Sunday, October 09, 2011

They bungled the SOFA coverage as well (C.I.)

Jim: This is a repost of a piece by C.I. Later the same day, she'd be proven correct when the Iraqi Parliament began exploring immunity. All the political blocs agreed to was that they were not (at that point) going to grant immunity themselves. A number of outlets including the notorious New York Times refused to stick to reality and took it upon themselves to 'improve' the news with details they invented.


They bungled the SOFA coverage as well

"Did you ever want to cry?," the Mamas and the Papas wondered on the 1967 classic Deliver. How about right now?

How about reading the nonsense from the New York Times? Specifically this awful article by Tim Arango and Michael S. Schmidt.

Where to begin?

They're covering what we spent 16 paragraphs on in yesterday's snapshot.

And they're doing an awful job of it.

Trainers have been agreed to (yes); however, then they add this, "but they declared that any remaining troops should not be granted immunity from Iraqi law." Really? Because that's not what the statement Jalal Talabani issued said.

It said, the political blocs had agreed they wouldn't grant immunity.

Not "should not."

Last night and this morning I spoke with three friends at the State Dept and two with the White House. State Dept is more cautious and their view is summarized as 'the deal is on track' -- keeping US forces on the ground in Iraq beyond 2011. The White House? All five were asked to give me one word describing the results of the meet-up. State Dept's varied. The two at the White House? "Promising." That was both of their one word choice.

I expect more than a headline crawl from the New York Times. Maybe that's my mistake?

Please note, though Tim Arango was not in Iraq or in charge of the coverage then, they also bungled the SOFA coverage. They were so wrong on the SOFA. They've never apologized for that. They've never even acknowledged that they were wrong.

But having been so grossly wrong then, you'd think they'd be a little more careful today.

They're not.

Why is you get the feeling that the SOFA and the Strategic Framework Agreement are foreign documents, unknowns, to Arango and Schmidt?

The last five paragraphs show promise but a friend with the State Dept was laughing (with me) on the phone as we read over them this morning. They have no damn clue what they're describing. It's as though they're reporting is strung together guesses from 25,000 Pyramid. (Yes, it has been years since I've watched that show. Try the seventies. I'm sure the dollar amount in the title got much higher before the show got axed.)

And the paragraph right before that produced the most howls.

But at least the five paragraphs attempt to go somewhere.

All the other paragraphs add up to little more than a CNN crawl that's been repeatedly teased out, like a bad 50s beehive.

They can't tell you what happened. They have to get creative.

It's a disaster.

Let's assume for a moment that they're correct and that there will be no immunity for US troops, that that was the decision of the meet-up.

Okay, so I assume the paper's reporters covering the State Dept and White House will be leading the questioning at today's State Dept briefing and whatever Jay Carney pulls together on the road today for the White House? I assume that these reporters will be demanding to know how the US military can stay in Iraq without immunity? And that, in addition, Michael R. Gordon will be leading that questioning at the Pentagon's briefing today?

Because that belief is what the paper sells its readers today. So if that's what the paper believes, then surely it will have its best and brightest all over DC today demanding answers. Right?

As 2008 was winding down, members of the administration serving in the Senate were very clear what would happen if the SOFA wasn't passed or a UN mandate wasn't quickly put in place. They were very clear because without either of those, the US military had no immunity.

If you can read Arabic, you should read this article by Al Sabaah whose wording is clear that the meet-up decided they would not grant immunity. (If you're not grasping my point: There's a world of difference between the political blocs saying THEY won't grant immunity and the political blocs stating NO immunity will be granted by anyone. Nouri al-Maliki should have the power to grant immunity in his role as commander in chief as evidenced by the fact that he was granted the right to decide if trainers were needed based upon that role and as evidenced by the Strategic Framework Agreement.)

Not only does the paper fail with their report today, they FAIL to inform why the meet-up was necessary. To read the New York Times solely is to be unaware of Political Stalemate II. Not only have they ignored the NGOs' criticism of this stalemate, they've covered for Nouri by refusing to address the outrage over the non-implementation of the Erbil Agreement. To read the New York Times for Iraq coverage and nothing else is to never know that the Kurds and Iraqiya are on one side and Nouri the other. As an excuse, stupidity only goes so far.

