filkins may have gotten a pass in many places, but he never got one here.
And we should pay attention to the fact that the operation was illegal. The government intended this propaganda to reach Iraqis and to reach Americans. The later of which is illegal. It must be nice to have a New York Times reporter that you can rush to when you're trying to lie to the American people. It must be nice to know he'll type up the lies and they'll end up on the front page.
Are people going to start noticing Dexter Filkins? Probably not. Since the invasion he (and his mentor John F. Burns) have largely gotten a pass. But let's all play bash-the-bitch one more time and go after Miller, right?
Miller (and others) helped get us over there with bad reporting. Filkins has helped keep us there with lies and distortions.
Lastly Danny Schechter (again) has a take on Katie Couric that I was dared to note (by a friend, not a community member). I'll note it. I know both the writer and the topic. So I will just wonder whether the same sort of critique greeted Brian Williams move to anchoring the evening news? Or if "gravitas" just 'hang naturally' on men? I think we're seeing a lot of criticism come into play that doesn't when the topic is a male. Having noted the prior link, we'll also note Feminist Wire Daily's "Katie Couric Makes History."
However, I actually may say more later because, going beyond Danny's piece, there's an attitude that's really beginning to grate on my nerves popping up throughout. In fact Ava thinks we may take it on together in a joint entry here or at The Third Estate Sunday Review.
The e-mail address for this site is common_ills@yahoo.com. And members should use the designated backup site or the public site because there have been problems with the site designated for members since this morning.
democracy now
seymour hersh
greg palast
danny schechter
joan mellen
harpers magazine
michael ratner
center for constitutional rights
articles of impeachment against george w. bush
lewis lapham
elizabeth holtzman
tom hayden
the new york times
dexter filkins
feminist wire
the third estate sunday review
Talk is cheap. Use Yahoo! Messenger to make PC-to-Phone calls. Great rates starting at 1¢/min.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)