Sunday, March 08, 2009

Friday roundtable on Iraq

[Jim note: Rebecca moderated this roundtable on Iraq Friday night. Ava and C.I. participated so we are reposting it here.]





Rebecca: We're doing an Iraq roundtable tonight and we'll do one next Friday as well as part of the lead up to the March 19th actions. We've done two roundtables already in recent weeks and participating tonight are The Third Estate Sunday Review's Ava, me, Rebecca of Sex and Politics and Screeds and Attitude, Betty of Thomas Friedman Is a Great Man, C.I. of The Common Ills and The Third Estate Sunday Review, Kat of Kat's Korner (of The Common Ills), Cedric of Cedric's Big Mix, Mike of Mikey Likes It!, Trina of Trina's Kitchen, Wally of The Daily Jot, Stan of Oh Boy It Never Ends, Marcia of SICKOFITRADLZ and Ruth of Ruth's Report. Betty and Cedric participate by phone. In the last Iraq roundtable, Jim of Third Estate sat in with us to figure out a way to see if there was a way to make it more manageable at Third to do a roundtable. What's been decided is that the core six of Third -- Jim, Dona, Ty, Jess, Ava and C.I. -- along with Kat who lives in the same area and Betty and Wally who live at C.I.'s home will do an Iraq roundtable at Third. Others can participate if they want but most will be taking the chance to bail and be done at an earlier time than usual. Except for Cedric and Betty, we are all at Trina's for this roundtable. I'm going to toss to Mike to start with because, twice this week, the Associated Press tried to spin on Iraq and he blogged about both times. Mike?

Mike: Okay, First up, February ended and March began so it was time for 'monthly stats.' As C.I. had pointed out, February violence -- by Iraqi government figures -- was up 35% but the AP wanted you to believe, via their headline and spin, 'second lowest month ever!' Then yesterday it was "sharply reduced budget" which was only a 7% reduction. It's amazing when you think of how little coverage Iraq gets currently that they still have time to spin.

Cedric: And, as is noted in today's snapshot, James Rainey (Los Angeles Times) reports broadcast networks ABC, CBS and NBC offered 1/10 less coverge of Iraq in 2008 compared to 2007 and they haven't even filed 12 stories so far this year. So it really is something, as Mike said, with so little coverage of Iraq that AP still finds the need to spin. How many articles did the New York Times offer this week?

C.I.: In print? I believe Alissa J. Rubin's made it into print today but I couldn't read those pages of the paper since they were printed with mystery ink --

Rebecca: The pages were blank. No quality control at the New York Times.

C.I.: Right. There was Rubin's article we covered today that hopefully was in the paper -- but a pretty important John F. Burns article last week never made the paper though it was online -- and, earlier in the week, Tuesday, one of those 'justice' in Iraq pieces, by Steven Lee Myers. That's it in the paper.

Elaine: And yet the company spends millions staffing Iraq and never gets called on it by Wall Street. If you're going to spend the money, you should have something to show for it. I'm sure that will be seen as, "Pull the Iraq coverage!" That's not what I'm saying and pulling it will not suddenly make the coverage cost effective. If they pulled it tomorrow, they would still not be able to justify the costs of the coverage.

Ava: Whereas if anyone at the paper did more than sit on their ass, they would run an Iraq article in the paper every day and they would advertise their coverage. "Why we read the New York Times? We're in the United States. We're in Iraq, We're in Afghanistan. We're everywhere you need." That's what you do when you are discredited, when your entire industry is discredited -- and it is, it's seen as antiquated -- you make a point to show what you have. You make a point to advertise.

Rebecca: I'm going to jump in because that's true. P.R. is what I did and I was very good at it. You want people to buy you, you need to tell them why. Were the paper not the New York Times, it would be having even more problems. But they need to make it clear to people who don't know the brand or don't care why they should pick up the paper. And you can't just say it. You have to show it. If they used a slogan like Ava's and someone sees it and picks up the paper, Iraq better be in there and not by AP. The paper's only calling card is what they can offer that no one else can. That means filing, filing, filing. Always filing. One of the things they skipped, that everyoe skipped is in C.I.'s snapshot today, a February 23rd press conference in Baghdad on prisons. Let's talk about that just to emphasize it. Ruth?

Ruth: At one point, according to US Brig Gen David Quantock, and I find this shoking, the US military was holding 900 Iraqi juveniles. That is the highest number, according to the general, the US ever held in Iraq at one time. That is appalling and so is the idea that the US military is currently holding 38 Iraqi juveniles.

Kat: That is disgusting, I'm with Ruth. And it's disgusting that at one point we had nearly 1,000 children imprisoned. What's an average? Do we know? Average number of Iraqi prisoners.

C.I.: I'm tired but we can go with 18,000 because I can get a link for that in April 2007 -- a Washington Post article if I'm remembering correctly.

Kat: So nearly 1,000 children and in 2007, the total prison population, run by the US that the US will admit to, was 18,000? That is disgusting. And why is the US military holding children to begin with?

Ruth: And, really, what is the waves in America. There was a tiny wave of repulsion when it was revealed that the prison at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba had children and then we apparently all decided we could live with it or had expressed ourselves as a country. And I see this momentary pang really benefits the US government and allows them to avoid being accountable or facing pressure to stop their disgraceful actions.

Rebecca: I believe "pang" is the correct word for it, as Ruth used it, because it illustrates exactly how momentary outrage has become. It's disgusting. Say your spiel and then quickly move on to the 'fun' stuff because we have so many other things we can do. And Ava and C.I. just exchanged a look.

Ava: Sorry, TV thing. Complaint from a friend with a show and we just both had an idea of how to address it. Non-Iraq related, go on.

Rebecca: Okay. The way it works is Ava and C.I. are taking the notes. We're all also drinking and if they both need a break, Trina will grab the notes if they nod to her. Cedric and Betty may or may not be drinking. But if someone wants a link, they only get it if they say so. Otherwise Ava and C.I. -- who will type this up -- aren't under any obligation to hunt down a link. Betty, Cedric, drinking alcohol?

Cedric: No. Was planning a beer or two but my stomach started killing me after lunch today and still is. Betty?

Betty: Dona and Ty made margaritas so I've been sipping on one since we started. I'm half-way through with it.

Rebecca: So everyone but Cedric, whose poor stomach is bothering him, is drinking. We have beers and drinks here. And wine. Ruth and Stan are hitting the wine. Trina, Mike, Wally and I are having beers. Ava and C.I. have Bloody Marys in front of them but are doing shots of tequila more than sipping from those. And my husband, by the way, is playing bartender. Sherry, longtime reader at my site, asked what we drank during the roundtables since we'd mentioned booze before. Now Goldie had a question as well. It's about actions. There's one coming up. Who wants to note that?

Stan: I'll grab that. Numerous groups -- such as The National Assembly to End the Wars, the ANSWER coalition, World Can't Wait and Iraq Veterans Against the War -- are taking part in an action in almost two weeks. Iraq Veterans Against the War explains:
IVAW's Afghanistan Resolution and National Mobilization March 21st
As an organization of service men and women who have served in Iraq, Afghanistan, stateside, and around the world, members of Iraq Veterans Against the War have seen the impact that the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan have had on the people of these occupied countries and our fellow service members and veterans, as well as the cost of the wars at home and abroad. In recognition that our struggle to withdraw troops from Iraq and demand reparations for the Iraqi people is only part of the struggle to right the wrongs being committed in our name, Iraq Veterans Against the War has voted to adopt an official resolution calling for the immediate withdrawal of troops from Afghanistan and reparations for the Afghan people. (To read the full resolution, click here.) To that end, Iraq Veterans Against the War will be joining a national coalition which is being mobilized to march on the Pentagon, March 21st, to demand the immediate withdrawal of troops from Iraq and Afghanistan and further our mission and goals in solidarity with the national anti-war movement. This demonstration will be the first opportunity to show President Obama and the new administration that our struggle was not only against the Bush administration - and that we will not sit around and hope that troops are removed under his rule, but that we will demand they be removed immediately.
For more information on the March 21st March on the Pentagon, and additional events being organized in San Francisco, Los Angeles, and Orlando, to include transportation, meetings, and how you can get involved, please visit: http://www.pentagonmarch.org/ or http://www.answercoalition.org/.


Rebecca: Thank you, Stan. Goldie's taking part in it and she assumes Kat, Wally, Ava and C.I. -- who are on the road Monday through Friday talking about the illegal war -- are promoting this when they speak on campuses and to groups. That is correct? Wally, you haven't spoken?

Wally: Yeah. We go over that twice. We grab it at the start and at the end of every discussion. A little before Valentine's Day, we started including it in every talk to be sure people had advance notice because they might need to travel.

Rebecca: And what's the reaction?

Wally: Right now it's positive, especially among people my age and younger -- actually, really younger. It's been over two years since the last real action and, people may not realize this, that's two new classes in college. You've got freshman and sophomores who never saw any national actions on Iraq during their college careers. Now Goldie, she started going to protests when she was in middle school and she started her own house party -- she and her mother -- to end the illegal war. But not everyone's like that. And there are juniors and seniors in high school who we speak to who want to take part. Whether they will or not, I don't know. But Wednesday one was telling me that he felt like he had to find a way to be there because he, his words, had not take a public stand against the Iraq War. I'd say there is strong interest.

Kat: And that's good because most people who are interested won't go. We all know that. We've seen it over and over with each activity. But it's not just when it comes to protesting the illegal war. Let's say we all love --

Betty: Diana Ross!

Kat: Diana Ross, okay. And she's coming to the Bay Area and we're all saying we'll go and our friends are saying it and when the concert rolls around out of fifty people saying they'll go maybe 10 will try to get tickets, maybe eight.

