Jim: It's roundtable time and we're mainly focusing on e-mails that have come in. Dona looked at the ones Ty and I had selected and said there was no way it would be a mailbag so we might as well make it a roundtable. Participating in this roundtable are The Third Estate Sunday Review's Dona, Ty, Jess, Ava, and me, Jim; Rebecca of Sex and Politics and Screeds and Attitude; Betty of Thomas Friedman Is a Great Man; C.I. of The Common Ills and The Third Estate Sunday Review, Kat of Kat's Korner (of The Common Ills); Cedric of Cedric's Big Mix; Mike of Mikey Likes It!; Elaine of Like Maria Said Paz; Ruth of Ruth's Report; Wally of The Daily Jot; Marcia of SICKOFITRDLZ and Stan of Oh Boy It Never Ends. We're going to start out with something raised in an e-mail by ChazTiger97 who wrote to say that we are opposed to Caroline Kennedy being appointed a Senator and "yet you're not at all bothered or angry about a Biden dynasty. I smell favoritism."
C.I.: I'll jump in there because I know Joe Biden and I like him and if anyone's playing favorites here, it would be me. Chaz whatever doesn't know what he's talking about. Joe Biden is no longer a Senator, he is the incoming vice president of the United States. His seat has been filled: Edward Kaufman who has been his chief of staff. Kaufman is not planning to run for re-election and he's more than familiar with the needs of Delaware's constitutents. He doesn't need on the job training, he knows what he's doing. Beau Biden was not appointed to Joe's seat. Ruth Ann Minner, the governor of Delaware, has stated an election will be held for the seat in two years. So Kaufman is the perfect choice. There's no learning curve, he knows what he's doing. So in two-years, less than two actually, a special-election will be held for the seat. Now the concern by people like Chaz is that Beau, who alreadys holds office, will run in two years for the Senate seat. And that's what people are calling a 'dynasty' and falsely comparing to Caroline Kennedy's attempt to buy her way into the Senate. First off, Beau Biden is Delware's Attorney General. He was not appointed to that office. He ran in a state wide election and he won. He has been tested by the voters which, right away, puts him several up on Caroline Kennedy. Now he is deployed to Iraq and, I'm sorry, I'm going to speak out of school. Joe could have pulled Beau. Beau didn't have to go. Strings can be pulled if you're a US Senator, let alone if you're now about to become the vice president of the United States. A doctor suddenly finds an inner ear problem or what have you. Beau would never have stood for that. Beau signed up and is of the belief that he completes the service he promised. Would Joe have gone for that? If Beau had asked him, absolutely. He loves his children very much. So if Beau wanted to be appointed a US Senator, he could have it, he could have right now -- provided the governor went along. And Minner's no push over so I don't want to imply that she is. But in this "It's a grand conspiracy!" theory, Minner's rendered a push over. She's no such thing in reality. In two years, Beau -- unless he signs up for another tour -- may run for the US Senate. He may not. And it really goes to how ignorant people are about the Iraq War that they seem to think it's just a holding space. No one knows what's going to happen over there. Hopefully, Beau will make it home physically and mentally intact; however, this isn't a week at Club Med, this idea that everyone knows what Beau is going to do is just utter crap. Beau doesn't know what he's going to do. But if the "Grand Conspiracy" is true and this has all been doing because Beau wants the Senate seat and Minner wants him to have it and Joe wants him to have it and the entire political establishment in Delaware wants him to have it, Beau would still be running in an election and would require the people signing off by voting for him. There is no comparison at all between Beau Biden and Caroline Kennedy. Beau is not a spoiled brat, he is not asking to cut in line or be given anything. Should he become a senator it will be because he ran for the office and the voters picked him. Those partaking in the "Grand Conspiracy" should grasp something else. A GOP candidate for the senate has the next two years to run. The next two years to court Delaware voters and to form some bond of trust or increase a bond that already exists. There is no Beau Biden lock even if every piece of the "Grand Conspiracy" perfectly falls into place. I'm truly insulted that Beau, who is serving his country in Iraq, is being compared to the pampered, spoiled princess Caroline. That's deeply offensive to me. How did Caroline spend her youth? Oh, that's right, running around the Big Apple with various married men and no one was supposed to talk about it because little princess needed her privacy. Except for other women's husbands, Caroline has never given her all to anything. And photos exist. Why aren't we seeing any of them? Jann Wenner squiring Caroline to this Broadway play and that. She wants to be a US Senator. Why isn't the limited public aspect of her life being explored?
Elaine: Exactly. Jann Wenner was twice her age and married. That's just one example, by the way. Why isn't Caroline's fondness for married men being explored. Why, for that matter, aren't the people who knew her as the spoiled brat at The New York Daily News being interviewed? I spoke to one last week and he said no one had tried to contact him. She interned there and did damn little work. Not unlike her record as an 'educational czar.' But the real difference between a Beau Biden and a Caroline Kennedy is that if Beau had crashed Elvis' funeral, it would have been because he cared about the man's music. He would not have lied to the family, he would have not studied Lisa Marie -- a child -- to turn her heartache over her father's death into cheap tabloid fodder which is exactly what Caroline did. She was such a lousy journalist -- which is no one's ever believed the 'co-author' actually writes those books -- that everyone passed on her eye witness article. She managed to interested her 'steady' Jann and he fobbed the article off on Rolling Stone's editor who had to do a top to bottom re-write to bring life to Caroline's bad writing. Caroline's never apologized for that. Her attitude is that her 'birthright' allows her to prey on others' tragedies. It's the same attitude on display where she thinks her record as a socialite with make-work charity hobbies qualifies for the experience needed to be appointed a US Senator.
Jim: Okay, and I'm going to toss to Ty for the next one but I think it's been clearly established that there are no similarities between Caroline begging to be appointed to a job and the prospect that, in two years, Beau Biden would run for an open Senate seat. Ty?
Ty: Bracee e-mailed with a question for Stan. Since Stan's the only reason that the community sites are continuing through at least April, Bracee wonders if Stan feels pressure from that "or guilt?"
Stan: Not until now. I hadn't thought of it like that. I started my site not that long ago, I just got my 40th post last week. And I was wanting to but told C.I. I didn't want to start it if everyone else was about to shut down their sites. So C.I. said, "I can make it to April." As Bracee points out, I should feel pressure or guilt or both. I hadn't really thought about it.
Ruth: Well, to be clear, other than Elaine and C.I., we are all more than willing to go on for a bit longer. My site is not that old. I started doing reports at The Common Ills in 2005 but my own site is not that old. Do not feel pressured or guilty on my part.
Betty: I agree with Ruth but let me ask a question here. We know how Elaine and C.I. feel and we know how Ruth feels which is similar to the way Mike, Cedric, Rebecca and others feel. But do we really know how Third feels? I feel like we assume we do. But I'm not sure that we do.
Ava: I'm with C.I. I would have been happy to fold tent the day after the November election which was the plan as far back as 2005. We agreed to hold our review a show for a friend working on the show, agreed to hold it until mid-season. We weren't thinking at the time or we would have said, "Mid-season? We'll be done by then." But we agreed and we included that in one of our commentaries. Jim reads it aloud and points out that we just extended the life of Third. We hadn't caught that until Jim pointed it out. So, in terms of Stan, we were already going through January or February for that one show. Don't feel any pressure or guilt. I'm also pretty sure that, come the end of April, C.I. will extend for six more months but I wouldn't bet on much more than that.
Jess: There are times when I have the time to really participate and there are weekends where I'm lucky just to keep my eyes open. I don't know. We've been doing this since January 2005. I'm not sure what it would be like to have weekends off at this point. My attitude is, as long as everyone else -- Dona, Jim, Ty, Ava and C.I. -- want to do this site, I'll be here. I'm not going to argue for it to extend or for it to end. Dona?
Dona: Well, here's the thing for us -- for Jim and me. We are engaged now and we do have a wedding planned and a honeymoon. If this site is still going then, we'll be off for some time. A minimum of three weekends. I'm not trying to end things, my attitude is similar to Jess' attitude, and I'll be here working as long as everyone wants to do it. Now if Ava or C.I. walked -- and I think if one walked, they'd both walk -- we would probably end it. If Ty wanted out, we would consider ending it or Jim or Jess. But if Ava and C.I. walked, we would absolutely end it.
Ava: Because?