By the way, the State Dept has a legal opinion on contractors and immunity. Before the paper next muses on the topic, they might try asking someone at State to review that opinion with them. Just a thought.

It's cute the way the paper's interested in immunity today. Half-assed, at least. Al Mada reports that Parliament's backing Sabah al-Saadi and not lifting immunity from the MP. See, they skipped that story as well. Nouri al-Maliki, the prime minister, remember?, swore out an arrest warrant on al-Saadi because the MP is a critic of Nouri's and because of a private conversation al-Saadi had in which he told another person that Nouri would face the same ending that Saddam Hussein did. Nouri can't arrest al-Saadi as long as he has immunity -- which all MPs do -- so he's attempted to get Parliament to lift the immunity. Nouri's attorney has stated that if it's not lifted, they'll just wait (years) until Parliament's term ends and then arrest him. It's interesting how that's just not big news to the paper of record.

Yesterday's snapshot
covered the House House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform hearing in which the Committee heard testimony from the Commission on Wartime Contracting in Iraq and Afghanistan. With the Commission's records locked up for decades and only a thin volume released as a report, you might think, if only to review how the Commission spent tax payer dollars, the press would be covering the hearing. Charles Keyes (CNN) covers the hearing here. He may be the only one who did. (I saw Joshy Micah's site. That's not a report of the hearing. But the writer did utilize prepared opening statements to pretend to cover the hearing.)

Reuters notes violence sweeps Iraq today with a Taji roadside bombing injuring four pilgrims, the mayor of Tuz Khurmato being shot dead, a Baghdad grenade attack left two Iraqi soldiers injured, another Baghdad attack left two police officers with bullet wounds, a Baquba attack claimed the lives of 2 Iraqi soldiers with three more injured, and, dropping back to last night, a Baquba boming claimed 1 life and left six more people injured, the corpse of 1 Sahwa was discovered in Qaiyara, and a Taza bombing injured one person.

Occupy Wall St. (Tony Murphy, Workers World)

Repost from Workers World:


Occupy Wall Street leaps to new level

Published Oct 6, 2011 9:23 PM

Oct. 6 — The police have once again proved to their bosses at JPMorgan Chase and Goldman Sachs that they can be relied upon to bust heads to protect Wall Street.


New York, Oct. 5.
WW photos: G. Dunkel

A police riot last night, in which protesters against Wall Street were clubbed and arrested, must be added to the long list of reasons the New York Police Department should be shut down. These include spying on the Muslim community and occupying Black and Latino/a communities.

Just three nights ago, New York cops shot and killed a homeless person outside the New Providence Residence, a substance abuse shelter for women. The reason? She had a knife, they said.

Once again the ongoing police attacks on righteous protests against corporate greed and unemployment must be condemned.

It would be a mistake for the latest police attack to obscure the monumental tipping point solidified yesterday by the Occupy Wall Street movement. It decisively expanded its power and influence by marching with thousands of workers from major unions.

Students from at least a hundred college campuses around the country walked out of class to protest continuing tuition hikes, even as tens of thousands of people were marching in the streets of New York against austerity and Wall Street criminals.

This moment might best be described by the famous statement attributed to V. I. Lenin, leader of the 1917 Russian Revolution: “There are decades where nothing happens; and there are weeks where decades happen.”

A dialectical turning point

This quote is not just a clever description that happens to fit the moment. It is a perfect Marxist explanation of the unfolding occupy movement. It is an explanation of the way true change happens, according to the laws of dialectics.

Dialectics is an academic-sounding word meaning the science of change — or more accurately, the science of development.

One of the laws of dialectics is that everything is in a constant state of change, even if it looks like it’s standing still. The change becomes visible when a qualitative point is reached.

This is true of any inanimate object — even if it’s just sitting there, it may be rusting or decomposing — and it’s also true of society.