Marcia: I agree, people always talk more than they do -- and they have someone just like themselves in the White House now! -- but, Kat, is this enthusiasm across the board?

Kat: No. And, Marcia, I'm going to let Wally cover the rest of it because I've spoken and spoken and you, Stan, Wally, Betty and Cedric haven't. But I feel like I've jawed everyone's ears off. Wally?

Wally: Right. Marcia, guess where the enthusiasm is and where it's not?

Marcia: Enthusiasm with the young.

Wally: Exactly. Why did you guess that?

Marcia: Because you emphasized high school and college in your remarks.

Wally: UPFJ is United For Peace and Justice and everyone participating in this roundtable knows just how useless that organization is. But we follow Iraq regularly. Now young people know UPFJ is worthless because it's not uncommon now to find the organization called out and they don't do s**t to end the Iraq War. So students know. If you're in college or high school and you follow the Iraq War even a little, you generally know that UPFJ is not a peace group, is not a group working to end the Iraq War.

Marcia: But?

Wally: But adults are different. Maybe because they're busy with their lives? I don't know. But they seem to panic a bit over UPFJ's refusal to join in and they will ask things like, "Is this another A.N.S.W.E.R. - UPFJ split?"

Stan: So how do you explain it? You're speaking to labor groups and to women's groups, and to the elderly as well. How do you explain to them that UPFJ isn't doing anything?

Wally: Sometimes we'll try to do the slow walk through. More often that doesn't work so we toss to C.I. who has a two-line quip that explains it all, gets a laugh and we move on to the groups who matter.

Cedric: What's the joke?
Wally: We're using it now so we won't tell.

Cedric: Backing up. You were very effective campaigning for Hillary. For those who don't know, every state Wally campaigned in for Hillary, Hillary Clinton won. I was fortunate enough to spend about a month with him in Texas on that and Marcia spent about a month or six weeks with him in other states working on that. During that period everyone wanted to know about Wally's effective speech.

Wally: Oh sure. We should have told that awhile back --

C.I.: Stop. The set up you need before Wally speaks is to know he's a young man, blond, very good looking --

Betty: Young Robert Redford!

C.I.: I didn't say that, I know he gets tired of hearing it. But Wally's charming people, men and women. And if you're older, especially, than Wally, when he explains what he's about to explain, you really want to help him make it right. Wally?

Wally: So let's say someone shows up for us to talk about Hillary, okay? And let's say it's when the media's trying to run Hillary out of the race --

Cedric: So bascially, hours after the Iowa caucus ends.

Wally: That's true, I'm laughing. But let's say it's a little further down. Let's say we're in Ohio because I didn't campaign there and I don't have to worry that someone's going to say "You must like ___ state better than my state!" So I'm in Ohio and someone says, "You know, I want to vote for Hillary but the thing is the media says it's over for her." And that's when I explain, look, I'm from Florida. I don't know if you know this, but we did our part. We went to the polls and we voted and we overwhelmingly chose Hillary. Now they won't let her have the votes she won. They're saying our primary won't even be counted. I've been robbed of my vote. My grandfather, my mom, we've all been denied our right to vote. And they may get away with stealing our votes. But if you go and vote for Hillary, you're not just speaking for you, you're speaking for all of us in Florida who overwhelmingly chose Hillary and our votes aren't being counted. You're helping us and you're saying, it's not right, and we don't treat Florida that way, we don't treat anyone that way, this is America.

Marcia: That's the condensed summary and you really need to hear him expand upon it. It was an amazing speech and there were people, especially African-Americans, who would be nodding with Wally with tears in their eyes. I saw many people nod along with him, but African-Americans -- probably because we remember it was us denied in Florida in 2000 -- would really get behind what Wally was saying and usually shout out support. When Wally gave that speech, you did not want to go after him because no one was listening to you. They were thinking about Wally's speech and about Florida 2000 and just wondering what the hell the Democratic Party was doing and what they'd become that they would deny anyone the right to vote? And to pull this back to Iraq, when we speak, that's what we all basically do. And Wally credits C.I. with that. I credit Wally because he's the one I spoke with day after day and saw it in action. You have to be you, you have to bring you to the table. I can't compete with Wally and be a better Wally. But I can find something about, for example, Iraqi refugees that speaks to me, that reminds me of my own life and I can talk about it that way and be effective. Maybe not the best, but effective.

Rebecca: Okay, before we started, C.I. jotted a few notes down for me of topics to explore if we hit a block. We haven't, but one of them was, C.I. noted this, IVAW's Matthis Chiroux wants people to focus on the refugees and the dead. I'm assuming this is in the discussion with Debra Sweet, Matthis and Elaine Brower that people can see the video of.
C.I., can you set that up and then I'll come back to Marcia with a question about refugees.

C.I.: Sure. Matthis Chiroux, first off, has a hearing March 12th in St. Louis, Missouri, regarding his decision to stick with his discharge, thank you very much, and refuse to ship off to Iraq when the military tried to pull him back into the service. That's one of the things there wasn't room for in the snapshot today and it ended up being cut. But that hearing takes place March 12th and you can find out more by clicking here. As you guessed, it does take place in the discussion with Debra Sweet and Elaine Brower. He expresses the belief that it's time for America to find it's conscience and that he's used to the signs of X number of US service members killed or wounded but what he wants to see this time is recognition of what's been done to the people of Iraq. And Afghanistan, but I focus on Iraq. So he wants to see acknowledgements of how many people have been killed, how many people have been turned into refugees, etc.

Rebecca: Okay. And, for the record, no one supports the Afghanistan War here. I don't believe anyone ever has but I know Elaine and C.I. -- and have known them since we roomed together in college -- and they were adamantally opposed to the Afghanistan War before it started. They never drank the Kool-Aid, whether George serves it up or Barack. Now Marcia, in Iraq, there is a refugee crisis. You have approximately four million refugees -- both external, who've fled the country, and internal, who remain in the country. You're speaking to high schoolers, how do you connect or get that story across?

Marcia: I speak briefly about when I was a little girl and my grandfather died and my grandmother lost the house. How devastating that was and how, even with adults trying to keep that from me, the reality of it, I knew enough and it scared me and I was frightened my parents would lose their home and where would we live and where would my toys go or my dog? And I'd talk about how I wasn't at risk. And it wasn't as if all around me people were becoming homeless. But that did frighten me. And imagine if I had grown up in Iraq, during this war, when refugees were normal. When living in tent cities or on the streets -- as so many Iraqi children do -- was normal. And maybe I make it through and maybe I don't, but what does that mean if I do? What happened to my grandmother is nothing I have ever forgotten. Imagine what it's like for an Iraqi child who ends up on the streets. She or he has lost at least one if not both parents. And is trying to survive, to make it, in a war zone. Think about it.

Ruth: Marcia, that was very good. Very good.

Marcia: I learned watching Wally. Grab that experience that is your own and use it to talk about what you want to.

Rebecca: Yes, well done, Marcia. Okay, let's talk about external refugees which have been in the news lately and the US State Dept, as C.I. noted in two snapshots this week, had a problem with a press briefing in terms of accuracy about information.

Betty: Right, they had to correct it after the press conference. Which goes to how confusing the process is for Iraqi refugees if even State Dept spokespeople find the process confusing. I want to talk about something here. There was a couple in a snapshot awhile back. They had both been college professors in Iraq. They were desperate for work and frightened that they would have to return to Iraq because they couldn't find work. It's the Feb. 27th snapshot, please link to it here, and the woman wa Rand Hikmat-Mahmood who had settled in Houston, Texas with her family. And C.I. made the point of asking why they were in Houston? Why they were in Fort Worth, for example, which is close to a base or has one, and where they could be teaching soldiers about Iraq. And I agree with that. We're willing to spend tons of money on that deceitful counterinsurgency; however, we have two people, educators, who can provide information about Iraq, and the culture, to soldiers and we're not using them? Why does Rand Hikmat-Mahmood have to look for work? Why didn't someone -- in the long process that she and her husband had to go through to get to the US -- suggest to them that they give trainings on Iraq? That is pretty obvious. And she and her husband would be earning their money but the fact that they are refugees due to a war this country started, I wouldn't care if she wasn't a qualified educator and had every class play Simon Says for an hour. I know she wouldn't do that,she came off like a very professional woman. But I'm saying,t he US has some huge debts to make good on with Iraqis. The very least they can do is put her in a job she's qualified for that will assist her and assist the service members.

Rebecca: Betty, I think you said that beautifully and think we can move into debt unless someone has something to add? No? Okay. Like I said, Betty covered it. Well done. Okay, there is a debt and the debat is both for what the US military did under orders and what they did on their own. Let me change that to what they did under legal orders because you're not supposed to obey an unlawful order. In today's snapshot, C.I. emphasized Steven Dale Green and Santos A. Cardona. I need Stan, Mike and Cedric to speak during this and Ruth can come in as well and I'd love it if Elaine did. But I'm looking at the time and we need to wrap up so Stan, Mike and Cedric, get in here. Both Green and Cardona have War Crimes in common. Steve D. Green is accused of them and denies them and Santos A. Cardona was tried for them and found guilty.

C.I.: Found guilty of one.

Rebecca: Okay. So Stan, grab one. The accused or the convicted. Grab one and start us off.

Stan: I'll go with Cardona. He was found guilty in the Abu Ghraib scandal. He is the dog handler in some of the photos with the dog snarling at naked Iraqi prisoners. You know what, I'm passing to Cedric. He and Wally have been vocal on this topic in the past.