Dona: Hilda's Mix subscribers will get to enjoy the appalled tone in Ava's voice. [Note: Hilda's mix audio subscribers get the roundtable in audio form.] Because of the fact that you and C.I. do the calling card. Your TV commentaries have always been the biggest hit each week, always the site's calling card. If you leave, what are we going to do? Someone else is going to grab TV? Oh, that'll go over well with the readers. So we just leave TV out of the mix? I think the readers would be outraged by that as well. It's a no-win situation. So if you two left, we'd shut down. I think Ty, Jess, Jim or me could leave --just one of us -- and the site could go on. It would be different and maybe better but it wouldn't be as noticeable.
Jim: I agree with Dona and I was doing some math while she was speaking. Ava and C.I. take over the weekly TV commentaries solo two or so weeks after they start here in 2005. In 2006 and 2007, they frequently did more than one commentary a week -- also true in 2008. So they have easily done over 206 TV commentaries here at Third. Now if our little magazine lasted 10 or 15 years, yeah, we could bring in a replacement for Ava and C.I. and then a replacement for the replacement and it would be like Vanity Fair going on after Dorothy Parker was no longer their theatre critic. But we don't plan to go that long -- not even for Stan! -- so Dona's right. That would be the end. And she's right that it wouldn't be one of them leaving. We all squared off that first weekend all those years ago. And it really was all of us and Ava until C.I. started saying, "Wait, wait. Listen to Ava's suggestion." Or "that was a funny line." And that's just because Ty, Jess, Dona and I are more than happy to fight for ideas and mix it up and Ava wasn't really like that. But my point is that those two bonded and if one decided to leave, the other would as well. And Jess is playing like it wouldn't impact him but he and Ava have been a couple for how long now? If Ava wanted to go, then C.I. would go and, I bet, Jess as well. So Third would be Dona, Ty and me. We'd have to shut down. Do I want to shut down? I have a blast every weekend and sometimes feel like I'm the only one with Third that does. I love it all. The frustration, the stress, the tempers, you name it. I don't mind the arguing. I eat it all up. But not everyone agrees. Were it up to me, I could see this site going through 2010 easily. Ty?
Ty: I don't know. In the summer of 2005, we were all working on an edition and C.I. said, paraphrase, 'The Common Ills goes dark after the November 2008 election. I can't go on and on. I need a date to work towards.' And we didn't shy away from noting that or noting that we were shocked. There weren't as many sites back then. I think it was just Rebecca, Betty, Kat and Cedric. Ruth was already writing for The Common Ills but hadn't started her own site. But she was helping out that weekend. But I didn't understand it. I got that C.I. was tired but that's all I got. Now I get it a lot better and I'm like C.I. in that I would prefer to commit to small blocks of time. I can do six months. And then, at the end, see about six more. And the whole thing could well take us up to 2011, like Jim's talking about, but I couldn't commit to 2011 right now. That's way too much. If I thought we were going to 2011 right now, I'd be thinking, "Two more years! Two more years!"all the time. I'd be very unhappy. Six months I can agree to. I can't pin myself down for more than that. So Stan shouldn't feel guilty, to get back to the question. And to get back to Betty's question, we've covered it now in terms of Third. Is there anyone who is ready to shut down besides Elaine, Ava and C.I.?
Jim: Let the record show no one spoke. Speak now or forever hold your peace. Okay. Kat, Katherine e-mailed to complain that you only wrote 9 CD reviews this year and wanted to know if you intended to do more than that in 2009?
Kat: First, I wrote at least 10 CD reviews. I believe I wrote more than that, but I did at least ten. I also did my end of the year piece ("2008 in music"). I don't think it was a good year for music, 2008. I also have some people I will never review as a result of their 2008 actions. I plan to write about that next week at my site, hopefully on Monday. But I should only be doing 12 pieces a year and I believe I went over that this year. If I didn't, I missed it by one. Considering that the music sucked and that there was so much more to do, I think that's more than enough. I would like for my next review to be a double disc set and like it if that could go up this coming weekend. But that doesn't mean it will. I'm not going to say what it is because if I don't go on to review it, some will think there's a problem with it. That's not what it means. It just means I didn't have a way to write about it. I will say that if 2009 is as sucky as 2008, I will probably drop back to review some of my favorite older albums. If so, I'll be grabbing a Stevie Nicks' solo album for sure. I should also add that I'm now downloading more than buying CDs in the store. That's in part due to all the store closings -- including my beloved Tower -- but also because we're on the road during the week and it's so much easier when I get back to the hotel just to download an album than to try to make plans to stop somewhere and get it or order it online to have mailed to me.
Jim: Do you want to explain any about 'some you'll never review again'?
Kat: I'll write about it at my site. C.I.'s asked us to just never mention one person in particular here again and we never will. There are several like that and they can kiss my ass.
Wally: I'll toss mine out. Bright Eyes, go f**k yourself. Never need to hear your adenoidal whine again. Bruce Springsteen, punks like you were born to R-E-T-I-R-E. You realize, don't you, Bruce, that you've got two generations of music buyers to whom you mean nothing. Go do another "wee-wee" lyric, old feller. On the other hand, my opinion of John Mellancamp has soared and I'd love it if he could get a link. By September, Mellencamp was the only one I was buying and I bought up all his stuff on CD between September and December. "So you went to a party with Jaqueline Onassis, if you're so cool, why don't you wear glasses . . ." "Between A Laugh & A Tear" is another great song. There are so many and all I knew of him before March or so was the song he did with Indie Arie. Then he started speaking truth when others were acting stupid and C.I. turned over several live recordings to me to listen to on the road. There's a really great duet on "Pink Houses" between him and Maria McKee from a Farm Aid. For those trying to figure out what was going on when he caught my attention, he announced he would do a benefit for Barack and he announced he would do a benefit for Hillary. I respected that. And respected him for it. He only continued making sense throughout the year and I started buying the CDs in the fall.
Marcia: If I could weigh in on what Wally's talking about, it needs to be noted that John Mellencamp is a lot more advanced than Bruce who is a reactionary musically and one of the stiffest of all the performers. Bruce has two tricks, Phil Spector wall of sound or Woody Guthrie pose. The Lonesome Jubilee is an album Springsteen could never have done. It required too much stretching musically and the person had to be comfortable in their own skin.
Rebecca: That's a very good point. Mellencamp can get loose but Springsteen? I'm thinking of the 'dancing' in the video for "Dancing in the Dark." His 'dancing,' not Courtney Cox. He sort of embodies Billy Crystal's joke about the dancing abilities of White men, doesn't he? He really has no sense of rhythm which is why his non-acoustic numbers tend to clod-clod along.
Dona: Mike and Cedric have not spoken. Am I missing anyone else? We've got two more e-mails and I know one of them is really going to be an Ava and C.I. response. So Jim, save the question on movies and let Ty ask his question.
Ty: Ginger e-mailed wanting to know the biggest hope for 2009 and the biggest lesson of 2008. As Dona pointed out, Mike and Cedric have not spoken at all so we'll let them grab this and if others want to add after, feel free.
Cedric: Mike?
Mike: You start.
Cedric: Okay, I'll grab hope. My hope for this new year is that people will grow the hell up and stop believing that deluding yourself is a positive sign. Foolish is foolish, no matter how many times you try to put in a t-shirt with "HOPE" written across the front of it. Trust but verify. I think we could all use a lot more realism in our lives and my wish is that we get some reality back into our lives. I'm really sick of grown adults acting like saps. It's embarrassing. If there's any benefit to growing older, it's being able to have a sense of perspective. Perspective needs to be valued. 2008's disappointments are many. I agree with Betty's "Thinning out the herd (2008)" about Grace Lee Boggs and hope Mike will address that but I grabbed 2009, so I'll toss to him on 2008.
Mike: Well Cedric really called it on what we need this year: Perspective. I'm sick of seeing people older than me -- and I'm a grad student -- acting moon and cow-eyed. Grow up. As for 2008, Grace Lee Boggs? Does she have dementia? She might as well. She embarrassed herself and no one needs to bring on her radio or TV anymore. She's not getting any younger. She can't speak near a microphone without you hearing smacking from her dry lips and her constant clearing of her dry throat. I can't imagine she has many more years left in her. So it was grossly embarrassing that she refused to hold Barack accountable and just hopped on the bandwagon by public declaring that kids like him. She shirked her duty, she embarrassed herself. She destroyed her legacy.
