The Third Estate Sunday Review focuses on politics and culture. We're an online magazine. We don't play nice and we don't kiss butt. In the words of Tuesday Weld: "I do not ever want to be a huge star. Do you think I want a success? I refused "Bonnie and Clyde" because I was nursing at the time but also because deep down I knew that it was going to be a huge success. The same was true of "Bob and Carol and Fred and Sue" or whatever it was called. It reeked of success."
"If I were a lawyer, I tell him he has the Fifth Amendment right to
stuff a sock in his mouth but he's not capable of doing that, and he
continually makes remarks that are frankly incriminating," Conway said
Tuesday on CNN.
Ava and C.I. wrote three pieces. If we had this edition ready, as Rebecca notes in "another republican name endorses kamala harris," meant that Ava and C.I. kept writing different pieces to try to be timely. This is a really strong piece.
This resulted from an e-mail asking why we weren't doing more visuals and why we weren't noting Isaiah's comics of late. We scramble to get an edition together. There are weeks when it's only Ava and C.I. that pull something together.
AP notes, "The United States military and Iraq launched a joint raid targeting
suspected Islamic State group militants in the country's western desert
that killed at least 15 people and saw seven American troops hurt,
officials said Saturday." Haley Britzky, Mary Kay Mallonee and Hamdi Alkhshali (CNN) add:
Five of the personnel were wounded during the operation,
with one evacuated for further treatment. Two other US personnel were
injured “from falls during the operation,” the officials said, with one
having to be evacuated “out of theater for follow on care.”
All of the injured personnel are stable.
NBC News was first to report on the injured US troops.
The early morning raid came after months of
intelligence-gathering, the Iraqi military said Saturday. It said that
the ISIS militants were found in four locations in western Iraq and that
following the raid, an airborne unit was dropped into the locations.
Over the weekend, APA noted, "The foreign minister of Iraq will travel to Washington next month to
make a formal announcement about the withdrawal of American military
forces from the Arab country, informed sources said, APA
reports citing TASNIM." Officially, 2,500 US troops remain in Iraq.
The number is actually much higher. Last month, someone at the US
Embassy in Baghdad shot a woman in an apartment across the way leaving
her hospitalized which has increased the calls for US troops to leave
Iraq. As noted in this snapshot,
the wife of Dr Abdul Amir al-Hazali was praying in her apartment when
she was shot. As we noted then, the shooting resulted in another push
to expel US troops from Iraq:
Abdul Amir Al-Ghazali spoke with ALSUMARIA
and explained to them that the shooting took place on Friday while his
wife was praying. The Badr Organization accuses the US government of
converting the US Embassy in Baghdad into a "military base," condemns
the action citing the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations 1961,
and, citing the Iraqi Constitution (Articles 1, 15, 50 and 109) calls
for Iraq's legislative and executive branches to expel the US military
from Iraq.
The Badr Organization is part of the
alliance that controls the Parliament. Over the weekend, another group
began echoing the call. SABA reports,
"State of Law Coalition member Ahmed Al-Sudani on Sunday said that
Washington is procrastinating in determining the withdrawal paragraph
from Iraq, stressing that the withdrawal of US forces is necessary to
achieve national security. State of Law is former prime minster and
forever thug Nouri al-Maliki's coalition. Arabic social media is
showing some excitement about the upcoming September trip to DC with the
hope that an announcement will be made that US troops are leaving.
Love to see that happen but don't see it happening.
Iraq has postponed announcing an end-date for the US-led
military coalition’s presence in the country due to “recent
developments,” raising questions about the future of US military
presence in the Gulf state amid heightened tension in the region.
Iraq’s Higher Military Commission had aimed to propose an
end date for Operation Inherent Resolve, the US military operation
combatting terror group ISIS.
“We were very close to announcing this agreement, but due to
recent developments, the announcement of the end of the international
coalition’s military mission in Iraq was postponed,” a statement by
Iraq’s foreign ministry said Thursday, without giving further details on
what the “recent developments.”
It's not
happening. And one reason may be found in Friday's incident. Where are
the Iraqi casualties? Even the Iraqi media isn't reporting any. So a
supposed joint-exercise carried out by Iraqi forces and US forces
resulted in no Iraqi injuries? But seven US troops were wounded.
Are
you getting it because what it looks like is the US didn't provide
'support,' the US military carried out the action. Maybe the Iraqis
were part of it from a distance, maybe they weren't. What appears
obvious is that, 21 years after the start of the illegal war, US forces
remain on the ground in Iraq to do the work that the Iraqi military
still can't or won't.
Is this still about
'training'? US forces were clear when Bully Boy Bush occupied the White
House that Iraqi troops were not showing up for training exercises. By
the time Barack Obama became president, it was left to the US State
Dept's Brooke Darby to explain to Congress why the training facility
that US taxpayers built in Iraq was not being used but was, instead,
being boycotted by the Iraqi military.
This has
happened repeatedly over the years and we've documented it here
repeatedly. There's no reason for US forces to still be in Iraq. And
if the Iraqi military isn't up to defending Iraq, that's really their
problem.
"Number one, does the government of Iraq -- whose personnel we intend
to train -- support the program?" asked US House Rep Gary Ackerman
yesterday. "Interviews with senior Iraqi officials by the Special
Inspector General show utter disdain for the program. When the Iraqis
suggest that we take our money and do things instead that are good for
the United States, I think that might be a clue."
That
was Ackerman's important question yesterday afternoon at the House
Foreign Affairs Subcommittee on the Middle East and South Asia hearing
on Iraq. US House Rep Steve Chabot is the Chair of the Subcommittee, US
House Rep Gary Ackerman is the Ranking Member. The first panel was the
State Dept's Brooke Darby. The second panel was the Inspector General
for the Office of the Special Inspector General for Iraq Reconstruction
Stuart W. Bowen and SIGIR's Assistant Inspector General for Iraq Glenn
D. Furbish. [. . .]
Ranking Member Gary Ackerman: When will they be willing to stand up without us?
Brooke Darby: I wish I could answer that question.
Ranking Member Gary Ackerman: Then why are we spending money if we don't have the answer?
[long pause]
Ranking
Member Gary Ackerman: You know, this is turning into what happens after
a bar mitzvah or a Jewish wedding. It's called "a Jewish goodbye."
Everybody keeps saying goodbye but nobody leaves.
Gary said that in a 2012 Congressional hearing. And it's still true today.