Cedric: Contractors? Yeah. Your kids need you at home. You go out and risk your life to try and make big bucks don't kid yourself that you're doing it for your kids. Wally and I both lost our fathers early on and we don't have any sympathy for the "I wanted to make money for my kids!" nonsense. Your kids need you there, more than anything else, they need you there. And he leaves behind a daughter. The Washington Post had an article today about it that was boo-hoo city. And who really cares? He wanted to make money, he became a mercenary. People who do that can die. It's why it's not a smart job to try to turn a profit in a war zone. So he gets convicted and he can't re-enlist. They don't kick him out, but they won't let him sign up for another hitch. New rule should be that if you're convicted for abuse of any sort, you're out. That should obviously be conduct unbecoming for all service members. So he ends up becoming a mercenary in Afghanistan after that. With his dog. And I don't have any tears for the man. I don't. No tears at all. Stan?

Stan: Well, on the tears, I think the issue is basically that we're not in the mood. Abu Ghraib was a War Crime -- non-stop War Crimes. And you can be one of the low hanging fruit and complain that those at the top walked, no problem. But you can't be a low hanging fruit that refuses to take accountability and that's what Cardona was. It wasn't his fault and those people at the top didn't get punished! You terrorized Iraqis. You were in a position of authority and trust. You terrorized them. They didn't know whether you'd let the dog actually rip them to shreds or not. They lived in terror because of you. You can whine that were you told to do it but you need to take accountability for what you did. You can point to higher-ups but that doesn't change the fact thatyou need to take accountability.

Mike: I think Stan just summarized it perfectly. If you took part in abuse at Abu Ghraib, I don't need for you to rot in hell. You're really not my concern. I would hope you would try to make amends for what you did. But you become my concern when I hear that you are minimizing your actions. What was done? War Crimes. And, hey, blow the whistle on every one above you. I'll applaud you for it. Even after you've been convicted. But don't ever think that because there was evil at the top, you're innocent. You weren't. You knew better. An eight-year-old boy knows not to threaten his little brother with a dog. So Cordova really has no excuse. And he made no efforts to make amends -- apparently because he didn't feel it was his fault. I agree with Stan, this, "It's their fault," that doesn't cut it. You need to take accountability. You didn't shoot an innocent Iraqi child by accident because you were storming into a home with guns blazing in the middle of a battle. That's awful, but that's not a war crime. It's a tragedy. It's a mistake. But I don't think most people would feel the service member was at all responsible. But there's a world of difference between that andbeing assigned to a prison and deciding you can abuse and terrorize prisoners. And saying, "I was ordered to." Well you know what's right and what's wrong. Does that mean you could've stopped? It means you should have. Now maybe you're too weak willed to stand up? Well that's what it is but that doesn't change that you are accountable for your actions.

Stan: And there was no sense of accountability. Just a push to erase it. This "I will prove that's not who I am." Well, if that's not who you are then, when you bring it up, people expect to hear remorse from you. Like Mike said, no one's saying, "Rot in hell!" That's for -- my opinion -- someone else to determine. But we're not going to pretend like you were tricked into what you did. You need to take accountability.

Cedric: Of all of them, I feel sorry for Lynddie England because, honestly, she didn't strike me as all there. But even with that sympathy, if she gave an interview where she didn't take accountability for what she did -- and we all remember her from those photos, I'd have no sympathy for her. Those were War Crimes. And we don't even know how bad things were, remember, because the US Congress decided the American people didn't have right to see all the abuse.

Rebecca: Good point, Cedric, and good points all. We still have Steven D. Green. Any of you three that wants to jump in, feel free. But I'm tossing to Ruth to start.

Ruth: I am going to toss to Betty for set-up and then I will offer a few quick thoughts.

Betty: Thank you, Ruth. Steven D. Green stands accused of being the ring-leader in the gang-rape and murder of Abeer Qassim Hamza al-Janabi and the murders of Abeer's parents and her five-year-old sister. Other US soldiers accused have entered guilty pleas and all have fingered Green as the ring-leader. Abeer's brother has noted that she did not like Green, that he made her uncomfortable. He was in charge of a checkpoint right by her house. One day, as he got more foward -- remember this is a 14-year-old girl -- he ran his hand along her face. She lived in terror and complained to her parents. Had the assault been planned for the next day, Abeer wouldn't have been there because her parents had planned for her to stay in another home starting the next day. They were attempting to protect her. But Green, who states he is innocent -- doe she? Wait a second, C.I., Green, in the snapshot today, we learn Green filed his intent to plead not guilty by reasons of insanity. So is that the same as claiming he's innocent?


C.I.: You're correct. Your point is correct. If someone pleads not guilty by reasons of insanity, they aren't pleading innocent. But the thing to remember is that Steven D. Green has not spoken to the press and his attornenys no longer speak to the press. The last anyone heard from Green or an attorney speaking on his belahf, the statement was that Green was innocent. Once the trial starts, April 27th, if Green enters a plea of not guilty by reason of insanity, then it really isn't accurate to simply state, "Green claims he is innocent." That plea is one that says: "I am guilty but I shouldn't be held liable due to my frame of mind." If he enters that plea, we certainly won't be under any obligation to state, "Green asserts he is innocent." We may start using "Green admits his guilt" because that is what's taking place. And that really is telling about the case. Because if they stick with that plea, Green is confessing. He says, "But wait, because there's one more thing I want to tell you, but, yes, I am guilty." Did that do it?

Betty: Yes, thank you, that covered it. So when his attorneys used to talk to the press it was conveyed he was innocent. That appears to have changed. Ruth?

Ruth: Well, I am glad Betty brought up that point and C.I. clarified it, however, it left me with little to say. So, if he pleads that way, as his legal team has indicated, he is not denying he took part in the crimes. Will the anti-death penalty people take up his cause?

Ava: Let me grab that because Jess, my boyfriend Jess, is anti-death penalty and works on that issue as do his parents. But they've said they don't believe in the death penalty but this isn't going to be an issue for them. They point to it being international in scope. Meaning, it's not a simple case. And, as advocates, it would require more teaching moments than will be possible.

Trina: Well, I would think, my opinion, that it would be a loser for the cause -- and I'm firmly opposed to the death penalty. But you've got a man who appears to be about to plead, "Yes, I was the ringleader." That means he planned the whole thing. Not just the crimes of rape and murder, but also the cover up. Add in that he's an adult and she's a child, Abeer was a child. Add in that it was his job, given to him by the US government, to protect her neighborhood. I mean, it's like, "Are we going to make the execution of a prison guard who willfully murdered prisoners are cause?" I mean, it would be great if we did. It would mean that the issue had progressed so far that we were saying, "No one deserves to be put to death." But we're not there yet. The movement tries to find the most sympathetic -- and often photogenic -- test cases. That's not a negative criticims on my part. There's much work to be done on the issue and on awareness. I understand the reluctance.

Rebecca: Trina speaking right now reminds me that she hasn't spoken and I actually wrote her name down but forgot about her. Trina, I'm so sorry. Okay, let's operate under the assumption that his plea is going to be not guilty by reason of insanity and that he's not quibbling over any of the charges. Describe what the means Steven D. Green did.

Trina: That would mean that -- as the other soldiers testified -- he planned it all. He lusted after this under-age girl. He knew it was wrong and this was not spur of the moment but a carefully crafted plan. As ringleader, he was the one deciding who went with him into the home and who was the lookout. And, note, that this was all planned ahead of time because everyone knew what to wear. C.I., help me, those still in the military had invidual trials but they all had the same court-martial. What did the prosecutor say at the hearing?

C.I.: "Murder, not war. Rape, not war. That's what we're here talking about today. Not all that business about cold food, checkpoints, personnel assignments. Cold food didn't kill that family. Personnel assignments didn't rape and murder that 14-year-old little girl." And that's Captain Alex Pickands being quoted.

Trina: And they carried it out. They plotted it and they carried it out. The others in the house -- meaning participating in the gang-rape of Abeer -- say they started the gang-rape while Green murdered Abeer's sister and her parents in the bedroom. They gang-rape took place in the living room. So they're raping her, one after the other, and she can hear her parents being killed in the next room, she can hear her sister being killed. Then Steven D. Green comes out and wants his 'turn'. So he gang-rapes her and then kills her. Then he tries to set her body on fire so that they can dispose of the evidence and blame it on insurgents. They then return to the base, where they proceed to grill chicken wings, kick back and get drunk. I don't see any public sympathy for Green but maybe his lawyers are miracle workers? I don't know.

Rebecca: Trina, cutting you off for a moment. I don't think anyone feels sympathetic for Green. But let me play devil's advocate. C.I., you're building sympathy for Steven D. Green, what do you do?

