The Third Estate Sunday Review focuses on politics and culture. We're an online magazine. We don't play nice and we don't kiss butt. In the words of Tuesday Weld: "I do not ever want to be a huge star. Do you think I want a success? I refused "Bonnie and Clyde" because I was nursing at the time but also because deep down I knew that it was going to be a huge success. The same was true of "Bob and Carol and Fred and Sue" or whatever it was called. It reeked of success."
Monday, August 21, 2017
Truest statement of the week
The scoundrels and misleaders in the Democratic Party are leaving no stone unturned in their effort to escape responsibility for their ignominious defeats. There is no evidence of the Russian government “hacking” the election. Instead evidence points to a leak at the Democratic National Committee which revealed the gory details of their corruption and incompetence.
The lies have fallen apart one by one. After months of repeating that seventeen intelligence agencies agreed on Russian election interference they finally admitted that the number was actually three. The Democratic Party is willing to risk hot war and irreparable damage to the system in order to escape blame for their electoral failures. They have been exposed as little more than a brand management team that does nothing to help the millions of people who are still willing to vote for them.
Members of the Congressional Black Caucus such as Barbara Lee and Maxine Waters have been in the forefront of this charade and now they have been joined by others. The Root online magazine announced it is joining this dubious group in doing the business of the bipartisan war party and the discredited democrats. “How Russia Used Racism to Hack White Voters” was the first installment in a new series, Black Guide to Russia. The Root promises that “each story will analyze the latest developments of the Russia investigation with a fresh, black perspective.” What is the black perspective on 21st century McCarthyism, on the craving for endless war or supporting the party which consigns black voters to the losers’ column?
-- Margaret Kimberley, "Freedom Rider: The Root and Russophobia" (BLACK AGENDA REPORT).
Truest statement of the week II
Four Michigan Democrats running for governor in the 2018 election
spoke in Flint on August 12 at a town hall forum. The event, billed as
the kick-off in the contest for the Democratic gubernatorial nomination,
was held in Flint, the former center of General Motors auto production
and symbol of social devastation caused by mass layoffs and plant
closures. The city of 100,000 recently gained national and international
attention as a result of a health crisis caused by the lead poisoning
of its water supply by state and local authorities.
The decision to hold the initial Democratic campaign event in Flint was presented as a sign of the Democratic Party’s sensitivity to the ongoing problems faced by Flint residents as a result of the water crisis, and the party’s commitment to address them. The Democrats are fearful of the anger among Flint workers and youth over the failure of the government to take any serious measures to address the water crisis. Their aim is to contain and dissipate that anger.
What the town hall forum in fact demonstrated was the indifference of the Democratic Party to the crisis facing Flint workers and its inability to propose any serious policies to address either the immediate crisis or the longer-term economic and health issues facing Flint residents, especially children, whose mental and physical development has been jeopardized by exposure to toxic levels of lead. The event was an exercise in cynicism and political evasion.
-- WSWS, "Democratic gubernatorial town hall in Flint: No policies to address lead poisoning disaster."
The decision to hold the initial Democratic campaign event in Flint was presented as a sign of the Democratic Party’s sensitivity to the ongoing problems faced by Flint residents as a result of the water crisis, and the party’s commitment to address them. The Democrats are fearful of the anger among Flint workers and youth over the failure of the government to take any serious measures to address the water crisis. Their aim is to contain and dissipate that anger.
What the town hall forum in fact demonstrated was the indifference of the Democratic Party to the crisis facing Flint workers and its inability to propose any serious policies to address either the immediate crisis or the longer-term economic and health issues facing Flint residents, especially children, whose mental and physical development has been jeopardized by exposure to toxic levels of lead. The event was an exercise in cynicism and political evasion.
-- WSWS, "Democratic gubernatorial town hall in Flint: No policies to address lead poisoning disaster."
A note to our readers
Hey --
A Sunday.
Somehow we did it four weeks in a row.
Let's thank all who participated this edition which includes Dallas and the following:
The Third Estate Sunday Review's Jim, Dona, Ty, Jess and Ava,
Rebecca of Sex and Politics and Screeds and Attitude,
Betty of Thomas Friedman Is a Great Man,
C.I. of The Common Ills and The Third Estate Sunday Review,
Kat of Kat's Korner (of The Common Ills),
Mike of Mikey Likes It!,
Elaine of Like Maria Said Paz),
Cedric of Cedric's Big Mix,
Ruth of Ruth's Report,
Wally of The Daily Jot,
Trina of Trina's Kitchen,
Marcia of SICKOFITRDLZ,
Stan of Oh Boy It Never Ends,
Isaiah of The World Today Just Nuts,
and Ann of Ann's Mega Dub.