In other words, while it has seemed for a long time that things were getting worse and worse under capitalism with no relief in sight, in actuality things were bubbling under the surface until they erupted into the political landscape we see now.

Just this Sept. 17, Occupy Wall Street was an encampment of maybe a hundred people sleeping in New York’s Zucotti Square, with no formal demands and vague leadership.

Today the movement has spread like wildfire, with occupations or Wall Street-focused protests in more than 160 U.S. cities. Chicago’s occupation has just completed its second week. Thousands are expected to march today in Los Angeles. Occupy Madison, Wis., home of the gigantic pro-union demonstrations this spring, begins today.

Probably the most dynamic feature of the occupy movement has been its rapid embrace by so many sectors of society. Students, unions, community groups, people of color, LGBTQ people, the unemployed — thousands have been activated to protest.

Yesterday, members in New York City of 15 of the country’s largest unions — as well as students who walked out of classes at New York University, the City University system, Columbia University and the New School — joined the huge “March in Solidarity with Occupy Wall Street.”


Earlier this week, the Transport Workers Union took a bold stand, filing suit against the NYPD’s commandeering of city buses to ferry masses of arrested protesters. This police practice includes ordering passengers off buses — as if public transportation hasn’t been cut back enough.

In Boston yesterday, Northeastern University students blocked Atlantic Avenue and held a standoff with police. Three buses carrying several hundred nurses from the Massachusetts Nurses Association joined the protest.

Hundreds of State University students in many upstate New York campuses walked out of class.

The last four years’ acceleration of layoffs, foreclosures and looting of pensions came after decades of layoffs, cutbacks, the growth of the prison-industrial complex and the destruction of the socialist camp. This period of reaction could not go on indefinitely.

It was literally only a matter of time before the people rose up again. While it might be tempting to compare this movement with that for civil rights in the 1950s, which inspired the student, Black, gay and women’s liberation uprisings of the late 1960s and early 1970s — the last time this country saw a sustained movement that challenged the status quo — the crucial difference this time is the unemployment crisis.

On Sept. 29 a CEO association called Business Roundtable released the results of a survey of 140 executives. Of those surveyed, the number planning job cuts had more than doubled since the second quarter.

The capitalist crisis has created a movement for which the capitalists have no solution. The eruption of protest nevertheless demands a solution. And this has put the question of socialist revolution squarely on the table.


Occupy Wall St (Socialist Worker)

Repost from Great Britian's Socialist Worker:


Wall Street occupation inspires resistance across the US

comment on article | email | print
Share on: Delicious | Digg | reddit | Facebook | StumbleUpon

Police arrested hundreds in protests at New York’s iconic Brooklyn Bridge (Pic: bogieharmond/Flickr)

Police arrested hundreds in protests at New York’s iconic Brooklyn Bridge (Pic: bogieharmond/Flickr)

by Anindya Bhattacharyya

A left wing protest movement in New York has captured the imagination of ordinary people across the US.

The Occupy Wall Street movement set up camp on 17 September with only a few hundred people. Since then it has grown in numbers and broken into the mainstream US media.

A brutal police clampdown at the weekend drew further attention to the extraordinary scenes in Manhattan. Now similar protests are springing up across the US.

Mary Clinton, a student based in New York and a participant in Occupy Wall Street, spoke to Socialist Worker. “I’m involved with the labour outreach committee, which builds links between the occupation and organised workers,” she said.

“We’re mobilising for a huge march on Wednesday of this week that will bring together labour and community groups with Occupy Wall Street.

“We need labour union support in order to build momentum. At first there was a lot of curiosity but also wariness from the labour movement. But we’ve managed to persuade people that Occupy Wall Street is something they want to get behind.”

Protesters have put together a busy programme of marches and demonstrations to draw attention to their action.

Those marches met a heavy-handed response from the police, but one that has only strengthened the protesters’ resolve, says Mary. “The police reacted brutally—there was a ton of arrests, lots of pepper spray.

“A lot of ordinary Americans were shocked to see this kind of brutality in their backyard. People think we have the right to voice our opinions—so to see videos of mass arrests and so on is really powerful.