C.I.: Didn't you leave out "pop quiz," Dennis Hopper? Uh, well I stress the troubled childhood. I stress the stunted effects that had on his maturity and growth. I talk about his non-stop trouble with the law and, in effect, put the US military on trial. I ask why -- and I've made this argument at The Common Ills -- no red flags went up when Green attempted to enlist, either while in jail or while leaving? Where were the red flags? I put the US military on trial and ask for the records. I cast doubt that the US military was unaware of what Green was, what his problems were. My guess is they willfully ignored the red flags. But I would plant doubt there. I would ask what happens when you put a troubled -- beyond troubled from private accounts I've heard -- young man, emotionally not even an adult yet into a combat zone? What happens? I would throw to the jury repeatedly. I'd point to Steven and say, "I think we all know what happens. I guess the question is, 'Are we thatmuch smarter than the US military or did the US military take a gamble?' And if they rolled the dice, why is the only one being forced to pay Steven D. Green?" To be perfectly clear, I am very angry about the actions I perceive Steven D. Green was responsible for,participated in and orchestrated. However, go back to some of the early snapshots when his problems are first known. I don't want us to go around saying, "Hang 'em." One by one. But I will say for the record that if he doesn't get the death penalty, I won't be surprised and I won't be screaming my head off -- in person or online. From what I'm hearing, he's a very sick person and, if that's true, and if his attorneys can establish that, then he never should have been accepted into the military, the 'moral' waiver never should have been granted and the US military command needs to take accountability for their actions because, if true and presented convincingly, Steven D. Green has serious problems. Now I'm not saying he does have these problems. I am saying that's the word and that's what's being tested. If true, if it holds up in court, it could change the dynamic. Add in that most outlets refused to even print Abeer's name and she remains faceless and nameless to so many and you're dealing with a victim few can relate to. The prosecution would be very smart to get her brother and put him on the stand. If they don't and they lose, they will have that mistake to blame for it. They need to bring her brother into the United States for the trial. For them to win what they want to win, the prosecution needs to put a face on Abeer. The jury will hear all about 'poor Steven.' Abeer's just a dead girl in another country -- from the jury's perspective. They don't know her so she's already the 'other.' They don't know her so they have no ties to her. I think Capt Pickands did an amazing job bringing her to life in the Article 32 hearing in the summer of 2006; however, that went to him and his style. I wouldn't count on the same thing from this team of prosecutors. They need Abeer's photo in that courtroom and they need her brother. They need the family member who misses her, the family member who lost her, who lost his parents, who lost his five-year-old sister. Without him in the courtroom, you're talking about a crime which took place overseas in a war zone -- the jury will be thinking that -- and happened to a bunch of people with 'strange' names that no one knows. So if they lose or even have a partial loss and they did not call the brother to the stand, the prosecution will have only themselves to blame.

Trina: I think, Rebecca's pointing to me, I think C.I. makes the case for the defense and the prosecution. I don't know. I don't know how it's going to go. What I do know is that he got into legal trouble and was sane or aware enough to know that he could go into the military and escape consequences for his actions. That apparently was part of his road of not believing in consequences. I appreciated both views C.I. just offered but I really do think it comes down to that point C.I. made about whether or not the brother's there or the prosecution manages to put a face on the victims in some other way. If he did what he's accused of, he murdered four people in cold blood. Without any real remorse. Without any real hesitation. If they put a face on his victims, I see him getting convicted and getting the death penalty because, if I were serving on the jury, what I'd be thinking was, "Four people are dead. He joined the military to escape consequences. If he gets away with these murders and the gang-rape, no one in the US is safe from him."

Rebecca: Ruth, Betty, closing thoughts. Starting with Betty.

Betty: I think I'm the only one other than Ava, C.I., Wally and Kat who saw the stream of the discussion about the Iraq War and Afghanistan. I believe it's Debra Sweet who says that we're about to hit the sixth anniversary of this illegal war and we don't want to see the seventh. We don't. So what's it going to take. Elaine Browder believes, and I don't doubt her, that it's going to take massive civil disobedience. Sit-ins that shut down a city for example. There is so much to do, this is what I'm saying, and if you can't at least participate in the actions on the 19th or 21st, how do you make up for that? Do you chain yourself to the door at City Hall? I don't know. I know that the easiest thing in the world is for us to participate in these actions. There's so much more that could be done and should be done and these actions that are scheduled are nothing to be scared of. If I can go on for just one more second, Matthis made a point that I would have stood and applauded if I'd been there. He pointed out that just because Barack's "Black" -- put quotes around that, because he isn't and I don't consider him to be that -- doesn't mean that the racist wars are any less racist. I thought that took and demonstrated real guts and I wanted to give him some praise for that. It took a lot to make that valid point and a lot of people wouldn't have even attempted it.

Ruth: What Betty said. Seriously. I really think that if you do not stand up with these actions, you really are asking for this to be just the mid-way point of the illegal war. At least the mid-way point. If you're not going to participate, you really are asking for actions to stop and for the illegal war to continue. I did not have time to watch the stream but from what Betty said and a summary C.I. gave me earlier, Matthis Chiroux was talking about accountability. This is what we were talking about earlier. Guess what? If you do nothing, you are no better than the War Criminals from Abu Ghraib who try to offer excuses. If you sit silently and allow this illegal war to continue, you are sending a message to the world that you endorse and embrace the slaughter.

Rebecca: And on that note, we'll wrap this up. This is a rush transcript. We will do another Iraq roundtable next Friday.

Highlights

This piece is written by Rebecca of Sex and Politics and Screeds and Attitude, Cedric of Cedric's Big Mix, Kat of Kat's Korner, Betty of Thomas Friedman is a Great Man, Mike of Mikey Likes It!, Elaine of Like Maria Said Paz, Ruth of Ruth's Report, Marcia of SICKOFITRADLZ, Stan of Oh Boy It Never Ends and Wally of The Daily Jot. Unless otherwise noted, we picked all highlights.








"I Hate The War" -- Most requested entry and this will be a surprise to C.I. who gutted this Thursday entry at Jim's request. C.I. will say, "It must be the topic that was popular."








"The Roundtable in the Kitchen," "Roundtable on Iraq ," "roundtable on iraq," "Putting Iraq back on the table," "Roundtable," "Roundtabling Iraq," "Iraq roundtable," "Iraq roundtable," "Iraq" and "Iraq roundtable" -- Friday night roundtable.











"AP spins so does Paul Street" and "AP gets creative with figures for violence" -- Mike explains how AP always sees the sunny side even when the 'sun' is a raging fire.





"Barack's tales of celebrity" and "THIS JUST IN! IT'S CELEB LIFE BAMA STYLE" -- Cedric and Wally chart the musical chairs of Barack's love life.








"Thoughts on PUMA" -- Betty explains








"helen thomas asks why the war on single-payer?" -- We plan to highlight the exchange between Helen Thomas and the White House as Rebecca did.





"Cheap ass Michelle" -- Marcia calls it straight up.





Isaiah's The World Today Just Nuts "Rounding up Lucy"; Isaiah's The World Today Just Nuts "Making Dennis the Menace" and Isaiah's The World Today Just Nuts "Shutting Down The Domestic Arts Czar." -- Three -- yes, three! -- comics from Isaiah last week.





"Kat's Korner: The charity album that just takes" -- Kat covers an album for children of war.





"Huey"-- Betty talks about the comics and her kids.











"nbc's monday line up" -- Rebecca blogs on three TV shows: Chuck, Heroes and Medium.





"Organic foods, Hillary's MidEast and European trip" -- Ruth offers some photos of Hillary's trip and, uh-oh, how do you know organic is safe?





"Music, Amazon" and "Isaiah, Virign Megastore" -- Kat offers some Amazon and music tips.





"Message to Fat F**k Tim Wise" -- Like Stan, we're sick of Tim Wise.





"Dustin Alan Parks, John Pilger" -- Elaine highlights two important voices.





"Ted, read the Constitution" -- Ted Kennedy may be knighted, Mike make puke.





"Belle of the ball" and "THIS JUST IN! MARTHA STEWART, WATCH YOUR BACK!" -- Cedric and Wally on Party Gil Barry.

Sunday, March 01, 2009

Truest statement of the week

[Katrina] Vanden Heuvel's most recent piece in The Nation runs under a title in the form of a query, "Obama's War?" Whose war does she think it is anyway? Even the mainstream media calls it Obama's war -- sans question mark. Her piece ran shortly after Obama ordered 17,000 more troops to Afghanistan and almost a month after both Afghan and Pakistani civilians were first bombed at Obama's orders. She concludes her piece, after citing the deployment of additional troops, "Up to this point the Afghan war belonged to George W. Bush, but Obama's escalation threatens to make it his own. There's still time to change direction. President Obama don't make this your war"! (Emphasis mine. If escalation of the AfPak war (the war on Afghanistan and Pakistan) only "threatens" to make the war Obama's, what will it take to give him ownership?)
Having supported Obama during the election when he was very clear about his coming Crusade in Afghanistan and having made no demands in exchange for their support, the liberals are now reduced, their leverage gone, to begging for a change in course. Pity, pathos, disgust or a sense of betrayal -- it is hard to know what to feel when one encounters this stuff.
Similarly Cagan's United for Peace and Justice, dominated by the "Progressive" Democrats of America ("P"DA) and the "Communist" Party of the U.S.A ("C"PUSA) -- more or less the same thing, not because "P"DA is radical but because the "C"PUSA is not -- has been all too silent on Obama's AfPak War. As a result there have been discordant rumblings among the rank and file about UFPJ's failure to call a national demonstration against the wars flaring from Iraq to Pakistan and refusal to join the only one called, that by ANSWER (Act Now To Stop War and End Racism) for March 21.




-- John Walsh, "Indict Bush and Impeach Obama: Liberal Leaders Betray Antiwar Cause To Serve Dems and Obama -- Again" (Dissident Voice).

Truest statement of the week II

John Walsh said on February 26th, 2009 at 12:51pm #

"P"DA is complicit in war.

In response to Laura Bonham’s claim that "P"DA is principled and consistent on the question of war, I have to ask, Is she kidding? Or whom does she think she is kidding?

"P"DA supported John Kerry in 2004 when he ran on a prowar platform.

"P"DA supported Barack Obama in 2008 - even as he called for a 100,000 increase in men and women in the active duty army and marines and even as he called to step up the war on Afghanistan and Pakistan.

So far as I know, "P"DA will not be joining the March 21 national mobilization in DC against what the mainstream media call Obama's war.

Obama has been bombing Pakistan, an act of war, without any Congressional declaration of war, an impeachable offense. "P"DA has not called for impeachment.