And what did we come up with?
Peace,
-- Jim, Dona, Ty, Jess, Ava and C.I.
A Sunday.
Somehow we did it four weeks in a row.
Let's thank all who participated this edition which includes Dallas and the following:
The Third Estate Sunday Review's Jim, Dona, Ty, Jess and Ava,
Rebecca of Sex and Politics and Screeds and Attitude,
Betty of Thomas Friedman Is a Great Man,
C.I. of The Common Ills and The Third Estate Sunday Review,
Kat of Kat's Korner (of The Common Ills),
Mike of Mikey Likes It!,
Elaine of Like Maria Said Paz),
Cedric of Cedric's Big Mix,
Ruth of Ruth's Report,
Wally of The Daily Jot,
Trina of Trina's Kitchen,
Marcia of SICKOFITRDLZ,
Stan of Oh Boy It Never Ends,
Isaiah of The World Today Just Nuts,
and Ann of Ann's Mega Dub.
And what did we come up with?
Another truest from Margaret Kimberley.
A truest for WSWS.
How did we get this out of order? Who knows? We'll let it stand. Ava and C.I.'s review of NETFLIX's latest.
And it always has been.
Your feedback on the Emmy nominees who should have been.
Let's try to be rational.
Seriously.
Greenpeace got very little attention.
As did this action. Repost from Party of Socialism and Liberation.
Repost from Great Britain's SOCIALIST WORKER.
What we listened to while writing.Peace,
-- Jim, Dona, Ty, Jess, Ava and C.I.
Editorial: Truth is hard for PBS
More than 1 million people once lived in Mosul, Iraq, a city reduced to rubble after three years of ISIS occupation.
2 replies7 retweets6 likes
Really?
Mosul reduced to rubble over the last three years?
Kind of seems like it was reduced to rubble during The Mosul Slog which started in October of last year.
By the way, how many hard hitting stories did PBS do on the War Crimes carried out by the militiais in Iraq during The Mosul Slog?
Right, zero.
Thanks PBS.
Keep distracting with BS -- the same way you did in the lead up to the Iraq War.
xx
TV: The disappointing DEFENDERS
Friday, NETFLIX debuted THE DEFENDERS.
Eight episodes unraveled, pulling four previous shows together DAREDEVIL (two seasons aired so far), JESSICA JONES (one season so far), LUKE CAGE (one season) and THE IRON FIST (one season).
It could have been an opportunity for The Water Cooler Set to rethink their trashing of THE IRON FIST and Finn Jones.
Finn Jones, you may remember, was trashed for playing the character of the Iron Fist by people who felt the White character in the comics should have been retooled into another race.
They didn't have that feeling, remember, about either Jessica Jones or Matt Murdoch (Daredevil).
As they wrote their attacks, it became obvious that (a) they didn't know about the character Iron Fist and (b) they didn't understand contrasts.
Krysten Ritter was rightly praised for the character of Jessica Jones -- brash and haunted. Charlie Cox's portrayal of Daredevil benefited largely from the atmosphere of the first season (season two didn't have the same power). Mike Colter's Luke Cage was filled with promise (that still hasn't panned out).
Then there's Danny the Iron Fist.
He has/had idealism -- something missing in the other three.
For that he was slammed.
Is Superman slammed for that?
Danny was "Moon River." Henry Mancini's one octave and a note song Audrey Hepburn could sing, all white keys -- no sharps, no flats.
IRON FIST was far more popular outside The Water Cooler Set because Danny was actually the traditional superhero.
(You can even argue that neither Jessica Jones nor Luke Cage currently qualifies as a superhero -- you can even argue that, though no one from The Water Cooler Set did.)
In THE DEFENDERS, Finn's Danny at times seems to be the only contrast and you long for Luke and Jessica especially to stop trying to out bad ass the other.
Colter's best moments are not with either Cox or Ritter -- or even Rosaria Dawson who again plays Claire and again manages to hold your attention.
His best moments, his only fresh moments, come from his interaction with Jones.
