Obama shows his commitment to close Guantánamo by fighting release of 74-pound hunger striking prisoner
October 17, 2015
That is the cruel and absurd world of Guantánamo, where Tariq Ba Odah,
long cleared for release by every U.S. security agency, still
languishes in a cell 13 years on, waiting for the State Department and
the Pentagon to finally agree on when to free him.
On Thursday, I joined Tariq’s attorney, CCR’s Omar Farah, in Washington DC, where he urged U.S. District Court Judge Hogan to order the Obama administration to release Tariq on medical grounds. Tariq has been on hunger strike,
protesting his indefinite detention, since 2007. At 36-years old, he
weighs roughly the same amount as the average 10-year old American
boy—just 74 pounds. For more than 8 years he has been force-fed by
prison staff every day.
Judge Hogan repeated these damning facts throughout the
hearing, clearly concerned about Tariq’s grave medical condition and his
prolonged imprisonment. “I’m not sure what the government is doing,” he
said. “I don’t understand the delays.”
Omar argued that whether or not the government ever had
the authority to imprison Tariq to begin with, that authority had surely
now expired under section 3-12 of Army Regulation 190-8, which
incorporates elements of the Geneva Conventions into US law and calls
for the humanitarian release of gravely ill prisoners. The government’s
lawyers were asked directly, but could give no explanation as to why
Tariq’s weight hasn’t increased even though he is forcibly-fed 2600
calories a day. Still they asserted that at 74 pounds he is “clinically
stable”, and therefore ineligible for these humanitarian law
protections. Moreover, they tried to convince the Court to stay-its-hand
in this urgent dispute by claiming that Tariq is not entitled to these
basic humanitarian law protections because the government unilaterally
declared that he lacks prisoner-of-war status.
That’s the Obama Justice Department in 2015 making the same
Bush-era arguments, taking exception to the Geneva Conventions, that
President Obama once disavowed and the Supreme Court roundly criticized
in Boumediene v. Bush.
It is troubling, indeed schizophrenic,
that this is what the Obama administration says in court to a dying
man, all while trying to convince the American public that it has a
“new” plan to empty the prison. If the administration can’t work
together to free Tariq, how could it possibly close Guantánamo?
Meanwhile, Tariq’s life is on the line, and with each
additional day the consequences of the president’s inaction get more
dire. In his concluding remarks, Omar articulated why the court’s
intervention is so necessary.
“The government does not actually oppose Mr. Ba Odah’s release. It is here fighting on principle…so that the government can maintain the right to warehouse Mr. Ba Odah and force-feed his 74-pound frame to keep him alive only to prolong his detention,though he is cleared, so it can release him at the time and place of the government’s choosing…That's an alarming distortion of the government's detention authority. The Court should determine that this has gone on long enough.”
We hope Judge Hogan will not let this cruel injustice continue.