If Bush were doing any of this "P"DA would be yelling at the top of its lungs. But I hear only quiet when Obama does these things -- perhaps a few statements on the web site to cover their ass, but no action at all.

As Eugene McCarthy, echoing Daniel Webster, said of the war on Vietnam, it went on because too many placed party over principle. That is exactly what "P"DA is doing.

john walsh



-- John Walsh responding to PDA propaganda left in comments at his article "Indict Bush and Impeach Obama: Liberal Leaders Betray Antiwar Cause To Serve Dems and Obama -- Again" (Dissident Voice).

A note to our readers

Hey --

Sunday and we're done surprisingly quickly. A busy edition and a long one but one that is over. Later today Dee Dee Myers appears on NBC's Meet The Press, by the way. We had a 'heads up' post planned noting that and other things but there wasn't time to rough it out and the illustration wasn't ready.

Along with Dallas, the following worked on this edition:

The Third Estate Sunday Review's Jim, Dona, Ty, Jess, and Ava,
Rebecca of Sex and Politics and Screeds and Attitude,
Betty of Thomas Friedman Is a Great Man,
C.I. of The Common Ills and The Third Estate Sunday Review,
Kat of Kat's Korner (of The Common Ills),
Cedric of Cedric's Big Mix,
Mike of Mikey Likes It!,
Elaine of Like Maria Said Paz,
Ruth of Ruth's Report,
Wally of The Daily Jot,
Marcia of SICKOFITRDLZ
and Stan of Oh Boy It Never Ends.


We thank everyone for their assistance.

And what did we come up?

Truest statement of the week -- This is from an article John Walsh wrote. Walsh has gotten truest before.

Truest statement of the week II -- He has never gotten two truests in one week. No one has. (Mike said to put in that stat because his readers love it when he notes things like that.) We thought the first (and possible only) ever multiple truest should go to Walsh. Here he's responding to a flack for Pathetic Democrats of America who left a comment at his article.

Editorial: Wishin' And Hopin' -- We love this editorial. We thought about going heavy and had that prepared. But we were in Dusty mood and Dona pointed out that we had some lengthy things and also a very hard hitting edition. She recommended we go for an important topic and do it with a light touch. By the way, Ty reminds, we couldn't figure out one line we quote because I (Jim) went online and looked up the lyrics. "That's not right, it's . . .," I insisted. Wrongly. C.I. got in on it and said, "What the hell are you talking about?" C.I. then pulled down various pieces of sheet music to show the real lyrics. After we read the lyrics and then listened, I could hear that was what was being said. So be warned about trusting the lyrics online at those lyric sites. (I could not find any Dusty site online that had lyrics. I would assume a site devoted to just Dusty Springfield would have the lyrics correct.)

TV: Felons, Frauds and Fluff -- Ava and C.I.'s amazing TV commentary. I was really worried about Tuesday's speech. It's always difficult to get them to hold off on something. I didn't even ask this time. When Wednesday's snapshot was done, I did make a point to leave a call me message for them and, when Ava returned it, asked her if C.I. was holding back for the piece to go up here? She said C.I. was worried about that but that she and C.I. honestly believed that speech would be over and forgotten by the week's end. And that is how it turned out. So much for the press management the new administration believes it is so great at. Ava and C.I. open with Oprah -- the liar who sold the illegal war and now visits some of the people wounded due to her lies and promotion. They then move on to huckster Al Sharpton. Covering a blip of TV time we don't believe anyone else caught. Then it's on to Barack. Non-stop Barack. This is a powerful commentary from them and I think they've touched every base possible and then some.

More faux change from Barack -- The new 'policy' is not a return to the original policy. Barack is instead offering a policy that is half of the policy Bully Boy Bush offered. That's not change. We could have gotten that with John McCain. And you'll note Barack's treated like a savior for taking an awful policy and making it only half-awful. It's embarrassing the way his faux change gets applauded.

Amazon.com: Bargains and sexism offered -- Music article. This almost got ditched. Kat insisted on it and Dona backed her up saying this is a hard hitting edition and we need something on entertainment to add to the mix. They were both correct. The Weepies album is a great one. My favorite tracks are "Can't Go Back Now" and "Lighting Candles." We were really hoping that Amazon would continue the sale until Tuesday so we could urge you to go download it at that bargain price (entire album for $1.99) but they didn't. We'd suggest that future sales last through Tuesday. Tuesday is when new music is released, makes sense for them to offer sales through Tuesday each week. (The Weepies' Hideaway is still a bargain at $8.99 to download the full album.) As always, C.I. and Betty lead on the Diana Ross section. (And C.I. knows and loves Diana and has known her for years. C.I. says put in that disclosure before someone shows up whining in the e-mails.) E-mail address is thirdestatesundayreview@yahoo.com, by the way.

Crazy Ray LaHood? Not so crazy after all. -- An update to an article last week. We got a ton of e-mails on this article. A lot of you enjoyed it. And some of you praised us for the flip that comes about mid-way (Derek called it "highly cinematic"). That flip wasn't planned. The article was supposed to continue in that vein. Jess didn't care for that. He asked why we were taking the word of Robert Gibbs and C.I. had already alluded to something that hadn't really registered. C.I. explained that LaHood had been seen with two members of the commission and, presumably, what LaHood was suggesting was echoing the upcoming report. C.I. tracked down three addtional people who could confirm those sightings and Jess and C.I. argued for a new section to be written. That's where the 'flip' begins. Were it not for that, we would have written the same let's-mock-Ray-LaHood article everyone else did.

The Katrina goes to Phyllis Bennis -- While Ava and C.I. worked on the TV commentary, the rest of us looked for a hard hitting topic to write about. Elaine brought up Phyllis Bennis' bad article. Ruth and Marcia grabbed on -- there were several suggestions of topics at this point -- to Elaine's suggestion and added to it that it could be a Katrina which we hadn't done in awhile. The fact that an illustration already existed for that made it an easier sale. This turned out very well, we think.

Liar-in-chief Barack -- I'd just finished reading Ava and C.I.'s commentary out loud to everyone when Wally and Cedric both insisted that either we do a humor post or a short post or something. They said this needed to be underscored and really emphasized. So we pulled the part revealing Barack is LYING today about the 16 months and how he didn't break a promise and paired that with Isaiah's comic (thank you to Isaiah for the use of his comic). To further emphasize their catch, I posted Ava and C.I.'s TV commentary at The Common Ills mirror site this morning.

TV Spotlight: Washington Week -- Ava and C.I. wrote a lengthy commentary. Before we saw it, they gutted several things. Including a longer excerpt from Washington Week. They put that over into this and also noted some tech issues regarding the program. This is their article, by the way.

The Condi II -- Iraqi refugees do not need to return to Iraq. It is not safe. Nor is it true -- a point we forget here but one C.I. covered in Friday's "Iraq snapshot" -- that the US is in any place to call on other nations to help with the 'burden' of Iraqi refugees. See C.I.'s snapshot for more on that.

The Bronze Booby goes to . . . David Martin -- Read it and be enraged. How dare he. First off, that's an editorial comment that should have never made it into what was supposed to be a reporter reporting. Second off, that comment is designed to enrage and that no one noticed that does not bode well for those involved.

Iraq roundtable -- Rebecca called a roundtable Friday night. Third was represented by Ava, C.I. and myself. I learned how Rebecca does it so smoothly. I'm not sure it would work for me here. First off, Rebecca (as she's pointed out) has been friends with Elaine and C.I. forever (they were roomates in college). So she can get them to participate and she can also do things that I can't (she can shorthand and do so knowing that her shorthand won't lead to a longer discussion because she knows where they stand on pretty much everything whereas a shorthand attempt on my part could lead to a long discussion). She also assigns ahead of the roundtable and during the roundtable. If she wants to -- she didn't this Friday -- she can also put Elaine and C.I. on the spot and they'll humor her. (Whereas Elaine would cuss me out. I'm laughing but that's true. Ask her, she'll tell you. And Elaine and I get along very well before e-mails in a panic start coming in.) The other big thing is that there's more of a jockeying here (which I may encourage). Rebecca's roundtables are more laid back. It's also Rebecca's personality which is better at squelching things and getting away with it. Check out the start of the roundtable where Ruth's comments lead to something Rebecca talks over and hands off to someone not even trying to talk. What was going on there? We were naming people who were disappointments. Rebecca cut that off and hollered "WAIT!" Everyone did and the roundtable went on pause. Ava and C.I. noted they had everything being said and that the topic could be raised but it needed to be raised after the speech was discussed. Which was Rebecca's point in ignoring all the attempts. (Elaine, who is sick this week so we really appreciated her helping out here, told me that Rebecca saw the looks on Ava and C.I.'s face during this and that's one reason she screamed "WAIT!" and overruled the attempts to introduce a new topic at that point.) And that parenthetical, C.I.'s pointing out, is another issue. Betty, Cedric and I participated by phone. Everyone else was face to face. Rebecca makes a special point to bring in people on the phone because they're not able to see each other and whose body language means they're about to speak. But she also is able to direct traffic in person and our roundtables here are generally more spread out. With more people participating by phone.

Highlights -- Mike, Elaine, Kat, Betty, Ruth, Rebecca, Marcia, Stan, Cedric and Wally wrote this and we thank them for it. Stan? Not on the highlights but in terms of editorial decision this edition I need to give a shout out to Stan. This is a hard hitting edition and not only are the bulk of the articles here that way, the ones that ended up on the cutting room floor were as well. We're trying to get all those who are not the core six (those of us signing this note) done and off to their own things as early as possible. Stan ended up sticking around (on the phone) and helped tremendously when we were selecting which pieces were making this edition and which weren't. There are two pieces that made the final cut just because of his strong advocacy for them. Thank you, Stan.