US forces need to leave Iraq. US taxpayers need to stop footing the bill for wasted training of Iraqi forces.
And it's really past time that supposed 'joint exercises' are leaving US troops injured but not Iraqi troops.
Is
there still no buy-in on the part of Iraqi forces into the future of
their own country? I have no idea. If there isn't, one reason might by
that US forces refuse to leave.
But 21 years after
the US invasion of Iraq, US forces do not belong on the ground in Iraq
and they should have left long ago. No, they should have never been
sent there to begin with. But I do remember a lot of Americans
insisting US forces would leave Iraq -- a number of those Americans were
in the US Congress and a few still are.
But they dropped the ball. They got distracted. They act as though the Iraq War never happened.
And
not just members of Congress but people who ran for president. Jill
Stein is on her third run. On her previous two she couldn't (wouldn't)
address the Iraq War. But a lot of people think the useless fool is
going to be there ticket to ending the assault on Gaza. Some people are
born stupid but, yes, some people have to work very hard to remain
stupid. All their life.
Speaking of useless trash.
NPR had an article on Gaza. We're not noting it. Jane Arraf was The
Whore of Baghdad. She never broke a story in her years in Iraq. That's
under Saddam, that's throughout. A useless piece of garbage who
refused to report because that might mean her getting kicked out of Iraq
(see Eason Jordan's infamous 2003 NYT column "The News We Kept To
Ourselves" which described the trade CNN made to stay on the ground in
Iraq. That's how Jane 'learned' reporting. And when CNN dumped her
(finally), it didn't matter where she ended up -- THE CHRISTIAN SCIENCE
MONISTOR, ALJAZEERA, NPR, THE NEW YORK TIMES, PBS' THE NEWSHOUR . . .
Since
1991, she's reported badly on Iraq. We used to give her the benefit of
the doubt. Then Twitter came along. And Jane, on Twitter, had actual
news. It never made it into her reports. That included the Iraqi
military attacking protesters. Shooting them dead. But that never made
it into her reporting, did it. And when they attacked protesters in
Tahrir Square in Baghdad -- one of the most ghastly attacks, Jane could
be found on air on NPR stating that it was just tear gas and blah blah
blah.
Reality, they fired on the protesters with live
ammunition. Did they also use tear gas? Yes, they did and they fired a
tear gas cannister into an Iraqi protester's head. That was all over
Twitter but there was Jane Arraf on NPR insisting the response from the
Iraqi military was careful and controlled.
The Whore of Baghdad.
She earned the title.
She
never reported anything bad until every other outlet was reporting it.
Why? That's what she learned at CNN (in fairness, some of her
colleagues have told me that she did that at REUTERS as well before she
joined CNN0.
How do you cover Iraq for decades and never once lead on a story? How do you never once have a scoop?
You do it by being a suck up to the government in Iraq and being too cowardly to report news.
I'm
sitting here and thinking of how long the Iraq War has been. And there
are some people in the US who can be forgiven because they were too
young. So let's note how ghastly the attack on Iraqi protesters was --
this is what Jane Arraf ignored in her supposed 'reporting' on it for
NPR. Dropping back to the October 25, 2018 snapshot:
In addition, Qassim Abdul-Zahra (AP) reports, "Iraqi police fired live shots into the air as well as rubber bullets and
dozens of tear gas canisters on Friday to disperse thousands of
protesters on the streets of Baghdad, sending young demonstrators
running for cover and enveloping a main bridge in the capital with thick
white smoke. One protester was killed and dozens were injured in the
first hours of the protest, security officials said."
The cost of freedom is always high, but Iraqis have always paid it. I’m sorry for the horrible video but this is the democracy USA brought to Iraq a protester been shot in head with tear gas canisters #baghdad#iraq#USA_democracy
/>
0:09
The first one killed is said to have been hit with a tear canister. The
video above is supposed to be of that protester after he was hit.
So,
no, we're not interested in Jane Arraf. Her entire career is
whitewashing -- it's one journalistic crime after another. And when she
does finally cover a story, you can be sure at least five other outlets
have already covered it.
Polio, which has been gone from the
Gaza Strip for decades, is back as the war there continues. But there
is the possibility of good news. Tomorrow, the United Nations will begin
to vaccinate children in Gaza against that preventable and highly
contagious virus. It'll be an enormous effort, one that NPR
international correspondent Aya Batrawy will follow from her base in
Dubai. And she joins us now. Aya, thanks for being with us.
AYA BATRAWY, BYLINE: Thank you, Scott.
SIMON: Tell us about how this vaccination campaign's being rolled out.
BATRAWY:
Well, the U.N. has really big aims here. They want to reach more than
640,000 children across Gaza to give them two courses of the polio
vaccine. It will be given orally in droplets, but it needs refrigeration
at every step, and pretty much Gaza has no electricity. They're just
running on generators and fuel that's in short supply. Another
logistical challenge here is that the whole population is displaced, and
so it's not easy for them to reach U.N.-run clinics. But the U.N.
groups leading this vaccination effort, which is UNICEF and the World
Health Organization, they say the most critical factor is a pause in
airstrikes so that the vaccines can reach all these children. Now,
Israel says it's agreed to short pauses. Basically, it won't attack for
about eight hours a day in specific parts of Gaza for the few days that
this campaign is being rolled out, and Hames says they'll also
cooperate.
SIMON: How did the polio spread there in the first place?
BATRAWY:
Doctors tell me this was a combination of factors. You know, you have
children, Scott, that haven't had access to vaccines, but also most of
Gaza's hospitals have been destroyed or closed. You also have wastewater
treatment plants and desalination plants that have been bombed, so
people have been drinking dirty water to survive. And we know from the
Gaza Health Ministry that more than 40,000 people have been killed by
Israeli fire in this war, but we don't have a tally for people who've
died from illness. However, we know there's been a huge spike in kids
with infections and diarrhea. Children are hungry. They are
malnourished. They're living in these overcrowded shelters or in the
open in tents and with weak immune systems.
SIMON: And do we know how widespread polio could now be in Gaza?