Betty: She really did. I am so intensely disappointed in her. There aren't enough words to express what a grave disappointment she was.
Jim: Okay, last one. Solomon e-mailed that he loves Stan's Friday movie posts and he notes that Stan's "Michael Winship and Bill Moyers stumble upon the truth" and Ruth's "UNAMI, Bill Moyers, Janis Ian, Michael Winship" both highlight an essay by Bill Moyers and Michael Winship where they pick the 'best' films of 1933. He's wondering if "the cultural critics would agree with those choices"? And in an e-mail reply -- to me -- he stated that, yes, he meant Ava and C.I. and he was intending "cultural critics" as "a sign of the esteem I hold their opinions in."
Ava: What were the movies Moyers and Winship picked?
Ruth: King Kong, 42nd Street, The Invisible Man and Duck Soup.
Ava: Well, we'd agree on Duck Soup.
C.I.: That really is it. The other three are not the 'best of' period. The most glaring omission -- and telling -- is Mae West. Does Mae West threaten the PBS boys? Is she too much woman for them? Mae West single handledly saved Paramount. 1933 saw two classic films by mae West. First up was She Done Him Wrong, a classic, designated as such by the Libary of Congress. A famous comedy that establishes Mae as a lead actress in film. I'm No Angel was her follow up film. Cary Grant again co-starred. The film was a huge success and variations of her line "It's not the men in your life that counts, it's the life in your men." still exist today. West had already triumphed on Broadway as an actress and playwright and she was one of the few performers -- male or female -- to be the writers on their films. It's not just a curious oversight on Moyers and Winship's part, it's a telling one. Mae West was the biggest thing of 1933 movies, go back through the real-time coverage, and those films are classics. Not just classic Mae West films, they are film classics period.
Ava: C.I. and I have toyed with writing a piece on Mae West films for some time. I believe Kat noted that here back in June. But in addition to Mae West, 1933 is a strong year for Katharine Hepburn. Her Little Women is still considered the filmed version of the book. And that year's Morning Glory teamed her up with Douglas Fairbanks Jr. The film is still considered a classic and its the film that she won the first of four Best Actress Oscars for. C.I.?
C.I.: Bombshell with Jean Harlow is a classic screwball comedy. Harlow had many hits that year but Bombshell and Dinner At Eight are the ones that are acknowledged classics.
Ava: Garbo's Queen Christina.
C.I.: Miriam Hopkins and Gary Cooper in Ernst Lubitsch's Design For Living -- and I wasn't aware that Lubitsch ever fell off the best of lists.
Ava: So Moyers and Winship ignore all those films that women played a role in. They do pick King Kong, famous for Fay Wray's breasts being exposed. Did we really need that? Do we really need the rank racism of King Kong? Today, can anyone avoid calling out the sacrifices of the women or the idea that White Fay was worth six Black women? It's a disgusting and disturbing film and that those quacks would pick it as one of the best says a great deal.
C.I.: Jean Harlow, Mae West, Miriam Hopkins, Greta Garbo, Katharine Hepburn. All making classic films in 1933 that remain classics to this day and it just sails over the boys' heads. Mae's apparently too strong for them and Little Women too 'girly.' So they choose Fay Wray's breasts and a horror film whose special effects have not aged well. They don't choose a single film that a woman is an equal or, heaven forbid, the lead. 42nd Street? Women are objectified. At least they get to keep their breasts covered.
Ava: For all those wondering how 2008 never resulted in Bill Moyers taking a moment to note the historic nature of Hillary, Cynthia or Sarah's runs for office, there's your answer, in his best of film picks. He doesn't give a damn about women unless he can see their legs or their breasts.
C.I.: And to be really clear here, Joan Crawford and Loretta Young and Barbara Stanwyck had hit films in 1933. We're not grabbing hits of the time. We're talking about classic films that have held up. And possibly Stanwyck's Baby Face qualifies as a minor classic. But the ones we went with are the ones established and agreed as classics. It's amazing how they all get ignored in the best of 1933 offered. It's amazing how much objectifying and violence aimed at women you can find in the selections Moyers and Winship made.
Jim: And on that note, we'll end the roundtable. The illustration is by Betty's oldest son. This is a rush transcript.
Sunday, January 04, 2009
This week's Bronze Boobies
The Katrinas are awarded to the extreme idiots. For the foolish we have the Bronze Boobies. This week, two strut forward eager to bag a Bronze Boobie as they 'cover' Iraq.
First up, Scotty Horton. One of the gravest disappointments of 2008. So bad that we truly wish he'd kept his word to STOP BLOGGING. He said he was done. He posted his 'goodbye cruel world' post at Harper's. And there he was, back again. Scott, how can we stop flipping you off if you never park your car?
Scotty showed up Saturday (1:37 p.m., according to the Harper's time stamp) with "Bush a 'Total Failure' Says Former Iraqi PM." Oh, was that news? Noting the same Saturday morning Reuters' report hours earlier, C.I., knowing the entire world hated the Bully Boy and that it took no courage for Allawi to critique the outgoing Bully Boy, reduced that to an aside and zoomed in on the savage critique Allawi had for the SITTING PRIME MINISTER Nouri al-Maliki. But Scotty skipped that part. Apparently Bush Hatred trumps everything.

Grab a Barack Boobie, Scott, and grasp this: If the entire focus of your life is going to remain the outgoing Bully Boy, you're going to have a very limited social circle and even less to talk about. The actual news -- and maybe you'd have to lose the xenophobic idea that only the US matters to realize this was the news -- came when Allawi slammed al-Maliki.
Scotty's attached himself to Barack's right nipple which means the left one's available for Leila Fadel. Fadel is Baghdad bureau chief for McClatchy Newspapers and is damn determined to ruin the chain. Jess exchanged e-mails with a former colleague of Fadel's two weeks ago and even the colleague voiced dismay over the s**t Leila's shoveling these days.
Fadel seems damn determined to white-wash everything going on in Iraq. Friday's "Iraq snapshot" explained, "Leila, thinking 'happy thoughts' might have allowed Peter Pan to fly, but there's no evidence to suggest it will do the same for a news outlet." The point was lost on Leila. Friday saw a bombing that took approximately 30 lives (plus the bomber) and wounded over a hundred. So you just knew Leila and that crack bureau she runs in Baghdad would be all over this story, right? Wrong.
No article. If you were McClatchy and spending all the money on a Baghdad bureau (at a time when broadcast networks are leaving Iraq), we think you'd ask, "Where the hell was the f**king article? How the hell did you miss that?"
The Washington Post had their story on it, The Los Angeles Times had their story, The New York Times had their article. And McClatchy? Off yammering about commercial flights. It's the sort of thing that should lead to a sit-down review of job duties.
Other outlets covering the bombing included CNN, The Times of London, and McClatchy's Kansas City Star. Yes, we're aware of that. We're aware that yet again a story has made it into some McClatchy's paper, by McClatchy staff, but a decision was made to keep it off the McClatchy Iraq page. That's another job duty that should be reviewed in a sit-down.
The bureau has serious problems. McClatchy was hoping to syndicate pieces by Iraqi correspondents but that fell apart the minute the thing finally got going because Iraqi correspondents began posting less and less to the paper's Inside Iraq blog. Right there, you had your first indication that there were problems with the bureau and they were hurting the chain (and its reputation). But that got ignored.
Leila has serious problems and her former colleague shared with Jess a theory Jess has since adopted as well: Leila did a s**t poor job covering the treaty masquerading as a Status Of Forces Agreement. And instead of admitting that, she has backed herself into a corner and can't move forward as a result.
There's also her determination to take part in a wave of Operation Happy Talk and ignore bad news out of Iraq. A real bureau chief, for example, would have long ago noted that McClatchy's daily violence report has suffered for months now, that the roundup that once trumped Reuter's FactBox is now regularly trounced each day by that wire service. That's the sort of thing a competent bureau chief would notice and would move to rectify. Immediately.
The fact that Leila Fadel no longer appears to give a damn about anything other than continuing to misinterpret the treaty means she can grab Barack's left one and Scotty doesn't even have to slide over.
First up, Scotty Horton. One of the gravest disappointments of 2008. So bad that we truly wish he'd kept his word to STOP BLOGGING. He said he was done. He posted his 'goodbye cruel world' post at Harper's. And there he was, back again. Scott, how can we stop flipping you off if you never park your car?