And that's it, we'll see you next week.

-- Jim, Dona, Ty, Jess, Ava and C.I.

Editorial: Wishin' And Hopin'

Wishin' and hopin' and thinkin' and prayin'
Plannin' and dreamin' each night of his charms,
That won't get you into his arms


Nor will it end the illegal war and we feel we need to add that due to all the 'anti-war' 'leaders' so busy wet dreaming over Barack that they have no time to work towards ending the Iraq War or, for that matter, calling their Dream Lover out.

lejeune04-hero




Friday, Barack spoke at Camp Lejeune and broke his 'promise' on 16-months, lied that he always said he'd listen to military commanders (not on the 16-month -- as Ava and C.I. explain), and revealed there's no real withdrawal. It's a draw down. Which the White House would prefer everyone spell "drawdown." So we'll call it a "draw down."



Here's ego maniac I Need Attention Benjamin of CODESTINK, "While the move toward withdrawal is positive, this timeline and leaving tens of thousands of residual troops sounds more like occupation-lite than an end to occupation. But compared to the past eight years of moving backward, at least there's an atmosphere now where we can continue to apply pressure on the administration to push forward." The previous administration is gone, Medea. So what's your damn point?



The previous administration is one that you and CODESTINK said were War Criminals and needed to be impeached. So you're telling America that the Bush Administration is now the acceptable standard to judge by? Do you realize how insane you sound?



'Cause wishin' and hopin' and thinkin' and prayin',
Plannin' and dreamin' his kisses will start
That won't get you into his heart


And we have to remind I-Need-Attention, Leslie Cagan, Tom Hayden and all the other losers posing as leaders of that fact. Tom, we know you'd gladly flop on your back and throw your legs up in the air, spread them as wide as your bad knees will allow them go, and 'receive' Barack.



Well, hey, Tom-Tom, go for it.



But don't confuse that lust with any work that's needed for the peace movement.



What these losers posing as leaders are doing is showing the world that they just care for Barack.



He can bomb Pakistan. (As he's done.) He can chat up PBS (as he did Friday) about his need to 'take on' Iran (one day after US Ambassador to the UN Susan Rice makes threats to Iran). He can escalate the war on Afghanistan. He can bring about no withdrawal at all for Iraq.



And none of that matters to the losers posing as leaders.



So to Tom-Tom, Carl Davidson, Jeffy Cohen, Leslie Cagan, Medea and all the other wet-pantied, lovesick fools, we urge you to declare your love for Barack, to work towards bedding down with Barack and to stop pretending you are a part of -- let alone a leader -- of the peace movement.



Just walk right up to him and say, "Barack, this circus ride goes round and round with you or without you but it'd be cool if you'd hop on and give a spin.. You won't regret it." Who knows what will happen? But, lovelies, we'd caution to be sure Michelle's not in ear shot when you proposition Barack.



And we again remind you . . .


Just wishin' and hopin' and thinkin' and prayin'
Plannin' and dreamin' his kisses will start
That won't get you into his heart





The sooner you start openly working on what . . . excuse us, on who you want and stop pretending to give a damn about Iraq, the better it will be for the real peace movement.


Such as those participating in this month's actions: The National Assembly to End the Wars, the ANSWER coalition, World Can't Wait and Iraq Veterans Against the War. From IVAW's announcement:

IVAW's Afghanistan Resolution and National Mobilization March 21stAs an organization of service men and women who have served in Iraq, Afghanistan, stateside, and around the world, members of Iraq Veterans Against the War have seen the impact that the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan have had on the people of these occupied countries and our fellow service members and veterans, as well as the cost of the wars at home and abroad. In recognition that our struggle to withdraw troops from Iraq and demand reparations for the Iraqi people is only part of the struggle to right the wrongs being committed in our name, Iraq Veterans Against the War has voted to adopt an official resolution calling for the immediate withdrawal of troops from Afghanistan and reparations for the Afghan people. (To read the full resolution, click here.)
To that end, Iraq Veterans Against the War will be joining a national coalition which is being mobilized to march on the Pentagon, March 21st, to demand the immediate withdrawal of troops from Iraq and Afghanistan and further our mission and goals in solidarity with the national anti-war movement. This demonstration will be the first opportunity to show President Obama and the new administration that our struggle was not only against the Bush administration - and that we will not sit around and hope that troops are removed under his rule, but that we will demand they be removed immediately.For more information on the March 21st March on the Pentagon, and additional events being organized in San Francisco, Los Angeles, and Orlando, to include transportation, meetings, and how you can get involved, please visit: www.pentagonmarch.org or www.answercoalition.org.

--
"Wishin' And Hopin'" written by written by Hal David and Burt Bacharach.

TV: Felons, Frauds and Fluff

Last week, one song kept going through out heads as we followed assorted broadcasts. Sometimes it was sung by Linda Ronstadt, sometimes by the Springfields (Dusty's group).

Silver threads and golden needles cannot mend this heart of mine,
And I dare not drown my sorrow in the warm glow of your wine.

We'd look at each other and start singing during the strong broadcasts and during the weak. And sadly, there was a lot of weak.



tv7

Let's start with the strong. Big Bro O tore herself away from sex tips, sex scandals, 'uplifiting' via bad books, Suze Orman (she and Oprah have so much in common) and her usual crap-fest long enough to go to Walter Reed Army Medical Center.

Ginmar loathed Oprah's Thursday broadcast. We liked it and for many of the reasons Ginmar hated it. First off, Oprah's nothing but afternoon trash. She started out that, tried to smear a little lip gloss on, but still remains that. This is the woman who gets outraged over every little thing and hoards a hell of a lot more than food but then wants to offer up that happiness comes from doing without. She's a joke and, with each passing year, she becomes more of one. Her recent weight gain only makes it more likely she will orbit the earth -- certainly her feet never touch the ground.

Oprah Winfrey was sacrificed years and years ago. The wig-headed woman in front of the cameras bears as much resemblance to Oprah as it does to an actual human being: NONE.

So the thought of Oprah taking her tired act (and ass) to Walter Reed Army Medical Center was one we found made for strong TV. It's was a bit like seeing John Wayne wandering through the wounded from Vietnam. Or has everyone forgotten that Oprah used her trashy show to pimp the Iraq War? Has everyone forgotten how a woman in the audience called the garbage out and Oprah got curt and nasty?

There was Oprah -- in the only moment of TV she should be remembered for -- getting all mean and nasty, that fat neck tensing up, as she let the little peon know that Oprah knows what's what and so do her guests, thank you very much, now shut up and let Judith Miller provide us with more 'facts.'

That's right, Oprah pimped the war, she even brought on Judith Miller to do so.

Oprah rallied her audience of shut-ins to the Bully Boy and to cheer on the Iraq War.

So the idea that the Closet Case had to be confronted with the loss of limbs she caused was something we really, really enjoyed.

Big O tried to grin and pull it off but she couldn't. No, no one beat her with a prosthetic limb. That would have made for classic TV. There she was in her Della Reese-like wig with multi-layers (she does realize it looks like a bird's nest, right?), wearing her lumpy white sweater (she has no taste) and a pair of tight (on her) black pants which really reminded us of the Big Girl's favorite 'slimming' outfit of a decade past -- bulky dark sweater and leggings.

With one soldier, John Hoxie, you could see Oprah attempting to use that iron will to make his wounds into her own personal salvation but it never took. And if you watched closely, you saw she grasped it as well.

It was like watching Adolf Eichmann touring a Nazi concentration camp.

Yeah, the Big O had a crew of Leni Riefenstahls there to make her look better but, have you watched, these days they can't even make her look 'fresh-faced.'

She posed, she tried to appear interested (the left finger and thumb around the chin while Justin Knowles spoke about a bombing blowing off his leg -- "I saw my leg when I got blown up"), but couldn't pull it off. By the time she was speaking with Nicholas Koulchar, who lost both legs serving in Iraq, it didn't even look like she was trying.

That occasional nervous twitch in her eyes had been replaced with a strained face and more and more white of the eyeball showing. She looked like Joan Crawford in Johnny Guitar -- no, that's not a pretty sight.

Ginmar didn't like the way Oprah interacted with a female soldier because Oprah kept referring to her as a mother -- even emphasizing that more than soldier. We'd agree Oprah showed no respect at all for women who serve but we were actually loving that section as well. Who is Oprah's audience? Largely women staying home with small children. So there was Oprah explaining to America that she herself was one of the great hazards.

No, she didn't put it that way but she allowed her show to be used to sell the Iraq War and a soldier serving there, a mother like so many in her audience, was wounded, lost her left hand. When Juanita Wilson shared that her young daughter asked her for a sandwich, she had to explain that she couldn't make her one.

Oprah's ratings have been falling for some time and the longterm commitment so many stations have to make when they take her syndicated show is the only reason several big markets are still carrying it. Big cities have moved on past Oprah. As her show struggles, it's good to see TV's War Criminal forced to meet her victims.

And grasp that the audience -- still hanging on to Oprah, still living in their own little world, encased in safe reading and celebrity gossip -- Thursday, like Oprah, got confronted with some reality.

We began brainstorming about what we'd like to see. We thought a special that teamed up Henry Kissinger and The Big O. She could accompany him to Vietnam and provide comfort while he was confronted and then they could head on over to Iraq. But would Kissinger provide her comfort?

We decided whether he could or not didn't matter because he'd probably never make the airport -- Vietnam authorities would have locked him away in a jail to await trial. So the second half of the special could do what her series does, exist to fuel her own ego.