BATRAWY:
Well, there's already been a case confirmed in a 10-month-old baby boy
who was active and crawling, and he's now paralyzed in one leg after
contracting polio. And he is the first case of polio in a
quarter-century in Gaza. Now, it comes after the Gaza Health Ministry
and the World Health Organization - they sounded the alarm on this in
July when they announced that the polio virus had been found in sewage
water flowing in the streets around the tents of displaced people. And
there are now at least two other suspected cases as well. Now, the
symptoms for polio show in one out of every 100 to 1,000 people. So the
doctors I spoke with say this means thousands of people in Gaza likely
already have contracted polio. It is spreading, and one doctor called it
a powder keg.
Yolande Knell (BBC NEWS) notes, "To be effective, the World Health
Organization (WHO) says at least 90% of children under 10 must be
immunised in a short time frame. It
follows the discovery of the first confirmed case of polio in 25 years
in Gaza, with a UN expert saying more children are likely to be infected
and that there could be a wider regional outbreak if the virus is not
dealt with." Amr Mostafa (THE NATIONAL) reports,
"Teams will be
based at the health centres affiliated with the ministry and
international organisations, including the UNRWA, in addition to mobile
teams that will tour the enclave including the camps of the displaced
people, Mr Dahir said. Another round will start on September 17 and will
revisit the same areas. Yousef
Abu Al Reesh, Gaza's deputy minister of health, said vaccination teams
would try to get to as many areas as possible to ensure wide coverage
but he said only a comprehensive ceasefire could guarantee enough
children are reached." The roll out depends on a level of safety and
it's a level that the Israeli government is unwilling to ensure. ALJAZEERA notes that a few children got the vaccine today and that, "On Saturday, the Palestinian Civil Defence agency in Gaza said at least
three people were killed and dozens injured in an Israeli attack in the
vicinity of the al-Ahli Arab Hospital (Baptist Hospital)."
Hersh Goldberg-Polin, an Israeli American taken hostage in
the Oct. 7 Hamas terror attacks, is among six hostages whose bodies were
recovered Saturday.
"With broken hearts, the
Goldberg-Polin family is devastated to announce the death of their
beloved son and brother, Hersh. The family thanks you all for your love
and support and asks for privacy at this time," a family representative
said.
President Joe
Biden said the bodies of Goldberg-Polin and five other hostages held by
Hamas were recovered in a tunnel under Rafah.
A group representing the families of Israeli hostages held
in Gaza has called for the public to mobilize after the Israel Defense
Forces (IDF) reported finding “a number of bodies” in the war-torn
territory.
The demands by the Hostages and Missing Families Forum came as thousands rallied across Israel on Saturday demanding that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu sign a ceasefire-for-hostages deal.
The IDF said in a statement Saturday that it had “located a
number of bodies during combat in the Gaza Strip,” but it has not
confirmed whether any of the bodies are those of hostages and asked the
public to “refrain from spreading rumors.”
However, many Israelis have taken the statement to mean that
more Israeli hostages have been found dead and it has amplified calls
for the government to secure a ceasefire-for-hostages deal.
The Hostages Families Forum, which has confirmed their deaths, has
organised nationwide rallies and hit out at Prime Minister Netanyahu for
failing to secure a ceasefire deal.
"Today, the entire nation
will stand alongside the hostages' families to protest the cabinet's
ongoing neglect if the hostages," it said, calling on the public to join
a demonstration "demanding a complete halt of the country and the
immediate implementation of a deal to release the hostages."
"If
it weren’t for the saboteurs, the excuses, and the spin, the hostages
whose deaths we learned of this morning would probably be alive,” the
forum said on X.
Gaza remains under assault. Day 327 of the assault in the wave that began in October. Binoy Kampmark (DISSIDENT VOICE) points out, "Bloodletting as form; murder as fashion. The ongoing campaign in Gaza
by Israel’s Defence Forces continues without stalling and restriction.
But the burgeoning number of corpses is starting to become a challenge
for the propaganda outlets: How to justify it? Fortunately for Israel,
the United States, its unqualified defender, is happy to provide cover
for murder covered in the sheath of self-defence." CNN has explained, "The Gaza Strip is 'the most dangerous place' in the world to be a child, according to the executive director of the United Nations Children's Fund." ABC NEWS quotes UNICEF's December 9th statement, ""The Gaza Strip is the most dangerous place in the world to be a child.
Scores of children are reportedly being killed and injured on a daily
basis. Entire neighborhoods, where children used to play and go to
school have been turned into stacks of rubble, with no life in them." NBC NEWS notes, "Strong majorities of all voters in the U.S. disapprove of President Joe
Biden’s handling of foreign policy and the Israel-Hamas war, according to the latest national NBC News poll.
The erosion is most pronounced among Democrats, a majority of whom
believe Israel has gone too far in its military action in Gaza." The
slaughter continues. It has displaced over 1 million people per the US
Congressional Research Service. THE NATIONAL notes, "At least 40,691 Palestinian have been killed and 94,060 injured in
Israel's war on Gaza since October 7, the enclave's Health Ministry said
on Saturday. The latest toll includes 89 people killed and 205 injured in the past 48 hours, the ministry added in a statement." Early on, Jessica Corbett (COMMON DREAMS) pointed out, "Academics and legal experts around the world, including Holocaust scholars, have condemned
the six-week Israeli assault of Gaza as genocide." Months ago, United Nations Women noted,
"More than
1.9 million people -- 85 per cent of the total population of Gaza --
have
been displaced, including what UN Women estimates to be nearly 1 million
women and girls. The entire population of Gaza -- roughly 2.2 million
people -- are in crisis levels of of acute food insecurity or worse." Months
ago, AP noted, "About 4,000 people are reported missing." February 7th, Jeremy Scahill explained
on DEMOCRACY NOW! that "there’s an estimated 7,000 or 8,000
Palestinians missing, many of them in graves that are the rubble of
their former home." February 5th, the United Nations' Phillipe
Lazzarini Tweeted:
April 11th, Sharon Zhang (TRUTHOUT) reported, "In addition to the over 34,000 Palestinians who have been counted as
killed in Israel’s genocidal assault so far, there are 13,000
Palestinians in Gaza who are missing, a humanitarian aid group has
estimated, either buried in rubble or mass graves or disappeared into
Israeli prisons. In a report released Thursday, Euro-Med Human Rights Monitor said that the estimate is based on initial reports and that the actual number of people missing is likely even higher."
The
Israeli government's assault on Gaza continues and they've also upped
the assault on the West Bank. No, they aren't the same (as we noted
earlier this week). ALJAZEERA explains:
The occupied West Bank is part of historical Palestine on the west bank of the Jordan River.