“Some 700 of us were arrested last Saturday. It was a pivotal moment for us. We had to organise medical attention, food and water for some of those arrested. It created a strong sense of solidarity.”

Liberty

The occupation is based at Zuccotti Park, a privately owned park in Lower Manhattan. But protesters have reverted to its previous name—Liberty Plaza—partly as a reference to Tahrir Square in Cairo (“tahrir” means “liberation” in Arabic).

“There’s hundreds sleeping out every night,” says Mary. “The weather right now is beautiful, but it’s going to get colder. I’m from the Midwest so I’m pretty used to extreme weather—I’m hoping people here will toughen up!”

The occupation’s processes are a work in progress. “It’s non-hierarchical,” says Mary. “Individuals who see a need or an opportunity come together to form a working group.

“Working groups then report back to the general assembly. Things happen spontaneously, but in an organised fashion.”


Protesters initially got around a media blackout by using the internet and alternative media sources. “Everybody’s got cameras on their cellphones so we can develop our story without being dependent on mainstream media,” says Mary.

“But we were on the front page of the New York Times on Saturday and that was good for getting the word out.”

More than 70 cities across the US now have planning processes or are organising their own occupations.

“It’s really inspiring to know that’s going on. We’ve had an Arab Spring. Now we’re hoping for an American Fall—and the fall of the American empire.”


‘Austerity measures affect all of us’

The US economy has not been immune from the financial crisis. Earlier this year president Barack Obama announced savage cuts to welfare services in order to meet Republican demands for a “balanced budget”.

This has had a profound impact on the lives and political attitudes of ordinary Americans, says Mary.

“The occupation has struck a chord,” she says. “The cuts and closures to social services and education have been hitting a lot of people.

“We talk about how we are the 99 percent and they are the 1 percent—the financial and real estate industries that are running the government.

“People can’t pay their mortgages and have lost their homes, yet Wall Street and the banks got bailed out. So there’s a strong sense that we want to take our country back.

“The austerity measures are affecting all of us, from working class people who depend on social services right up to more middle class people who face losing their homes.

“Student debt is a huge issue—it’s higher than credit card debt. We were told to go to college, that it would pay off when we got a well-paid job. But we’re just not seeing those jobs.

“There’s this juxtaposition—not making the rich pay for this crisis, but instead making working and middle class pay. The millionaires’ tax was not extended. Stock transfer tax was not extended.

“Meanwhile there are cuts to schools, fire services, all the social services we depend upon. People get that—and it has inspired people to fight back.”

Mary said the protesters were inspired by the struggle in Wisconsin earlier this year, when striking workers occupied the state capitol to defend their trade union rights.

“Beforehand people felt that there were a lot of problems but maybe there was nothing we can do about it,” she says. “Wisconsin challenged that apathy and made us realise that there is something we can do about this.

“It didn’t start with the occupation of Wall Street and it won’t end here either. This has inspired people across the country, and it’s so rewarding to be part of something bigger than myself.

“Nobody can predict the revolution awakening. We’ve yet to see where this will go, but I’m looking forward to finding out.”


• Some 700 pilots from United and Continental Airlines marched down Wall Street, protesting about their contracts. The Transport Workers’ Union, the United Federation of Teachers and the Service Employees International Union are among unions backing a march on Wednesday of this week.


© Socialist Worker (unless otherwise stated). You may republish if you include an active link to the original

Highlights

This piece is written by Rebecca of Sex and Politics and Screeds and Attitude, Cedric of Cedric's Big Mix, Kat of Kat's Korner, Betty of Thomas Friedman is a Great Man, Mike of Mikey Likes It!, Elaine of Like Maria Said Paz, Ruth of Ruth's Report, Marcia of SICKOFITRADLZ, Stan of Oh Boy It Never Ends, Ann of Ann's Mega Dub, Isaiah of The World Today Just Nuts and Wally of The Daily Jot. Unless otherwise noted, we picked all highlights.