Good TV. Not great, but good. Unintentionally, to be sure, but in a weak week, Oprah stood out . . . with blood on her hands.

Weak was Al Sharpton. Al spent last week (and the week before) railing against a comic because, studies have shown, editorial cartoons lead to more school-age violence than any other factor. They don't? Oh, then maybe Al wasted his time? His time? Try his life.

And he made that very clear when he appeared on MyTV last week. Yes, Al Sharpton -- while publicly demonizing Rupert Murdoch -- had a special on Murdoch's MyTV. That's because Al's never been anything but a damn hypocrite. Or, as What About Our Daughters pointed out last November, a camera whore.

So there was 'political' and 'spiritual' leader Al Distraction sitting across from D.L. Hughley (whom WAOD also called out in the previous link) and acting the fool. At one point, when Rev Jesse Jackson was being smeared, Al spoke out, right?

Wrong.

He didn't do a damn thing. Saying Jackson got 88 votes in his 1988 campaign for the Democratic Party's presidential nomination isn't just an insult it grossly inaccurate. 88 votes in that run would not have allowed him to win the primaries in DC, Alabama, Georgia,, Louisiana, Mississippi, Virginia and Puerto Rico. Nor would 88 votes have allowed him to win the caucuses in Vermont, Michigan, South Carolina and Delaware. Rev Jackson received over 6 million votes.


What did Al do?. He looked around. Like a tired, old man. He sat on the couch, looked around. Then looked down, then sort of buried his head.

That last action is something we encourage him to do much more often. Especially when the impulse to speak takes him.

And then there's Barry. Big Barry to some, Princess Tiny Meat to us.

Did he have his own reality show? Was he a contestant on American Idol?

He seemed to be everywhere last week.

6-hero-c2p


Tuesday night he was yammering away in an alleged address to Congress -- one in which he forgot the Iraq War. Supposedly, the US economy is in the toilet and Barack would go on later in the week to continue to commit approximately $11 billion a month to the illegal war. If he was going to talk to Congress -- and address the nation -- he needed to remember the ongoing, illegal war. He didn't. Ross Colvin (Reuters) noted, "When former President George W. Bush addressed the U.S. Congress in January 2008 he gave three pages of his speech to the Iraq war. On Tuesday night his successor Barack Obama spoke a single sentence." What was the sentence? "We are now carefully reviewing our policies in both wars, and I will soon announce a way forward in Iraq that leaves Iraq to its people and responsibly ends this war." (Click here for full transcript.)

_MG_0474-hero

Barack's silence on Iraq Tuesday night mirrored the commercial broadcast network's silence Monday evening. Only viewers of PBS' evening newscast The NewsHour would learn that three US soldiers were killed that day. Gwen Ifill, "Three US soldiers and their interpreter were killed in Iraq. The US military reported they died in combat in Diyala Province, north of Baghdad. For the month of February, 13 Americans have died in Iraq." Why does the country need an evening newscast from ABC, CBS and NBC when they can't even report the basics? All three broadcast networks MADE time Monday evening to show footage of the Oscars, to show stock footage from India (due to the best picture win). They, like their president, just didn't have time to do the damn news.

For such a heavily promoted, 'big' speech, interest in it 'waned' quickly. Not that there was all that much interest to begin with. Andrew Malcom (Los Angeles Times) explained the size of Barack's audience Tuesday night, "However, Obama still lags the audience-drawing power of one President Bill Clinton. Sixteen years ago this week, when there were millions fewer Americans, Big Bill drew nearly 15 million more viewers -- 66.9 million for his first congressional speech in 44.2 million homes for a 44.3 rating."

The morning after the not-so-big speech, US Vice President Joe Biden would appear on NBC's Today Show for a segment that lasted approximately five minutes. The last seconds of the interview would find Matt Lauer asking about Iraq. Matt wanted to know, ". . . Are you keeping a campaign promise or breaking a campaign promise" on Iraq in Barack's upcoming speech and Joe replied, "We're keeping a campaign commitment." (The entire Iraq exchange -- it's small -- can be found in Wednesday's Iraq snapshot.)

A promise or commitment was being kept? It wasn't.

But damned if the bulk of the press didn't work overtime to pretend otherwise. Friday morning on CBS' The Early Show, Bill Plante would inform, "The president makes good on a campaign promise today. Down at Camp Lejeune, he will announce an end to the US combat mission in Iraq, . . . with a few conditions, as of August 31, 2010. Just a little later than he promised." The Brookings War Hawk was quoted (by Plante) calling it a "significant change" from Barack's campaign promise and then the Brookings spoke to the camera stating "but to me that's good." Of course it is. And to those who want the illegal war ended, it's bad. But no one appeared to grasp that except for a few elected Democrats who were largely ignored. Remember that.

CBS Evening News with Katie Couric Friday (here for the online folder for CBS Evening News with Katie Couric video) briefly noted them at the end of a report. Chip Reid explained, "Many anti-war Democrats are disturbed that so many troops could remain in Iraq for nearly two years but John McCain who called Mr. Obama's plan naive during the campaign today called the new version reasonable." And then Reid mouthed that US Secretary of the Defense Robert Gates said "Barack always said even on the campaign trail he'd listen to military commanders." Remember that too. We'll be coming back to it. CBS didn't.





They had no time for Democratic opposition (which should have been particularly newsworthy since the president is supposed to be a Democrat) but they had time for passing an editorial by reporter David Martin off as a report. During the days of Cronkite, Martin probably wouldn't have gotten away with his little stunt. He would have had to reword it. Reword what?


"[Joe Dan] Whorely and all the other fighting men and women who carried the rest of us on their backs, have the most invested in the president's decision."

What the hell was that?


CBS News is already looking into that statement (which has already led to a few viewer complaints) but the question is how the hell that ever made it on air?


A good-sized portion of the US public was opposed to the illegal war before it ever started. Speaking as two who were, nobody "carried" us. We didn't ask a damn person to go to Iraq. In fact, we've applauded those who have refused to do so or have refused to return.


One such person is Matthis Chiroux who wrote last month:

March 12, I'll attend a board hearing in St. Louis, Missouri, to determine what the nature of my discharge from the Individual Ready Reserve will be. The Army has alleged "misconduct" and they're shooting for a "general discharge," but I'm pushing for "honorable," as my refusal to deploy was not an act of misconduct.
I will attend this hearing in uniform as ordered, but only for the purpose of these administrative proceedings. I'm not contesting the fact that I did not report as ordered to deploy to Iraq. However, I intend to paint a clear picture of my convictions to the military, and I seek to corroborate them with first hand accounts of occupation.
No person is bound to act against the dictates of conscience, let alone their understanding of the law. I know the occupation of Iraq and further the Global War on Terror to be an illegitimate and ultimately murderous campaign waged for economic gain, fueled by misinformation and greed. I know it to be in violation of not only international law, but the U.S. Constitution. Far more importantly, it is against the dictates of my own conscience, and never again will I compromise my humanity to support or ignore the crimes of my government.







The United States was not attacked by Iraq. How dare David Martin claim that anyone carried our burden, how dare he presume to speak for the entire United States or do so while pretending to just be reporting. That was highly offensive and it never should have made it on air. We spoke to CBS news execs (who repeatedly told us it was being handled) and we spoke to people who worked on CBS Evening News during the Cronkite years. We were told back then that the statement would have immediately been flagged and Martin would have been instructed to rework that statement.



Martin then declared, "And US military officers do not expect to meet their goal of getting all US combat troops out of Iraqi cities by this June." Goal?


The US most likely will not be pulling out of Iraqi cities by June and that's been admitted before. But why is that a "goal"? Every other time they report on the Status Of Forces Agreement, the news outlets tell us that this is happening, that these are contractually bound events, things that must take place. The out of Iraqi cities in June is not a "goal." It's stated in the SOFA that it WILL take place. We think the treaty masquerading as a Status Of Forces Agreement is meaningless. We've always maintained that. But you can't treat it as the Holy Grail one moment and then refer to it as a 'goal' in another.



Martin gets some credit for noting, "In the back of everybody's mind is the last time a president declared combat ending and troops coming home. That was more than 4,000 troops ago." But he loses all credit when his reporting leaves the impression that the US is in Iraq to fight (and fighting) al Qaeda. Explaining how the US has 'succeeded' in some areas such as Falluja, Martin then declared, "al Qaeda is hanging out in places like Mosul." If it's "al Qaeda," it's "al Qaeda in Iraq" (or "Mesopotamia") which is a product of the illegal war. In a report that acts as if the US was attacked by Iraq, that's no small point of difference.



Always on the campaign trail, Barack himself appeared on The NewsHour (click here for transcript and video) with Jim Lehrer and what was most obvious was that, like the previous White House occupant, he tires easily. This explains why he (yet again) trotted out his line about how hard it is for him to sign letters . . . Wait, let's let him tell it (in the cleaned up transcript):

But I will tell you that the most sobering things that I do as president relate to the deployment of these young men and women. Signing letters of those who have fallen in battle, it is a constant reminder of how critical these decisions are and the importance of the Commander in Chief, Congress, all of us who are in positions of power to make sure that we have thought through these decisions free of politics and we are doing what's necessary for the safety and security of the American people.

That's Barack, Friday, all tuckered out, so tired that he makes it sound like, after someone dies in Iraq, Barack's stuck signing their letters. "Letters of those"? No, letter to the families of the fallen. Don't blame us, we never spread the lie that Barack was smart. Nor did we ever claim he could speak well. That would be the press which repeatedly cleans his uh-uh-uhs and stumble-bum speaking manner up. Take the exchange with Lehrer. Here's how PBS' transcript says one section took place:

BARACK OBAMA: And I won't lie to you. I wish that they weren't all having to be made at once. It would nice to be able to stage them on one another.