Probably because so many of the other characters are minor keys not fully developed.
Brooding only goes so far in the action genre.
Much is made of Colter and Jones' discussion about privilege. Did everyone miss the slow build up to friendship that happened in subsequent episodes?
If Jones' Danny is the high point of THE DEFENDERS, what's the low point?
Probably when Sigourney Weaver's Alexandra dies.
Weaver makes Alexandra fresh and fierce and we need her especially in those early episodes where the rhythm hasn't hit its stride and things aren't adding up.
That said, it never really adds up.
Daredevil dies in the big climax.
You know, like Superman in BATMAN V. SUPERMAN: DAWN OF JUSTICE?
And, like Superman, at the end of that movie, it turns out Daredevil isn't really dead.
But it kind of feels like MARVEL's NETFLIX franchise is.
A team up of Luke Cage and Danny Rand (in the comics, they were teamed for POWER MAN & IRON FIST) might be interesting.
But even THE DEFENDERS is a let down.
Readers of the comic at its height can be forgiven for wondering: Who the hell are these characters?
Except for Luke Cage, they're not The Defenders.
Where's Hellcat and Valkyrie?
Oh, yeah, that's the other thing.
Jessica Jones.
Four characters, still only female superhero.
At their most popular, THE DEFENDERS comic book featured at least two women on the team: Hellcat and Valkyrie.
Why are we accepting this?
Yes, Weaver is a villain and Elektra's brought back to life to be a villain.
But why are we not noticing that in 2017, there really aren't super heroines on NETFLIX?
Grasp that, unlike the faux Social Justice Warriors of The Water Cooler Set, we're not asking that an existing character has their gender changed -- the way they trashed Jones' Danny for not being any other race than White.
No, we're asking that a series called THE DEFENDERS, loosely based on the comic book of the same name, feature two female characters who were part of the team.
From issue four of THE DEFENDERS to the conclusion of the comic book title, Valkyrie was a member.
Hellcat?
Yes, Trish Walker is a version of the character -- Jessica Jones' friend and adopted sister. But she's a powerless version of her.
Hellcat is a member from issue 44 to 124 (issue 125 starts THE NEW DEFENDERS).
Why are we applauding a mini-series that features only one female super hero?
We're not.
Strip away Colter, Jones and Weaver and THE DEFENDERS has little to offer.
It seems to just tick off cameos and plot points as what should have been a rallying cry instead goes out as a sotto voiced whisper.
Eight episodes unraveled, pulling four previous shows together DAREDEVIL (two seasons aired so far), JESSICA JONES (one season so far), LUKE CAGE (one season) and THE IRON FIST (one season).
It could have been an opportunity for The Water Cooler Set to rethink their trashing of THE IRON FIST and Finn Jones.
Finn Jones, you may remember, was trashed for playing the character of the Iron Fist by people who felt the White character in the comics should have been retooled into another race.
They didn't have that feeling, remember, about either Jessica Jones or Matt Murdoch (Daredevil).
As they wrote their attacks, it became obvious that (a) they didn't know about the character Iron Fist and (b) they didn't understand contrasts.
Krysten Ritter was rightly praised for the character of Jessica Jones -- brash and haunted. Charlie Cox's portrayal of Daredevil benefited largely from the atmosphere of the first season (season two didn't have the same power). Mike Colter's Luke Cage was filled with promise (that still hasn't panned out).
Then there's Danny the Iron Fist.
He has/had idealism -- something missing in the other three.
For that he was slammed.
Is Superman slammed for that?
Danny was "Moon River." Henry Mancini's one octave and a note song Audrey Hepburn could sing, all white keys -- no sharps, no flats.
IRON FIST was far more popular outside The Water Cooler Set because Danny was actually the traditional superhero.
(You can even argue that neither Jessica Jones nor Luke Cage currently qualifies as a superhero -- you can even argue that, though no one from The Water Cooler Set did.)
In THE DEFENDERS, Finn's Danny at times seems to be the only contrast and you long for Luke and Jessica especially to stop trying to out bad ass the other.
Colter's best moments are not with either Cox or Ritter -- or even Rosaria Dawson who again plays Claire and again manages to hold your attention.
His best moments, his only fresh moments, come from his interaction with Jones.
Probably because so many of the other characters are minor keys not fully developed.
Brooding only goes so far in the action genre.