It measures 5,650sq km (2,180sq miles) of landlocked territory surrounded by Israel, Jordan and the Dead Sea.
Approximately 3 million Palestinians live there, alongside an
increasing number of Israelis who built illegal settlements and outposts
on land taken by force from Palestinian families.
The West Bank has some 871,000 registered refugees,
a quarter of whom live in 19 refugee camps, descendants of the
Palestinians ethnically cleansed from their homes and lands to make way
for the creation of Israel in the Nakba of 1948.
Israel has launched the largest scale assault of the occupied West Bank for more than 20 years.
Some ministers are demanding that Israel spreads the same
tactics it used in Gaza in the West Bank assaults. This includes forcing
people out of their homes to clear certain areas.
Israel began its fourth day of assaults in the West Bank
on Saturday. Troops fired live bullets and tear gas and rampaged through
parts of the territory backed by helicopters and drones.
Bulldozers followed, destroying homes and roads. Israeli
forces have killed at least 22 Palestinians. Called “Operation Summer
Camps,” the Israeli army has deployed three separate brigades to invade
the northern West Bank cities of Jenin, Tulkarem, and Tubas.
Israel has injured thousands of people, and now they want more revenge on the civilian societies in the West Bank.
The Israeli government decided to annex the West Bank. It wants to go
on taking over our land, so they sectioned 60 percent of the West Bank
right away and put it under their direct control. And they continue to
attack other areas with complete silence from the Palestinian Authority.
Now they are focusing on the refugee camps—their existence means Palestinian people still have an opportunity to return.
Israel is preparing to delete a generation’s memory of the Nakba. By
destroying and evacuating the refugee camps, they destroy the symbol of
the people, of their right to return back.
Site note, I don't usually delete what goes up here. An hour or so ago, "Diana Ross - Say We Can Live @ Workin' Overtime Tour [1989]"
went up. When it did, the video was visible. The 'owner' (ha ha, l
they don't own s**t, they pirated the video from TV but want to pretend
like it's their video) restricted it ten minutes later. While working
on this entry, I put up "Diana Ross - Say We Can Live @ Workin' Overtime Tour [1989]"
and we'll leave that up. "Say We Can" is from Diana's WORKIN' OVERTIME
album and was written by Nile Rogers and Cathy Block.
While
we're noting videos, Friday, we posted Stevie Wonder's new video.
Stevie's an old friend and I cried hugging him in Chicago last week. It
was so good to catch up. Let's note his new video that he released
Friday.
"You're not telling us anything we don't know." So declared Zac and Gavin on the latest VANGUARD as they . . . repeated the points that we've been making for weeks (and made them during Jill's second run for president and at the end of her first run) -- points that they never made before and that went against the last weeks of their pro-Jill Stein propaganda.
But before we get to that, "You're not telling us anything we don't know"?
You know nothing. The two of you are online idiots. You're as bad as MAGA.
Labor Day brought a live broadcast of THE VANGUARD where they talked politics and 'politics' and football and all the other bulls**t that keeps their male fans and their male-identifying fans happy.
"She is an unlikable person," Gavin declared of AOC.
"She" and "person." That's the first time "person" was used. Previously, the boyz were talking about "men" or "men" -- you know, like the men Zac 'polled' while tending bar.
The whole live broadcast was insane.
For
years now, the boyz have been Briahna Joy Gray groupies. We find her
to be a con artist and a grifter and we've noted that repeatedly. But
they've praised her through the roof.
The problem?
Bri-Bri noted that Jimmy Dore was right about something.
This was just too much and the long haired boy had to Tweet to her. And this led to the meltdown and explosion.
She wanted him out of her mentions and apparently long hair's not used to a woman dismissing him.
It
can't be noting Jimmy Dore was right because not only have THE VANGUARD
boyz noted that in the last six months themselves but Jimmy Dore can be
right.
Or could be. We
don't watch him now. But he was right about Force The Vote. He's
become a transphobe and a grifter. We don't watch him. We made an
exception when he had Cornel West on. That interview got a lot of
attention. That interview got a lot of hate hurled Jimmy's way.
We
watched that interview and it was a tough interview. We didn't slam
Jimmy for that. We think interviews should be tough. We also think
that's when Cornel became a real candidate. He'd been treated like a
baby by most -- THE VANGUARD, BREAKING POINTS, most of BLACK POWER MEDIA
(now BLACK LIBERATION MEDIA). Cornel faced serious pushback and it
opened his eyes. He comes alive in that interview and becomes a real
candidate.
We're not Jimmy
fans (we don't support transphobes). But Jimmy deserves credit for the
interview he did. Saying that doesn't make us grifters so we wouldn't
say Bri was a grifter for that statement. Or that THE VANGUARD was for
their previous praise of Jimmy in the last six months.
So let's get to what really happened: Long hair wanted to call her out and Bri didn't want to play.
So
they explode at her in a segment and pretend otherwise. Long hair even
lied that he wasn't trying to put her on the spot. But that's exactly
what he was trying to do.
At the end of the day, does it matter?
In some ways: No.
They
spent forever being fan boyz of a person who didn't deserve fan boyz.
She was never the great legal brain they pretended she was. They fanned
boy over her and then they grew disenchanted.
Is she a grifter?
She
may be, she may not be. We don't watch her. Why? Because life is
just too short. If you know someone has nothing to offer, you learn to
avoid them.
And we try to
avoid THE VANGUARD for the same reason; however, here they were, in the
title of their about to be livestream, going to address Bri-Bri and
Jill Stein.
But
they really didn't. They're cowards and they're fools. Their lack of
education is obvious every time that they open their mouths.
They savaged Bri -- for no good reason.
But they were praising Jill Stein endlessly.
Cornel
has made some comments regarding vaccines that have some people calling
him out. That includes THE HUMANIST and is not just THE VANGUARD.
What did he say?
We don't care. We're not voting for him but we're not attacking him because he's a real candidate. Do we think he'll win?
No.
But
more power to him. He's not a lunatic and ego maniac the way Jill
Stein and Robert F. Kennedy Jr are. (We're also not attacking Chase
Oliver of the Libertarian Party. He is also a real candidate.)
Zac and Cody (as we love to call Zac and Gavin) want to attack Cornel over vaccine remarks.
They
wanted you to know that Jill was great. It was the Green Party. They
wanted you to know that the Greens don't do anything for four years.
They should be building between the elections, they should be doing this
and that. But Jill's great.