JIM LEHRER: Sure.



BARACK OBAMA: Let's - you know, we'll take, you know, the economy first and then we'll take Afghanistan after that and then Iraq after that and Iran after that and, you know, the banking system somewhere out there, autos, you know. It would be wonderful if we didn't have all the planes in the air at the same time.


Here's the way the above really was spoken:

BARACK OBAMA: I-I I won't lie to you. I-I wish that uh-uh they weren't all having to be made at once. It would nice to be able to stage 'em -- one another.


JIM LEHRER: Sure.

BARACK OBAMA: Let's - you know, we'll take, you know, the economy first and then we'll take Afghanistan after that and then Iraq after that and Iran after that and, you know, uh-uh banking system somewhere out there, autos, you know. It would be wonderful if-if we didn't have all the planes in the air at the same time.

The stumble bum Barack. That is. Not taking in. To account. His pattern of. Creating periods where. There. Are. None. The strip-the-gears way he has of speaking, the start and stop motion that betrays someone with huge fundamental, cognetive problems.

The press created the lie that he could speak well. He can't. And our biggest regret when he speaks today is that he's not wearing a flowing wig. Either a Farrah or one of Tina Turner's from the sixties would work great. That way he could get the hair toss really going as he robotically swings his head from one teleprompter to another. He is stiff, he is robotic and he is one of the worst speakers to ever occupy the White House.


The press refuses to tell you that just like they refuse to tell you he is lying -- and so are they. Washington Week on PBS Friday came closest to getting at the truth. We'll note the following exchange:


Gwen Ifill: And then, Martha, we get to today, in which he goes to Camp Leujune and he says 'we are -- I'm going to keep another campaign promise. I said we were going to be out of Iraq in sixteen months, well, maybe eighteen months, and then he says --

Martha Raddatz: Or nineteen.

Gwen Ifill: Or nineteen. 50,000 troops are going to stay behind. But they'll be gone by 2011. Is any of this possilbe.

Martha Raddatz: I, well, I think first of all you've got to look at his language. Certainly, they're going to start the draw down. And what I've been told is in the next six months, they'll only have eight to ten thousand soldiers and Marines leaving Iraq. The bulk of the draw down that he promised will start in probably January and February and then you'll have 80,000 troops pulling out of Iraq from January to August. That would leave 50,000 trooops. The thing I would quibble with is they will no longer have combat missions. Look at what the mission will be. And General Ray Odierno sent a letter out to the troops today saying essentially their goals would be training Iraqi secruity forces, conducting coordinated counterterrorism mission and protecting our ongoing civilian and military efforts within Iraq. I don't really know how you do that without combat troops and frankly all of the US forces are trained combat troops.


There was a strong discussion on the plan. It offered more reality than most of the 'reports' on other broadcasts did. But even so, it left out an important thing.


We gave you two flags with "Remember that." Hopefully you have.


Barack Obama, the lie says, always said he'd listen to commanders on the ground. Therefore, his blowing off his 16-month 'promise' is not a big deal. Right? That's what he said he'd do, after all.! But it's not what he said.



And it's a damn lie for people to pretend it's what he promised.


During the battle for the Democratic Party's presidential nomination, Hillary Clinton was very clear about what she planned to do. Barack lied the way he always does. He told his wet-pantied-and-briefs crowd one thing and he told reporters another (which rarely received the amplification it needed). Unlike a report read by a few people, the debates were watched by many.



In the debates, Barack was repeatedly clear that withdrawal would start immediately, take 16 months and that there would be no interference with the civilian leadership decision on that. The military could have input on ways to carry out his order but, if president, that would be the order.



Doubt us?


April 16, 2008 debate between Hillary Clinton and Barack, aired on ABC, moderated by Charlie Gibson and George:



GIBSON: And, Senator Obama, your campaign manager, David Plouffe, said, "When he is" -- this is talking about you -- "When he is elected president, we will be out of Iraq in 16 months at the most. There should be no confusion about that." So you'd give the same rock-hard pledge, that no matter what the military commanders said, you would give the order to bring them home?



OBAMA: Because the commander-in-chief sets the mission, Charlie. That's not the role of the generals. And one of the things that's been interesting about the president's approach lately has been to say, "Well, I'm just taking cues from General Petraeus." Well, the president sets the mission. The general and our troops carry out that mission. And, unfortunately, we have had a bad mission set by our civilian leadership, which our military has performed brilliantly. But it is time for us to set a strategy that is going to make the American people safer. Now, I will always listen to our commanders on the ground with respect to tactics, once I've given them a new mission, that we are going to proceed deliberately, in an orderly fashion, out of Iraq, and we are going to have our combat troops out. We will not have permanent bases there. Once I have provided that mission, if they come to me and want to adjust tactics, then I will certainly take their recommendations into consideration. But, ultimately, the buck stops with me as the commander-in-chief.






Is that clear enough for you?





Feb. 21st UT Texas debate between Barack and Hillary Clinton, he declared:


On the issues that have come up that a commander in chief is going to have to make decisions on, I have shown the judgment to lead. That is the leadership that I want to show when I'm president of the United States. On the issues that have come up, that a commander in chief is going to have to make decisions on, I have shown the judgment to lead. That is the leadership that I want to show when I'm president of the United States.



What last week demonstrated is that he is not up to his job. He's either a liar or he's weak-willed. Or maybe both. But let's all drop the lie that what Barack announced on Friday was in keeping with what he promised and that, although it may fudge on the months, he always said he would listen to the military. BOLD FACED LIE. He said he would give the order for a 16-month withdrawal (the mission) and he would take into account their suggestions on how to achieve that mission.





Silver threads and golden needles can't mend these hearts of ours, no, nor can they turn President Pinocchio into a real boy.






More faux change from Barack

From Saturday the 21st through Friday the 27th, the deaths of seven US service members in Iraq were announced. You would never have known that from the bulk of the media coverage which censored the news. The same week that deaths were being censored by the press, the press 'won' the right to photograph coffins of US service members returning to the US . . . maybe.



The story begins this month on February 9th when Barack Obama holds a press conference and CNN's Ed Henry has a question.



Ed Henry: Thank you, Mr. President. You've promised to send more troops to Afghanistan. And since you've been very clear about a time table to withdraw our combat troops from Iraq within 16 months, I wonder what's your time table to withdraw troops eventually from Afghanistan? And related to that, there's a Pentagon policy that bans media coverage of the flag-draped coffins from coming into Dover Air Force Base. And back in 2004, then-Senator Joe Biden said that it was shameful for dead soldiers to be, quote, snuck back into the country under the cover of night. You've promised unprecedented transparency, openness in your government. Will you overturn that policy, so the American people can see the full human cost of war?



Barack: [. . .] Now with respect to the policy of opening up media to loved ones being brought back home, we are in the process of reviewing those policies in conversations with the Department of Defense. So I don't want to give you an answer now, before I've evaluated that review and understand all the implications involved.



A review was in process? With the DoD? No, he damn well lied. The day after the press conference, Secretary of Defense Robert Gates would announce he was starting a review, as Katharine Q. Seelye (New York Times) reported. A review Barack had told America was already taking place. Only Jamie McIntyre (American Journalism Review) dared raise that issue: "The president responded with a classic dodge . . . While President Obama artfully avoided making a promise he might not want to keep, Henry had skillfully fulfilled one of journalism's basic functions: holding elected officials accountable for their own words. It's unclear whether the policy was truly under review before Henry's query put the president on the spot, but by the next day it plainly was."



And last week, Gates had another announcement: The ban had been lifted and photos could be taken . . . sort-of.



CNN reminded that supporters of dropping the ban "point out that the unmarked coffins make it impossible to identify specific remains." That's a basic point and one that needs to be remembered.



Basic points fell by the wayside as the press got ready to stroke off Barack yet again. Somehow Gates' statements were turned into a "new policy!" proclamation by outlets such as The Boston Globe and The Los Angeles Times. By contrast, Ann Scott Tyson (Washington Post) noted Gates was saying he needed "a group of advisers to come up with a plan on how to implement the new policy." (Gates told the press, "I have tasked the working groups to examine ways in which we might further assist the families of those who made the supreme sacrifices for our country" and that the tasks would be completed quickly because there were "short deadlines") .

Ken Fireman (Bloomberg News) explained Gates said "if their families agree" then photos of the coffins can be taken, under circumstances to be decided on at a later time.



The policy was not overturned. Overturning the policy would mean restoring what was in place prior. Instead of doing that, Barack has crafted a new policy.



This policy, the claim is, shows greater 'sensitivity' to the families of survivors. Nonsense. As noted earlier, the coffins are closed. No one's privacy is intruded upon by photos of the coffins being taken. These coffins returning are returning the bodies of US service members sent to a battlefield by the US government. You do not hide the costs of war.



You do not give "kill rights" on news photos.



Barack's latest Hopey Changing is more of the same garbage and should frighten the left. If this is how the Bush policies are to be 'changed,' then there's no change. They're halved and kept. Bully Boy pulled the United States closer to fascism than any White House occupant prior. The idea that his policies can be halved and that's an improvement is the sort of lunacy Medea Benjamin would applaud but no sane person would cheer.



casket04



Russ Kick (The Memory Hole) got the photos (like the one above) out during the Bully Boy Bush years. He didn't do it via a policy asking, "Hey, everybody, are we cool with me publishing these news photos?" Repeating, the news never provides anyone with "kill rights" to a story or photo.
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported License.
 
Poll1 { display:none; }