The Third Estate Sunday Review focuses on politics and culture. We're an online magazine. We don't play nice and we don't kiss butt. In the words of Tuesday Weld: "I do not ever want to be a huge star. Do you think I want a success? I refused "Bonnie and Clyde" because I was nursing at the time but also because deep down I knew that it was going to be a huge success. The same was true of "Bob and Carol and Fred and Sue" or whatever it was called. It reeked of success."
Tuesday, April 15, 2025
MEDIA: YOUR FRIENDS & NEIGHBORS and your non-friends too!
Last week, we noted SUITS LA and how awful it is. And it's awful. We were reminded of that as we watched YOUR FRIENDS & NEIGHBORS.
No, not Neil LaBute's 1998 film classic starring Amy Brenneman, Catherine Keener, Jason Patric, Aaron Eckhart, Nastassia Kinski and Ben Stiller. The same title is also the name of the new APPLE TV+ series starring Jon Hamm, Amanda Peet, Mark Tallman and Olivia Munn.
Jon's becoming the Nicole Kidman of male actors. He wrapped up an amazing performance on FARGO in 2024, GOOD OMENS in 2023 and he's currently in this APPLE TV+ series as well as as LANDMAN for PARAMOUNT+. He's also done ten episodes of APPLE's THE MORNING SHOW in 2023 and he's also done five live action films since 2022 which is not counting his voice work on TV and in film. When you're doing that volume of work, you have to choose wisely.
Otherwise, expect the yawn that's greeted Michelle Williams' latest TV wreck -- a pioneering study of the effects of chemo -- is Robert Kennedy Junior a co-producer --which finds the cancer treatment actually increases your sex drive but neither bloats you nor makes your hair fall out.
Who knew?
In the first ten minutes of episode one of YOUR FRIENDS & NEIGHBORS, you know you're watching something special. Coop (Hamm) and Mel (Peet) have broken up and she's got custody of their two kids and the house which is often visited by Nick (Tallman) who is Nick's former friend and the man Coop caught Mel in bed with as their marriage ended. Coop loses his job on trumped up charges and will be lucky to last six months without steady income -- a big problem since his former boss has blackballed him and Coop also signed a contract with a two-year non-compete clause.
Coop could have come off an overgrown manchild and Mel a bitch ex-wife. But the writing is much more layered than that as are the performances. So you care about them and get involved in, caught up in, the dynamics -- so much so that you may forget the first scene in the series -- a scene in the future -- is Coop waking up on the floor next to a dead body
If a show wants to pull you in, they have to make you care about the characters.
Empathy.
We've caught two important discussions on empathy in the last weeks. One was on THE KAREN HUNTER SHOW.
We'd love to tell you that we're prone to empathy for all. But we're not.
People in need, absolutely.
But cheap whore hustlers who preach hate -- who attack empathy to justify their racism, sexism, homophobia, transphobia, et al? We have nothing but contempt for them.
Elizabeth Grace Matthews reminded us of that last week. She's a fat, balding, ugly
woman incapable of any real thought or even a fleeting idea. She
demonstrated that at THE HILL last week when she decided to write
another series of lies and to attack Jane Fonda. Attack Jane Fonda?
Yes, it's how Liz Grace Matt gets her revenge -- remember, she's fat,
balding, ugly and incapable of thought so Jane Fonda frightens her like
no one else can. Jane's the body and the brain, Jane's the can do and
the reach.
Just the thought of Jane terrifies a hate monger like Liz Grace as she wallows in her own filth waiting for some volunteer to show up and hose
her off.
She's offended by Jane's recent speech.
Seeing Jane get the Screen Actors Guild Lifetime Achievement Award, sent Liz Grace into a rage because her own life has been devoid of
applause, absents of pats on the back and lacking even someone calling out
"have a good day."
Realizing
that, at this late date, her joyless life is unlikely to change, Liz
Grace decided to write her own speech full of what she'd say if anyone
was ever stupid enough to hand her a Lifetime Achievement Award
She entitled her hogwash "Yes, masculinity can be toxic, but so can femininity" and no link to trash but do GOOGLE it if you're in a need of a good laugh.
Picture her heaving her tiny bosom and nodding to Jon Voight as she insists, "Fonda
is right: Empathy is not weak -- or woke. At least, not per se. It is
best understood as the impulse and ability to feel and identify with the
feelings of others. Correlated with agreeability, empathy is a
characteristic disproportionately evinced by women." For more fun, picture her pronouncing "per se" as "Percy" because she truly is that stupid.
Just what we quoted should be enough to let you know she's a hatemonger, she's dishonest, and she's a right-wing Christian Nationalist.
Empathy, she wants to lie, is killing the country. Empathy is bad and, to make sure she sells that point in a sexist society, she identifies it with the feminine.