Scotty showed up Saturday (1:37 p.m., according to the Harper's time stamp) with "Bush a 'Total Failure' Says Former Iraqi PM." Oh, was that news? Noting the same Saturday morning Reuters' report hours earlier, C.I., knowing the entire world hated the Bully Boy and that it took no courage for Allawi to critique the outgoing Bully Boy, reduced that to an aside and zoomed in on the savage critique Allawi had for the SITTING PRIME MINISTER Nouri al-Maliki. But Scotty skipped that part. Apparently Bush Hatred trumps everything.

Grab a Barack Boobie, Scott, and grasp this: If the entire focus of your life is going to remain the outgoing Bully Boy, you're going to have a very limited social circle and even less to talk about. The actual news -- and maybe you'd have to lose the xenophobic idea that only the US matters to realize this was the news -- came when Allawi slammed al-Maliki.
Scotty's attached himself to Barack's right nipple which means the left one's available for Leila Fadel. Fadel is Baghdad bureau chief for McClatchy Newspapers and is damn determined to ruin the chain. Jess exchanged e-mails with a former colleague of Fadel's two weeks ago and even the colleague voiced dismay over the s**t Leila's shoveling these days.
Fadel seems damn determined to white-wash everything going on in Iraq. Friday's "Iraq snapshot" explained, "Leila, thinking 'happy thoughts' might have allowed Peter Pan to fly, but there's no evidence to suggest it will do the same for a news outlet." The point was lost on Leila. Friday saw a bombing that took approximately 30 lives (plus the bomber) and wounded over a hundred. So you just knew Leila and that crack bureau she runs in Baghdad would be all over this story, right? Wrong.
No article. If you were McClatchy and spending all the money on a Baghdad bureau (at a time when broadcast networks are leaving Iraq), we think you'd ask, "Where the hell was the f**king article? How the hell did you miss that?"
The Washington Post had their story on it, The Los Angeles Times had their story, The New York Times had their article. And McClatchy? Off yammering about commercial flights. It's the sort of thing that should lead to a sit-down review of job duties.
Other outlets covering the bombing included CNN, The Times of London, and McClatchy's Kansas City Star. Yes, we're aware of that. We're aware that yet again a story has made it into some McClatchy's paper, by McClatchy staff, but a decision was made to keep it off the McClatchy Iraq page. That's another job duty that should be reviewed in a sit-down.
The bureau has serious problems. McClatchy was hoping to syndicate pieces by Iraqi correspondents but that fell apart the minute the thing finally got going because Iraqi correspondents began posting less and less to the paper's Inside Iraq blog. Right there, you had your first indication that there were problems with the bureau and they were hurting the chain (and its reputation). But that got ignored.
Leila has serious problems and her former colleague shared with Jess a theory Jess has since adopted as well: Leila did a s**t poor job covering the treaty masquerading as a Status Of Forces Agreement. And instead of admitting that, she has backed herself into a corner and can't move forward as a result.
There's also her determination to take part in a wave of Operation Happy Talk and ignore bad news out of Iraq. A real bureau chief, for example, would have long ago noted that McClatchy's daily violence report has suffered for months now, that the roundup that once trumped Reuter's FactBox is now regularly trounced each day by that wire service. That's the sort of thing a competent bureau chief would notice and would move to rectify. Immediately.
The fact that Leila Fadel no longer appears to give a damn about anything other than continuing to misinterpret the treaty means she can grab Barack's left one and Scotty doesn't even have to slide over.
Complaint Dept.

This e-mail came in Tuesday from longterm reader Jessie:
I enjoyed the look back features this week (12/28 - 01/04) a lot but ... I like to laugh and it was a really a surprise to me that there was nothing including a good humor book. On film, at least you included House Bunny and that is hysterical.
I come back each week because you keep me focused and because you keep me laughing.
Since you do both, I know you value humor.
I do too and I've found damn little of it in books in 2008.
Matthew Honan's Barack Obama Is Your New Bicycle: 366 Ways He Really Cares seemed like it would be a funny book but it wasn't. It was an embarrassment. "Barack swam across the channel with you." "Barack Obama arranged flowers in a vase and left them on your doorstep." It was a piece of crap and the laugh was on me because I didn't want to spoil the laughter by reading it in the store. So I paid twelve bucks and tax for this thing before I ever opened it up.
Then there were the priss-pots Christopher Cerf and Victor S. Navasky who are about as funny as they are young. Bill Moyers raved over this book, Mission Accomplished! Or How We Won The War In Iraq. It's crap and a clip-job at that.
Even the illustrations by Robert Grossman sucked and I thought the illustration of Jessica Lynch was both unfair to her and sexist.
So I was really hoping for a book recommendation, one that would have me laughing.
Maybe next year,
Jessie [edited out]
It is the next year now, Jessie.
We racked our brains for a book to recommend. 2008 didn't bring a funny one and we'd advise you not to pin your hopes on Tina Fey's offering this year. So we racked our heads for something to recommend. What was funny?
What was funny and something Jessie hadn't seen?
C.I., "Ty, e-mail and ask, 'Do you read cookbooks?'"
Answer came back no.
Recommendation: James Lileks' The Gallery of Regrettable Food. The book was published in 2001 and Lileks has a website for it.
The book jacket describes the contents as "a simple introduction to poorly photographed foodstuffs and horrid recipes from the Golden Age of Salt and Starch." Jessie went to a Half-Priced Books store and found a copy and "can't stop laughing." You won't stop either.
Lileks work is best in book form because it lulls you in. You know it's going to be funny and, sure enough, after the intro, you'll smile at the the wacky things they did (page 18), you'll laugh at "wriggling, erect wieners" joke (especially with photo, page 19) and then you get to, "If your guests are as drunk as you are, just shove stuff in a glass and dump sugar on a plate. They're just going to throw it up anyway."
If you're not laughing non-stop and out loud by page 59, you either don't have a sense of humor or you misplaced it in your rush to leave a New Year's Eve party.
Ty's Corner

A number of e-mails came in during the last three weeks from readers we picked up in 2008 and there seemed to be various questions about the weekly writing editions. So this corner is just going to go over the basics of that.
Third Estate Sunday Review is Jim, Dona, Jess, Ava, C.I. and myself. We are very fortunate to have many people helping out each week but we are the ones responsible for the content. Dallas gets a special thank you each week and is mentioned on the left side of the site because he does so much and has for so long. We have repeatedly offered to include him as part of Third but he is fine with his current status.
Each week, everyone (not just Third people) working on the edition gets together. Generally speaking these days, Third is in California as are Kat and Wally. Others participate by phone. We are pitching ideas. We're tossing out what we have. It may be some elaborate pitch or just a sentence. Sometimes it's less than a sentence. "Roland Barris." I don't know who tossed that out this weekend but we all knew we'd be covering the topic long before the weekend rolled around. So there are things like that which we know we'll cover. (Though sometimes the features turn out badly and we end up shoving that into the print edition that goes out on our campuses.) Then there are the things that are maybes. This is a very in-depth process and time consuming.
B.B. wanted to know if Ava and C.I. truly are in charge of their space? Yes, they are. Jim will make suggestions before they start writing or ask them to work something in but that's their call. They do the weekly TV feature themselves, it's their beat and they can cover what they want. While Jim makes suggestions or requests, Ava and C.I. also generally give us an idea of what they're doing if it's out of the norm. This week, for example, they wanted everyone to know ahead of time that they were focusing on a game show and only a game show. This wasn't going to be a hard hitting piece. They outlined their reasons (which they didn't have to, they don't owe anyone an excuse). First, Saturdays are ignored by the networks and CBS was finally programming a new show on Saturdays, they didn't want any other topics to dilute from that. When we started up, we quickly became aware that our core audience included a lot of young couples who couldn't afford to go out on the weekends. So a Saturday show is a big deal to our longterm readers. Second, due to coming events, things are going to heat up in the real world quickly and Ava and C.I. wanted to do just an entertainment piece before that happened. There are readers who prefer them. There may have been a third reason. If so, I've forgotten.
Highlights? Why is it not written by Third?