If
you're as stupid as Zac and Cody, you may be nodding along. However,
many of you have been reading for years and you grasp our long criticism
of Jill Stein that goes all the way back to her 2012 run.
Zac
and Cody insulted Howie Hawkins who ran as the Green Party's
presidential nominee in 2020. They don't like him but voted for him.
And we're left to wonder why? They do realize that Howie Hawkins is the
only presidential nominee that the Green Party has ever had who did not
disappear after the elections, right?
Because
he didn't. He produced content on YOUTUBE at least once a week. He
addressed Green issues and brought on Greens. In the mid-terms, he
brought on Greens running for office around the country. No one did
that. Cynthia McKinney, after her 2008 run, pursued her education.
Jill disappeared after 2012 and after 2016. The Greens need to work on
building their party -- a point we have long made and one that Zac and
Cody made also -- and the only work on that nationally was done by Howie
Hawkins after his 2020 run. (Howie was highlighted by community sites
-- including this one -- as he did that work up until he came out in
favor of arming Ukraine. We believe in peace and we stopped noting
him.)
The Green Party is awful, Zac and Cody wanted you to know, but Jill is wonderful.
Uh, Jill is the party.
How do you not grasp that?
If
you think the party is awful then you better believe that Jill -- with
enough influence to be their party's presidential nominee three times --
is part of that problem.
And
it's not the Green Party that's the problem. It's the national Green
Party that's the problem. And that's where Jill, among others, has way
too much influence.
It's not just smart people that call her out, it's thinking people. But no one can ever accuse Zac and Cody of thought.
There
are strong chapters in many states that work on building a Green
Party. And they are stymied by the national Green Party which does have
a few -- a very small number -- figures worthy of praise. It also has a
lot of corruption.
Zac
and Cody should be aware of that. They praised Cornel last year. They
praised him for being the Green Party's presidential nominee.
Let's repeat that: They praised him for being the Green Party's presidential nominee.
Point of fact, he was never the party's nominee.
Serial plagiarist Chris Hedges set himself and Cornel up for the People's
Party's presidential ticket. Zac and Cody have never told their viewers
this story. Chris was supposed to be on the ticket. Chris has never
told this story either -- it's the kind of lie and failure to disclose
that led to THE REAL NEWS NETWORK firing him. At the last minute,
Chris' wife said she didn't want him to run so Chris stepped aside. The
slams Cornel took for running as the People's Party's pick for about
one week should have been aimed at Chris as well but people either
stayed silent or lied.
Cornel was then told by Chris and by Jill Stein that he could be the Green Party's nominee.
And while he could have been or not, they then presented him as the nominee.
Again, the Green Party is corrupt on the national level and that's the level Jill operates on.
Cornel
believed what he was told. He was genuinely surprised when Green Party
members -- rank-and-file -- began objecting to this. They were rightly
outraged. That wasn't hate for Cornel. It was their party screwing
them over again. It was a year before their national convention --
where they decide who will be their nominee -- and Jill and Chris were
saying Cornel was the nominee.
That's not how it works.
We
told you about this when it was happening -- and we were kept informed
by the heads of various state chapters as well as Green Party
rank-and-file members. We told you but Zac and Cody never did. A
little too much work for the doofuses to do.
But
when Cornel finally caught on to what was happening, he announced he
was running as an independent. He did that because he was lied to and
because Jill Stein made herself his campaign manager and was trying to
turn him into a puppet.
Did you notice that someone hasn't endorsed Jill, by the way.
Gavin,
tell Zac to stop stroking his beard and his chins and pay attention
because this is where we drop a little news on you and our readers.
(And, Zac, lonely people touch themselves excessively. Try to make some
friends.)
Where's
Chris Hedges' endorsement of Jill Stein? He's endorsed her in the
past. He hasn't this run. Why? Because he's scared to death that
Cornel's going to talk -- to talk more. Cornel's made it very clear
that Jill is a liar and that she tried to dupe him. Chris Hedges, his
friend, did the same thing. And the moment Chris endorses Jill is the
moment Cornel is out for blood and outs both of them for what they did.
We've argued he should have done that long ago.
If
he does, however, don't expect THE VANGUARD to tell you about it. As
Tracy Chapman could easily sing about them, they "come late, when they
come at all."
Idiots and
dupes. On the left, you've got Zac and Cody, attacking Bri as a grifter
(we've seen no proof of that but whatever) while praising the ultimate
grifter Glenn Greenwald. In the very episode they trashed Bri in, they
praised the transphobic liar Glynneth.
Idiots and dupes on the right?
MAGA. They don't raise them any more stupid.
Donald
Trump has been attacking people who served in the US military since he
was president. His campaign recently insulted those who had received
the Medal of Honor. Then last week, there was the Arlington
National Cemetery incident where Donald used the "hallowed ground" for
political purposes -- forbidden and earning him a rebuke from both the
VFW and the US Army -- and his staff also assaulted an employee who
tried to stop the photography and filming from taking place. Now Donald
should have known it was forbidden. He was president once. But
instead of apologizing, he lied and lied again. He offered one story
after another.
And yet there are MAGAs who are too stupid to grasp what took place and are too scared to call him out for what he did.
They're
as stupid as Zac and Gavin. We'll be kind and end there before we go
all in on how much Zac looks like Miss Sassy JD Vance.
Jim (Con't): AP's reporting "Grieving and angry Israelis surged into the streets Sunday night after
six more hostages were found dead in Gaza, chanting 'Now! Now!' as they
demanded that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu reach a cease-fire with Hamas to bring the remaining captives home." Thoughts?
Rebecca: These protests have been taking place for some time. The difference is that they keep getting larger and larger.
Ruth: I'd add, as a Jewish woman, that this goes to the idiotic nonsense of Sarah Silverman, Amy Schumer, Jerry Seinfeld and so many others. It's bad enough that they believe being an American Jew means you have to act as though you're a citizen of Israel, but there's also the fact that they refused to call out Mr. Netanyahu who is now a War Criminal but was already a criminal before the ongoing assault started in October. He has used the assault to distract from the criminal charges he is facing and the likes of Ms. Silverman, Ms. Schumer and Mr. Seinfeld -- among others -- have allowed him to distract, to remain in power and to undermine any cease-fire.
Jim: Ava and C.I. have talked about how fatigue is setting in on this issue.