Much is made of Colter and Jones' discussion about privilege. Did everyone miss the slow build up to friendship that happened in subsequent episodes?
If Jones' Danny is the high point of THE DEFENDERS, what's the low point?
Probably when Sigourney Weaver's Alexandra dies.
Weaver makes Alexandra fresh and fierce and we need her especially in those early episodes where the rhythm hasn't hit its stride and things aren't adding up.
That said, it never really adds up.
Daredevil dies in the big climax.
You know, like Superman in BATMAN V. SUPERMAN: DAWN OF JUSTICE?
And, like Superman, at the end of that movie, it turns out Daredevil isn't really dead.
But it kind of feels like MARVEL's NETFLIX franchise is.
A team up of Luke Cage and Danny Rand (in the comics, they were teamed for POWER MAN & IRON FIST) might be interesting.
But even THE DEFENDERS is a let down.
Readers of the comic at its height can be forgiven for wondering: Who the hell are these characters?
Except for Luke Cage, they're not The Defenders.
Where's Hellcat and Valkyrie?
Oh, yeah, that's the other thing.
Jessica Jones.
Four characters, still only female superhero.
At their most popular, THE DEFENDERS comic book featured at least two women on the team: Hellcat and Valkyrie.
Why are we accepting this?
Yes, Weaver is a villain and Elektra's brought back to life to be a villain.
But why are we not noticing that in 2017, there really aren't super heroines on NETFLIX?
Grasp that, unlike the faux Social Justice Warriors of The Water Cooler Set, we're not asking that an existing character has their gender changed -- the way they trashed Jones' Danny for not being any other race than White.
No, we're asking that a series called THE DEFENDERS, loosely based on the comic book of the same name, feature two female characters who were part of the team.
From issue four of THE DEFENDERS to the conclusion of the comic book title, Valkyrie was a member.
Hellcat?
Yes, Trish Walker is a version of the character -- Jessica Jones' friend and adopted sister. But she's a powerless version of her.
Hellcat is a member from issue 44 to 124 (issue 125 starts THE NEW DEFENDERS).
Why are we applauding a mini-series that features only one female super hero?
We're not.
Strip away Colter, Jones and Weaver and THE DEFENDERS has little to offer.
It seems to just tick off cameos and plot points as what should have been a rallying cry instead goes out as a sotto voiced whisper.
The ten we missed
Back in July, we offered "The Acting nominations that should have been." Here are the top ten people readers said we overlooked.
1) Jennifer Lopez.
Her portrayal on SHADES OF BLUE has been praised here and we readily agree with readers that it was an oversight that we did not include her on the list for BEST ACTRESS in the drama category. She clearly had earned a right to be on the list. Well over 50% of the e-mails pointed that out and we do not dispute the point in the least.
After Lopez, the next three were all from the same show.
2, 3 and 4) Dan Stevens, Jean Smart and Aubrey Plaza.
The three were in FX's LEGION. Stevens, some readers felt, should have been nominated for BEST ACTOR while Smart and Plaza should have been nominated for BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS.
5) Aja Naomi King.
King plays Michaela Pratt on HOW TO GET AWAY WITH MURDER. Last season was a standout for her and many e-mails argued she deserved a nomination for BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS.
6 and 7) Rami Malek and Christian Slater.
Readers pointed out Rami Malek had won the Emmy for BEST ACTOR last go round but wasn't nominated this time by the Emmys or by us on our July list. They felt this was an oversight. They also felt Christian Slater had earned a supporting nomination for the same series.
8) Gavin Houston.
Oprah Winfrey's OWN network is often overlooked but many readers felt Gavin Houston had more than earned an Emmy nomination for his performance of Jeffrey Harrington on OWN's THE HAVES AND THE HAVE NOTS.
9) David Alan Grier.
THE CARMICHAEL SHOW wrapped up its final season this month and did so, a number of you noted, without ever getting an Emmy acting nomination. Those readers noting this felt David Alan Grier had more than earned a supporting actor nod.
10) Kat Dennings.
2 BROKE GIRLS' Kat Dennings also never received a nomination for her comedic work. As many of you pointed out, Julia Louis-Dreyfus' automatic nomination has made Louis-Dreyfus the most overrated actress currently working.
Estrenando Nueva Música... #NiTuNiYo #July42017
1,102 replies2,802 retweets17,123 likes
1) Jennifer Lopez.