"I Hate The War" -- most requested highlight for the week. (But don't ask C.I. for comment. She says, "I fell asleep three times while writing that. I have no idea what it says or what its point was an I never plan to read it.")

Isaiah's The World Today Just Nuts "La Femme Barack" -- Isaiah on the Girl Power presidency.

"Super Sugar Crisps," "Frosted Mini Wheats," "4 men, 1 woman," "oatmeal," "Bagels, lox, Matzo Brei," "Corn flakes," "Cap 'n Crunch with Crunch Berries," "Great Grains," "Fruit Loops" and
"Lucky Charms" -- Betty, Trina, Ann, Rebecca, Ruth, Kat, Marcia, Stan, Elaine and Mike weigh in on breakfast in a theme post.

"Who sat Wonkette at the grown ups' table?" and "THIS JUST IN! THEY LOWER US ALL!" -- it is confusing when Wonkette's treated a political expert.

"Chewy Cherry Cookies in the Kitchen" -- Trina offers a tasty recipe.

"Dems try to take over" -- And Trina on the efforts by the Cult of St. Barack to take over the Occupy Wall Street protests.


"Solyndra e-mails," "Solyndra, BlackBerry, press conference" -- some of Ruth's Solyndra coverage.


"Witches" -- Kat talks childhood and beyond.

"Get a damn life, Terry O'Neill" -- Marcia calls out the nonsense.

"Sommersby,""Movie Pass"and "RocknRolla" -- Stan and Elaine cover movies.



"Just Words" -- Isaiah dips into the archives for this one on pretty speeches.

"The Nation and other disasters" -- Elaine shares a memory and an evaluation.

"Idiot of the Week: John Pilger" -- Mike rightly picks John Pilger who is now LYING in print to whore for Julian Assange. And, in doing so, he's going to piss people off all over again. What an idiot.


"THIS JUST IN! HOW LOW CAN HE GO?" and "Princess Barry gets more bad news" -- Wally and Cedric chart Barry O's decline which includes a 55% disapproval rating.


"Solyndra and Jack In The Box" -- Betty joins Ruth in covering Solyndra.

"i had no idea" -- Rebecca explains.


"Wish I'd known before I sat through Snakes On A Plane" -- Marcia weighs in on a hot topic.

Sunday, October 02, 2011

Truest statement of the week

Is this the world we want? Where the president of the United States can place an American citizen, or anyone else for that matter, living outside a war zone on a targeted assassination list, and then have him murdered by drone strike.

This was the very result we at the Center for Constitutional Rights and the ACLU feared when we brought a case in US federal court on behalf of Anwar al-Awlaki's father, hoping to prevent this targeted killing. We lost the case on procedural grounds, but the judge considered the implications of the practice as raising "serious questions", asking:

"Can the executive order the assassination of a US citizen without first affording him any form of judicial process whatsoever, based on the mere assertion that he is a dangerous member of a terrorist organisation?"



-- the Center for Constitutional Right's Michael Ratner, "Anwar al-Awlaki's extrajudicial murder" (Just Left). Michael Ratner co-hosts the radio program Law and Disorder Radio -- a weekly hour long program that airs Monday mornings on WBAI and around the country throughout the week -- with fellow attorneys Heidi Boghosian and Michael S. Smith.

Truest statement of the week II

Every American adult knows what an armed conflict is. The U.S. is engaged in armed conflict in Afghanistan and Libya. It engaged in combat in Iraq from 2003-2011. Thus, every American knows that the U.S. is not engaged in an armed conflict in Yemen - not a real armed conflict. Nevertheless, President Obama placed an American citizen in Yemen on a kill list. Anwar al-Awlaki and several other people were killed on September 20 by a “barrage” of missiles launched from drones operated by the CIA.

The president and his officials know that it is unlawful to kill persons in this way outside of armed conflict hostilities. So they have been asserting the U.S. is in a worldwide “armed conflict with al Qaeda, the Taliban and associated forces.” This assertion defies common sense. So officials also assert we have a right to kill persons who pose an “imminent” threat under the law of self-defense. In fact, the law of self-defense, found in the U.N. Charter, permits force in self-defense on the territory of a state if the state is responsible for a significant armed attack. Yemen is not responsible for any significant armed attacks.