When we started doing highlights, what we did was completely repost. The way it works now is you get a link to something and a description in "Highlights." The way it used to work was all of those things in "Highlights" would be reposted in full here. Near the end of that, I remember C.I. and I getting so frustrated by the whole thing and Mike saying he'd take care of it. We gladly slid it over to him. But to repost, you need to watch the spacing and do this and do that and it's time consuming and a pain. When Mike realized that, he started doing a form of the "Highlights" that now goes up each week. So that's their feature and Jim always lists Mike first due to the fact that Mike's the one who came up with how we currently do that feature.
Jim's note to the readers. It's always Jim typing it up unless he's taking time off. Dona used to joke (or not joke) that Jim wanted to play publisher while she got stuck with the grunt work of editor and that's why Jim wanted to do the "A note to our readers" each week. The note offers an overview of the week's edition and, on good weeks, a lot more than just that. Jim's note has fans and the few times we've said, "It's too late, we just want to go to bed" and convinced Jim to forget doing a note, the e-mails have come in complaining.
Kyleen e-mailed on the editorials and wanted to know "is it normal to feel outraged after reading one?" Normal or not, that's the reaction Jim wants. The editorials. Ay-yi-yi, as Ava would say. That's generally the last thing written. By that time, it's often Jim, C.I., Mike and Rebecca who are still functioning. And it's generally Jim and C.I. doing this back and forth with Jim really pressing buttons trying to get anger or sadness out of C.I. From that, we write up the editorial. Last week's editorial was just not working. Everyone was tired. Jim was off. Rebecca came up with an idea to save it and it worked. It gave it a different flavor, which Jim's not used to, and in his note you can't tell he's unsure of what to make of that editorial. This week's editorial will call Barack Obama a "bastard." As in "Make the bastard work for you." It's eye catching. It's supposed to make an impression. And we've discussed that editorial more than many we do -- discussed in advance. There is a lethargy with regards to political action and we went over a list of terms and a list of issues we especially wanted to raise. This will be an editorial that hopes to snap you to attention. Or that's the plan. It's not written yet, so who knows how it will end up? But Jim does want a reaction. In the original notes back in the day, he'd always write that he didn't care if you laughed, screamed, cursed us or the topic we were covering as long as something here grabbed you. And back when we had time to reply to e-mails, Jim would only reply to the ones disagreeing. He really enjoys those who disagree. His goal with this editorial (provided we're not all sleepy when it gets written) is to splash cold water on people's faces. It's okay to read it and say, "I hate Third Estate!" That's not the issue. But even if that's your initial take-away -- or especially if that's your initial take-away -- you're going to find yourself thinking about the topic. We throw St. JFK on the fire in it too, or that's the plan.
"Truests," was Olivia's issue. She wanted to know why it took so long because we'd mentioned that it can take forever. When you add six or more people and everyone's got a suggestion of what they believe was the truest thing said last week, there's going to be discussion, there's going to be debate and it can take forever. FOREVER. This week, I know C.I.'s pushing for Betty, Ruth and Martha & Shirley. I am going to be pushing for them as well as is Kat. I don't anticipate it will be a problem. The only problem is that I know Mike and Stan have several things they want for truest that come from C.I.'s "2008: The Year of Living Hormonally (Year in Review)." C.I. won't go for it and the sooner Mike and Stan drop it, the better. Three is pushing it for Truest and Kat, C.I. and I think the three pieces mentioned did something amazing and really deserve an extra bit of recognition. (That's not me saying I don't think that C.I.'s deserves extra recognition. I think it does but I know C.I. will nix the suggestions.)
Seven of you wanted more book features. Book roundtables are out. They are just too time consuming. Between now and April, we'll probably do one and no more. But we are trying to find ways to do more on books and we have a short piece this week that is on a book.
Larken feels that "sometimes the mix works better and sometimes it doesn't." No one working on these editions would ever disagree with you. We try to get a variety as much as possible. Some weeks it works, some weeks it doesn't. We're under no mistaken belief that each weekend is a home run. When we started, the first three months it killed us if everything wasn't perfect and it was never perfect. We have enough of a body of work behind us now that we're used to it. Also true is that stuff we all hated has gone up because it had to. If it didn't, we'd have only half an edition. So it's gone up with us hating it and some of that stuff has resulted in e-mails from people happy with it. Which just underscores how everyone's personal taste isn't the same.
Cliff was among those e-mailing to express how much he enjoyed last week's short story, "The New York State Annie Riots." He wishes we could do more of that. Each summer, we do our Summer Beach Read edition. That includes Ava and C.I.'s TV commentary plus fiction. It might be poetry, it might be parody, it might be anything. But we do that each summer. I would love to do it more often. Not a full edition but just tossing in a short story every now and then. Why don't we? Jim. If I pitched a short story idea this weekend and Jim loved it, he would tell me it was perfect and he would write down a note for us to work on it in June or July for that fiction edition. Jim hordes that stuff, afraid we'll do it and nothing will come up to replace it so we need to hold onto it. The reality is Jim's little note, read this summer will not jog my memory much and, if it does, I won't have the same enthusiasm. So I disagree on the waiting. Last week's short story made it to the writing process because Dona and C.I.'s friend (the Broadway composer) were both telling Jim it was too good to hold on. Cliff, I will convey your wishes to Jim again (I've already done so once) the next time any of us have a short story idea and he asks us to table it until this summer. Can't promise it will do much good, but we'll see.
Les wants to know how he can get his blog linked in an article here? E-mail. If you'd mentioned the blog's name (or provided a link), I'd be saying right now, "Check out Les at ___." Like Sol Bellel who e-mailed and he's following Caroline Kennedy's attempt to buy a Senate seat:
http://dbellel.blogspot.com/2008/12/sweet-caroline-for-senator-1.html
http://dbellel.blogspot.com/2008/12/sweet-caroline-for-senator-2.html
http://dbellel.blogspot.com/2008/12/sweet-caroline-for-senator-3.html
http://dbellel.blogspot.com/2008/12/sweet-caroline-for-senator-4.html
http://dbellel.blogspot.com/2008/12/sweet-caroline-for-senator-5.html
http://dbellel.blogspot.com/2008/12/sweet-caroline-for-senator-6.html
http://dbellel.blogspot.com/2008/12/sweet-caroline-for-senator-7.html
http://dbellel.blogspot.com/2008/12/sweet-caroline-for-senator-8.html
http://dbellel.blogspot.com/2008/12/sweet-caroline-for-senator-9.html
http://dbellel.blogspot.com/2008/12/sweet-caroline-for-senator-10.html
http://dbellel.blogspot.com/2008/12/sweet-caroline-for-senator-11.html
http://dbellel.blogspot.com/2008/12/sweet-caroline-for-senator-12.html
http://dbellel.blogspot.com/2008/12/sweet-ring-ding-ding-caroline.html
http://dbellel.blogspot.com/2008/12/sweet-caroline.html
http://dbellel.blogspot.com/2008/12/nyc-royal-family.html
See, just like that. (We don't link to pornography. We're a site for the left so keep that in mind as well.) Sol actually linked to us and e-mailed to let us know (I believe he reposted one of Isaiah's comics). And he linked to Elaine. Who didn't see the e-mail he sent her. (Sunny, Elaine's assistant who runs her office, reads Elaine's e-mails. Sunny was on vacation last week. Elaine didn't see the e-mail until Sunday morning when I mentioned she might want to check. She plans to note Sol on Monday at her site.)
Andy e-mails asking not to "ever change" but he worries about our future journalism careers. I guess our sidebar sketch still isn't good enough. Here's what's what. C.I. was never a journalism major. C.I. was not in college with us. C.I. holds multiple degrees, none are in journalism. I have a bachelor's in journalism. I am not using it. I work in the film industry. Dona and Jim have their bachelors and are currently in grad school. Jess has his and is currently in law school. Ava has her degree (journalism) but she's on the road with C.I., Kat and Wally each week speaking out against the illegal war. She's put work, college, on hold to do that. Like C.I., Ava has money. That doesn't mean everything's easy because of it. (But, they'd both tell you, it does mean you don't have a panic attack when something breaks down or an unexpected bill or crisis emerges.)