Elaine: Any crisis in the news becomes less of an outrage the longer is goes on. That's due to the fact that it's no longer new and that's due to the fact that people don't want to feel powerless. The longer an outrage continues, the more powerless people feel.
Mike: And duped. Don't forget duped. Students of today, take it from someone who was a student when the Iraq War first started, a lot of the people you're listening to are con artists. Norman Solomon, for example, pretends like he's all in on your movement. He did the same with Iraq. Seven US soldiers were injured in Iraq Friday. Why? Among other reasons because they're still there. And Norman was the great pretender on Iraq. He was not going to be silenced! He was not going to stop until all US troops were out of Iraq! This was illegal! Then Barack Obama gets elected and Norman's silent on the topic.
Ty: There are two ways we can go on that topic and, due to an e-mail, I'm going to steer us in another direction and we can come back to Iraq and fatigue in a moment. Cassie e-mailed that she appreciates the need to get Kamala Harris elected and to defeat Donald Trump. "I agree," she writes, "that Trump will destroy this country but I don't know that people will join me in holding Harris accountable after the election."
Isaiah: I can understand that worry but it's directed at the wrong camp. We've held Bully Boy Bush and Trump accountable. We held Joe Biden accountable and we held Barack Obama accountable. So that's a valid fear but you're aiming it at the wrong group.
Kat: I'll jump in because she sure is. We went from Bully Boy Bush leaving the White House to Barack moving in and speaking to college campuses about Iraq and no one wanted to hear it. I would be terrified in January when we went to speak to groups, January 2009, because there was this cult around him and people would boo. C.I. could handle it. She would make a joke, everyone would laugh and the tension would vanish. But I don't have her speaking ability and it was scary. It was probably the start of March 2009 when I stopped being nervous. But it was such a huge change in reception. Bully Boy Bush is in the White House and the crowds were for ending the Iraq War. He's out and Barack's in and no one could handle reality.
Dona: To be clear, those signs were there before he got elected. It's an argument we made here several times ahead of the 2008 election about why Hillary Clinton would be the better choice. As president, Hillary wouldn't be able to charm her way out of accountability.
Jess: Right. And in March of 2008, for example, John Nichols and the other lying whores are writing about Samantha Power leaving the campaign and lying about why. It had nothing to do with her calling Hillary a "monster." It had everything to do with her interviews she'd given in England including one that the BBC was about to air where she revealed that Barack's 'promise' to remove all US troops from Iraq within ten months of being sworn in was not a real promise. She said he'd get to the White House and then decide what he would do. But, at the time, he was winning over voters by lying that elect him and all US troops would be out of Iraq.
Stan: He lied and it was going to come out and that's why Samantha Power quit -- being in the campaign when that interview aired meant the press might have to cover it. So she resigned and liars like John Nichols covered for her. I think THE WASHINGTON POST was the only one who treated the interview seriously by actually reporting on it. And this wasn't an accident. THE NEW YORK TIMES lied for him in their interview. He told them that he'd send troops back into Iraq after withdrawing them. He ended up doing that in 2012. But the paper didn't put that in the interview. It was C.I. who took the time to read the transcript of the interview that got posted online to hip you to that.
Cedric: I want to bring Wally in on that. Wally, you know what I mean -- who I mean, our fan.
Wally: Tom Hayden. Tom was forever writing to object to how we worded something or how we emphasized this and not that. Blah blah blah. But Cedric and I did joint-posts and Tom would always e-mail me and not Cedric whom Tom knew was African-American. That made his already embarrassing speech at his son's wedding all the more embarrassing. And I would reply back, "You know Cedric co-writes these. Maybe e-mail him." I did not know him, had never met him at that point. In 2008, I did meet him through C.I. And I did point out to his face that he was refusing to write Cedric and that looked suspect.
Cedric: And Wally always shared the e-mails with me. But there was Tom acting like he was Mr. Racial Justice but couldn't even write a Black man? What a chicken s**t. So it was no surprise when the March interview was going on, Tom was silent. Then July 4th weekend of 2008, Tom wants to act like this is just news -- Samantha's March interview with the BBC. Tom's mad because Barack is now waffling about the ten months publicly. And so Tom writes this lie filled column for HUFFINGTON POST claiming to just have learned about this and lying that it wasn't covered in real time and lying that Hillary Clinton's campaign ignred it and didn't raise it to the press.
Wally: And Tom knew about it in real time. We had a face to face conversation about the BBC interview about six days after it was aired. He was just a liar. Always a liar.
Isaiah: And a coward. How spineless do you have to be in order to be Tom Hayden? Barack's repeatedly publicly sneering at "Tom Hayden Democrats" and Tom can get his tongue off Barack's nut sack? And Tom refused to call Barack out once he was president. There's one moment when it appeared he might have been but even then he was actually distracting from a more salient point about Barack and Iraq. The big news was that, in 2012, Barack sent US special forces back into Iraq and Tom pulled something else from that NEW YORK TIMES report -- by?
C.I.: Tim Arango.
Isaiah: Thank you. So Tom pulls something else from that report to emphasize. iI was planned distraction and he was useless.
Betty: So the point is, the person e-mailing is e-mailing the wrong people. We've never been afraid to call out. We've never backed away. You need to look at Tom Hayden -- well he's dead now. But look at John Nichols, Leslie Cagen, Susan 'Medea' Benjamin and the many others who refused to hold Barack Obama accountable. That includes Norman Solomon and especially David Swanson. And I want to note that when it was obvious Barack was failing to keep his promises, at the end of 2010, you had idiots refusing to hold him accountable and attacking anyone who tried to -- like Latoya Peterson. From Ava and C.I.'s "TV: Hermetically sealed 'independent' media:"
In DC, Latoya participated in a discussion with Marc Steiner, David
Swanson and Norman Solomon. Only Norman bothered to provide even a
slight push-back to Latoya's nonsense.
Her nonsense?
She noted throughout the evening that Barack and the Democratic Party
were not living up to what was needed nor what was promised. At one
point, she was mocking Gloria Feldt and others for saying that people
had to vote and that they could hold the elected accountable after the
election. That, said Latoya, was like giving your lollipops over to the
playground bully hoping he won't beat you up. Yet Marc Steiner floats
the notion of a progressive candidate challenging Barack in 2012 and
Latoya goes spastic.