Her portrayal on SHADES OF BLUE has been praised here and we readily agree with readers that it was an oversight that we did not include her on the list for BEST ACTRESS in the drama category. She clearly had earned a right to be on the list. Well over 50% of the e-mails pointed that out and we do not dispute the point in the least.
After Lopez, the next three were all from the same show.
2, 3 and 4) Dan Stevens, Jean Smart and Aubrey Plaza.
The three were in FX's LEGION. Stevens, some readers felt, should have been nominated for BEST ACTOR while Smart and Plaza should have been nominated for BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS.
5) Aja Naomi King.
King plays Michaela Pratt on HOW TO GET AWAY WITH MURDER. Last season was a standout for her and many e-mails argued she deserved a nomination for BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS.
6 and 7) Rami Malek and Christian Slater.
Readers pointed out Rami Malek had won the Emmy for BEST ACTOR last go round but wasn't nominated this time by the Emmys or by us on our July list. They felt this was an oversight. They also felt Christian Slater had earned a supporting nomination for the same series.
8) Gavin Houston.
Oprah Winfrey's OWN network is often overlooked but many readers felt Gavin Houston had more than earned an Emmy nomination for his performance of Jeffrey Harrington on OWN's THE HAVES AND THE HAVE NOTS.
9) David Alan Grier.
THE CARMICHAEL SHOW wrapped up its final season this month and did so, a number of you noted, without ever getting an Emmy acting nomination. Those readers noting this felt David Alan Grier had more than earned a supporting actor nod.
10) Kat Dennings.
2 BROKE GIRLS' Kat Dennings also never received a nomination for her comedic work. As many of you pointed out, Julia Louis-Dreyfus' automatic nomination has made Louis-Dreyfus the most overrated actress currently working.
On monuments
Well I looked at the granite markers
Those tribute to finality to eternity
And then I looked at myself here
Chicken scratching for my immortality
-- "Hejira," written by Joni Mitchell, first appears on her album of the same name
Chicken scratching for some immortality.
Can we all grasp that everyone -- as many as 50% in PBS' poll last week -- objecting to demolishing statues is not a racist?
Can we agree that a lot of people have a problem with change, regardless of what the change is?
Ourselves?
We believe history is ever changing, constantly being re-evaluated.
And we believe Lucy Hughes-Hallett more than established that with her book CLEOPATRA: HISTORIES, DREAMS AND DISTORTIONS as she examined how history, throughout history, had portrayed various versions of Cleopatra. As Hughes-Hallett notes in the opening of her book:
A story is a protean thing, changing its nature as well as its shape when viewed from different angles. A single set of facts, arranged and rearranged, can point to a variety of contradictory conclusions. The vicissitudes of Cleopatra's legend, to which so many different morals have been attached, may act as a reminder that even the simplest piece of information can be made to serve a polemical purpose. Every story-teller, whether journalist, historian, poet or entertainer, is also -- willy nilly -- something of a propagandist.
We learn as time goes along, we hopefully advance.
As such, we re-examine.
What once seemed triumphant now appears to be a wreck.
It's called learning, it's called evolving.
We don't disagree that some statues need to be removed -- and certainly include the statue of J. Marion Sims in Central Park.
At one time in our history, the 'good doctor' was considered praise worthy.
Today, we're advanced enough to agree that forced experimentation on women who had no say in the matter is not just wrong, it's criminal.
Future generations will always reflect and reconsider -- that is their right.
And in that struggle to sort things out, to rethink, some monuments will come down.
Change happens.
And for some it is a struggle.
That doesn't make them racist or bad people.
It just means that some people are always going to be scared of change.
How about they stick to reporting?
On Sunday's RELIABLE SOURCES, personality Brian Stelter wondered if journalists should not begin questioning the sanity of US President Donald Trump.
Because?
That's what the media does?
We realize it's not as fun as gas bagging but the media is supposed to report.
It's not supposed to concern itself with playing therapist.
It's not supposed to put people on the couch.
We grasp that Brian Stelter has never grasped journalism.
We get that.
But shame on anyone who pretends that those barely trained to perform journalism are now capable of determining someone's mental capacity.
In the meantime, let's ask a more easily answered question.
Is Brian Stelter too ugly to be on TV?
Yes.
If the president is "unfit" -- then what?
151 replies184 retweets371 likes
Because?
That's what the media does?