Andy's fear is that we'll never be able to work in the MSM. We're not really trying to except maybe Dona and Jim and I'm not really sure what they're planning to do. They're engaged so they're planning to marry but, beyond that, I don't know. Andy notes that we don't play favorites and we don't. And that's fine. We're not trying to kiss ass. And especially these days, we have to hit hard. We are frequently the hardest and harshest critics. Let me offer a comparison. Paul Street is systematic in his criticism. And he will hold Barack accountable. He deserves much praise for that. But -- outside of his comments at ZNet -- he could be considered 'reasoned' or whatever. We're not trying for that. We're making the strongest case in our editorials, for example, and we hopefully make those few brave voices like Street seem less extreme as a result. We move the playing field to the left. The real left, where the actual people are. Which has me thinking of a feature so I'll stop there.
We really do not have time for personal replies. I'm sorry about that. But e-mails are read and we are trying to find ways to work them in each week (thirdestatesundayreview@yahoo.com). And Elaine has noted a feature C.I. should do, a short one, and Jim noted it here recently. The film's a bomb. It's an obvious bomb. I can't believe papers are insisting otherwise. Your first day isn't all that and it drops each day after? You're a bomb. But C.I. can't say that. Couldn't before the film opened. Couldn't after it opened. Was hoping to do so this week but the Water Cooler Set is still claiming it's going to be a hit. It's not as this weekend's box office will demonstrate. We hope to get C.I. to do that feature next week. But if you're e-mailing on that, it wouldn't hurt to e-mail a reminder closer to the end of the week. In a busy news week, things can get forgotten very quickly.
Idiot of the week
"These are Americas problems, and we must come together as Americans to meet them with the urgency this moment demands," babbled Barack Obama, president-elect and Princess Tiny Meat always, in yesterday's Democratic Party address thereby winning this week's Katrina for Idiot of the Week.

"These are Americas problems, and we must come together as Americans" -- as opposed to coming together as British? As Russians? As the French? As Mexicans? As Australians?
Every time he opens his mouth, Princess Tiny Meat sounds like the just crowned Miss America.
The Katrinas are an honored tradition and a copyrighted one. Named after the fabulously foolish reality-TV expert Katrina vanden Heuvel who shows extreme bravery, if not intelligence, each time she attempts to grapple any issue far beyond her reach (e.g. anything that not airing on broadcast TV during prime time hours).

"These are Americas problems, and we must come together as Americans" -- as opposed to coming together as British? As Russians? As the French? As Mexicans? As Australians?
Every time he opens his mouth, Princess Tiny Meat sounds like the just crowned Miss America.
The Katrinas are an honored tradition and a copyrighted one. Named after the fabulously foolish reality-TV expert Katrina vanden Heuvel who shows extreme bravery, if not intelligence, each time she attempts to grapple any issue far beyond her reach (e.g. anything that not airing on broadcast TV during prime time hours).
Highlights
This piece is written by Rebecca of Sex and Politics and Screeds and Attitude, Cedric of Cedric's Big Mix, Kat of Kat's Korner, Betty of Thomas Friedman is a Great Man, Mike of Mikey Likes It!, Elaine of Like Maria Said Paz, Ruth of Ruth's Report, Marcia of SICKOFITRADLZ, Stan of Oh Boy It Never Ends and Wally of The Daily Jot. Unless otherwise noted, we picked all highlights.
"Thinning out the herd (2008)," "2008 in music," "2008: The Year of Living Hormonally (Year in Review)," "2008 in books (Martha & Shirley)," "Ruth's 2008 Public Radio Report" "Editorial: Democracy or fan club?," "TV: 2008, the lows and really lows," "The 2008 Bronze Boobies," "Best and worst in hardcover music journalism," "Music 2009" and "2009 in DVDs" -- Year in reviews. That's Betty, Kat, C.I., Martha & Shirley, Ruth and Third. And "Year-end thoughts" by Ruth again and we're setting it by itself so that it gets noticed.
Most requested highlight by readers of this site was C.I.'s year-in-review. Second most requested? The Friday "Iraq snapshot" which Ty says Yazz dubbed "wickedly funny."
"Green Beans and Tomatoes Casserole in the Kitchen" -- Trina offers an economical recipe and addresses the year and the slaughter.
"additional thoughts" & "the truth versus the whoring liar" -- Rebecca's bookends. And for those not around in 2006, she takes this issue very personally. It's is probably her key non-domestic issue.
"Michael Winship and Bill Moyers stumble upon the truth" -- Stan's Friday night movie post but you get a lot more with this one.
"Gaza, Janis Ian, more" -- Kat advocated for this post by Mike because she loves his description of Janis Ian's song.
"THIS JUST IN! THE UNITY TRAIN KEEPS ROLLING" & "Unity train keeps on rolling . . ." -- Wally & Cedric's joint-post and this one surprised us when we read it. We generally now have enough of handle on them that we know where they're headed but this one shocked us. By the way, in case it's not noted anywhere else, Wally is off crutches after his skiing accident. And he's back in California at C.I.'s and swearing never, ever to go skiing again unless it is on water.
Isaiah's The World Today Just Nuts "Princess Brat Speaks" -- Isaiah's latest on Caroline Kennedy, the princess. And, no, it's not sexist, f**king idiots. Here's Caroline BFF speaking to The New York Times about her last week, "That comes from her lineage." Get it, Dumb Asses? She's American 'royalty' and has always been billed that way. She's also the whoring funeral crasher who invaded Lisa Marie Presley's space at her father's funeral and then took her trashy article about Elvis' funeral all over New York until her then steady boyfriend Jann (married, but gay) agreed to publish it in Rolling Stone, requiring Harriet to do an intensive line-by-line edit to make it readable. She's a Princess according to the media. She's a whore for wanting her own privacy but invading Lisa Marie's privacy (with the lie that she was there on behalf of her family to pay respects).
"Congratulations, Senator Burris." "Don't disrespect Roland Burris," "Don't start nothing, there won't be nothing," "Back off Barack," "Roland Burris is the Senator," "C Kennedy, Roland Burris, pardons" and "Crying Junior" & "THIS JUST IN! JUNIOR'S TURN TO CRY!" -- some of the Roland Burris coverage in the community and we tossed in Wally and Cedric on the whiner who didn't get the appointment (JJ Jnr.).
"Winter, ugh" -- Everyone's trying to figure out if Betty's taking the promotion. Says Betty, "I've had more e-mails on that than on what was going to happen to Betinna. Suddenly, everyone's my dad." (Her father wants her to take it, her mother says it's Betty's decision.)
"Caroline, Ted, etc" -- Trina explains how Caroline could slide in to the US Senate.
"Matthew Rothschild is really, really sick" -- Ruth's Monday post was so popular it was recylced Saturday at the site that wrote her bragging how much they loved her and asking her to write them back. The one that when she did, blew her off. The one that was on a fishing expedition. Yeah, you know who we mean. Big Penny.
"NYT finds out that smutty may come witha price" -- Kat on the latest bad news for The New York Times.
"Isaiah, Michelle Shocked and more" -- Stan covers music in this post.
"Caroline and Melissa" -- Elaine covers the two fools.
"Thinning out the herd (2008)," "2008 in music," "2008: The Year of Living Hormonally (Year in Review)," "2008 in books (Martha & Shirley)," "Ruth's 2008 Public Radio Report" "Editorial: Democracy or fan club?," "TV: 2008, the lows and really lows," "The 2008 Bronze Boobies," "Best and worst in hardcover music journalism," "Music 2009" and "2009 in DVDs" -- Year in reviews. That's Betty, Kat, C.I., Martha & Shirley, Ruth and Third. And "Year-end thoughts" by Ruth again and we're setting it by itself so that it gets noticed.
Most requested highlight by readers of this site was C.I.'s year-in-review. Second most requested? The Friday "Iraq snapshot" which Ty says Yazz dubbed "wickedly funny."
"Green Beans and Tomatoes Casserole in the Kitchen" -- Trina offers an economical recipe and addresses the year and the slaughter.
"additional thoughts" & "the truth versus the whoring liar" -- Rebecca's bookends. And for those not around in 2006, she takes this issue very personally. It's is probably her key non-domestic issue.
"Michael Winship and Bill Moyers stumble upon the truth" -- Stan's Friday night movie post but you get a lot more with this one.
"Gaza, Janis Ian, more" -- Kat advocated for this post by Mike because she loves his description of Janis Ian's song.