There
are books we've noted repeatedly here over the years. Four that we
mention the most often? Susan Faludi's BACKLASH: THE UNDECLARED WAR ON
AMERICAN WOMEN is one -- and it's famous enough that we doubt it needs
any summary but we'll note Pulitzer Prize winner Faludi looks how
culture shapes work, entertainment and perceptions. We also have
repeatedly noted here Lucy Hughes-Hallett's CLEOPATRA: HISTORIES,
DREAMS AND DISTORTIONS which is another amazing book. That one focuses
on how society imposes their values and standards upon the historical
figure Cleopatra and how she changes for various generations. Stephanie
Coontz's THE WAY WE NEVER WERE: AMERICAN FAMILIES AND THE NOSTALGIA
TRAP which documents how false narratives distort the reality of our
lives -- past, present and future. Carol Tavris' THE MISMEASURE OF
WOMAN: WHY WOMEN ARE NOT THE BETTER SEX, THE INFERIOUR SEX OR THE
OPPOSITE SEX -- a book that debunks a lot of 'science' that is not true
science.
We
recommend all four of those books often and if you've read even one of them
you probably raised an eyebrow when we quoted Liz Grace, "Fonda is
right: Empathy is not weak -- or woke. At least, not per se. It is best
understood as the impulse and ability to feel and identify with the
feelings of others. Correlated with agreeability, empathy is a
characteristic disproportionately evinced by women."
Informed
feminists grasp immediately the problem there. Who's defining empathy
and how are they defining it?
Feminists are common sense people. We're also informed people.
Unlike Liz Grace who thinks she's cribbing the second part of that
sentence from a 2014 'study' but its roots are pure Leon Trotsky.
Empathy,
despite the many useless words Liz Grace offers, is not a feminine
trait. It's a trait that all humans share. Some are conditioned to
exhibit in one way, some in another. Historically, the most empathetic
figure spoken of would be Jesus Christ.
Maybe
Liz Grace doesn't believe in Jesus? Even if she doesn't, she should be
aware that the concept of Jesus has been used throughout history to
teach empathy. In fact, THE BIBLE is filled with empathy -- even if
she's a non-believer, we would encourage Liz Grace to read it -- such as
Romans 12:15 which has the Lord declaring, "Rejoice with those who
rejoice, weep with those who weep."
Here's Liz Grace: "What
Fonda is really implying, though -- and what today’s most vocal
leftists uniformly believe — is that empathy is a virtue unto itself
when indiscriminately deployed on behalf of the systemically
marginalized. Or, as Fonda put it: 'Woke just means you give a damn
about other people'. "
Again, here's what the Lord states, "Rejoice with those who rejoice, weep with those who weep."
Sorry,
Liz Grace, hope you're not thinking you're headed to heaven because the
Lord may need to have a word with you first. It's Jane Fonda's remarks that
line up with the teachings of Jesus, not your own.
Enemies of empathy make up the Christian Nationalist front in this country just as they made up the Nazi Party in the Germany.
You can't kill innocents and embrace empathy. You have to scorn empathy and you have to 'other' (as a verb) human beings in order to send them into gas chambers.
The second video we saw in the last weeks that was really good on the topic of empathy
was this one by Dan McClellan
.
People rightly express concern over the 'bro' podcasts. But is anyone paying attention to the vile the fright-wing hate mongers are putting out there? There is an attack on empathy and they have to launch that attack because without it, they're not going to be able to do all the evil things they hope to do. They can't destroy Social Security without destroying empathy, the can't destroy Civil Rights without destroying empathy, they can't deports thousands without destroying empathy.
So they work overtime to attack empathy and to insist that this basic virtue, preached by Jesus, is a bad thing.
They have to tell that lie and they have to convince others of that lie in order to destroy, main and kill and, yes, that is their end-game.
Empathy is not an emotion Liz Grace possesses. She makes this clear:
This
is the false belief that makes today’s elite left and its predominantly
educated, female adherents so out of touch with everyday Americans —
and, as I have written, so apt to hurt the very people they purport to
help. For example, in the name of fighting institutionalized racism,
they agitate to eliminate the tools of law and order that majorities of
people of every demographic are depending upon to keep them safe.
Or,
for another example, they welcome male athletes claiming a transgender
identity onto female teams, and thereby endanger and disenfranchise the
women for whom those teams exist.
Leave
it to the deeply stupid Liz Grace to rally against the "predominantly
educated." Give them the chance and they'll always confess to more than they ever realize. Their compulsion to confess might be interesting but nothing about the Liz Graces themselves is fascinating, wanted or needed -- which would make them perfect for cast members on SUITS LA.
Jim, Dona, Jess, Ty, "Ava" started out this site as five students enrolled in journalism in NY. Now? We're still students. We're in CA. Journalism? The majority scoffs at the notion.
From the start, at the very start, C.I. of The Common Ills has helped with the writing here. C.I.'s part of our core six/gang. (C.I. and Ava write the TV commentaries by themselves.) So that's the six of us. We also credit Dallas as our link locator, soundboard and much more. We try to remember to thank him each week (don't always remember to note it here) but we'll note him in this. So this is a site by the gang/core six: Jim, Dona, Ty, Jess, Ava and C.I. (of The Common Ills).