After Norman's agreed with Steiner, Latoya is pronouncing the idea
"tantamount to a betrayal." What? Yes, according to Latoya, if Barack
is challenged, it would be a betrayal. At this point, she once again
wanted to speak for Latino voters. It was a thread that just didn't die
throughout the broadcast which should have been billed as For Latino Voters Who We Won't Allow To Speak For Themselves. It would be a betrayal "disappointing us," she said including Latinos in her 'us,' and "you need to give this man a chance!"
While David Swanson tried not to look at anyone and awkwardly sat in
silence, Norman had the good sense to challenge her, "Well where is the
betrayal? Are you saying he betrayed us or we're betraying him if we
don't give him a second term on a silver platter?"
"I don't think we should give him a second term on a silver platter,"
insisted Latoya -- apparently eyeing plastic trays at the Dollar General
instead. "I think we need to hold him more accountable. But I think
if White progressives were to say, 'Okay now we're going to chuck this
Black guy, we're going to get somebody else in, we're going to find an
Edwards that doesn't have a scandal . . .'"
She never came up for air and we don't serve in her court so we'll cut
fat mouth off right there to inject some reality. No one had identified
a potential candidate -- not as male or female, and certainly not the
race, How telling that Latoya automatically assumed it would be a White
man. And how stupid is she? Edwards' run for the presidency wasn't
brought down by a sex scandal. That scandal was covered up and only
exploded long after he'd shut down his campaign. In fact, if he hadn't
hid out in a hotel bathroom, he probably could have gotten away with the
scandal. (Edwards, while married to Elizabeth Edwards, had multiple
affairs. One such affair produced a child.)
Betty (Con't): So to the e-mailer, I'd argue, that's on you. You allowed people like John Nichols to get away with grifting. He's on grifter Katie Halper's program despite all of his lies and all of his whoring. And he's part of a big number of lefties that try to present themselves as our voices in the media. If Kamala gets elected, and I pray she does, I will hold her accountable. Don't worry about me, I do what I say I will do. Take care of yourself and stop frequenting political whores like John Nichols and Norman Solomon and Davis Swanson.
Jim: Okay. Now for the part that Ty was saying, about the fork in the road. There's fatigue on Gaza and fatigue on Iraq allowed Iraq to disappear from our radar. A number of supporters of Gaza are trying to harm Kamala's election. That's the only way to describe it.
Marcia: They're writing one attack on her after another. I can't go to COMMON DREAMS because it reads like a right-wing website. I'm sick of it. And it's getting to the point where I don't respect, like or listen to the 'uncommitted' voters be they in Michigan or wherever. I no longer care because you've argued -- while my rights and my very existence is under threat -- that the most important thing in the world to me and the deciding factor on my vote in a US presidential election should be Gaza. Sorry, I'll argue in favor of the Palestinians but I'm not withholding my vote from Kamala. And I'm not part of your movement, you've made sure of that by telling me that the rights of my wife, that my rights don't matter. The MAGA crowd is calling for overturning my rights. They're even calling for gay people to be shot in the back of the head. So, f**k you. I have to protect myself. I don't slam the Palestinians for protecting themselves so why in the world would you slam me for protecting myself? Too may people are coming off freaks.
Ann: And it's pushing away support for Palestinians. These freaks are harming the cause. And if Trump gets back in the White House, the Palestinians are screwed. But they may not be better if Kamala's elected and that has nothing to do with Kamala but everything to do with Democrats. I'm a Green. I'm voting for Kamala but I'm a Green. She'll be the first Democrat I've voted for. Ralph Nader? He lost everything due to his 2000 run. Susan Sarandon? She's still being punished by Democrats. If the election ends up close, you better grasp that the yellow dog Democrats will work to bury the issue of Gaza because of the way its supporters have behaved in this election cycle. And if Trump gets back in the White House? Not only will he go after them but Democrats won't do a thing to stop him because they'll be ticked off. It was always a stupid strategy but it only becomes more ignorant and more harmful with each passing day.
Dona: Someone's going to claim Ann's threatened them. I'm not joking, I know how the e-mails here are. Ann, are you in charge of the Democratic Party?
Ann: No, I'm a Green. And this is what'll likely happen. I know that as a Green who's observed past elections. Am I right, Jess?
Jess: Yeah, you're right. Like Ann, I'm a Green. Ralph Nader's very successful turnout in 2000 did not make Democrats rethink their platform. No electoral move against them ever does. What will? I have no idea because I'm not a Democrat. But I do know that they respond harshly to efforts to get people not to vote Democratic.
Jim: Jess, who are you voting for?
Jess: Kamala Harris. Like Ann, this will be my first time voting a Democrat for president. And don't give me that: We have to vote Green so we have access on the ballots for president in 2028!!!! What, we're going to run that loser a fourth time for president. I'm a Green. I'm not a member of the Jill Stein fan club. That anti-vax nut should have been sent packing after her 2012 loss. Instead, she's our presidential candidate for the third time. I'm not voting for that losing asshole who pretends she's a doctor while preaching that vaccines cause autism. And she chooses other nut jobs to stand with her, people who insist 9/11 didn't happen or it wasn't an attack from foreigners or no planes hit the Twin Towers. She's a nut job who surrounds herself with nut jobs. She's a disgrace and here's a message we can send with out votes as Greens: Stop running the same loser over and over.
Ann: Amen.
Marcia: Betty whatever happened to that idiot Latoya Peterson who insisted a primary challenge to Barack would be a "betrayal"?
Betty: Like most grifters, she moved on to another grift. Her blog RACIALICIOUS is thankfully no more. She does have a Twitter account with that name but hasn't posted there since 2023. She has at least two other Twitter accounts and, again, no posts since 2023.
Marcia: Good riddance.
Jim: Correct me if I'm wrong but I believe everyone participating plans to vote for Kamala. We've never had that moment before. Whether primary season or doing the general election, we've never all been lined up behind one candidate. This is a life changer of an election. The Republican's not Mitt Romney or John McCain. With those candidates, I had disagreements. If they won, I was prepared to roll up my sleeves and fight the next four years. This is different. This is Donald Trump and it's Project 2025 and it's Moms for Bigotry. This is about destroying the advances of the last 100 years. And I'm sorry but when I see their efforts to push child labor, I'm pretty sure that means they'd gladly bring back slavery as well. I'm probably the safest among those of us doing the roundtable. You know, Mike, Jess, Wally and I are straight White men. People of color and women and LGBTQ+ people are the ones being targeted immediately. Our children are being targeted -- all children. The fright wing behind Trump wants to destroy our education system, wants to ban books. And it's a war on knowledge and history. And they're doing that to our schools and our colleges. The University of Virginia is stopping the tours of Thomas Jefferson's home because they can't handle the tour guides noting reality: Jefferson was a slave owner. That's reality, stop trying to hide it. Marcia's "I'm supporting Kamala -- and noting the non-Blacks on the left who aren't" is so important because she is right, Trump gets a second term and, as a Black person, as a woman and as a lesbian, she is the first one they're coming after. And they want to destroy her marriage and they want to destroy Ty's marriage. All they want to do is destroy, not lift up.