"THIS JUST IN! THE UNITY TRAIN KEEPS ROLLING" & "Unity train keeps on rolling . . ." -- Wally & Cedric's joint-post and this one surprised us when we read it. We generally now have enough of handle on them that we know where they're headed but this one shocked us. By the way, in case it's not noted anywhere else, Wally is off crutches after his skiing accident. And he's back in California at C.I.'s and swearing never, ever to go skiing again unless it is on water.
Isaiah's The World Today Just Nuts "Princess Brat Speaks" -- Isaiah's latest on Caroline Kennedy, the princess. And, no, it's not sexist, f**king idiots. Here's Caroline BFF speaking to The New York Times about her last week, "That comes from her lineage." Get it, Dumb Asses? She's American 'royalty' and has always been billed that way. She's also the whoring funeral crasher who invaded Lisa Marie Presley's space at her father's funeral and then took her trashy article about Elvis' funeral all over New York until her then steady boyfriend Jann (married, but gay) agreed to publish it in Rolling Stone, requiring Harriet to do an intensive line-by-line edit to make it readable. She's a Princess according to the media. She's a whore for wanting her own privacy but invading Lisa Marie's privacy (with the lie that she was there on behalf of her family to pay respects).
"Congratulations, Senator Burris." "Don't disrespect Roland Burris," "Don't start nothing, there won't be nothing," "Back off Barack," "Roland Burris is the Senator," "C Kennedy, Roland Burris, pardons" and "Crying Junior" & "THIS JUST IN! JUNIOR'S TURN TO CRY!" -- some of the Roland Burris coverage in the community and we tossed in Wally and Cedric on the whiner who didn't get the appointment (JJ Jnr.).
"Winter, ugh" -- Everyone's trying to figure out if Betty's taking the promotion. Says Betty, "I've had more e-mails on that than on what was going to happen to Betinna. Suddenly, everyone's my dad." (Her father wants her to take it, her mother says it's Betty's decision.)
"Caroline, Ted, etc" -- Trina explains how Caroline could slide in to the US Senate.
"Matthew Rothschild is really, really sick" -- Ruth's Monday post was so popular it was recylced Saturday at the site that wrote her bragging how much they loved her and asking her to write them back. The one that when she did, blew her off. The one that was on a fishing expedition. Yeah, you know who we mean. Big Penny.
"NYT finds out that smutty may come witha price" -- Kat on the latest bad news for The New York Times.
"Isaiah, Michelle Shocked and more" -- Stan covers music in this post.
"Caroline and Melissa" -- Elaine covers the two fools.
Third Estate 2008 archives by week
So here's the deal on this feature. In 2007, Dona, Jim and Ty decided to flip our template. They grabbed a new one. They thought it was groovy and delovely and life altering.
All it really did was destroy our archives. They are a huge mess. What we were able to do is, as 2007 ended, grab the weeks before they disappeared and paste them into " 2007 Archives." And that's what we're doing for 2008.
We know, we know. 2005 and 2006 are a pain in the ass. If you use the links to the left [► 2006 (957) and ► 2005 (448)], you have to go through pages and pages and it's just not worth it. Two things, you can search by date in Google. Search us for "A note to our readers" for any week and it should provide you with an index of that week's articles. Not every week had a note. It should have and many readers were asking for one and got blown off back then.
Our apologies.
But we said "two things." The other thing. C.I. figured out how to get 2006 and 2005 to display for weekly archives in a post. (Don't ask us how, we don't know and C.I.'s been playing with it for about a half-hour before getting it to work.) So we now have the 2005 and 2006 archives scrollable by week once again. And Dona, Jim and Ty swear they won't do anything to f**k it up this time. Honest.
▼ 12/28 - 01/04 (15)
Truest statement of the week
Truest statement of the week II
Truest statement of the week III
A note to our readers
Editorial: Democracy or fan club?
TV: 2008, the lows and really lows
The 2008 Bronze Boobies
The New York State Annie Riots
The Princess Brat Chronicles
Best and worst in hardcover music journalism
Music 2009
2008 in DVDs
Highlights
'Iraq now, Vietnam then' (Workers World)
US anthem "When The Money's Gone"
► 12/21 - 12/28 (13)
Truest statement of the week
A note to our readers
Editorial: The Pathetic and Shameful UPFJ
TV: Twins Anne Slowey and Gwen Ifill
Roundtable
The Ultimate Tina Turner Collection
An indictment of the 'New' Iraq goes unnoticed
DVD release of The Women (Ava and C.I.)
Hmmm . . .
The Princess Brat Chronicles
Carolyn Maloney works her ass off for New Yorkers
Andrew Cuomo works his ass off for New Yorkers
Highlights
► 12/14 - 12/21 (14)
Truest statement of the week
Truest statement of the week II
A note to our readers
Editorial: The treaty's not that confusing
TV: Left In The Dust
Best digital download buys
The remake of Strangers On a Train
A gold watch for Robert Byrd?
The Princess Brat Diaries
Hmm . . .
Amy Poehler leaves SNL (Ava and C.I.)
Corrente's Sarah Did Not Vote
ETAN Says NO to Dennis Blair
Highlights
► 12/07 - 12/14 (14)
Truest statement of the week
Truest statement of the week II
A note to our readers
Editorial: A step is not marathon
TV: The Fairy Tale
Must grab download: DeShannon's Laurel Canyon
Shame 20 years on down the line
Dowd to Fey: And when they met, it was murder (Ava...
► 11/30 - 12/07 (12)
► 11/23 - 11/30 (13)
► 11/16 - 11/23 (11)
► 11/09 - 11/16 (13)
► 11/02 - 11/09 (13)
► 10/26 - 11/02 (13)
► 10/19 - 10/26 (12)
► 10/12 - 10/19 (11)
► 10/05 - 10/12 (14)
► 09/28 - 10/05 (13)
► 09/21 - 09/28 (13)
► 09/14 - 09/21 (11)
► 09/07 - 09/14 (13)
► 08/31 - 09/07 (12)
► 08/24 - 08/31 (11)
► 08/17 - 08/24 (13)
► 08/10 - 08/17 (11)
► 08/03 - 08/10 (11)
► 07/27 - 08/03 (13)
► 07/20 - 07/27 (12)
► 07/13 - 07/20 (13)
► 07/06 - 07/13 (11)
► 06/29 - 07/06 (14)
► 06/22 - 06/29 (11)
► 06/15 - 06/22 (10)
► 06/08 - 06/15 (14)
► 06/01 - 06/08 (12)
► 05/25 - 06/01 (9)
► 05/18 - 05/25 (12)
► 05/11 - 05/18 (11)
► 05/04 - 05/11 (12)
► 04/27 - 05/04 (10)
► 04/20 - 04/27 (14)
► 04/13 - 04/20 (11)
► 04/06 - 04/13 (13)
► 03/30 - 04/06 (10)
► 03/23 - 03/30 (12)
► 03/16 - 03/23 (13)
► 03/09 - 03/16 (9)
► 03/02 - 03/09 (12)
► 02/24 - 03/02 (14)
► 02/17 - 02/24 (11)
► 02/10 - 02/17 (13)
► 02/03 - 02/10 (12)
► 01/27 - 02/03 (14)
► 01/20 - 01/27 (10)
► 01/13 - 01/20 (10)
► 01/06 - 01/13 (12)
All it really did was destroy our archives. They are a huge mess. What we were able to do is, as 2007 ended, grab the weeks before they disappeared and paste them into " 2007 Archives." And that's what we're doing for 2008.
We know, we know. 2005 and 2006 are a pain in the ass. If you use the links to the left [► 2006 (957) and ► 2005 (448)], you have to go through pages and pages and it's just not worth it. Two things, you can search by date in Google. Search us for "A note to our readers" for any week and it should provide you with an index of that week's articles. Not every week had a note. It should have and many readers were asking for one and got blown off back then.
Our apologies.
But we said "two things." The other thing. C.I. figured out how to get 2006 and 2005 to display for weekly archives in a post. (Don't ask us how, we don't know and C.I.'s been playing with it for about a half-hour before getting it to work.) So we now have the 2005 and 2006 archives scrollable by week once again. And Dona, Jim and Ty swear they won't do anything to f**k it up this time. Honest.
▼ 12/28 - 01/04 (15)
Truest statement of the week
Truest statement of the week II
Truest statement of the week III
A note to our readers
Editorial: Democracy or fan club?