We realize it's not as fun as gas bagging but the media is supposed to report.
It's not supposed to concern itself with playing therapist.
It's not supposed to put people on the couch.
We grasp that Brian Stelter has never grasped journalism.
We get that.
But shame on anyone who pretends that those barely trained to perform journalism are now capable of determining someone's mental capacity.
In the meantime, let's ask a more easily answered question.
Is Brian Stelter too ugly to be on TV?
Yes.
Tweet of the week
Shirtless Pundit Retweeted
BREAKING: We're confronting JPMorgan Chase in downtown Seattle for funding tar sands pipelines! http://bit.ly/2fSB2UL #DefundTarsands
2 replies78 retweets126 likes
March and rally for prisoners’ human rights in San José, Calif.
From LIBERATION:
Download PDF flyer
March and rally for prisoners’ human rights in San José, Calif.
By Jon Britton
Aug 20, 2017
Hundreds marched and rallied in San José, Calif., Aug. 19, at a sister action for prisoners’ human rights to the main one that
took place the same day in Washington, D.C. California Prison Focus and
the united-front coalition Rise Up for Justice were the main
co-sponsors and organizers of the action.
RU4J General Secretary Matthew Sahagian, who provided overall tactical leadership, introduced Troy Williams for an opening presentation at the Raymond Bernal Jr. Park assembly point. Williams, the newly appointed editor of the San Francisco Bay View, a “Black newspaper,” and a former “lifer” incarcerated for decades at San Quentin, had been paroled two and a half years ago after founding a video production program at the prison. His goal, he said, was “to give a voice to those who have not had a voice.”
Participants set off on a 1.3-mile march, whose route included a community known as Japantown. Tourists and other patrons in the patio area of a neighborhood restaurant spontaneously broke into applause as the chanting marchers passed by.
A variety of chants included: “Human rights apply to all, even those behind the wall” and “Brick by brick, wall by wall, we will make the prisons fall.”
The march route also included First Street, along which a half dozen or so widely hated bail bonds outfits have their offices. Because the march was led by Williams and a number of other parolee ex-prisoners whose security was paramount, the march did not stop to denounce these vultures.
Rally near county jail
The march concluded with a lengthy but spirited rally near the Santa Clara County jail, which included a minute of silence for the prisoners inside. Nube Brown of California Prison Focus and Rise Up for Justice, along with Troy Williams, chaired the rally. Many former prisoners presented heart-rending stories of the injustices they experienced in prison and after being released.
Among these, former Black Panther Dorsey Nunn, executive director of Legal Services for Prisoners with Children, appealed to the audience to call California Assembly members to pass AB 1008, the Fair Chance Act, which would “ban the box” on job applications.
Others called for building a movement to modify the Thirteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, which ended slavery “except as a punishment for crime whereof the party has been duly convicted. …”
Laurie Valdez, an activist/advocate and single mom also spoke. She founded justice4josia.org, after the murder of Antonio Guzman Lopez by SJSU PD officers on Feb. 21, 2014. He was the father of their then four-year-old son. Josia took the mic to say loudly and clearly in response to his mother’s question, what should happen to the police who killed your father, “They should go to prison!”
Bato, one of the San Quentin Six and co-founder of California Prison Focus, spoke near the end. He noted that few of the veterans of earlier struggles, such as Hugo Pinell, also one of the San Quentin Six and still incarcerated in Pelican Bay, were still alive but urged the younger generation to carry on the fight for human rights.
RU4J General Secretary Matthew Sahagian, who provided overall tactical leadership, introduced Troy Williams for an opening presentation at the Raymond Bernal Jr. Park assembly point. Williams, the newly appointed editor of the San Francisco Bay View, a “Black newspaper,” and a former “lifer” incarcerated for decades at San Quentin, had been paroled two and a half years ago after founding a video production program at the prison. His goal, he said, was “to give a voice to those who have not had a voice.”
Participants set off on a 1.3-mile march, whose route included a community known as Japantown. Tourists and other patrons in the patio area of a neighborhood restaurant spontaneously broke into applause as the chanting marchers passed by.
A variety of chants included: “Human rights apply to all, even those behind the wall” and “Brick by brick, wall by wall, we will make the prisons fall.”
The march route also included First Street, along which a half dozen or so widely hated bail bonds outfits have their offices. Because the march was led by Williams and a number of other parolee ex-prisoners whose security was paramount, the march did not stop to denounce these vultures.