Trina: Marcia, Ava, C.I. and I did a piece for a community newsletter on this topic and we quoted from Olay's latest video -- a roundtable that I'd like to insert here because it was an intelligent conversation and those are in short supply.
Jim: We'll put it in and in that piece you four wrote, one of the points was the housing program and the failure of COMMON DREAMS and other supposedly left websites to explore the benefits of programs she is addressing and proposing.
Trina: I can't go anywhere online. Forget WSWS, I had to drop them because they can't cover LGBTQ+ issues -- even the homophobic attacks and transphobic attacks -- physical attacks -- they won't cover it. I have eight children and love them all. One of my sons is gay. And, sorry, like Ruth, I'm not going out with my country attacking LGBTQ+ people or turning back the clocks on them.
Ruth: I think having a gay grandson, having a great friend like Marcia, having a great friend like Ty makes it very personal to me. I think Mike having the same friends and a brother makes it very personal to him. Knowing someone personally who is LGBTQ+ has helped us progress as a society and we can't go back.
Ty: Which is why it's harder and harder for me to address Gaza, to be honest. I'm Black and I'm gay, I'm married to a man. And when Rania whatever and the other YOUTUBERS start frothing like rabid dogs and pretending that Gaza is at stake in this US election? I just lose interest. I'm sorry. And I'm also sorry that they won't let us be joyful about Kamala Harris. Joe Biden? He would have lost this November. It was over. And now we have Kamala as the nominee and it is joyful. But we're not allowed to fill joy? What the hell is that? A great deal of the attacks on Kamala are about sexism and about racism.
Marcia: I do not hate Joe Biden. He did a lot in his four years and he did a lot in his career. I don't agree with everything he did in the Senate or as Vice President or as President. But I do find stuff to applaud and I'm proud to have voted for him in 2020. I would have voted for him in 2024. But it was over, after the debate, when the media painted that debate as worse than it was and spent every day after questioning his capabilities. And I thought it was over -- I thought for those of us who were women, those of us who were Black, those of us who were LGBTQ+, it was really over. I thought democracy stood no chance. So forgive me if I'm not in the mood to be lectured to by a bunch of self-righteous YOUTUBERS who've done nothing to help anyone but themselves. And, yes, I am glad Kamala Harris is our nominee and, yes, I am excited to vote for her. I'm excited to see what she'll do as president. And you better believe that when she needs calling out -- not if, when, all politicians need to be held accountable -- I'll do it. And I won't pussy foot around it or try to sugar coat it.
Jim: Agreed. Now we need to wind down --
Ty: Nope. One more e-mail. It's about C.I. and THE COMMON ILLS and I think Ava should be the one to speak to it. Isla e-mailed to comment on C.I.'s Wednesday snapshot and she writes, "Thank God, she covered it Wednesday morning because it wasn't getting attention, the attacks in Texas on those of us who are Latino. This is very serious. The attorney general of our state trying to intimidate us and scare us away from voter registration and voting. This is an attack on our rights and our freedoms. And it got local coverage but wasn't a national issue when it should have been. This Republican attack on Latinos will register with other Latinos in other states but only if they know about it. And they need to know about it because if they'd do it to us in Texas, the GOP would do it any state that they thought they could get away with it." Ava?
Ava: For those who don't know, I'm a Latina which is probably why Ty's tossing to me -- that and the fact that C.I. and I write a lot of things together about the media and the fact that C.I. said she didn't want to talk at all in this roundtable. Yeah, Isla is correct. I'm in California and I was outraged to learn that the attorney general in Texas, Ken Paxton, was sending armed officers to the homes of Latinos involved in voter registration, barging into their homes at six in the morning, refusing to let them get dressed and treating them like criminals. It's outrageous and it's offensive. There was no legitimate reason for it but it was intended to terrorize the Latino population in Texas. As a Latina, I call it out. CBS did something Wednesday evening and I'd like to include it.
Ava (Con't): Ken Paxton should be carted off in handcuffs for those raids. And Texas Latinos -- Democrats, Republicans, independents and non-voters -- need to especially register what happened. They need to turn out and they need to support Colin Allred for the US Senate and Democrats in every race to send a message to the GOP in Texas and elsewhere that this is not acceptable and we will not ignore it.
Jim: C.I., you and Texas community members Sabina and Francisco have been writing a lot about this over the last few days. Do you know what the last day to register to vote in Texas is?
C.I.: I didn't want to talk but I'll grab this. Sabina and Francisco are doing great work in Texas and it's great to talk to them and amplify them in any way possible. One thing not being reported is that Texas has disabled online voter registration. If you're planning to vote in Texas in November, the first thing you need to do is to check and make sure you weren't purged because Governor Greg Asshole has purged over a million people from the voter rolls. The next thing you need to know is that Greg Asshole has stopped online voter registration. You will need to register by October 7th. That may require you going to your local voter registration officials office. If you're renewing your drivers license or getting a replacement for it, you can register at the DMV. Fall means county fairs and there will be people with booths and tables set up to register voters.. You can also print up an application online and mail it in. You need to move quickly on that because October 7th is the deadline.
Jim: And on that note, we do wind down. This is a rush transcript.
Jim, Dona, Jess, Ty, "Ava" started out this site as five students enrolled in journalism in NY. Now? We're still students. We're in CA. Journalism? The majority scoffs at the notion.
From the start, at the very start, C.I. of The Common Ills has helped with the writing here. C.I.'s part of our core six/gang. (C.I. and Ava write the TV commentaries by themselves.) So that's the six of us. We also credit Dallas as our link locator, soundboard and much more. We try to remember to thank him each week (don't always remember to note it here) but we'll note him in this. So this is a site by the gang/core six: Jim, Dona, Ty, Jess, Ava and C.I. (of The Common Ills).