TV: 2008, the lows and really lows
The 2008 Bronze Boobies
The New York State Annie Riots
The Princess Brat Chronicles
Best and worst in hardcover music journalism
Music 2009
2008 in DVDs
Highlights
'Iraq now, Vietnam then' (Workers World)
US anthem "When The Money's Gone"
► 12/21 - 12/28 (13)
Truest statement of the week
A note to our readers
Editorial: The Pathetic and Shameful UPFJ
TV: Twins Anne Slowey and Gwen Ifill
Roundtable
The Ultimate Tina Turner Collection
An indictment of the 'New' Iraq goes unnoticed
DVD release of The Women (Ava and C.I.)
Hmmm . . .
The Princess Brat Chronicles
Carolyn Maloney works her ass off for New Yorkers
Andrew Cuomo works his ass off for New Yorkers
Highlights
► 12/14 - 12/21 (14)
Truest statement of the week
Truest statement of the week II
A note to our readers
Editorial: The treaty's not that confusing
TV: Left In The Dust
Best digital download buys
The remake of Strangers On a Train
A gold watch for Robert Byrd?
The Princess Brat Diaries
Hmm . . .
Amy Poehler leaves SNL (Ava and C.I.)
Corrente's Sarah Did Not Vote
ETAN Says NO to Dennis Blair
Highlights
► 12/07 - 12/14 (14)
Truest statement of the week
Truest statement of the week II
A note to our readers
Editorial: A step is not marathon
TV: The Fairy Tale
Must grab download: DeShannon's Laurel Canyon
Shame 20 years on down the line
Dowd to Fey: And when they met, it was murder (Ava...
► 11/30 - 12/07 (12)
► 11/23 - 11/30 (13)
► 11/16 - 11/23 (11)
► 11/09 - 11/16 (13)
► 11/02 - 11/09 (13)
► 10/26 - 11/02 (13)
► 10/19 - 10/26 (12)
► 10/12 - 10/19 (11)
► 10/05 - 10/12 (14)
► 09/28 - 10/05 (13)
► 09/21 - 09/28 (13)
► 09/14 - 09/21 (11)
► 09/07 - 09/14 (13)
► 08/31 - 09/07 (12)
► 08/24 - 08/31 (11)
► 08/17 - 08/24 (13)
► 08/10 - 08/17 (11)
► 08/03 - 08/10 (11)
► 07/27 - 08/03 (13)
► 07/20 - 07/27 (12)
► 07/13 - 07/20 (13)
► 07/06 - 07/13 (11)
► 06/29 - 07/06 (14)
► 06/22 - 06/29 (11)
► 06/15 - 06/22 (10)
► 06/08 - 06/15 (14)
► 06/01 - 06/08 (12)
► 05/25 - 06/01 (9)
► 05/18 - 05/25 (12)
► 05/11 - 05/18 (11)
► 05/04 - 05/11 (12)
► 04/27 - 05/04 (10)
► 04/20 - 04/27 (14)
► 04/13 - 04/20 (11)
► 04/06 - 04/13 (13)
► 03/30 - 04/06 (10)
► 03/23 - 03/30 (12)
► 03/16 - 03/23 (13)
► 03/09 - 03/16 (9)
► 03/02 - 03/09 (12)
► 02/24 - 03/02 (14)
► 02/17 - 02/24 (11)
► 02/10 - 02/17 (13)
► 02/03 - 02/10 (12)
► 01/27 - 02/03 (14)
► 01/20 - 01/27 (10)
► 01/13 - 01/20 (10)
► 01/06 - 01/13 (12)
Third Estate 2006 archives by week
Yes, we have the 2006 archives by week!!!! Thanks to C.I. Stop the e-mails attacking three of us (Jim, Dona and Ty) for flipping the template and thereby losing forever the archives. We have this and we have 2005. You can now, once again, select a week and see that week's content.
Thank you, Spaceballs. Bless you, High Anxiety. Watch over us, Blazing Saddles. Isn't that what Alanis sings?
► 2006 (957)
► 12/31 - 01/07 (13)
► 12/24 - 12/31 (13)
► 12/17 - 12/24 (13)
► 12/10 - 12/17 (11)
► 12/03 - 12/10 (10)
► 11/26 - 12/03 (10)
► 11/19 - 11/26 (11)
► 11/12 - 11/19 (13)
► 11/05 - 11/12 (20)
► 10/29 - 11/05 (22)
► 10/22 - 10/29 (19)
► 10/15 - 10/22 (19)
► 10/08 - 10/15 (21)
► 10/01 - 10/08 (18)
► 09/24 - 10/01 (22)
► 09/17 - 09/24 (12)
► 09/10 - 09/17 (25)
► 09/03 - 09/10 (12)
► 08/27 - 09/03 (23)
► 08/20 - 08/27 (23)
► 08/13 - 08/20 (24)
► 08/06 - 08/13 (23)
► 07/30 - 08/06 (14)
► 07/23 - 07/30 (18)
► 07/16 - 07/23 (19)
► 07/09 - 07/16 (21)
► 07/02 - 07/09 (10)
► 06/25 - 07/02 (22)
► 06/18 - 06/25 (18)
► 06/11 - 06/18 (22)
► 06/04 - 06/11 (17)
► 05/28 - 06/04 (23)
► 05/21 - 05/28 (20)
► 05/14 - 05/21 (23)
► 05/07 - 05/14 (23)
► 04/30 - 05/07 (21)
► 04/23 - 04/30 (22)
► 04/16 - 04/23 (19)
► 04/09 - 04/16 (24)
► 04/02 - 04/09 (22)
► 03/26 - 04/02 (20)
► 03/19 - 03/26 (23)
► 03/12 - 03/19 (19)
► 03/05 - 03/12 (20)
► 02/26 - 03/05 (15)
► 02/19 - 02/26 (17)
► 02/12 - 02/19 (17)
► 02/05 - 02/12 (10)
► 01/29 - 02/05 (12)
► 01/22 - 01/29 (17)
► 01/15 - 01/22 (16)
► 01/08 - 01/15 (18)
► 01/01 - 01/08 (18)
► 2005 (448)
Thank you, Spaceballs. Bless you, High Anxiety. Watch over us, Blazing Saddles. Isn't that what Alanis sings?
► 2006 (957)
► 12/31 - 01/07 (13)
► 12/24 - 12/31 (13)
► 12/17 - 12/24 (13)
► 12/10 - 12/17 (11)
► 12/03 - 12/10 (10)
► 11/26 - 12/03 (10)
► 11/19 - 11/26 (11)
► 11/12 - 11/19 (13)
► 11/05 - 11/12 (20)
► 10/29 - 11/05 (22)
► 10/22 - 10/29 (19)
► 10/15 - 10/22 (19)
► 10/08 - 10/15 (21)
► 10/01 - 10/08 (18)
► 09/24 - 10/01 (22)
► 09/17 - 09/24 (12)
► 09/10 - 09/17 (25)
► 09/03 - 09/10 (12)
► 08/27 - 09/03 (23)
► 08/20 - 08/27 (23)
► 08/13 - 08/20 (24)
► 08/06 - 08/13 (23)
► 07/30 - 08/06 (14)
► 07/23 - 07/30 (18)
► 07/16 - 07/23 (19)
► 07/09 - 07/16 (21)
► 07/02 - 07/09 (10)
► 06/25 - 07/02 (22)
► 06/18 - 06/25 (18)
► 06/11 - 06/18 (22)
► 06/04 - 06/11 (17)
► 05/28 - 06/04 (23)
► 05/21 - 05/28 (20)
► 05/14 - 05/21 (23)
► 05/07 - 05/14 (23)
► 04/30 - 05/07 (21)
► 04/23 - 04/30 (22)
► 04/16 - 04/23 (19)
► 04/09 - 04/16 (24)
► 04/02 - 04/09 (22)
► 03/26 - 04/02 (20)
► 03/19 - 03/26 (23)
► 03/12 - 03/19 (19)
► 03/05 - 03/12 (20)
► 02/26 - 03/05 (15)
► 02/19 - 02/26 (17)
► 02/12 - 02/19 (17)
► 02/05 - 02/12 (10)
► 01/29 - 02/05 (12)
► 01/22 - 01/29 (17)
► 01/15 - 01/22 (16)
► 01/08 - 01/15 (18)
► 01/01 - 01/08 (18)
► 2005 (448)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