So are we seeing a repeat of the famous “torture memo” strategy? Arguments are being asserted that are just plausible enough to keep Congress, the courts and U.S. allies at bay so targeted killing can continue. Where we once debated the legality, morality and effectiveness of “harsh interrogation methods”, we now discuss the legality of intentionally killing of suspected terrorists far from any actual armed conflict hostilities. In other words, the end justifies the means, especially with a plausible-sounding legal cover story.



-- Mary Ellen O'Connell's "Killing Awlaki was illegal, immoral and dangerous" (CNN).

Truest statement of the week III

"The assassination of Anwar Al-Awlaki by American drone attacks is the latest of many affronts to domestic and international law. The targeted assassination program that started under President Bush and expanded under the Obama Administration essentially grants the executive the power to kill any U.S. citizen deemed a threat, without any judicial oversight, or any of the rights afforded by our Constitution. If we allow such gross overreaches of power to continue, we are setting the stage for increasing erosions of civil liberties and the rule of law.


-- Vince Warren, "CCR Condemns Targeted Assassination of U.S. Citizen Anwar Al-Awlaki" (the Center for Constitutional Rights).

A note to our readers

Hey --

For a change, an early Sunday.


First up, we thank all who participated this edition which includes Dallas and the following:

The Third Estate Sunday Review's Jim, Dona, Ty, Jess and Ava,
Rebecca of Sex and Politics and Screeds and Attitude,
Betty of Thomas Friedman Is a Great Man,
C.I. of The Common Ills and The Third Estate Sunday Review,
Kat of Kat's Korner (of The Common Ills),
Cedric of Cedric's Big Mix,
Mike of Mikey Likes It!,
Elaine of Like Maria Said Paz),
Ruth of Ruth's Report,
Wally of The Daily Jot,
Trina of Trina's Kitchen,
Marcia of SICKOFITRDLZ,
Stan of Oh Boy It Never Ends,
Isaiah of The World Today Just Nuts,
and Ann of Ann's Mega Dub.


What did we come up with?

This week we have three truests and they all focus on the same issue. This is Michael Ratner.
This is Mary Ellen O'Connell who teaches law at Notre Dame.
This is Vince Warren.

And the editorial is on the same topic as the truest statements. This really is one of the most important issues today. A major shift takes place if we accept that the president of the United States can assassinate anyone he wants, that he's judge and jury.

I (Jim) came up with the title. Ava and C.I. asked, after they heard my title, that I explain in the note that I'm referring to adult males who see Shirley Temple as the ideal woman. In this piece, Ava and C.I. tackle three new sitcoms featuring women. This is what they planned to cover last week but got sucked into Saturday Night Live instead. I actually asked them to cover something else but they made it very clear to me that this would be the topic. Reading it, I see why. This is one of those pieces that they write that is immediately popular and then, a year from now, becomes one of those pieces people just can't stop reading. Currently, their three most popular pieces are "TV: Cougar Town Roars," "TV: Aftermath leaves an aftertaste" and "TV: Why bad TV happens to good viewers" -- all three have over 35,000 views according to the "stats" section of Blogger/Blogspot.

We continue to pick ten books of the last ten years that you should look for in your local library.

C.I. brought a wonderful idea into this edition. It was poorly executed and didn't work. "Oh for ___," C.I. finally groaned. "Put it on hold until next week and we'll write it as a short story." We loved that idea. (This is the pitch that Marcia mentioned in a post last week, by the way.) But we were going to be short for the edition. Ava and C.I. wrote this to fill it out.

This was the idea C.I. said at The Common Ills that she would be bringing here. Yes, we finished this one.

A repost from Workers World.
A repost from Socialist Worker (UK).

And Mike and the gang did this and we thank them for it.

That's what we came up with. And we are earlier than we've been in months.



Peace.

-- Jim, Dona, Ty, Jess, Ava and C.I.
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported License.
 
Poll1 { display:none; }