Rally near county jail
The march concluded with a lengthy but spirited rally near the Santa Clara County jail, which included a minute of silence for the prisoners inside. Nube Brown of California Prison Focus and Rise Up for Justice, along with Troy Williams, chaired the rally. Many former prisoners presented heart-rending stories of the injustices they experienced in prison and after being released.
Among these, former Black Panther Dorsey Nunn, executive director of Legal Services for Prisoners with Children, appealed to the audience to call California Assembly members to pass AB 1008, the Fair Chance Act, which would “ban the box” on job applications.
Others called for building a movement to modify the Thirteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, which ended slavery “except as a punishment for crime whereof the party has been duly convicted. …”
Laurie Valdez, an activist/advocate and single mom also spoke. She founded justice4josia.org, after the murder of Antonio Guzman Lopez by SJSU PD officers on Feb. 21, 2014. He was the father of their then four-year-old son. Josia took the mic to say loudly and clearly in response to his mother’s question, what should happen to the police who killed your father, “They should go to prison!”
Bato, one of the San Quentin Six and co-founder of California Prison Focus, spoke near the end. He noted that few of the veterans of earlier struggles, such as Hugo Pinell, also one of the San Quentin Six and still incarcerated in Pelican Bay, were still alive but urged the younger generation to carry on the fight for human rights.
Detroit exposes the racism of US society in the 1960s
This is from Great Britain's SOCIALIST WORKER:
Detroit exposes the racism of US society in the 1960s
Soldiers in tanks roll nervously through abandoned streets.
A flutter of curtains in an upstairs apartment and a National Guardsman shouts, “Sniper”. Machine guns blaze, and glass and brickwork are smashed in a hail of bullets.
Behind the curtain was a young black girl who made the mistake of looking out her window.
Director Kathryn Bigelow’s Detroit grabs you by the throat from its opening minutes until the last.
The story of the 1967 Detroit Uprising was never going to be easy to tell. The scale of the revolt itself—five days of rioting involving 10,000 participants, 43 deaths and 1,200 people injured—makes picking out particular events difficult.
In the film, the chaos of police raids and shooting intermingle with looting and fires that spread across the city. They are interspersed with archive shots of the crumbling political establishment struggling to find a way to quell the rising.
The visual and narrative discord mix, creating a sense of tension and panic. In Detroit, events have a habit of spiralling out of control.
Torture
Bigelow has chosen the gruelling story of torture at the Algiers Motel to stand for the brutal racism that lay behind the riots.
A group of young black men and a couple of white women are hanging out in the Algiers, a place known as a party venue.
When the cops mistake a starting gun shot for sniper fire they raid the motel.
Already infuriated, the police are further enraged when they find an inter-racial group in one of the rooms. The possibility of inter-racial sex drives them wild with hatred.They set about torturing and then killing some of the guests that are now their captives.
Detroit holds nothing back. The agony of the victims is prolonged and as brutal as you are ever likely to see.
The action lasts for more than an hour and every minute is excruciating.The subsequent investigation and court case tell us everything we need to know about the 1960s US.
All the police officers are white. The judge and jury are white. The lawyers and expert witnesses are white—only the tortured victims and their families are black, and they are demonised almost as a matter of routine.
Rather than the traditional Hollywood depiction of racism, where a few rotten apples are responsible, Bigelow shows the workings of an entire racist system. But Detroit is not without weaknesses.
Black people are at the very centre of this film but the political consequences of the uprising are nowhere to be seen.
The riots were the harbinger of a new consciousness in the ghettos—Black Power.
Detroit is out on Friday 25 August
Click here to subscribe to our daily morning email newsletter 'Breakfast in red'
This edition's playlist
1) Alicia Keys' HERE.
2) Steve Grand's ALL AMERICAN BOY.
3) Blondie's POLLINATOR.
4) Sam Smith's IN THE LONELY HOUR DROWNING SHADOW EDITION.
5) Aretha Franklin's ARETHA SINGS THE GREAT DIVA CLASSICS.
6) Tori Amos' UNREPENTANT GERALDINES.
7) Janet Jackson's UNBREAKABLE.
8) Janet Jackson's THE VELVET ROPE.
9) Tori Amos' LITTLE EARTHQUAKES.
10) Tori Amos' UNDER THE PINK.